Red tape for clinical trial consent can be lethal: Experts
'Unethical' regulations which delay emergency treatment can kill
2011-03-24
(Press-News.org) Current rules requiring researchers to obtain consent for patients to take part in clinical trials in emergency situations are causing life-threatening delays to treatment, experts have argued.
They say that in severe trauma cases, waiting for a relative to give written permission is "unethical" because of the importance of prompt treatment.
Professor Ian Roberts, Dr Haleema Shakur and Dr David Prieto-Merino, from the Clinical Trials Unit of the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, make their point in a letter published in The Lancet.
It is co-signed by Sir Iain Chalmers, of the James Lind Initiative in Oxford, and Professor Jon Nicholl, from the University of Sheffield.
The researchers analysed data from a large international clinical trial in severe head injury and found that initiation of treatment is delayed by over an hour where written consent from relatives is required.
But when early treatment is vital – such as in the case of tranexamic acid for severe internal bleeding – this delay can prevent patients from benefiting and increase their risk of death.
The authors argue that about one sixth of patients in the CRASH-2 trial missed out on the chance to benefit from a life-saving treatment because of unethical application of what they call "consent rituals".
"The need for urgent treatment, even in patients who are conscious and whose relatives are available, excludes the possibility of fully informed consent," the letter states. "If consent rituals delay the start of a trial treatment such that the treatment effect could be reduced or obscured, we maintain that seeking consent is actually unethical."
It adds: "Informed consent procedures, like other well-intentioned public health interventions, should be assessed rigorously.
"The lethal effects we have shown might have been found decades ago had the research ethics community accepted a responsibility to provide robust evidence that its prescriptions are likely to do more good than harm."
INFORMATION:
END
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
2011-03-24
Disorders of the circulatory system- vascular diseases- are common in the developed world, and can lead to heart attacks, strokes and even death. However, treatments for these disorders, such as bypass surgery and angioplasty, themselves induce vascular injury, after which the cells of the blood vessel can over-proliferate in a way that limits blood flow. Nitric oxide (NO) is an important molecule that helps maintain the contractility and health of vascular smooth muscle cells, and multiple studies have linked vascular pathology to a decreased level of NO. Therefore, therapies ...
2011-03-24
EDITOR'S PICK
Why salad helps you say yes to NO
Disorders of the circulatory system- vascular diseases- are common in the developed world, and can lead to heart attacks, strokes and even death. However, treatments for these disorders, such as bypass surgery and angioplasty, themselves induce vascular injury, after which the cells of the blood vessel can over-proliferate in a way that limits blood flow. Nitric oxide (NO) is an important molecule that helps maintain the contractility and health of vascular smooth muscle cells, and multiple studies have linked vascular ...
2011-03-24
Myocardits is an inflammation of the heart muscles that is a major cause of heart failure in young patients. In some cases, the disease is caused by viral infection, but in other patients it is linked to an autoimmune attack on the heart muscle. There are few effective treatment options for myocarditis, in part because the molecular mechanisms that underlie the defect are poorly defined.
In this paper, researchers led by Myra Lipes, at the Joslin Diabetes Center in Boston, Massachusetts, used a mouse model of spontaneous myocarditis. They found that the disease occurs ...
2011-03-24
Niche Retail, a Magento Enterprise Solutions Partner, has announced a free review of Magento websites for those who are interested in maximizing customer conversions and in increasing exposure for their site. Specializing in advanced, Magento-based designs for online retail stores, Niche Retail has been developing sites for retail clients with a great deal of success, helping companies drive traffic to their online stores and convert those visits into sales. Now, Niche Retail is offering free exposure to those who have utilized the Magento platform for their business, with ...
2011-03-24
The drug, called carbamazepine, is commonly used to treat patients with epilepsy and other diseases such as depression and trigeminal neuralgia. Although successful in treating the majority of patients, carbamazepine can cause side-effects that range from a mild skin irritation to severe blistering of the whole body.
The team, in collaboration with the Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute, screened more than a million variants in DNA across the human genome to understand why some patients are more prone to the drug's side-effects than others. Research in Taiwan has already ...
2011-03-24
A survey of over 9,000 people in seven different countries across Europe has shown that the majority would want to improve the quality of life in the time they had left, rather than extend it. The survey reveals attitudes across Europe for dealing with serious illnesses such as cancer, and issues raised when caring for a close friend of relative in the last few months of life. The research was carried out as part of an EU-funded project led by researchers from King's College London.
The telephone survey of 9,339 people was carried out to explore attitudes to end of life ...
2011-03-24
CHESTNUT HILL, MA (3/24/2011) – A new catalytic chemical method for the synthesis of a large and important class of carbon-carbon double bonds has been developed by scientists from Boston College and MIT, the team reports in the journal Nature. The findings substantially expand the versatility of a set of metal-based catalysts discovered only three years ago by the researchers.
With molybdenum at their core, the catalysts have now proven capable of generating the higher-energy isomer of an alkene molecule from two simpler and much more readily accessible terminal versions, ...
2011-03-24
Chevy Chase, MD— A recent study accepted for publication in The Endocrine Society's Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism (JCEM) found that higher levels of perfluorocarbons (PFCs) in the body are associated with increased odds of having experienced menopause in women between 42 and 64 years old. Women in this age group with high levels of PFCs also had significantly lower concentrations of estrogen when compared to women who had low levels of PFCs.
PFCs are man-made chemicals used in a variety of household products including food containers, clothing, furniture, ...
2011-03-24
Chevy Chase, MD—Levels of the hormone ghrelin are low in obese women and a recent study accepted for publication in Endocrinology, a publication of The Endocrine Society, reports that mice whose mothers had low ghrelin levels were less fertile due to a defect in implantation.
Hormones involved in energy balance and metabolism, such as ghrelin, have been shown to regulate reproductive function in animals and humans. However ghrelin's role in reproductive tract development remains unclear. The current study examined the effect of ghrelin deficiency on the developmental ...
2011-03-24
ANN ARBOR, Mich. – Seemingly every year there are reports of a young, apparently healthy athlete dying on the court or playing field.
The sudden death of Wes Leonard, a junior at Fennville High School, who died of cardiac arrest from an enlarged heart on March 3, may have parents and coaches wondering if enough is being done to identify athletes at risk for dying suddenly.
"We would like to develop a better screening program to help prevent sudden cardiac death, but there is not enough rigorous data to support what that should look like," says Sanjaya Gupta, M.D., clinical ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
[Press-News.org] Red tape for clinical trial consent can be lethal: Experts
'Unethical' regulations which delay emergency treatment can kill
