October 26, 2012 (Press-News.org) The Fourth Amendment protects Americans from unlawful searches and seizures. Among other things, this means that if law enforcement suspects someone of a crime, they need a probable-cause warrant before they can search a person's home, car or otherwise invade their privacy.
But this does not seem to be the case for tracking cell phone GPS activity. A recent 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals decision held that law enforcement does not need a warrant to track a person through cell phone GPS signals. In the case, the DEA suspected a man of drug trafficking. They learned the suspect used a pay-as-you cell phone that was registered under a fake name. Without obtaining a warrant, the DEA obtained GPS data emitted from the cell phone and used it to track the suspects movements until finally apprehending him.
The suspect was convicted of drug trafficking and sentenced to 20 years in prison. He appealed his conviction, arguing that the DEA had violated his Fourth Amendment rights by not first obtaining a warrant.
The Sixth Circuit's Opinion
The 6th Circuit disagreed. In the court's view, using cell phone GPS data to track down a person believed to be in possession of illegal drugs is no different than using that person's scent and a hound dog to track him down. The court also stated that if criminals were able to use new technology, like pay as you go cell phones, to help them commit crimes, law enforcement has the same right to use that technology to catch them. The Court opined that deciding otherwise would mean that "technology would help criminals but not the police."
The U.S. Supreme Court recently held that police cannot attach GPS tracking devices on suspects' cars without a showing probable cause and obtaining a warrant. But the 6th Circuit distinguished the physical act of installing a GPS device on a suspect's car from merely accessing the cell phone data, concluding that the act of affixing a GPS tracker to a suspect's car is a search, for which a warrant is required, but obtaining cell phone GPS data from a third-party is not.
The 6th Circuit decision means that cell phone users have no expectation of privacy when it comes to GPS data and their locations can be tracked without a warrant. However, in 2010, the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals reached the opposite conclusion ruling that warrants were necessary before law enforcement could obtain cell phone GPS data. The differing opinions in the 3rd and 6th Circuits will likely mean that the U.S. Supreme Court will have to resolve the conflict.
If you or a loved one has been subjected to a warrantless search by law enforcement and believe your Fourth Amendment rights may have been violated, speak with an experienced Florida criminal defense attorney to discuss your situation.
Article provided by Damore, Delgado, Romanik & Rawlins
Visit us at www.communitylawfirm.com
No Expectation of Privacy When Using a Cell Phone
A recent 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals decision held that law enforcement does not need a warrant to track a person through cell phone GPS signals.
2012-10-26
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Personal Injury Claims: Small vs. Large Vehicles
2012-10-26
Did you know that smaller cars are involved in more personal injury claims than are larger vehicles? The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety and the Highway Loss Data Institute analyzed data for model years 2009 through 2011 to determine which automobiles are involved in the most insurance claims.
In this investigation, the organizations considered the following categories:
- Personal injury protection (harm to drivers and passengers)
- Bodily injury liability (injuries to other cars' motorists and passengers)
- Crashes (general property damage)
Vehicle models ...
Supreme Court of South Carolina Reverses Drug Crimes Conviction
2012-10-26
A variety of legal issues can influence the criminal defense strategy in any drug crimes case, from suppression of evidence to technical arguments about the nature or quantity of controlled substances. A recent South Carolina case involving charges of a drug trafficking conspiracy was finally resolved based on unconstitutional limits on the defendant's right to confront his accusers.
In State v. Gracely, the Supreme Court of South Carolina overturned a conviction for conspiracy to traffic a large quantity of illegal drugs. The basis for the reversal was the defendant's ...
New York Appellate Court Discusses Compensation for Workplace Assaults
2012-10-26
From office buildings to construction sites, sometimes tension runs high at the workplace. It is not uncommon for an employee to suffer serious injury in a physical altercation with a coworker, customer or some third party.
Normally, on-the-job injuries are compensable through the New York workers' compensation system. But what about injuries that stem from a workplace assault? As made clear in a recent New York appellate court ruling, the availability of worker's comp benefits depends largely on the nature of the incident.
Details of the Recent Case
Ann Belaska ...
Equitable Distribution and Divorce in New Jersey
2012-10-26
When going through a divorce, it is crucial to understand how marital assets are divided so that each party can determine what he or she believes is fair and does not have any regrets when the proceedings are finalized.
The process of distributing marital assets in New Jersey is often called Equitable Distribution. The parties themselves can decide how to divide the assets, but if they cannot do so, a judge will make the decision for them. It is important to note that in the legal context, equitable does not necessarily mean equal.
Property Included in Equitable Distribution
Equitable ...
Texas Farmers, Ranchers and Business Owners Need Estate Planning Now
2012-10-26
If you are a farmer, rancher or small business owner, you may not feel like one of the richest Americans. The government may tax you like you are though when it comes time to pass your family inheritance down.
It is incredibly important for Texas farmers, rancher and business owners to prepare a comprehensive estate plan to protect what they built so that it does not end up belonging to Uncle Sam. In order to ensure the legacy you fought for, take the time before the end of the year to plan for the future of your family for generations to come. Right now there are favorable ...
Study Warns That Patients Are Often Discharged With Lab Results Unread
2012-10-26
A recent study found that the results of medical tests done right before a patient is discharged from a hospital often go unread, and, as a result, can lead to serious health consequences for patients, including missed diagnoses and readmission.
The Australian study was published in August in the Journal Archives of Internal Medicine as a research letter. Its findings are also of concern for U.S. patients as evidenced by the U.S. National Library of Medicine citing it on its website as well as a statement by Dr. Gordon Schiff, Associate Director of the Brigham Center ...
Mortgage After Bankruptcy: Timelines for Eligibility
2012-10-26
Bankruptcy applicants often have concerns about the effects of Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy on credit ratings and future opportunities for borrowing. In many cases, people who are considering bankruptcy due to mortgage difficulties and foreclosure wonder how long it will take to qualify for a mortgage and purchase a home in the future.
Federal guidelines for reviewing borrower credit history are far less stringent in this respect than most people might think. After a couple or individual seeks relief in a bankruptcy proceeding, the Federal Housing Administration ...
Florida Working to Improve Pedestrian and Bicycle Safety on the Road
2012-10-26
One of the many benefits enjoyed by all South Florida residents is the ability to walk or ride a bike, rather than riding in a car, throughout the entire year. These methods of transportation are often the most affordable and economically sound choices. Despite the many advantages, walkers and bicyclists run the risk of sustaining injuries if involved in motor vehicle accidents.
Recently, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration reported that 4,280 pedestrians were killed nationwide in 2010 as a result of motor vehicle accidents. In addition, approximately ...
Federal Judge Orders Minnesota to Fix Sex Offender Program
2012-10-26
A federal judge recently ruled that the controversial Minnesota Sex Offender Program needs to be overhauled in order to make it fair. The program was designed to protect the public by civilly committing and treating only the most violent and dangerous sex offenders after they have served their prison time.
The practical reality for many individuals who have served their time for various sex crimes in Minnesota has been a life sentence with no opportunity for review and virtually no chance of release. Now a federal judge is ordering the state to make changes.
In order ...
More Operation Dirty Dozen Drug Traffickers Sentenced in Texas
2012-10-26
This September, five more drug traffickers were sentenced in the continuing investigation "Operation Dirty Dozen," a federal law enforcement initiative that began in 2009 and targeted one of Texas' largest drug trafficking organizations. These developments prompt a look into Texas drug crimes charges and the penalties these individuals face now that they have been convicted.
More "Operation Dirty Dozen" Traffickers Sentenced
The five drug trafficking organization members were sentenced for delivering five tons of marijuana and $120,000 in cash ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Study demonstrates low-cost method to remove CO₂ from air using cold temperatures, common materials
Masonic Medical Research Institute (MMRI) welcomes 13 students to prestigious Summer Fellowship program
Mass timber could elevate hospital construction
A nuanced model of soil moisture illuminates plant behavior and climate patterns
$2.6 million NIH grant backs search for genetic cure in deadly heart disease
Pennsylvania’s medical cannabis program changed drastically when anxiety was added as a qualifying condition
1 in 5 overweight adults could be reclassified with obesity according to new framework
Findings of study on how illegally manufactured fentanyl enters U.S. contradict common assumptions, undermining efforts to control supply
Satellite observations provide insight into post-wildfire forest recovery
Three years in, research shows regional, personal differences in use of 988 lifeline
Beyond the alpha male
For fish, hovering is not restful
Smithsonian-led team discovers North America’s oldest known pterosaur
A study shakes up received ideas on male domination among primates
LMD strengthens global ties in Italy: Deepening cooperation with Embassy, CNR, and University of Rome Tor Vergata
University of Cincinnati study explores fertility treatment risks for kidney transplant recipients
Study uncovers how harmful RNA clumps form — and a way to dissolve them
A new perspective on designing urban low-altitude logistics networks subhead: Balancing cost, safety, and noise through co-evolutionary multi-objective optimization
Mobile mindfulness meditation apps may improve attention
Positive emotions may strengthen memories
Polycystic ovary syndrome patients say they feel dismissed and misunderstood, according to new study
Audit published in research integrity and peer review identifies key failings of institutional animal care and use committees
NSF CAREER Award funds Rice project to shrink hospital-grade imaging into wearable devices
Treatment with Virtual Reality works quickly and effectively for psychosis
Following the pigeon's gaze
Rice engineering student honored for research to reduce surgical complications
AI-enabled piezoelectric wearable for joint torque monitoring: A breakthrough in joint health monitoring
In situ polymerization in COF boosts li‐ion conduction in solid polymer electrolytes for li metal batteries: A new approach to enhance ion transport efficiecyn
Eliminating the need for lifelong immunosuppressive medications for transplant patients
Open problems: Cracking cell complexity with collective intelligence
[Press-News.org] No Expectation of Privacy When Using a Cell PhoneA recent 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals decision held that law enforcement does not need a warrant to track a person through cell phone GPS signals.