(Press-News.org) COLUMBUS, Ohio – A new study using sophisticated brain scans shows how simple line drawings can capture the essence of a beach or a mountain for viewers just as well as a photograph would.
Researchers found that viewing a "beach" scene depicted in a line drawing activated nearly the same patterns of brain activity in study participants as did viewing an actual color photograph of a beach. The same was true when people viewed line drawings and photographs of other natural scenes including city streets, forests, highways, mountains and offices.
Even when researchers removed up to 75 percent of the pixels in a line drawing, people still did better than chance at determining what the lines represented -- as long as the remaining lines showed the broad contours of the scene.
"Our results suggest that our brains can recreate whole detailed scenes from just a few lines, said Dirk Bernhardt-Walther, lead author of the study and assistant professor of psychology at Ohio State University.
"The representations in our brain for categorizing these scenes seem to be a bit more abstract than some may have thought – we don't need features such as texture and color to tell a beach from a street scene," he said.
Walther conducted the study with Barry Chai and Li Fei-Fei of Stanford University and Eamon Caddigan and Diane Beck with the University of Illinois. Their results appear in the online early edition of the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
For the study, 10 participants viewed color photographs and line drawings of six categories of scenes -- beaches, city streets, forests, highways, mountains and offices -- while their brains were scanned using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI).
The fMRI images showed the researchers what was going on in several areas of the participants' brains when they viewed the photos and line drawings. The most significant results occurred in the parahippocomal place area (PPA), an area of the brain that scientists know plays an important role in the encoding and recognition of scenes (rather than faces or objects).
Using the data from when participants viewed the color photos, the researchers trained a software-based decoder to tell what type of scene the participants viewed -- a beach, mountain, etc., -- based on the patterns of brain activity in the PPA revealed in the fMRI.
The decoder was far from perfect, but it did better than chance at predicting what scene a person was viewing in a particular fMRI image.
Most importantly, the decoder could do just as well at predicting which scene a person viewed when it was focused on line drawings as it was on photographs. In fact, the decoder did slightly better -- although not significantly so -- at predicting line drawings compared to photographs in the primary visual cortex.
"We expected that line drawings would be good enough to allow some decoding, but it was surprising that there was no benefit to photographs -- the decoder was no better when it was used on photos than it was on line drawings," Walther said.
Findings showed that when the decoder was trained on photographs, it still did equally well at predicting which scenes people were viewing in line drawings, and vice versa.
"That suggests the brain uses the same information to decode which scene it is viewing when it is presented with line drawings or photos," he said.
In addition, results showed that when the decoder did make errors, it made similar errors in both photographs and line drawings. For example, if the decoder thought people were looking at a photo of a mountain when they were really looking at a photo of a forest, it would make the same mistake when it was analyzing line drawings.
"The patterns of error match incredibly well, so that's an additional piece of evidence that the representations for photos and line drawings are very similar in the brain," Bernhardt-Walther said.
But what is it about line drawings that allow people to recognize what they represent? As part of the study, the researchers removed some of the lines in the line drawings and asked participants if they could still tell what scene was depicted. In some cases, they removed up to 75 percent of the pixels in the drawing.
If the researchers left the long contours in the drawings, which represented global structure -- such as sky, water or sand -- participants could still correctly predict what kind of scene was depicted about 60 percent of the time.
However, when researchers took out these long contours and left only short ones -- representing details like leaves, windows in buildings or individual ridges in a mountainside -- the accuracy of participants went way down.
These findings cast doubt on some models of human visual perception which argue that people need specific information that is found in photographs -- such as color, shading and texture -- to classify a scene.
"Of course, we use the rich sources of information found in a photograph when it is available, but the brain is an opportunist -- it uses what is available," Walther said. "We can get a lot of information from a line drawing."
The results also suggest why line drawings have played such an important role in human history, both as an art form and a way of presenting information simply.
"Imagine the astonishment of early man when he discovered he could draw shapes on a rock wall and it resembled the actual animal he had just killed. Line drawings have been with us since prehistoric times," Walther said.
###
The research was funded with a grant from the National Institutes of Health.
Contact: Dirk Bernhardt-Walther, (614) 688-3923; Bernhardt-Walther.1@osu.edu (Email is the best way to reach Dr. Berhhardt-Walther.)
Written by Jeff Grabmeier, (614) 292-8457; Grabmeier.1@osu.edu
END
WASHINGTON — Even healthy adults with a safe driving record tend to make more driving errors as they age, including potentially dangerous mistakes, such as failing to check blind spots, according to a study published by the American Psychological Association.
Most studies of older drivers have focused on people with dementia or other conditions that might impair their performance behind the wheel. This study, conducted in Australia, comprised 266 volunteers age 70 to 88 who showed no signs of dementia, lived independently and drove at least once a week. The results ...
For those soldiers worried about the stigma associated with seeing a therapist, virtual reality applications for the treatment of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) may be the alternative to the traditional "talk therapy." A new paper¹, by Albert Rizzo from the University of Southern California, Institute for Creative Technologies, Los Angeles, and his team, reviews how virtual reality applications are being designed and implemented across various points in the military deployment cycle, to prevent, identify and treat combat-related PTSD.
Their findings are published ...
Global Banking and Finance Review, has awarded PT Bank Tabungan Negara (Persero) Tbk "The Best Investor Service Provider" in Indonesia 2011. BTN was chosen after a series of assessments by industry analysts on several important parameters. The parameters include strength of the management, innovation, transparency, and ability to serve the complaint.
The Director of BTN, Iqbal Latanro said this award is an appreciation for the excellent quality of BTN service to stakeholders, especially investors.
About PT Bank Tabungan Negara (Persero) Tbk
PT Bank ...
COLUMBUS, Ohio – The anti-inflammatory drug celecoxib, known by the brand name Celebrex, triggers liver cancer cell death by reacting with a protein in a way that makes those cells commit suicide, according to a new study.
Researchers also found that the combination of celecoxib with each of two chemotherapy drugs killed more liver cancer cells in culture, making those combinations more effective than either drug on its own.
"Each chemotherapy drug alone will reduce the growth of cancer cells, but when each single drug is combined with Celebrex, a greater growth suppression ...
COLUMBUS, Ohio – A pattern of earthen berms, spread across a northern peninsula of the big island of Hawaii, is providing archeologists with clues to exactly how residents farmed in paradise long before Europeans arrived at the islands.
The findings suggest that simple, practical decisions made by individual households were eventually adopted by the ruling class as a means to improve agricultural productivity.
The research was reported in the latest issue of the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
"Archeologically, this kind of research is really ...
Obese, asthmatic, anxious or depressed children are more likely to experience excessive daytime sleepiness, or EDS, according to Penn State College of Medicine sleep researchers.
"Although EDS in children is commonly assumed by physicians and the public to be the result of sleep-disordered breathing or inadequate sleep, our data suggest that EDS in young children is more strongly associated with obesity and mood issues as it is in adults," said Edward Bixler, Ph.D., professor of psychiatry and vice chair of research, Sleep Research and Treatment Center.
EDS is the inability ...
What does it take to regenerate a limb? Biologists have long thought that organ regeneration in animals like zebrafish and salamanders involved stem cells that can generate any tissue in the body. But new research suggests that multiple cell types are needed to regrow the complete organ, at least in zebrafish.
Researchers at Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis have shown that cells capable of regenerating a zebrafish fin do not revert to stem cells that can form any tissue. Instead, the individual cells retain their original identities and only give ...
(Boston) – Researchers from Boston University School of Medicine (BUSM), along with clinicians from Boston Medical Center (BMC), have found gastroenterologist knowledge of the appropriate immunizations to recommend to the inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) patient is limited. These findings, which currently appear on-line in Inflammatory Bowel Diseases, may be the primary reason why the majority of gastroenterologists believe that the primary care provider (PCP) should be responsible for vaccinations.
Current therapy for IBD patients often involves agents that suppress ...
Island Eye Surgicenter is only the fourth surgical facility to acquire this advanced technology in the US. Island Eye Surgicenter located in Carle Place is unique in that it focuses on the surgical care and treatment of eye disorders and specializes in the most advanced laser cataract surgery on Long Island.
Cataract surgery is one of the most common and safest surgeries performed in the US today. The Alcon LenSx Femtosecond Laser gives the surgeon precision and reliability vastly improving patient outcomes.This new procedure is extraordinary, and with this new technology, ...
For years Professor Leo von Hemmen, a biophysicist at the TU Muenchen, and Professor Bruce Young, a biologist at the University of Massachusetts Lowell, have been researching the sense of hearing in snakes. While discussing the toxicity of their snakes, it dawned on them that only few snakes inject their venom into their victims' bodies using hollow poison fangs. Yet, even though the vast majority of poisonous reptiles lack hollow fangs, they are effective predators.
Only around one seventh of all poisonous snakes, like the rattlesnake, rely on the trick with the hollow ...
