July 25, 2012 (Press-News.org) Last month, a Federal District Court Judge in Indianapolis upheld an Indiana law prohibiting sex offenders from accessing social networking websites after the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) challenged the law as part of a class action on behalf of sex offenders. The judge reasoned that the law did not violate the constitutional rights of a defendant.
The constitutionality of banning sex offenders from Internet websites has been brought to light recently and continues to be a hot topic.
The Case
In the most recent case of Doe v. Prosecutor, Marion County, the court considered the challenge to Indiana's statute that restricts released sex offenders from using social networking sites like, Facebook, Twitter and any site that relies on social network sites that allow minors, including some newspaper sites.
Doe argued that the statute was not "narrowly tailored" to the states interest of protecting minors from being targeted by sex offenders. (When a statute imposes a burden on a First Amendment right, such as the freedom of association, it must be "narrowly tailored to serve a significant governmental interest" or else it will be deemed unconstitutional.)
The Law
The court found there was a significant governmental interest, protecting minors from sexual exploitation by sex offenders. The law was also conceded to be content neutral, in that it did not restrict the type of speech of a sex offender could use on the social network sites, as it simply prohibited any speech.
The court notes that a content neutral law will be upheld if it, "(1) is "narrowly tailored to serve a significant governmental interest"; and (2) "leave[s] open ample alternative channels for communication of the information." If the statute satisfies these criteria, then it is deemed to be a "reasonable time, place and manner regulation[.]"
While the court found that this law would prohibit registered sex offenders from accessing websites that permit minors to use them, including Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and others, the court did not believe this to be an impermissible restriction.
Doe had argued that the law would prohibit him, and others from, "making comments about current events on the Indianapolis Star web site; participating in political discussions in certain chat rooms; advertising for businesses using certain social networking sites; or sharing photos and having group discussions with family members through Facebook."
Nonetheless, the court reasoned that, "Mr. Doe (and those similarly situated) can still communicate through email, message boards, and social networking sites that require the user to be 18 years old." This, the court thinks, provides "ample alternative channels for communication of the information."
Other Cases Across the County
A decision earlier this year from Louisiana, however, struck down a state statute because it was, in fact, unconstitutional. The court found the law overbroad because it banned sex offenders who had completed the terms of their sentence from accessing virtually all Internet sites, including court websites.
In that case, terms within the statute were defined imprecisely or not at all. Some argued that the Act was "unintelligible to the public, unenforceable by police and prosecutors and uninterpretable by the judiciary."
In 2009, a federal judge in Nebraska found parts of Nebraska's law were overbroad and unconstitutional.
Future Litigation
Given the newness of social networking sites, (Facebook began in 2004) the full contour of their effect on society is still a work in process.
The Indiana court notes that Facebook now has 901 million users. Courts may find it difficult to prove, as Facebook and its progeny expand and become more influential, that banning all registered sex offenders is sufficiently narrowly tailored. It remains to be seen, however, what will become of this case as either side may appeal the decision.
A further challenge is also pending in Nebraska to that state's law.
As more states actively legislate in this area, and the societal significance of social network websites increases, it is likely the Supreme Court will eventually grant certiorari and provide the last word.
Article provided by Cleveland Law Firm
Visit us at www.utahcriminallawyer.com
Is it Constitutional to Ban Sex Offenders From Social Networks?
The constitutionality of banning sex offenders from internet websites has been brought to light amid a recent Indiana federal district court decision.
2012-07-25
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Texas Child Support Orders After the Age of Majority
2012-07-25
Most people understand the basics of child support. They know that child support payments are ordered to provide funds for the care and welfare of children. The money is generally paid with blanket instructions to the children's caregivers to use the money for the children's physical, mental, educational and religious upbringing, but some child support orders are more detailed, breaking down precisely how the money is to be spent.
Some child support orders are valid for particular lengths of time, and some are open-ended. For the most part, though, Texas child support ...
New Fall Protection Measures Soon to Take Effect
2012-07-25
In an effort to reduce the number of falls in residential construction projects, the Occupational Health and Safety Administration (OSHA) will soon begin its enforcement measures stemming from its latest residential fall protection directive (STD 03-11-002). Under this new directive, employers are required to provide roofers and construction workers with fall protection equipment whenever work is performed six feet or higher above the ground.
The new directive will become effective on September 15, 2012.
It allows workers to use a number of safety measures, including ...
Illinois Drivers Must Carry Liability, Uninsured Motorist Coverage
2012-07-25
Illinois requires all drivers to carry minimum amounts of automobile insurance to operate vehicles in the state. Unfortunately, some motorists choose to ignore this law, which means that drivers they injure in an accident could be left high and dry with burdensome medical costs. In anticipation of these situations, it is imperative that drivers purchase uninsured motorist insurance to cover themselves in the event of car accidents with uninsured motorists or hit-and-run accidents.
Minimum Uninsured Motorist Coverage in Illinois
Illinois requires that all drivers have ...
Taser Debate Increases as the Supreme Court Declines to Hear Excessive Force Cases
2012-07-25
The debate on whether Taser use by police officers constitutes excessive force is gaining more steam even after the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear two cases coming from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. In one case, a pregnant woman was shocked three times by Seattle police officers after she refused to sign a traffic ticket for driving 32 miles per hour in a 20 m.p.h. school zone. Another case involved a Hawaii woman who was "Tasered" while officers attempted to arrest her husband following a domestic abuse call.
Both women filed suit against ...
Understanding Summer Rental Car Insurance Options
2012-07-25
Now that summer is here, many Americans are taking vacations and consequently using rental cars at increasing rates. Navigating the convoluted world of car rental insurance can put a damper on the season's festivities. Fortunately, there are a few things consumers can learn and act upon to ensure they are protected in the event of a motor vehicle accident involving a rental car.
Rental Car Insurance Options
Car renters have a few options for rental car insurance, including coverage provided by their personal automotive policies, non-owner automotive insurance policies, ...
New Massachusetts Alimony Law Makes Divorce Less of a Gamble
2012-07-25
Until recently, the prospect of alimony in Massachusetts was filled with uncertainty for spouses in a divorce. Courts had significant latitude to order lifetime alimony, even after short marriages. Going to court to overturn alimony in a divorce could be a gamble.
Sparked in part by a Massachusetts man who spent more than $250,000 and entered bankruptcy after a judge refused to reduce his $45,000-a-year alimony payments, a task force of family law attorneys, legislators and others created a proposal for the most dramatic and fundamental changes to the state's divorce ...
Study: Connecticut Women Less Likely to Violate Cellphone Ban
2012-07-25
A recent study of Connecticut drivers has disproven the old myth that women can't stop talking on the phone. Since the law banning hand-held cellphones went into effect six years ago, men have consistently been ticketed more often than women for talking on hand-held cellphones or texting while driving.
The study, conducted by the Associated Press, found that, of the total number of drivers ticketed for distracted driving in 2006, between 52 and 54 percent were men. In 2011 alone, men received nearly 16,000 tickets while women got only 13,690; in 2010, the tally of tickets ...
Recent Crane Incidents in Texas Give Rise to Safety Questions
2012-07-25
Construction of the 420,000 square-foot Paragon Outlet Mall in Grand Prairie, Texas, is set to open late this summer - a boon for the city of Grand Prairie - but in 2011 it was the site of a fatal accident involving a crane and falling wall panels. The victim, Sean Taylor, was a master welder who once served in the U.S. Navy, and was part of the construction crew erecting the walls, when the crane caused a deadly chain reaction.
Rob Crain is representing the Taylor family in a wrongful death claim. As Chris Hawes reports for WFAA-TV in Dallas-Fort Worth, Crain said, ...
Decatur Clients Succeed from Aggressive Defense
2012-07-25
Kalamazoo based criminal defense law firm Aggressive Criminal Defense Law Firm- a division of Willis Law achieves, yet again, for another of their clients.
Initially, their client faced a marijuana possession charge in the Van Buren County. With the help of aggressive criminal defense the client's charge was dismissed.
Marijuana possession is a serious crime taken by the Aggressive Criminal Defense Law Firm. A misdemeanor for marijuana possession can prevent people from getting a job or career.
Their client, a juvenile, was in a necessary position to get the ...
Airberlin's Frequent Flyers Earn Extra Miles with Choice Hotels
2012-07-25
Choice Hotels Europe, the company behind the Comfort, Quality and Clarion brands in Europe and part of Choice Hotels International, one of the largest and most successful lodging franchisors in the world, has launched a promotion enabling members of topbonus, airberlin's worldwide frequent flyer programme, to earn double miles when they stay at participating Choice Hotels properties.
Until September 19, 2012, topbonus members who present their topbonus card when checking-in will earn double topbonus award miles with every qualifying stay at all participating Choice Hotels ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Cercus electric stimulation enables cockroach with trajectory control and spatial cognition training
Day-long conference addresses difficult to diagnose lung disease
First-ever cardiogenic shock academy features simulation lab
Thirty-year mystery of dissonance in the “ringing” of black holes explained
Less intensive works best for agricultural soil
Arctic rivers project receives “national champion” designation from frontiers foundation
Computational biology paves the way for new ALS tests
Study offers new hope for babies born with opioid withdrawal syndrome
UT, Volkswagen Group of America celebrate research partnership
New Medicare program could dramatically improve affordability for cancer drugs – if patients enroll
Are ‘zombie’ skin cells harmful or helpful? The answer may be in their shapes
University of Cincinnati Cancer Center presents research at AACR 2025
Head and neck, breast, lung and survivorship studies headline Dana-Farber research at AACR Annual Meeting 2025
AACR: Researchers share promising results from MD Anderson clinical trials
New research explains why our waistlines expand in middle age
Advancements in muon detection: Taishan Antineutrino Observatory's innovative top veto tracker
Chips off the old block
Microvascular decompression combined with nerve combing for atypical trigeminal neuralgia
Cutting the complexity from digital carpentry
Lung immune cell type “quietly” controls inflammation in COVID-19
Fiscal impact of expanded Medicare coverage for GLP-1 receptor agonists to treat obesity
State and sociodemographic trends in US cigarette smoking with future projections
Young adults drive historic decline in smoking
NFCR congratulates Dr. Robert C. Bast, Jr. on receiving the AACR-Daniel D. Von Hoff Award for Outstanding Contributions to Education and Training in Cancer Research
Chimpanzee stem cells offer new insights into early embryonic development
This injected protein-like polymer helps tissues heal after a heart attack
FlexTech inaugural issue launches, pioneering interdisciplinary innovation in flexible technology
In Down syndrome mice, 40Hz light and sound improve cognition, neurogenesis, connectivity
Methyl eugenol: potential to inhibit oxidative stress, address related diseases, and its toxicological effects
A vascularized multilayer chip reveals shear stress-induced angiogenesis in diverse fluid conditions
[Press-News.org] Is it Constitutional to Ban Sex Offenders From Social Networks?The constitutionality of banning sex offenders from internet websites has been brought to light amid a recent Indiana federal district court decision.