September 10, 2010 (Press-News.org) The New Jersey Supreme Court recently issued an opinion that has major implications for law enforcement's implementation of the state's implied consent law. Like many jurisdictions, the Garden State's DWI statutes include a provision that all drivers suspected of intoxication must submit to testing for the presence of alcohol in their system. Those who refuse are subject to license revocation for at least seven months to a year and a fine of up to $1,000 for a first offense. The Supreme Court has now decided that all motorists are entitled to an explanation of the law in a language they understand.
In a published opinion released July 12, the state Supreme Court held in State v. German Marquez that an officer's reading of the standard implied consent statement in English to a Spanish-speaking defendant failed to inform the defendant that refusal to submit to a breath test had serious consequences. The Court's narrow majority opinion overturned the conviction and reversed a 2009 New Jersey Appellate Division decision.
How Do You Learn About the Consequences of Refusing a Breathalyzer Test?
Defendant German Marquez was suspected of intoxicated driving after a Plainfield, New Jersey, police officer responded to the scene of a collision in September of 2007 in which Marquez rear-ended another vehicle. The responding officer spoke to him in English, asking for his license, registration and insurance card, but had to repeat the request in Spanish to make him understand. Detecting an odor of alcohol and noticing Marquez's slurred speech, the officer attempted to have him execute field sobriety tests, explaining the actions in English. Marquez swayed visibly, but the officer could tell that he did not understand the attempt to test his reflexes and balance, and he was placed under arrest.
At the police station, a certified Alcotest operator attempted to administer a breath test after Marquez was read the thirteen paragraphs of the "Division of Motor Vehicles Standard Statement for Operators of a Motor Vehicle" in English. This statement outlines the consequences of breath-test refusal in New Jersey, and includes the important statement: "If you refuse to provide samples of your breath you will be issued a separate summons for this refusal."
The law enforcement personnel involved were all aware that Marquez did not understand what they were saying to him, and the prosecution did not contest this issue. At trial, the court found him guilty of DWI as well as refusal to submit to a breath test. The municipal court judge noted that defendant had refused to take the test and found no precedent requiring that the statement be read to a suspect in any language but English.
In upholding the conviction, the Appellate Division found that due process had been satisfied, but suggested that the Motor Vehicle Commission should translate the legal standard into Spanish and other prevalent languages. The Supreme Court decided to review the decision to consider Marquez's position that he was never "informed" of the consequences he faced if he refused to blow into an alcohol measuring device.
A Close Reading of Statutory Intent
In a four-to-three decision, the New Jersey Supreme Court overturned the conviction. The court did not reach the due process issue, focusing instead on the plain meaning of the implied consent law and its close companion, the statute that explains the consequences of driver refusal. The majority concluded that one of four essential elements of the law was that "refusal convictions require proof that an officer requested a motorist to submit to a chemical breath test and informed the person of the consequences of refusing to do so." Under the facts of this particular case, the court was convinced that the statutory elements were not met.
The court clearly distinguished this circumstance from a driver's inability to understand an officer's explanation because of intoxication. Although Marquez's sentence for refusal to submit to a test was vacated, his DWI conviction stood due to the responding officer's observations of intoxication, as well as video tape of Marquez. But the decision has major implications for law enforcement procedure and cases where the only clear proof of intoxication comes from a breath test. Innovations already in place, such as immediate over-the-phone translation services, may be implemented by some departments. But in many jurisdictions, the need for officers who are fluent in Spanish should already be self-evident.
Other issues will likely be resolved in future cases, such as the implications for deaf motorists, implementation of the new legal standard, and proof of a motorist's language abilities. But the vast majority of DWI cases will continue to revolve around such issues as officers' objective judgments of intoxication, reliability of test results and chain of custody for samples. Drivers accused of drug- and alcohol-related infractions can learn a great deal about their legal options by arranging a consultation with an experienced criminal defense lawyer.
Article provided by Mark M. Cheser
Visit us at www.866crimlaw.net
New Jersey Supreme Court Opinion Affects DWI Implied Consent Law
A recent New Jersey Supreme Court decision requires police to explain the implied consent law to motorists suspected of DUI in a language they understand.
2010-09-10
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Law Enforcement Officials Seize Over $1 Million in Marijuana
2010-09-10
Lexington County law enforcement recently received a tip concerning a large marijuana grow operation located in a remote swamp area off of Highway 178 near Pelion. As the site was not accessible by any vehicle, the Narcotics Enforcement Team, a multi-agency team from Lexington County, used aircraft surveillance to view the area prior to the raid.
No one was at the scene and no arrests have been made. Officials believe the area was abandoned shortly after the surveillance began. Nearly 2,000 plants were seized and police estimate the total value of the operation at $1 ...
Car Sharing: Social Media, Insurance and a New Model of Ownership
2010-09-10
With car-sharing pools growing in popularity for economic and environmental reasons, California is poised to take the concept to a new level. In June, the California General Assembly unanimously passed a bill that would enable owners to share their cars within car-sharing pools and be reimbursed for gas, maintenance and depreciation without losing their personal car insurance coverage. If and when the legislation passes in the State Senate, the effect is likely to stimulate many more car-sharing programs across the country, including Florida.
The economic and environmental ...
Complex Property Division in New Jersey
2010-09-10
Dividing property will always be one of the most challenging aspects of a divorce. New Jersey law calls for the equitable distribution of property, but separating spouses can rarely agree on the proper definition of equitable at the beginning of divorce proceedings.
The division of property becomes even more challenging when the marital estate includes assets that have accumulated during marriage but have not yet fully matured.
For example, consider the division of stock options. When stock options are granted during a marriage but will not vest until after the divorce, ...
Business Valuation As Part of Divorce in New Jersey
2010-09-10
Money matters often are among the most controversial aspects of a divorce. While other aspects of the divorce may be open to compromise based on the particular interests of the respective spouses, money is ultimately a zero-sum endeavor; every dollar assigned to one spouse is a dollar the other does not have.
Accordingly, issues such as the equitable distribution of property and alimony are at the heart of many disputes. Although these are clearly related issues, they must be considered independently. When a family-owned business has provided a significant source of ...
PA Governor Proposes Highway Cameras to Identify Uninsured Drivers
2010-09-10
Drivers in Pennsylvania are required to carry automobile insurance. Unquestionably, this is important to protect the interests of drivers and passengers on the roads. Insurance coverage ensures that that when an individual is responsible for a car accident, those harmed by the accident are not forced to deal with the financial consequences alone.
However, a recent proposal by Gov. Ed Rendell has many questioning how far the state should go to enforce this law.
In an effort to combat budget shortfalls, Gov. Rendell has suggested using cameras to catch those who are ...
Disruptive Behaviors of Medical Professionals Injure Patients
2010-09-10
As patients, we trust medical professionals to act as, well, professionals. With lives quite literally on the line, we assume that doctors will take their obligations seriously and adhere to the highest standards of professional responsibility.
Unfortunately, as a new report by the Pennsylvania Patient Safety Authority (PPSA) indicates, this trust is sometimes misplaced. In far too many cases, doctors put patient health and safety at risk through unprofessional behavior. According to the report, the PPSA found 177 incidents of "disruptive behavior" in the state over ...
Rules of the Road for Truckers
2010-09-10
Truckers have to comply with the rules of the road of every state in which they operate. In addition, the federal government, under the auspices of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA), has its own rules for truckers at 49 C.F.R. Part 392.
FMCSA Regulations on Operation of Large Commercial Vehicles
According to FMCSA rules, drivers may not operate their vehicles when their attention is impaired by fatigue, illness or any other cause that makes operation of a vehicle unsafe. More detailed regulations regarding the number of hours that may be logged ...
The Harley Medical Group Reports Surge in Liposuction Procedures
2010-09-10
The Harley Medical Group has reported thousands of enquiries for liposuction over the last month as a wave of what is termed 'beach envy' - jealousy of other women's bodies - hit holidaymakers.
The rise has been driven largely by 30-plus women, with clinic staff reporting patient feedback that suggests Victoria Beckham has the most coveted star stomach. Abdominoplasty surgery enquiries are also up 32% over the last two months with some patients even taking their summer holidays as 'surgery breaks', using the time off to recover before returning to work rejuvenated.
Liz ...
Bigmouthmedia Hires Fiona Robertson as Head of Affiliates and Performance
2010-09-10
On the back of the recent affiliate wins, Fiona Robertson (nee MacPherson) has been hired by bigmouthmedia to head up the Affiliates and Performance service. As well as running the team that works on the affiliate campaigns, Robertson will be responsible for the overall growth strategy of bigmouthmedia's affiliate and performance offering. Bigmouthmedia's current affiliate clients include Best Western, Habitat, Macdonald Hotels and Kwik Fit Insurance, amongst many others.
Fiona, who sits on the IAB's Affiliate Marketing Council, has over 6 years experience in affiliate ...
ChamonixInfo.com to Give Chamonix a Caffeine Boost
2010-09-10
Chamonixinfo.com, a leading resort information portal, has linked up with local delicatessen Papillon, in an exclusive deal to offer visitors to Chamonixinfo.com a free coffee when they make a purchase at the Papillon shop in Chamonix town centre.
Open since the beginning of 2010, Papillon has gained a fleet of fans looking for a good mug of coffee, a tasty lunch, a sweet or savory snack and even full meals all to take away. Food is freshly cooked on the premises, using quality ingredients and with a varying daily menu. The offer is open to travellers visiting Chamonix ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Dr. Gianluca Ianiro wins a prestigious grant from the European Research Council (ERC)
‘Rogue’ DNA rings reveal earliest clues to deadly brain cancer’s growth
Clinical study deepens understanding of mesothelioma and opens the door to potential treatment options
New study and major data updates expand the Kids First data ecosystem
Seaweed snare: Sargassum stops sea turtle hatchlings in their tracks
Scientists uncover key to decoupling economic growth from pollution in developing countries
Frailty fuels gut imbalance and post-surgery gastrointestinal risks
BMS-986504 demonstrates durable responses in MTAP-deleted NSCLC, including EGFR and ALK-positive tumors
Phase III trial finds hypofractionated radiotherapy with chemotherapy offers comparable survival and lower toxicity to conventional schedule in LS-SCLC
Lung cancer screening benefits adults up to age 80 if surgical candidates, UK study finds
Video assisted thoracoscopy surgery reduces mortality by 21 percent compared to lobectomy
NADIM ADJUVANT trial suggests benefit of adjuvant chemo-immunotherapy in resected stage IB–IIIA NSCLC
EA5181 phase 3 trial finds no OS benefit for concurrent and consolidative durvalumab vs consolidation alone in unresectable stage 3 NSCLC
Training to improve memory
Are patients undergoing surgery for early-stage cancer at risk of persistent opioid use?
Black youth, especially Black girls, use mental health services less than their White peers
Canada must protect youth from sports betting advertising
First-in-human trial shows promising results for DLL3-targeted antibody-drug conjugate SHR-4849 in relapsed small cell lung cancer
Ifinatamab deruxtecan demonstrates high response rate in previously treated extensive-stage small cell lung cancer: Phase 2 IDeate-Lung01 trial
Higher blood pressure in childhood linked to earlier death from heart disease in adulthood
AI helped older adults report accurate blood pressure readings at home
High blood pressure in childhood and premature cardiovascular disease mortality
Zidesamtinib shows durable responses in ROS1 TKI pre-treated NSCLC, including patients with CNS disease and ROS1 G2032R mutations
Crizotinib fails to improve disease-free survival in resected early-stage ALK+ NSCLC
Ivonescimab plus chemotherapy improves progression-free survival in patients with EGFR+ NSCLC following 3rd-generation EGFR-TKI therapy
FLAURA2 trial shows osimertinib plus chemotherapy improves overall survival in eGFR-mutated advanced NSCLC
Aumolertinib plus chemotherapy improves progression-free survival in NSCLC with EGFR and concomitant tumor suppressor genes: ACROSS 2 phase III study
New antibody-drug conjugate shows promising efficacy in EGFR-mutated NSCLC patients
Iza-Bren in combination with osimertinib shows 100% response rate in EGFR-mutated NSCLC, phase II study finds
COMPEL study shows continuing osimertinib treatment through progression with the addition of chemotherapy improves progression-free survival in EGFR-mutated NSCLC
[Press-News.org] New Jersey Supreme Court Opinion Affects DWI Implied Consent LawA recent New Jersey Supreme Court decision requires police to explain the implied consent law to motorists suspected of DUI in a language they understand.