(Press-News.org) Most school text books contain messages about health, but 24.6% of these are not based on any scientific evidence, according to a study by the Knowledge Management Unit at Baza Hospital (Granada), published in the journal BMC Public Health.
"We analysed a total of 844 health messages in primary and secondary school text books in order to identify the level of scientific evidence underpinning these texts, and we classified them into three categories – messages with a high, medium or low level of evidence, messages with an unknown level of evidence, and messages with no known evidence", Inés María Barrio Cantalejo, a researcher at Baza Hospital and the lead author of this study published in the journal BMC Public Health, tells SINC.
The research team compiled the information between 1 March 2006 and 1 June 2007 based on text books being used at the time in the city of Granada. Texts written in languages other than Spanish, "teachers' guides", and books not containing any health-related messages were discounted.
"We drew up a table to classify the messages and we recorded the data about the year and subject matter of the text book. We identified 237 books and we manually reviewed 129 that met the previously-stated requirements. Lastly, we used 80 as a sample", explains Barrio Cantalejo.
Out of all the books in the sample, 73.7% (59 books) were aimed at primary school level and contained 548 messages. The average number of messages per book was 10.6, with the highest levels of health-related content being found in books for the third year of secondary education (37%), and in terms of subject matter in Biology and Geology books (32.5%).
Out of the total of 844 messages studied, 61% were classified as having an unknown level of evidence (information such as "children should not cook without an adult's help in order to avoid domestic accidents"), while 15% fell into the category where the level of scientific proof was known.
However, 24.6% did not display any known evidence (such as "breathing through the nose instead of the mouth prevents colds" and "do not swim after eating, because this can affect the digestive system and you could suffer immersion syncope").
Out of the content in which the level of evidence was known, 6% was classified as having a high level of evidence, such as the statement that "children should use fluoride toothpaste when they brush their teeth"; and 7.7% with a low level, such as "alcohol consumption causes malnutrition and affects the digestive system". In addition, two messages went completely against scientific reality: "You should always rest following a muscular injury" and "wounds must be disinfected with hydrogen peroxide".
Oral health messages are most rigorous
When broken down by subject area, more than 70% of the messages relating to "balanced diets and malnutrition", "food hygiene", "smoking", "sexual behaviour and AIDS" and "rest and ergonomics" were based on an unknown level of evidence. "Oral health" had the highest percentage of messages based on a high level of proof (37.5%), followed by "pregnancy and newborn babies" (35%).
"Our results suggest the need to establish standards to show teachers and the editors of school text books how to select health messages. This would make it easier for schoolchildren to acquire factual knowledge", concludes Barrio Cantalejo.
INFORMATION:
References:
Inés M Barrio-Cantalejo, Luisa M Ayudarte-Larios, Mariano Hernán-García, Pablo Simón-Lorda, José Francisco García-Gutiérrez, Jesús Martínez-Tapias. "Are the health messages in schoolbooks based on scientific evidence? A descriptive study", BMC PUBLIC HEALTH 11 (54), 2011.
Around 25 percent of health messages in Spanish text books are not based on scientific evidence
2011-03-25
[Attachments] See images for this press release:
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
A Motorcycle Helmet: Use It or Lose It?
2011-03-25
The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) recently issued a press release putting mandatory motorcycle helmet use on its Most Wanted List of Transportation Safety Improvements.
It reported that from 1997 through 2008, the number of motorcycle fatalities more than doubled during a period when overall highway fatalities declined
The NTSB has recommended that everyone riding a motorcycle be required to wear a helmet. Currently, only 20 states, the District of Columbia and four territories have universal helmet laws that apply to all riders.
Twenty-seven states ...
Atlanta Airport Hotel Offers Nearby Lodging to Travelers Visiting Fernbank NatureQuest
2011-03-25
The Hampton Inn & Suites Atlanta Airport Hotel (North I-85) offers nearby accommodations to travelers planning to visit the Fernbank Museum of Natural History near midtown Atlanta. The Museum recently launched a new permanent exhibition, Fernbank NatureQuest. Guests can climb trees and cross rope bridges to a working clubhouse, which sits atop giant trees. Tickets for Fernbank NatureQuest are included with Museum admission and free for all members.
Fernbank's other permanent exhibitions include:
- Dinosaur Entrance Plaza
- Giants of the Mesozoic
- A Walk through Time ...
BrainGate neural interface system reaches 1,000-day performance milestone
2011-03-25
PROVIDENCE, R.I. [Brown University] — Demonstrating an important milestone for the longevity and utility of implanted brain-computer interfaces, a woman with tetraplegia using the investigational BrainGate* system continued to control a computer cursor accurately through neural activity alone more than 1,000 days after receiving the BrainGate implant, according to a team of physicians, scientists, and engineers developing and testing the technology at Brown University, the Providence VA Medical Center, and Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH). Results from five consecutive ...
Against the tide: Currents keep dolphins apart
2011-03-25
Conservationists from the Wildlife Conservation Society, the American Museum of Natural History, and other conservation and research groups have discovered that groups of dolphins in the western Indian Ocean do not mix freely with one another. In fact, dolphin populations are kept separate by currents and other unseen factors.
Specifically, the researchers have found that genetically distinct populations of the Indo-Pacific humpback dolphin may be formed in part by currents, surface temperature differences, and other environmental barriers, a finding made possible by ...
Debenhams Launches Android & Nokia Apps for Shoppers on the Move
2011-03-25
Debenhams has launched its latest app for the professional shopper on Android and Nokia phones, making the retailer the first on the high street to offer apps for the three key smartphones.
The free-to-download, fully transactional apps follow the highly successful launch of the Debenhams iPhone app in October 2010. Designed to target the on-the-move shopper and enrich the in-store experience, the Debenhams iPhone app achieved 360,000 downloads and sales of nearly GBP1 million within five months of launch.
With the success of the iPhone app and sales on the Debenhams ...
Eskimo study suggests high consumption of omega-3s reduces obesity-related disease risk
2011-03-25
SEATTLE – A study of Yup'ik Eskimos in Alaska, who on average consume 20 times more omega-3 fats from fish than people in the lower 48 states, suggests that a high intake of these fats helps prevent obesity-related chronic diseases such as diabetes and heart disease.
The study, led by researchers at Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center and conducted in collaboration with the Center for Alaska Native Health Research at the University of Alaska-Fairbanks, was published online March 23 in the European Journal of Clinical Nutrition.
"Because Yup'ik Eskimos have a traditional ...
Data streaming in from Space Station to OSU lab
2011-03-25
CORVALLIS, Ore. – A prototype scanner aboard the international space station has been taking new images of Earth's coastal regions during the 16 months since it was launched, providing scientists with a new set of imaging tools that will help them monitor events from oil spills to plankton blooms.
The images and other data are now available to scientists from around the world through an online clearinghouse coordinated by Oregon State University.
Additional details of the project will be announced in a forthcoming issue of the American Geophysical Union journal, EOS, ...
Travelzest Launches 2011 Hotel and Villa Collection Brochure
2011-03-25
Travelzest has announced the launch of its Hotel & Villa Collection brochure for 2011.
The 250-page brochure brings together four of Travelzest's biggest brands for the first time, in recognition of the fact that some of its customers are interested in more than one company in Travelzest's wide-ranging portfolio of luxury hotels and luxury villas. The included brands are Best of Morocco, Tapestry Collection, VFB Holidays and the Wow House Company.
Travelzest's Hotel & Villa Collection 2011 brochure includes over 30 different destinations in regions as diverse as Canada, ...
High-temperature superconductor spills secret: A new phase of matter
2011-03-25
Menlo Park, Calif. — Scientists have found the strongest evidence yet that a puzzling gap in the electronic structures of some high-temperature superconductors could indicate a new phase of matter. Understanding this "pseudogap" has been a 20-year quest for researchers who are trying to control and improve these breakthrough materials, with the ultimate goal of finding superconductors that operate at room temperature.
"Our findings point to management and control of this other phase as the correct path toward optimizing these novel superconductors for energy applications, ...
Access Legal Named Best Provider of Home Purchase and Sale Conveyancing Services
2011-03-25
Access Legal, the law firm from Shoosmiths, has been named best provider of home purchase and sale conveyancing services by the Conveyancing Alliance.
The national law firm came top in a survey conducted by the Conveyancing Alliance which was voted for by estate agents. Users of the Conveyancing Alliance portal ranked law firms on several service standards including communication levels, speed of delivery and client feedback.
Client feedback was a key area for Access Legal, as it is very customer focused and aims to treat people as individuals rather than just another ...