Home fingertip oxygen monitors less accurate for people with darker skin tones

Largest study on this topic suggests that measurement errors lead to potential delays in care and contribute to health disparities

2026-01-15

(Press-News.org) Fingertip monitors known as pulse oximeters that can be used at home to detect low blood oxygen levels (hypoxaemia) give higher readings for patients with darker than lighter skin tones, finds the largest study on this topic published by The BMJ today.

This means that low blood oxygen levels may be missed in patients with darker skin tones, potentially delaying care, while patients with lighter skin tones may get unnecessary treatment.

Pulse oximeters use light to measure the amount of oxygen in the blood (SpO2). For most people, a normal pulse oximeter reading is between 95% and 100%, with readings below 90-92% generally considered low and requiring medical attention.

They are known to be affected by several factors, including skin tone, as pigment in darker skin can absorb more light, making the device “think” there's more oxygen than there is. But so far, studies have been unable to draw any firm conclusions about the impact of skin tone on diagnostic accuracy.

To address this, researchers set out to test the measurement and diagnostic accuracy of five fingertip pulse oximeters provided by the NHS for use at home in the NHS England COVID oximetry @home scheme.

They drew on data from 903 critically ill adults (average age 56 years; 67% male) on 24 NHS intensive care units in England between June 2022 and August 2024.

Although the fingertip pulse oximeters tested were those used at home, intensive care units were used as the test laboratory as patients have lower blood oxygen values and routinely have their blood oxygen accurately measured using hospital machines.

For each patient, skin tone was measured objectively using a spectrophotometer (a type of camera that measures colour). The researchers then compared pulse oximetry blood oxygen values (SpO2) with “gold-standard” arterial blood gas measurements (SaO2).

SpO2 values were assessed at two thresholds in line with current guidance either to seek medical help (94% or lower) or to attend the emergency department (92% or lower).

A total of 11,018 paired SpO2-SaO2 measurements were analysed. All five pulse oximeters returned higher SpO2 values for patients with darker skin tones than patients with lighter skin tones, at any given level of SaO2 measurement.

SpO2 readings were, on average, 0.6-1.5 percentage points higher for patients with darker than lighter skin tone.

At both SpO2 thresholds assessed, false negative rates (low oxygen missed by the pulse oximeter when present) increased with darker skin tones, while false positive rates (low oxygen indicated by the pulse oximeter when absent) decreased with darker skin tone.

And while absolute differences in readings were small, “they can result in substantially higher rates of false negatives and lower rates of false positives in the diagnosis of hypoxaemia,” note the researchers.

This is an observational study, so no definitive conclusions can be drawn about cause and effect. And the authors acknowledge that the study was conducted in critically ill patients, which may limit the generalisability of the findings.

However, they say this was a large study using sophisticated statistical modelling to assess the performance of the pulse oximeters across multiple domains of both measurement and diagnostic accuracy.

As such, they conclude: “SpO2 readings should be interpreted in the context of other clinical information and trends in SpO2 values given greater importance than single readings, particularly in patients with darker skin tones.”

They add: “Healthcare systems should develop guidance to inform and aid practitioners, patients and the public, particularly in settings where additional clinical readings from other medical measurement devices would not be available.”

In a linked editorial, researchers agree that clinicians must recognise the limitations of current devices and interpret readings for patients with darker skin with care and caution, and they say regulation must now catch up with science to mitigate harm.

“The goal is not to abandon pulse oximetry but to understand its limits and make it equitable, ensuring that the technology designed to measure oxygen does not itself perpetuate inequalities in those who receive it,” they conclude.

END

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Six weeks in a cast no less effective than surgery for unstable ankle fractures

2026-01-15

Wearing a cast for six weeks appears to be no less effective than surgery for healing unstable ankle fractures and carries fewer treatment related harms, finds a clinical trial from Finland published by The BMJ today. Around two thirds of all ankle fractures involve a break in the fibula (the outer ankle bone). Known as Weber B fractures, they leave the ankle either stable or unstable (at risk of falling out of alignment). Surgery remains the main treatment for Weber B ankle fractures deemed unstable, despite recent trials and guidelines increasingly supporting non-surgical options in selected patients. To explore this further, researchers set out ...

Precautionary approach to alcohol-free and low alcohol drinks needed to protect public health, say experts

2026-01-15

Alcohol-free and low alcohol (“nolo”) drinks have the potential to improve public health, but experts in The BMJ today call for a precautionary approach that maximises potential benefits (eg. increased substitution of alcoholic drinks with nolo alternatives) while minimising risks (eg. preventing encroachment of nolo drinks into alcohol-free spaces). Sales of alcohol-free and low alcohol drinks have increased substantially over recent years, driven by improved manufacturing techniques and consumer demand for better and healthier alternatives to alcoholic drinks, ...

Gas-atomized Ca–Mg alloy powders produce hydrogen simply by adding water — high-efficiency hydrogen generation at room temperature

2026-01-15

Key findings Adding 100 mL of water at room temperature (25 ℃) to 1 g of the alloy powder results in nearly complete hydrolysis and yields a high hydrogen output in a short time. After correcting for water vapor, the measured hydrogen volume corresponds to approximately 737–760 mL H₂ per gram of powder (produced within about 10 minutes). Raising the water temperature to 60 ℃ further increases both reaction rate and total yield, reaching up to ≈835 mL H₂/g (uncorrected value). Microstructural analysis using SEM/TEM/EDS shows that the gas-atomized powders are spherical (diameter ~6–65 ...

British redcoat’s lost memoir reveals harsh realities of life as a disabled veteran

2026-01-15

Archival discoveries including a 19th-century autobiography transform our understanding of Shadrack Byfield, an English veteran of the War of 1812 who buried his own amputated arm and designed a custom prosthesis. A recurrent character in TV documentaries, books and museum exhibits in the USA and Canada, Byfield has been celebrated as an uncomplaining British soldier. But the new evidence reveals Byfield’s tenacious pursuit of veterans’ benefits and his struggles with pain, poverty, and the police. ‘They came and pushed me about, ...

World-leading rare earth magnet recycling facility launches in UK

2026-01-15

The University of Birmingham today (15 Jan) launched a new West Midlands-based facility for separating and recycling rare earth magnets that will help to reduce the UK’s reliance on imports of rare earth metals, alloys, and magnets.  Rare earth magnets are amongst the key ‘critical minerals’ that are integral to modern life. They form a core building block in technologies such as wind turbines, electric vehicles, medical equipment, pumps, robotics, and electronics. Demand for these minerals will only increase as the adoption of low-carbon technologies ...

Corday Selden selected for the Oceanography Society Early Career Award

2026-01-14

The Oceanography Society (TOS) has selected Dr. Corday Selden, an Assistant Professor at Rutgers University, as a recipient of the TOS Early Career Award, recognizing her outstanding early-career research contributions, leadership in ocean sciences, and exceptional promise for future impact in oceanography. Dr. Selden will be recognized at The Oceanography Society Honors Breakfast, February 24, 2026, during the Ocean Sciences Meeting in Glasgow, Scotland. Dr. Selden is a marine biogeochemist whose research has fundamentally advanced understanding of how marine microbial processes regulate ocean chemistry and Earth-system function. Her work integrates stable isotope geochemistry, ...

MIT chemists determine the structure of the fuzzy coat that surrounds Tau proteins

2026-01-14

One of the hallmarks of Alzheimer’s disease is the clumping of proteins called Tau, which form tangled fibrils in the brain. The more severe the clumping, the more advanced the disease is. The Tau protein, which has also been linked to many other neurodegenerative diseases, is unstructured in its normal state, but in the pathological state it consists of a well-ordered rigid core surrounded by floppy segments. These disordered segments form a “fuzzy coat” that helps determine how Tau interacts with other molecules. MIT chemists have ...

Same moves, different terrain: How bacteria navigate complex environments without changing their playbook

2026-01-14

Just like every other creature, bacteria have evolved creative ways of getting around. Sometimes this is easy, like swimming in open water, but navigating more confined spaces poses different challenges. Nevertheless, new research from the University of Chicago shows that a diverse group of bacteria has learned how to use the same basic movements to move through a wide range of environments no matter how complex, from unconstrained fluids to densely packed soil and tissues. ‘Run-and-tumble' vs ‘hop-and-trap' Some of the most common bacteria, like Salmonella and ...

Severe weather is deadly for vulnerable older adults long after the storm ends, study finds

2026-01-14

Audio: Study summation by Sue Anne Bell Older adults who were exposed to heavy rainfall after Hurricane Harvey in 2017 faced a 3% increase in the risk of death within the following year, a new University of Michigan study found. "These findings add to the evidence that disasters don't just cause short-term disruptions. They expose and magnify the underlying fragilities in our health systems," said lead author Sue Anne Bell, U-M associate professor of nursing. "For older adults who rely on regular ...

Expert panel highlights opportunities for improving cancer studies

2026-01-14

At the time of marketing authorization, many questions regarding the optimal use of new cancer drugs remain unanswered. This concerns, for example, the appropriate dosage for different patient groups and treatment duration, but also the comparison of the available treatment options with each other, or the optimal sequence. Because of these gaps in knowledge, the best possible results for patients are often not achieved. This problem has become more acute in recent years because efforts have focused more on accelerating the marketing authorization of new drugs than on optimizing their use in everyday clinical practice. The ...