(Press-News.org) This press release is available in German.
In a widely noticed study, developmental psychologists reported that 14-month-old infants imitate an unusual action if it was chosen deliberately by the person they observed, but not if it could be attributed to external constraints. This selective imitation was put forth as evidence for an early understanding of rational action and action goals. Scientists at the Max Planck Institute for Human Cognitive and Brain Sciences in Leipzig now present a much simpler explanation for the finding. A replication study revealed that the observed differences in imitation were likely caused by a distraction during the experiments.
Infant imitation is a key factor in early learning and has been studied by developmental psychologists for a long time. In 2002, a study published in the journal Nature seemingly showed astonishing cognitive abilities in children that were only 14 months old. In the experiment, a child would observe an adult performing the unconventional action of illuminating a lamp by touching it with the head. Being presented with the lamp later on, 70 percent of the children would copy this curious behaviour – but only if the hands of the person were free during the observed action. If the hands were occupied by holding a blanket wrapped around the body, which was before worn loosely over the shoulders, imitation rates dropped to around 20 percent.
This result has been explained with the children evaluating the rationality of the model's actions. Had the model freely chosen to use her head for illuminating the lamp, they may have assumed that there must be good reasons for it. But if the model acted under obvious constraints that they themselves did not have, there was no reason to imitate. It seemed that infants were able not only to understand the goals but also to follow the situational context of the observed behaviour.
This interpretation may now have to be revised, due to a factor that had previously not been taken into account. "The eye-catching sight of the person wrapped in a blanket may have distracted infants from the action they were observing", says Miriam Beisert of the Research Group "Infant Cognition and Action". To test if the outcome of the experiment was indeed influenced, the scientists replicated the original study, but added two additional conditions.
One alteration underlined how much eye- catching distractions influenced the children's response: When two red Smileys were put on the table before the experiment, imitation of the "hands-free"-condition dropped considerably. In order to reduce distraction during the second condition, the children were given time to familiarize themselves with the sight of the blanket in a five-minute warm-up phase, which preceded the demonstration of the head touch action. The imitation rate went up to around 70 percent, showing that it made no actual difference whether the model person's hands were free or not.
"Assuming rational imitation, seeing the blanket-wrapped person for a longer time should have, if anything, resulted in an even lower imitation rate", says Moritz Daum, head of the research group. "With these results, rational thinking can be ruled out as a reason for children's selective imitation at this age."
INFORMATION:
Original publication:
Beisert M, Zmyj N, Liepelt R, Jung F, Prinz W, et al. (2012) Rethinking 'Rational Imitation' in 14-Month-Old Infants: A Perceptual Distraction Approach.
PLoS ONE 7(3): e32563. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032563
Young infants' imitation not guided by rational thinking
Rationality of infants has been overstated
2012-03-27
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
9 million bicycles, but what about the cars in Beijing?
2012-03-27
Forget the fact of there being "9 million bicycles in Beijing, that's not a fact. Indeed, motor vehicle traffic is fast becoming a big problem that has led to unsustainable pollution and draconian rules in some parts of the city. Now, Nan Ji of the Hebei United University in China and colleagues have developed an algorithm to help traffic planners optimize the flow of traffic across roundabouts.
Writing in the International Journal of Innovative Computing and Applications, Ji and colleagues at the Tangshan Tanggang Expressway Management Office and Tian Jin Polytechnic ...
Rio+20 must radically rethink innovation
2012-03-27
A radical new approach to innovation is urgently needed to ensure a fair and green economy and avoid reversing progress made on global poverty reduction, according to leading scientists.
Ahead of the United Nations Conference on Sustainable Development, or Rio+20, the ESRC STEPS Centre calls on negotiators to rethink the way science and innovation can contribute to the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that are likely to emerge from Rio.
Rio+20 is a golden opportunity to enhance the role that science, technology and innovation of many kinds can play in building ...
School-based mental health support results in positive outcomes for children
2012-03-27
A study of more than 18,000 children across England found that embedding mental health support in schools as part of the Targeted Mental Health in Schools (TaMHS) programme led to greater improvements in self-reported behavioural problems among primary pupils. The benefits were even more pronounced where schools also provided pupils with self-help leaflets explaining how children could help themselves if they were feeling stressed or troubled.
The three year longitudinal study followed children in 25 local authorities across England and also found that tools designed ...
U of Toronto discovery of new catalyst promises cheaper, greener drugs
2012-03-27
A chemistry team at the University of Toronto has discovered environmentally-friendly iron-based nanoparticle catalysts that work as well as the expensive, toxic, metal-based catalysts that are currently in wide use by the drug, fragrance and food industry.
"It is always important to strive to make industrial syntheses more green, and using iron catalysts is not only much less toxic, but it is also much more cost effective," said Jessica Sonnenberg, a PhD student and lead author of a paper published this week in the Journal of the American Chemical Society.
The research, ...
Michigan's tourism industry to grow in 2012
2012-03-27
GRAND RAPIDS, Mich. -- Tourism spending in Michigan jumped a surprising 8 percent in 2011 and should increase by a healthy 6 percent clip this year, reflecting the ongoing economic recovery, Michigan State University researchers said in their annual tourism report.
Michigan's $17-billion-a-year tourism market – one of the state's largest industries – should have a "very strong" 2012, said Dan McCole, assistant professor of tourism.
"As long as the weather is good – and that's always the big 'if' – I think we're going to see a very strong year for tourism," McCole said.
McCole ...
AsiaRooms.com - Enjoy Classical Performances at Seoul's 2012 Orchestra Festival
2012-03-27
Seoul is to become a hotbed of classical music performances in April when the 2012 Orchestra Festival takes place for the 24th time.
The annual event will see 18 symphony orchestras from around the country giving a series of performances, as well as two college orchestras, the Unpa Memorial orchestra and Korea's version of the El Sistema Aloysius Orchestra.
Running from April 1st to 24th, the shows will be held at the Seoul Arts Center's concert hall, with pieces from composers such as Wagner, Liszt, Tchaikovsky, Shostakovich, Dvorak, Stravinsky, Elgar and more ...
Study suggests better survival with bypass surgery compared to coronary angioplasty
2012-03-27
CHICAGO -- Patients with coronary heart disease and their doctors have long been challenged by the decision of whether to pursue bypass surgery or opt for the less-invasive percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI, which includes stenting and balloon angioplasty). New evidence reveals bypass surgery appears to carry a higher long-term survival rate, according to research presented today at the American College of Cardiology's 61st Annual Scientific Session. The Scientific Session, the premier cardiovascular medical meeting, brings cardiovascular professionals together to ...
AsiaRooms.com - Pattaya to Host 2012 Thailand Junior and Cadet Open Table Tennis Tournament
2012-03-27
The International Table Tennis Federation (ITTF) will be holding its 2012 Thailand Junior and Cadet Open tournament from May 5th to 9th.
Taking place at the Pattaya Sports Stadium, it is the first ever ITTF Premium Junior Circuit event to be held in Thailand and will see up to 170 players - including local star Tamolwan Khetkuen - taking part in competitive matches.
Singles, doubles and team events will be taking place in the junior and cadet categories, as well as singles events in the Hopes category.
Competitors will be playing for a chance to win their share ...
Cardiac CT is faster, more effective for evaluating patients with suspected heart attack
2012-03-27
CHICAGO -- Cardiac computed tomography angiography scans (CT scans that look at the heart) can provide a virtually instant verdict on whether chest pain is from blockage of the coronary arteries. When used early to evaluate chest pain, the scans save patients and hospitals time and money by allowing doctors to quickly determine who should be admitted for treatment for a heart attack and who can be safely sent home, according to research presented today at the American College of Cardiology's 61st Annual Scientific Session. The Scientific Session, the premier cardiovascular ...
Researchers find new way to abate heart attacks before patients get to the hospital
2012-03-27
CHICAGO -- Paramedics can reduce someone's chances of having a cardiac arrest or dying by 50 percent by immediately administering a mixture of glucose, insulin and potassium ("GIK") to people having a heart attack, according to research presented today at the American College of Cardiology's 61st Annual Scientific Session. The Scientific Session, the premier cardiovascular medical meeting, brings cardiovascular professionals together to further advances in the field.
The study showed that patients who received GIK immediately after being diagnosed with acute coronary ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Standardizing frailty indexes to improve preclinical aging research
Hanbat National University researchers present new technique to boost solid oxide fuel cell performance
Even short school breaks affect student learning unevenly across socioeconomic backgrounds
When words matter: Language and culture shape early childhood outcomes
UBC enzyme technology clears first human test toward universal donor organs for transplantation
Birds’ vocal warnings provide new insight into the origins of language
Breakthrough results from elephant herpesvirus trial find vaccine to be safe
Final step in the biosynthesis of iridoids elucidated
New antibiotic targets IBD — and AI predicted how it would work before scientists could prove it
Glioblastomas affect much more than just the brain
Researchers uncover why mental maps fade with age
New mechanism revealed: How leukemia cells trick the immune system
Genetic map reveals influence of DNA on metabolism
Researchers use ultrasound holograms to influence brain networks
Unique videos show how trawling restrictions brings back life to the sea
Whooping cough can be fatal in young infants, experts warn
Knee-d for excellence: New regional training hub keeps surgeons sharp for ageing population
The Lancet: Billions lack access to healthy diets as food systems drive climate and health crises, but sustainable, equitable solutions are within reach, says new EAT-Lancet report
Countries with highest reported levels of hearing loss have lowest use of hearing aids
Early medical abortion at home up to 12 weeks is safe, effective, and comparable to hospital care
New approach to gravitational wave detection opens the Milli-Hz Frontier
Rice membrane extracts lithium from brines with greater speed, less waste
Exercise lowers disease risk. This researcher wants to understand how
Hurricane evacuation patterns differ based on where the storm hits
Stem Cell Reports welcomes new members to its Editorial Board
Researchers develop molecular qubits that communicate at telecom frequencies
Mayo Clinic awarded up to $40 million by ARPA-H for pioneering air safety research
People with Down syndrome have early neuroinflammation
CNIO researchers create the “human repairome”, a catalogue of DNA “scars” that will help define personalized cancer treatments
Strengthening biosecurity screening for genes that encode proteins of concern
[Press-News.org] Young infants' imitation not guided by rational thinkingRationality of infants has been overstated