Generic Drug Manufacturers Are Immune From Labeling Lawsuits

In 2011, the U.S. Supreme Court held that people harmed by generic prescription drugs cannot sue generic manufacturers under the claim of inadequate warning labels.

2012-06-14

June 14, 2012 (Press-News.org) In 2011, the U.S. Supreme Court held that people harmed by generic prescription drugs cannot sue generic manufacturers under the claim of inadequate warning labels. In PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing, the High Court dismissed the legal claims of two women who suffered physical injury because of the inadequate warning labels on their generic medication.

While the Court ruled in 2009 that injured plaintiffs could bring state law claims against pharmaceutical companies for poor labeling on name-brand drugs, the PLIVA ruling bars similar suits against manufacturers of the generic versions of those same medications.

Why the Discrepancy?

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approves and regulates pharmaceutical drugs, including the labels warning of potential health risks from their use. Federal law requires the labels on generic medications to mirror the FDA-approved versions on their name-brand counterparts.

The claims against PLIVA were brought under state laws requiring adequate consumer warnings on prescription labels. However, federal law governs the content of those labels. The Court held that it is impossible for PLIVA and other generic manufacturers to comply with both the state and federal laws. As federal law trumps any conflicting state law, the Court ruled that by federal law preempts the state law claims.

Impact on Plaintiffs

The PLIVA case eliminates 100 percent of potential failure to warn claims against generic pharmaceutical manufacturers as they are now essentially immune from inadequate warning liability. The ruling also eliminates about 70 percent of all potential failure to warn cases as approximately 70 percent of prescriptions are in generic form. This leaves a significant number of consumers without redress for their injuries, pain and suffering.

What Remedies are Available?

Plaintiffs' attorneys may now need to rely on a negligence theory or claims that the generic manufacturer failed to suggest label changes knowing of specific safety risks. However, the validity and strength of such theories is largely untested and unknown. The unfortunate reality is that consumers of generic prescription drugs may have no true remedy for injuries from defective drugs.

Faulty prescription drugs can cause life long and life altering disabilities. If prescription drugs have harmed you or a loved one, contact an experienced attorney to discuss your situation and your options.

Article provided by Cavanagh Law Group
Visit us at www.cavanaghlawgroup.com

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Sending sexually explicit photos by cell phone -- more common among teens than you might think

2012-06-14

A significant number of teenagers are sending and receiving sexually explicit cell phone photos, often with little, if any, awareness of the possible psychological, interpersonal, and sometimes legal consequences of doing so. Even many of those who believe there could be serious legal consequences are undeterred and still choose to engage in 'sexting'. These findings by Donald Strassberg, from the University of Utah (US), and colleagues are published online in Springer's journal Archives of Sexual Behavior. New communication technologies play an increasingly important ...

Consortium of scientists maps the human body's bacterial ecosystem

2012-06-14

SAN FRANCISCO, CA—June 13, 2012—Scientists at the Gladstone Institutes today are announcing their role in an unprecedented collaboration organized by the National Institutes of Health, which used groundbreaking methods to vastly improve our understanding of bacteria that reside in and on the human body. In a series of coordinated scientific reports, some 200 members of the Human Microbiome Project (HMP) Consortium from nearly 80 research institutions used advanced DNA-sequencing techniques to identify the thousands of microorganisms that live on humans. Researchers believe ...

Worried About Kids' Overexposure to Radiation, FDA Asks for Safer X-rays

2012-06-14

Children are not just miniature versions of adults. Their rapidly-developing bodies have different physiological sensitivities, and pediatric medical care should reflect this. However, for years, the same CT scans, fluoroscopy procedures and other X-ray imaging techniques have been used on both adults and children. Now, concerned about cancer diagnosis and other potential ill-effects of kids' exposure to radiation, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration is calling for X-ray imaging devices that take into account the unique health care needs of children. Cancer-Causing ...

Good news on using recycled sewage treatment plant water for irrigating crops

2012-06-14

A new study eases concerns that irrigating crops with water released from sewage treatment plants — an increasingly common practice in arid areas of the world — fosters emergence of the antibiotic-resistant bacteria that cause thousands of serious infections each year. The research appears in ACS' journal Environmental Science & Technology. Eddie Cytryn and colleagues explain that a large fraction of antibiotics given to people or animals pass out of the body unchanged in the urine and are transferred via sewage systems to wastewater treatment facilities. These facilities ...

1960s-era anti-cancer drug points to treatments for Lou Gehrig's disease

2012-06-14

A long-used anti-cancer drug could be a starting point to develop new treatments for the incurable nerve disease known as Lou Gehrig's disease or amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), scientists are reporting. Their research showing how the drug prevents clumping of an enzyme linked to ALS appears in the Journal of the American Chemical Society. Lucia Banci, Ivano Bertini and colleagues explain that ALS causes a progressive loss of muscle control as the nerves that control body movements wither and die. Patients become weak and have difficulty swallowing and breathing, ...

Ancient effect harnessed to produce electricity from waste heat

2012-06-14

A phenomenon first observed by an ancient Greek philosopher 2,300 years ago has become the basis for a new device designed to harvest the enormous amounts of energy wasted as heat each year to produce electricity. The first-of-its-kind "pyroelectric nanogenerator" is the topic of a report in ACS' journal Nano Letters. Zhong Lin Wang and colleagues at Georgia Tech explain that more than 50 percent of the energy generated in the U.S. each year goes to waste, much of it as heat released to the environment by everything from computers to cars to long-distance electric transmission ...

Injured On the Job? New Workers' Comp Rules May Leave Your Head Spinning

2012-06-14

In the aftermath of a workplace injury, slicing through the red tape of the New York workers' compensation process is something you may be ill-equipped for. You just want to get better, and need the money you're entitled to in order to see you through your time of need. Now, a new set of medical testing regulations could further complicate your pursuit of workers' comp benefits. Regulations Require Workers to Go to In Network Testing Facilities Workers' compensation provides payments for wage replacement and medical expenses during the time an employee is incapacitated ...

More than 1 way to be healthy: Map of bacterial makeup of humans reveals microbial rare biosphere

2012-06-14

WOODS HOLE, MASS. – The landmark publication this week of a "map" of the bacterial make-up of healthy humans has deep roots in an unexpected place: the ocean. Microbial communities that live on and in the human body, known collectively as the microbiome, are thought to have a critical role in human health and disease. Five years ago, the National Institutes of Health launched the ambitious Human Microbiome Project (HMP) to define the boundaries of bacterial variation found in 242 healthy human beings. "In order to understand what sick is, it's helpful to define the ...

Elder Abuse: A Continuing Problem in the United States

2012-06-14

The National Academy on an Aging Society has released its Public Policy & Aging Report (PPAR) that finds as many as one in 10 people age 60 and over has suffered some form of elder abuse. The National Academy is the policy institute of The Gerontological Society of America. Elder abuse covers a broad range of mistreatment, from physical abuse in a nursing home, to other forms neglect, including psychological and sexual abuse, and financial exploitation by caregivers and family members. Seniors are at risk by a great number of causes. Some have diminished mental ...

Strategic Default a Valuable Option for Homeowners Drowning in Debt

2012-06-14

Many homeowners in Georgia are continuing to struggle with the current economic crisis. Despite reports of modest improvements in the economy, a lot of Georgians are still floundering in the weak housing market. Stresses are compounded for those dealing with job loss or having their hours cut back. These financial pressures are making it increasingly difficult for people to afford their mortgage payments. Falling Home Values Can Limit the Choices Available to Homeowners Unfortunately, this problem is compounded by the fact that home values continue to drop. Homes ...