(Press-News.org) Research from Royal Holloway, University of London and the University of Bristol calls into question people's ability to form their own judgements about their preferred election candidate after finding voters could be heavily swayed by 'the worm' - a continuous response tracking measure this is increasingly being used in live election debates around the world.
The study "Social Influence in Televised Election Debates: A Potential Distortion of Democracy" is published today (30 March) in the journal PLoS One.
Televised election debates were introduced in the United States in 1960, and now play a prominent role in the election campaigns of many countries. The United Kingdom held its first televised election debates between the leaders of the main parliamentary parties in 2010. To help viewers evaluate voter response to the issues discussed in the debates, broadcasters including ITV and the BBC made use of a sampling methodology often referred to as 'the worm'; a similar methodology has been used by CNN in the United States and by broadcasters in Australia and New Zealand.
Unlike the sample sizes of hundreds or thousands of voters that are standard in political polls, the worm is based on a very small sample of undecided voters (sometimes as few as 12). These voters watch the debate live and record their satisfaction with what the leaders are saying using a handset. Their averaged responses result in a time series of data – the "worm" – that is superimposed over the video of the debate.
The researchers carried out their study by manipulating the worm and superimposing it on a live broadcast of the third UK election debate, which was viewed by the study subjects. The experimenters successfully convinced the majority of the viewers taking part in the study that they were watching an authentic audience response to the live debate. Two groups of 75 viewers took part; in one group, the worm favoured the incumbent Prime Minister, in the other group it favoured the leader of the Liberal Democrats Nick Clegg.
Professor Colin Davis, from the Department of Psychology at Royal Holloway explains: "We were amazed by the size of the effect that our worms had on viewers' opinions of who won the debate, and even on their choice of preferred Prime Minister. If our results were to generalise to the population at large, a biased worm in a debate shortly before polling day could determine the result of a close election.
He added: "In theory, an election debate should be an opportunity for the public to listen to the candidates and form independent opinions that are unfiltered by spin and commentary. The introduction of the worm compromises that possibility.
"The squiggly worm is certainly interesting to watch – sometimes more interesting than the candidates – but there's a real danger that we can get sucked in by the worm and allow it to sway, or even determine, our opinion. Results like ours force us to reconsider to what extent 'our' opinions really are our own."
###
Note to editors
Citation: Davis CJ, Bowers JS, Memon A (2011) Social Influence in Televised Election Debates: A Potential Distortion of Democracy. PLoS ONE 6(3): e18154.
doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0018154
Funding: This research was funded by the personal research budgets of the authors.
Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Using live worms as bait: Voters swayed by interactive 'worm' graph during election debate.
2011-03-31
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Horrible Trucking Accident on Indiana Highway Takes Three Lives
2011-03-31
On January 20, Chester Lee Mills Sr. was supposed to bury his wife, who had lost her battle with lung cancer. Instead, Mills was left to mourn the additional loss of his two children who died in a tragic truck accident en route to their stepmother's funeral. Amanda S. Mills, age 25; Logan R. Mills, age 21; and Anthony Suggs, age 25, were travelling to Georgia to attend the funeral when they were hit by a semi-truck after losing control of their car on icy roads. Witnesses said that the tractor-trailer turned over onto the passenger vehicle, pinning the three people in the ...
Scripps Research scientists: Sensory wiring for smells varies among individuals
2011-03-31
LA JOLLA, CA – March 30, 2011 – If, as Shakespeare's Juliet declared, a rose by any other name smells as sweet – to you and to me and to anyone else who sniffs it – then one might assume that our odor-sensing nerve cells are all wired in the same way. Alas, they are not, according to a new study from scientists at The Scripps Research Institute.
The researchers developed a new virus-based technique for highlighting individual nerve pathways, then applied it to the olfactory systems of mice. They found that mouse olfactory neurons send signals to two key processing regions ...
Brain scientists offer medical educators tips on the neurobiology of learning
2011-03-31
Everyone would like MDs to have the best education – and to absorb what they are taught. The lead article in the April 4 issue of the journal Academic Medicine* connects research on how the brain learns to how to incorporate this understanding into real world education, particularly the education of doctors.
"Repetition, reward, and visualization are tried and true teaching strategies. Now, knowing what is happening in the brain will enhance teaching and learning," said Michael J. Friedlander, executive director of the Virginia Tech Carilion Research Institute (www.vtc.vt.edu/research/index.html) ...
California Court Interprets Commercial Insurance Policy, Says Policy Covers Assault and Battery
2011-03-31
A California Court of Appeals case highlights why it is important for business owners to understand their company's insurance policy, especially the exclusions.
A Case in Point
In 2004, Terrell Ford was dining at a restaurant owned by Palmden. During this time, 20 gang members entered the restaurant and caused a disturbance. Shortly thereafter, the argument was brought outside and a fight instigated.
Ford attempted to leave, but the restaurant employees locked the front doors so he exited a back door. He was attacked and severely beaten by gang members and suffered ...
Increasing Motorcycle Safety to Have a Better Ride
2011-03-31
According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, more than 6 million motorcycles are registered in the U.S., which is about 3 percent of all registered vehicles in the country. However, motorcyclists are seriously injured and killed at a much higher rate than their 4-wheeled counterparts, as 11 percent of all highway deaths each year are motorcycle fatalities.
A variety of factors contribute to the high number of motorcycle crashes each year, including:
- Inexperienced riders
- Insufficient training
- Dangerous road conditions
- Low visibility to ...
Clinical trial success for Crohn's disease cell therapy
2011-03-31
Speaking at the UK National Stem Cell Network annual science meeting later today (30 March), Professor Miguel Forte will describe research into a new cell therapy for chronic inflammatory conditions such as Crohn's disease. Patient's own blood cells are used to produce a type of cell – Type 1 T regulatory lymphocyte – that can reduce the extent of the disease.
Professor Forte said "T regulatory lymphocytes are amazing cells – they secrete proteins – cytokines - that dampen down the over active immune response that causes the terrible symptoms of chronic inflammatory diseases ...
Tet further revealed: Studies track protein relevant to stem cells, cancer
2011-03-31
CHAPEL HILL, N.C. – Last year, a research team at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill discovered one way the protein Tet 1 helps stem cells keep their pluripotency—the unique ability to become any cell type in the body. In two new studies, the team takes a broad look at the protein's location in the mouse genome, revealing a surprising dual function and offering the first genome-wide location of the protein and its product, 5-hydroxymethylcytosine—dubbed the "sixth base" of DNA.
UNC biochemist Yi Zhang, PhD, whose team conducted the studies, called the findings ...
Consider Bankruptcy to Prevent Foreclosure
2011-03-31
Many homeowners struggling to make ends meet might feel that foreclosure is their only option. They may not realize that there might be a way for them to keep their home -- filing for bankruptcy. A bankruptcy filing is not ideal for every homeowner, but it might be a way to discharge enough other debt to be able to afford to make current their past due home payments.
Although bankruptcy is an admittedly effective solution for some homeowners, allowing them to escape from underneath a mountain of debt and still remain in their homes, it is still a drastic step. Prior ...
Texas Considers Deferred Adjudication for a First DWI Offense
2011-03-31
Texas lawmakers are considering a change to the state's Driving While Intoxicated laws. Under the law change, deferred adjudication would be available for those charged with their first DWI offense.
As proposed, opting for deferred adjudication would result in supervision, treatment and one year of probation. While it seems as though this may not provide a great alternative to current options for someone accused of DWI, the proposed law would also allow for an acquittal of the DWI charge at the end of the probation period if no further offenses are committed.
Speaking ...
Combination of 2 hormones increases height in girls with Turner syndrome
2011-03-31
(PHILADELPHIA) Giving girls with Turner syndrome low doses of estrogen, as well as growth hormone, years before the onset of puberty, increases their height and offers a wealth of other benefits, say a team of researchers led by Thomas Jefferson University. Their report is published in the March 31st issue of The New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM).
The study, which took more than 20 years to complete, will change the practice of treating girls with Turner syndrome, says the study's lead author, Judith Ross, M.D., professor of Pediatrics at Jefferson Medical College ...