Tennessee Tort "Reform": Calculating the Incalculable

So-called tort reform, in the guise of the Tennessee Civil Justice Act of 2011, is anything but civil justice for injured people.

2011-04-20

April 20, 2011 (Press-News.org) If a patient dies because of medical malpractice, a person loses her mobility because of a reckless driver in a motor vehicle accident, or severe injury is suffered because of a defective product or device, one thing is certain: A jury can tally the medical bills and lost earnings, but it's impossible to tally the losses that matter even more -- noneconomic damages like pain and suffering.

For that reason, we leave the question of noneconomic damages to juries. Only jurors, after they have heard stories of loss, are in the best position to determine what those losses are worth in dollars and cents.

But a proposal by Tennessee Governor Bill Haslam, House Bill 2008, looks to take that decision away from juries. If passed, the bill would cap noneconomic damages at $750,000 and punitive damages at $500,000, or two times the amount of compensatory damages awarded (whichever is greater). Damages for certain catastrophic injuries would be capped at one million dollars.

The Decades-Long Push for Tort Reform

Beginning in the mid-twentieth century, "tort reform" became a significant issue of public debate in the 1980s. In just two years (1985 and 1986), 41 states passed tort reform statutes that limited liability in civil lawsuits. Today, the debate continues at both the national and state levels, impacting health care reform and budget discussions.

Proponents of tort reform claim that it would save millions of dollars, reduce the cost of liability insurance, and protect professionals and companies from frivolous lawsuits. Most tort reform bills focus on medical malpractice and cite soaring malpractice premiums that are said to push physicians out of practice.

Governor Haslam has not padded his push for tort reform with medical malpractice language. Instead, he focuses on limiting products liability claims to keep Tennessee manufacturing companies competitive. However, the bill does not only focus on manufacturing-based products liability claims. It covers all civil tort actions, including medical malpractice, nursing home negligence, truck accidents, toxic tort cases and many other types of personal injury cases.

Proposed Cap on Noneconomic Damages

Tort reform does not seek to limit economic damages. Economic damages cover the actual financial losses that a plaintiff suffered or will suffer, including medical expenses, property damage and loss of income. Noneconomic damages, on the other hand, are subjective. They allow for financial recovery for pain and suffering, emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life, loss of consortium and other unquantifiable losses. Noneconomic damages are particularly important in wrongful death cases, where economic damages are insignificant when compared to the immense emotional trauma that families face when a loved one is lost.

Under House Bill 2008, "health care liability action" damages are capped at $750,000 per occurrence, while other personal injury damages are capped at $750,000 per plaintiff.

Proposed Cap on Punitive Damages

Punitive damages punish defendants after reckless or malicious actions. While not commonly rewarded, punitive damages can dissuade companies and individuals from causing future harm.

House Bill 2008 caps punitive damages at $500,000 or two times the total amount of compensatory damages (economic and noneconomic damages) awarded. It does not apply to cases involving felony actions or drunk driving (or driving under the influence of drugs).

Tort Reform's Impact on Injured Individuals and Families

Many individuals view tort reform favorably until they suffer an injury or lose a loved one. It's only then that they recognize the impact that a serious accident can have on someone's life. During testimony before the Tennessee House Judiciary Subcommittee, a mother and father told of their five-year old daughter's routine tonsillectomy gone horribly wrong. Due to medical malpractice, they lost their daughter to what should have been a simple procedure. Their child obviously did not have any income. Besides medical bills and funeral expenses, the parents would have no other source of recovery other than noneconomic damages - and a lesser sense of justice served.

We trust juries as fact-finders. A jury's sole job is to hear the case and come to a consensus about the facts. Juries are fully capable of deciding what a child's life is worth in a tragic medical malpractice case, or any other type of case that involves serious injury or wrongful death. Should the legislature make this decision instead?

Proponents claim that tort reform will save money and protect physicians, manufacturing companies and others from frivolous lawsuits. Yet, it is unlikely that caps on noneconomic damages and punitive damages will lower the cost of manufacturing or healthcare. Medical negligence, not medical malpractice lawsuits, is the primary problem. Research study after research study has shown:

- There are far fewer medical negligence cases than there are injured patients
- Very few frivolous claims actually succeed
- The increase in malpractice premiums was not caused by an increase in malpractice payouts

Tennessee House Bill 2008 is formally the "Tennessee Civil Justice Act of 2011." Is this civil justice? If you believe that protecting patient safety is more important than protecting insurance companies' bottom lines, you should say "no" to tort reform.

Article provided by Gatti Keltner Bienvenu & Montesi, PLC
Visit us at www.gkbm.com

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Study suggests another look at testosterone-prostate cancer link

2011-04-20

BOSTON – The long-standing prohibition against testosterone therapy in men with untreated or low-risk prostate cancer merits reevaluation, according to a new study published in The Journal of Urology. "For many decades it had been believed that a history of prostate cancer, even if treated and cured, was an absolute contraindication to testosterone therapy, due to the belief that testosterone activated prostate cancer growth, and could potentially cause dormant cancer cells to grow rapidly," says Abraham Morgentaler, MD of Men's Health Boston. "Generations of medical ...

Study confirms link between breast implants and rare form of cancer

2011-04-20

Breast implants appear to be associated with a rare form of lymphoma, but there is not yet evidence to show that the cancer is caused by implants or to suggest an underlying mechanism for how the disease might develop, according to a study by researchers from the RAND Corporation. The study, published online by the journal Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, also finds that the disease takes a slow course and can be controlled by surgical removal of the implant and surrounding capsule. The conclusions are based on an exhaustive review of the medical literature regarding ...

Encore of corporate tax holiday unlikely to stimulate economy

2011-04-20

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. — A repeat of a corporate tax holiday that found little success in stimulating the economy in 2005 is still a long-shot to jump-start a stagnant U.S. economy, says a University of Illinois expert in corporate and international taxation. Dhammika Dharmapala, a professor of law at Illinois, says that while the idea of a tax holiday has found favor among some politicians and presidential hopefuls looking to jolt the country out of the financial doldrums, it would have little positive effect on economic growth. "Ostensibly, the aim is to increase domestic ...

Recent Georgia Case Reinforces that Enterprise Goodwill of a Professional Business Is Marital Property

2011-04-20

When a couple decides that it is time to end their marriage they face many challenges, not the least of which is dividing the marital property. While there are exceptions, marital property is generally defined as property that is acquired after the date of marriage and before a spouse files for divorce. This can include a house, vehicles, bank accounts, debts, retirement funds and business interest. The division of marital property at times can be fairly straight forward and at other times very complex -- dividing a closely-held or family business is one of the most ...

Pennsylvania Legislature Implements New Measures to Curb Independent Contractor Misclassification by Construction Firms

2011-04-20

Independent contractors are widely utilized in the construction business to help reduce costs and bring in valuable outside expertise. For employers, using independent contractors means employment tax savings and the avoidance of certain labor laws. But, problems arise when employers start calling regular employees "independent contractors." Misclassified workers miss out on a number of benefits, including workers' compensation rights, unemployment insurance, and the ability to collectively bargain. In the construction industry, misclassification of employees ...

Gulf oil spill similar to Exxon Valdez in initial social and mental impacts, study finds

2011-04-20

The BP Deepwater Horizon oil spill caused social disruption and psychological stress among Gulf residents that is similar to the aftermath of the Exxon Valdez spill and the impacts are likely to persist for years, a new study finds. "Just ask the residents of Cordova today whether they are over the Exxon Valdez," said study co-author Liesel Ritchie, assistant director for research of the University of Colorado Boulder's Natural Hazards Center. The Alaska community was considered "ground zero" for the 1989 oil spill. The research was a collaborative effort among Ritchie, ...

Florida Courts May Begin Dismissing Foreclosure Lawsuits

2011-04-20

Homeowners facing foreclosure could see additional, although potentially short-term, relief from the Florida courts in the near future. Those with pending foreclosure actions that have not moved forward may see the case against them dismissed by the court because the bank has essentially abandoned the case or has not moved closer to concluding the action. Courts across the country are perpetually overwhelmed with cases; judges often struggle to keep their dockets moving along in a timely manner. To address the number of cases and to ensure that courts do not get bogged ...

Shared Custody in Illinois

2011-04-20

In today's modern families it is common for fathers and mothers to both play active roles in the parenting of their children. When these marriages come to an end, one of the most troublesome problems is the issue of where the children will live. Illinois law provides two options to resolve custody disputes, namely Sole or Joint Custody. When applied traditionally either option unsatisfactorily results in the children residing primarily with one parent while the other parent exercises visitation and pays child support. The response to this problem in Illinois family ...

LSUHSC research discovery may block ALS disease process

2011-04-20

New Orleans, LA –In the first animal model of Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS), developed by Dr. Udai Pandey, Assistant Professor of Genetics at LSU Health Sciences Center New Orleans, Dr. Pandey's lab has found in fruit flies that blocking the abnormal movement of a protein made by a mutated gene called FUS also blocks the disease process. The research is available online in the Advanced Access section of the journal Human Molecular Genetics website, posted on April 12, 2011. It will be published in an upcoming issue of the journal. The fruit flies were engineered ...

Chicago's Red Light Cameras: Do They Curb Intersection Accidents?

2011-04-20

Chicago's streets are home to almost 400 red light cameras that monitor 190 of the city's most dangerous intersections. The program began in 2003, when the city installed cameras at two intersections: 55th and Western, and Peterson and Western. Since then, the city has issued millions of violations--763,419 in 2010 alone--and made millions of dollars in revenue from the red light cameras. The cameras are connected to the intersection's traffic lights. When the light turns red, any vehicle that passes under the sensor get its picture taken and is recorded on a video device. ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

C-Path announces key leadership appointments in neurodegenerative disease research

First-of-its-kind analysis of U.S. national data reveals significant disparities in individual well-being as measured by lifespan, education, and income