(Press-News.org) ITHACA, N.Y. – Shifting from numerical to narrative-based performance reviews can significantly impact employees’ perceptions of fairness and their likelihood of improving performance based on the feedback, according to Cornell University-led research.
The study, published in the Academy of Management Discoveries, compared responses to performance feedback delivered in one of three formats: numerical-only, narrative-only or a combination of both. Their findings suggest that narrative-only feedback was generally perceived as the fairest, and gives recipients a clearer understanding of how to enhance their future performance.
“When we started this project, we thought that combined feedback might be best,” said Emily Zitek, a professor in Cornell’s School of Industrial and Labor Relations.
“But what we ended up finding was that the narrative-only condition was the best in terms of fairness perceptions and preventing people from feeling negatively evaluated.”
To examine the impact of various performance feedback formats on employees’ responses, they conducted four experiments in which they manipulated the format of the feedback given to 1,600 participants. Participants received the same evaluations in either numerical-only, narrative-only or a combined format.
The researchers concluded that purely numerical feedback without narrative components is not ideal, as even mid-range numerical ratings can make employees feel negatively evaluated, and that the review was unfair. The lack of context also may make it difficult for employees to understand how to improve.
“If someone did only OK, they’re probably going to feel worse about it if they have numbers in their feedback than if they don’t,” Zitek said. “So if you don’t want them to feel bad, give them the information in just a narrative.”
The research offers practical implications to organizations by laying out the costs and benefits of removing numbers from performance feedback so that organizations can best decide how to proceed.
“We are hesitant to suggest that employers go to completely narrative-based performance reviews,” Zitek said, “because if you don’t have numbers, there can be some other disadvantages when you are trying to do things like administer bonuses or promotions.”
For additional information, see this Cornell Chronicle story.
Cornell University has dedicated television and audio studios available for media interviews.
-30-
END
Narrative-based performance reviews deemed fairest by employees
2026-01-05
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
New insights reveal how advanced oxidation can tackle emerging water pollutants
2026-01-05
Scientists have taken a major step toward improving how wastewater treatment systems deal with emerging contaminants such as pharmaceuticals, antibiotics, and endocrine disrupting chemicals. In a new perspective article published in New Contaminants, researchers present a comprehensive framework explaining how advanced oxidation processes, or AOPs, remove these hard to eliminate pollutants from water.
Emerging contaminants are often present at very low concentrations, but they can pose long term risks to ecosystems and human health. Many conventional ...
New review shows how biomass can deliver low-carbon gaseous fuels at scale
2026-01-05
A new comprehensive review highlights how converting biomass into gaseous fuels such as hydrogen, methane, and syngas could play a critical role in the global transition to low-carbon energy systems. By combining techno-economic analysis with life-cycle assessment, the study provides one of the clearest pictures to date of when and where biomass-based gaseous fuels can be both climate-friendly and economically viable.
The review, published in Energy & Environment Nexus, examines thermochemical conversion pathways that transform agricultural residues, forestry waste, and other ...
Climate change is quietly rewriting the world’s nitrogen cycle, with high stakes for food and the environment
2026-01-05
Climate change is not only warming the planet and disrupting rainfall, it is also quietly rewiring the way nitrogen moves through the world’s croplands, forests, and grasslands. This hidden shift in the global nitrogen cycle carries major consequences for food security, water quality, biodiversity, and climate policy.
Nitrogen is a basic building block of proteins and DNA, and healthy terrestrial ecosystems depend on a steady but balanced flow of nitrogen through soils, plants, and microbes. When that balance is disturbed, harvests can fall, rivers can turn green with algae, and more greenhouse gases can escape into the atmosphere.
“In a warming world, nitrogen ...
Study finds SGLT-2 inhibitors linked to lower risk of diabetic foot nerve damage
2026-01-05
Embargoed for release until 5:00 p.m. ET on Monday 5 January 2026
Follow @Annalsofim on X, Facebook, Instagram, Bluesky, and Linkedin
Below please find summaries of new articles that will be published in the next issue of Annals of Internal Medicine. The summaries are not intended to substitute for the full articles as a source of information. This information is under strict embargo and by taking it into possession, media representatives are committing ...
Microbes may hold the key to brain evolution
2026-01-05
EVANSTON, Ill. --- A groundbreaking new study reveals that changes to the gut microbiome can change the way the brain works.
Humans have the largest relative brain size of any primate, but little is known about how mammals with larger brains evolved to meet the intense energy demands required to support brain growth and maintenance.
A new study from Northwestern University provides the first empirical data showing the direct role the gut microbiome plays in shaping differences in the way the brain functions across different primate species.
“Our study shows that microbes are acting on traits ...
Study examines how the last two respiratory pandemics rapidly spread through cities
2026-01-05
Public health researchers at Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health used computer modeling to reconstruct how the 2009 H1N1 flu pandemic and the 2020 COVID-19 pandemic unfolded in the U.S. The findings highlight the rapid spread of pandemic respiratory pathogens and the challenges of early outbreak containment. The study, published in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, is the first to comprehensively compare the spatial transmission of the last two respiratory pandemics in the U.S. at the metropolitan scale.
In the U.S., the 2009 H1N1 flu pandemic was responsible for 274,304 hospitalizations ...
Gender stereotypes reflect the division of labor between women and men across nations
2026-01-05
EVANSTON, Ill. --- Researchers at Northwestern University and the University of Bern in Switzerland have conducted the first cross-temporal, multinational study to compare views of gender using data collected 30 years apart.
An international study reveals that people’s beliefs about the attributes of women and men follow from the differing social roles that they typically occupy in homes and workplaces in their respective societies.
The goal driving the research was to understand the sources of stereotypes of men as assertive and ambitious and of women as the kinder and more caring gender. The study showed that these stereotypes reflect the differing social ...
Orthopedics can play critical role in identifying intimate partner violence
2026-01-05
A study by researchers at Mass General Brigham highlights the opportunity for orthopedic surgeons to play a critical role in identifying patients who have experienced intimate partner violence (IPV). While orthopedic surgeons are experts in musculoskeletal injuries, screening patients to identify IPV is not routine. This is highlighted by the findings that only 0.3% of referrals for IPV from orthopedic surgeons compared to 29% from the emergency department. Correcting misperceptions about the prevalence of IPV, ...
Worms as particle sweepers
2026-01-05
When observing small worms under a microscope, one might observe something very surprising: the worms appear to make a sweeping motion to clean their own environment. Physicists at the University of Amsterdam, Georgia Tech and Sorbonne Université/CNRS have now discovered the reason for this unexpected behavior.
Brainless sweeping
When centimeter-long aquatic worms, such as T. tubifex or Lumbriculus variegatus, are placed in a Petri dish filled with sub-millimeter sized sand particles, something surprising happens. Over time, the worms begin to spontaneously clean up their surroundings. They sweep particles ...
Second spider-parasitic mite described in Brazil
2026-01-05
When researchers studying spiders and scorpions at the Zoological Collections Laboratory of the Butantan Institute in São Paulo, Brazil, came across a few-millimeter-long spider wearing something resembling a pearl necklace, they knocked on the door of a colleague specializing in mites.
Ricardo Bassini-Silva, a researcher and curator of the Acarological Collection at the same laboratory, quickly identified the “necklace” as mite larvae. Previously, there had only been one record of spider-parasitic mites ...