November 21, 2012 (Press-News.org) In order to place someone under arrest, police officers need to have probable cause. This means that you cannot be arrested unless officers have a level of suspicion based on objective evidence that makes it reasonable to suspect you have probably committed a crime or are about to commit a crime.
However, there are certain limited circumstances in which you may be lawfully stopped by police without the encounter amounting to an arrest. One of these special situations is when you are the occupant of a house that the police are searching or are about to search under the authority of a valid warrant.
In 1981, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the police may detain the occupants of a house that is being lawfully searched in order to facilitate the search and to promote officer safety. For example, if police knocked on the door of a house to execute a search warrant, and the owner answered, the police would generally be within their authority to hold the owner outside on the porch while the search was being conducted.
The twofold reasoning of this rule made intuitive sense. Not only would it be cumbersome for officers to conduct a search with a building's occupants in the way, but the risk of evidence being hidden or destroyed with occupants wandering freely was high. Additionally, the threat of a suspect using a concealed weapon, especially if he or she observed officers coming close to the object of their search, justified an officer safety exception to the probable cause requirement of an arrest. Thus, building occupants at the scene of a search can be detained in a reasonable manner.
But, what if the suspect was not actually present at the premises to be searched when officers arrived? What if he was, in fact, almost a mile away?
That is exactly what happened in the case Bailey v. United States that will be decided by the Supreme Court this winter. Officers observed Chunon Bailey leaving his residence as they were about to conduct a search of the premises pursuant to a warrant. The officers watched Bailey for a time, then detained him approximately a mile from his home and brought him back there while they conducted the search. After the officers uncovered drugs and a gun, Bailey was arrested.
To be a valid detention of an occupant outside the premises to be searched, the actions of the police must be "reasonable." Bailey argues that it is unreasonable to detain an occupant who has left the immediate vicinity of the premises to be searched without probable cause for the arrest, as this furthers none of the justifications for such detentions that have previously been articulated by the Supreme Court. The government, on the other hand, says that detention a short distance away from the premises to be searched is no more intrusive than detention at the site itself, and is justified because the occupant may flee or could return to the premises to interfere with the search.
Outcome of Case Will Drastically Affect Many Future Cases Involving Searches
The outcome of Bailey v. United States will affect many future cases, particularly those that center around drug charges and similar allegations that typically rely heavily on physical evidence produced by police searches. If the Supreme Court accepts the government's reasoning, police will have far greater discretion to detain one-time occupants of a structure before or during a search, even if these individuals have left the immediate vicinity. However, if Bailey prevails, it will be clear that building occupants may only be detained at the site of a search, and that evidence collected as a result of violating a suspect's right not to be detained could be suppressed in court. Oral arguments were heard in Bailey v. United States on October 30, and the Supreme Court's final decision is expected in a matter of months.
If you are facing drug charges or another type of accusation, it is important to stage a strong legal defense so you can get unfavorable evidence thrown out. To learn more about how Bailey v. United States could affect your case or to contest evidence collected in violation of your rights, talk to an experienced criminal defense attorney today.
Article provided by Courtney & Molter, S.C.
Visit us at www.courtneyandmolter.com
Supreme Court to Rule on Detention of Building Occupants During a Search
Can police officers return a suspect to his home in order to execute a search warrant? A new case being considered by the U.S. Supreme Court aims to answer that question.
2012-11-21
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Keep Your Illinois Business in One Piece After Divorce
2012-11-21
If you operate a small business, it is probably more than just an asset to you. A small business generates income, but it is also a physical representation of all the hard work and vision you've expended to build something out of nothing.
Understandably, it can be a real concern when a major life event like divorce threatens your business. But, with the right strategies, and help from a business valuation and division divorce attorney, you can ensure your business weathers the storm of divorce and remains viable long into the future.
Accurate and Complete Business ...
After Deepwater Horizon, Could New Rules Make Gulf Drilling Safer?
2012-11-21
If there is a benefit to the 2010 Deepwater Horizon disaster, it is that offshore oil workers who risk their lives on the job may now be safer. The U.S. Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement (BSEE) has finalized new offshore drilling safety rules that are aimed at preventing another fatal explosion and environmental disaster.
As a result of the failures, the BSEE imposed new drilling safety regulations designed to make sure oil can be stopped if there are problems with the well. The changes strengthen requirements for:
- Safety equipment
- Well control systems
- ...
Untreated Traumatic Brain Injuries May Cause Mental Problems Later in Life
2012-11-21
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), nearly 1.7 million people in the United States suffer a traumatic brain injury (TBI) each year. And while physicians have long recognized that TBIs can cause problems in the short term, there is increasing evidence to suggest that they may cause life-long problems, as well.
Untreated Concussions Can Cause Significant Damage
Depending on their severity, traumatic brain injuries - such as concussions - can cause a variety of symptoms. It is not uncommon for those who have suffered a concussion to experience ...
Ignition Interlock Devices and California DUI
2012-11-21
In California, Judges have discretion to require people convicted of driving under the influence to install ignition interlock devices (IID) in their vehicles in many cases. Several counties require installation if convicted. These devices are intended to prevent driving with a measurable amount of alcohol in your system, and maybe ordered by a Judge or DMV along with other penalties for California DUI.
California DUI Laws
If a driver is arrested on suspicion of driving under the influence of alcohol, their driver's license will automatically be suspended in 30 days ...
Increase in Truck Traffic Leads to More Accidents
2012-11-21
The Eagle Ford Shale energy boom has been a large economic impact for southeast Texas, but there have been unanticipated consequences. Notably, the increase in oil and gas production has caused an increase in commercial truck traffic in the area, which has brought with it an increase in the number of large truck accidents.
According to the Texas Department of Transportation, truck accidents in the area have increased significantly over the past five years. While there were only four truck accidents in the area in 2008, there were 46 in 2011. What is worse, the increase ...
"Black Box" in Car Reveals Speed at Time of Crash
2012-11-21
In September, a Las Vegas man allegedly made a reckless decision to drink and drive and crashed into a crowded bus stop killing four people and injuring eight others. The driver is facing trial for the deaths of the four innocent victims and one of the key pieces of evidence against him is his car.
The driver's 2001 Monte Carlo, like all cars manufactured by General Motors since 1999, contained a computer chip known as an Event Data Recorder, or EDR. The EDR is similar to the "black box" in an airplane and records information on what a car is doing when it ...
The State of Annulment in Arizona
2012-11-21
More people in America would probably consider running for government office if it didn't open them up to such intense personal scrutiny. For example, speculation about the 1999 annulment of Arizona 2nd Congressional District candidate Martha McSally's two-year marriage surfaced in the media during her 2012 election run.
Reportedly, McSally and her family law attorney traveled almost 100 miles from Tucson to another county in Arizona to file for annulment from McSally's fellow-Air-Force-officer husband. Annulment can cause a raised eyebrow, as it is relatively uncommon ...
Filing for Bankruptcy Puts a Stop to Harassing Debt Collectors
2012-11-21
For many Americans, the troubling state of the economy has left them with depleted bank accounts and an inability to keep up with their bills. When people cannot make timely payments, debt collectors eventually become involved. Often, the practices employed by these collectors are distressing and illegal. Americans who are faced with a seemingly never-ending stream of harassing phone calls from creditors would be wise to consult with a skilled bankruptcy attorney to ensure their rights are being protected.
Often, the most effective way to stop creditor harassment when ...
Medical Malpractice Damages Caps Harm Injured Patients
2012-11-21
Recently, some have made the argument that New Jersey is experiencing a shortage of physicians due to the price of medical malpractice liability insurance premiums. Those making the claims have contended that doctors trained in New Jersey are leaving the state for other areas with cheaper premiums. After making this conclusion, they then argue that tort reform is the answer to keeping qualified doctors in New Jersey to care for our residents.
Unfortunately, these arguments are misguided and fail to take the rights of those harmed by medical malpractice into account. ...
Lose the Tobacco or Lose Custody? North Carolina's Family Court Judges Saying "No Smoking" to Parents
2012-11-21
More and more judges around the state - and around the country - are telling parents to put away the cigarettes before spending time with their children. Although exact numbers aren't available for how many custody cases involve the smoking of one parent or someone in their household, as new information arises about the dangers of secondhand smoke, it is becoming increasingly common for judges to consider smoking when making custody and visitation/parenting time decisions.
Why does smoking matter?
In a word: health. Judges, like everyone else, are privy to the countless ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
High-entropy alloy nanozyme ROS biocatalyst treating tendinopathy via up-regulation of PGAM5/FUNDC1/GPX4 pathway
SwRI’s Dr. Pablo Bueno named AIAA Associate Fellow
Astronomers detect radio signals from a black hole tearing apart a star – outside a galactic center
Locking carbon in trees and soils could help ‘stabilize climate for centuries’ – but only if combined with underground storage
New research shows a tiny, regenerative worm could change our understanding of healing
Australia’s rainforests first to switch from carbon sink to source
First-trimester mRNA COVID-19 vaccination and risk of major congenital anomalies
Glucose-lowering medication classes and cardiovascular outcomes in patients with type 2 diabetes
Rising seas and sinking cities signal a coastal crisis in China
Discovery of hundreds of new human gut viruses provides a new approach to studying the gut microbiome
Study indicates dramatic increase in percentage of US adults who meet new definition of obesity
Astrocytes are superstars in the game of long-term memory
WSU study finds positive framing can steer shoppers toward premium products
Study finds ending universal free school meals linked to rising student meal debt and stigma
Innovations in organoid engineering: Construction methods, model development, and clinical translation
Rescheduling coca: Aligning global drug policy with science, tradition, and indigenous rights
BIOFAIR roadmap for an integrated biological and environmental data network
SwRI, 8 Rivers patent more cost-effective, efficient power generation system with liquid oxygen storage
A sacred leaf on trial: Scientists urge WHO to support decriminalizing coca
World’s largest superconducting fusion system will use American technology to measure the plasma within
Mount Sinai receives $4.5 million NIH award to launch a pioneering women’s environmental health research training program
Strong grip strength may protect against obesity-related complications
How to double lung cancer screening rates
Researchers ‘zoom’ in for an ultra-magnified peek at shark skin
AI system finds crucial clues for diagnoses in electronic health records
Gut microbiota disruption predicts severe steatosis in MASLD patients
WSU project reduces hospitalizations among home health-care patients
Rain in the Sahara? UIC researchers predict a wetter future for the desert
Solar-powered lights keep sea turtles out of fishing nets
A prototype glucose battery inspired by the body’s metabolism
[Press-News.org] Supreme Court to Rule on Detention of Building Occupants During a SearchCan police officers return a suspect to his home in order to execute a search warrant? A new case being considered by the U.S. Supreme Court aims to answer that question.