US Supreme Court to Review State DNA Testing Law

The U.S. Supreme Court will hear a case that could set limits on when states can force accused criminals to submit to DNA testing.

2012-12-19

December 19, 2012 (Press-News.org) When it comes to protecting the rights of the accused, the Supreme Court of the United States gets the final say about what law enforcement officials can and cannot to do to investigate crime. Although law enforcement has generally been granted wide latitude to conduct investigations and collect evidence, they are limited by strong constitutional protections against unlawful search and seizure and unreasonable invasions of privacy.

During its current term, the Supreme Court will decide whether law enforcement officials are allowed to take DNA samples from people arrested on felony charges. The plaintiff in the case is a Maryland man who was convicted for rape based on DNA evidence obtained during an unrelated arrest.

The man was arrested on assault charges in 2009. Because he was charged with a violent offense, state law required law enforcement to take a sample of the man's DNA and submit it to a state database. The database showed that the man's DNA was connected to a 2003 rape. Ultimately, he was convicted of that crime.

The man appealed the conviction, arguing that the state should not have been able to take the DNA sample because people arrested for crimes have a higher expectation of privacy than those who have already been convicted. (The ability of states to obtain DNA samples from convicted criminals is not at issue.)

The Maryland Court of Appeals agreed, holding that the interests of law enforcement were outweighed by the privacy rights of the accused. It also noted that DNA testing was not necessary in order to identify the arrestee -- fingerprinting does a good enough job on its own.

After the Court of Appeals' ruling, the state appealed to the Supreme Court, which decided to allow the DNA testing law to remain in effect until a decision is reached.

Case will have nationwide impact

The consequences of the Supreme Court's decision will extend far beyond the state of Maryland. If the law is struck down, several other states will also have to revisit their DNA testing procedures. In addition, the Supreme Court's ruling will serve as precedent, guiding future state laws regarding the rights of the accused.

The Supreme Court's decision will also affect federal prosecutions, since all states make their DNA databases available for use by the FBI.

The case also highlights the importance of working with an experienced criminal defense attorney if you have been charged with a crime. Every person in the United States is entitled to the protections guaranteed in the Constitution, regardless of how serious the charges are. An experienced attorney will be able to evaluate the circumstances of the investigation and arrest to determine if any potential constitutional violations exist. If so, the attorney can challenge the resulting evidence to help ensure that rights of the accused are protected.

Article provided by Cunha & Holcomb, P.C.
Visit us at www.cunhaholcomb.com

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Minnesota Supreme Court to Examine Constitutionality of No Contact Orders

2012-12-19

Virtually everyone in Minnesota who has ever faced charges of domestic assault can tell you what a no contact order is. For most people, they are a suspension of their rights without having the ability to defend themselves. This is because judges in Minnesota have been routinely issuing no contact orders whenever a person is charged with domestic assault. Until now, few judges have been willing to listen to the defendant's point of view. That may soon change after a man from northern Minnesota challenged the law. A judge issued a domestic abuse no contact order, sometimes ...

Is Running a Business with Your Ex a Good Idea After Divorce?

2012-12-19

According to data from the U.S. Census Bureau, more than 3.7 million businesses in the United States are jointly owned by a married husband and wife. Considering how common divorce is, a significant number of these couples will likely end up facing a serious dilemma: should they continue to run their business together even though their marriage is breaking up? If you're considering going into business with your spouse, it is a good idea to meet with an attorney to create a contingency plan in case you end up divorcing at some point. While most people are aware that they ...

Bed Rails a Major Threat to Nursing Home Safety

2012-12-19

When people are admitted to nursing homes, it is usually because they are too ill or infirm to be cared for properly at home. Thus, it is always disturbing to learn of situations where admission into a nursing home actually increased the likelihood of serious injury or death. A recent story in The New York Times highlighted the role that bed rails have played in nursing home injuries and deaths throughout the United States. According to data from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, approximately 4,000 adults seek emergency room treatment each year because of bed rail ...

Lawyers Caution Texans About Do-it-Yourself Divorces

2012-12-19

The process of divorce involves intricate issues, which relate to children, the division of property and other important matters. However, a recent Texas Supreme Court decision has aimed to make things "simple" for divorcing couples, permitting a do-it-yourself divorce option that does not involve a lawyer. Nevertheless, legal scholars caution individuals about using this divorce option, warning that a simple mistake could result in heavy consequences. Six Texas Supreme Court justices recently approved the state's adoption of do-it-yourself divorce forms. The ...

Trainings and Surgical Checklists Reduce Postoperative Complications

2012-12-19

When a patient receives an operation, he or she hopes for the most superior care. Patients trust their lives in the hands health care workers, and their expectations should be taken seriously. Specifically, physicians and other health care providers should ensure that all safeguards are taken before, during and after procedures to prevent any postoperative complications. A new study performed by researchers at the University of Connecticut Health Center in Farmington and Saint Francis Hospital and Medical Center in Hartford has found that a surgical checklist, combined ...

Deanna Swenson Accused of Ballot Tampering, Retains Attorney Jason Short

2012-12-19

In a case that's receiving national attention, former Clackamas County election worker Deanna Swenson has been charged with ballot tampering. Ms. Swenson, a 55-year-old mother of two from Beavercreek, has served without incident as an election worker for at least 15 years. Around October 30 or 31, Ms. Swenson allegedly filled in a handful of down-ballot races left blank to cast additional votes for Republican candidates. However, Ms. Swenson was in a poor state of health; a lifelong asthmatic, she was suffering from a severe sinus infection, head cold and bronchitis ...

What the HSBC Settlement Means for Taxpayers With Foreign Accounts

2012-12-19

Dubbed the largest collective settlement in the Treasury Department's history, HSBC Holdings agreed to pay $1.92 billion in fines to U.S. authorities. The penalty assessment was based upon HSBC's conduct in violation of the Bank Secrecy Act and other U.S. sanctions. It has been reported that the bank's breakdowns in anti-money laundering (AML) compliance was particularly egregious, specifically allowing hundreds of million of dollars from Mexican drug cartels to flow through accounts in the United States. This penalty assessment does not merely flow from a single act ...

Freedom Weekend Aloft Names Holiday Inn Express Simpsonville Hotel's General Manager to Their Board of Directors

2012-12-19

Greg Carpenter, General Manager of the Holiday Inn Express Simpsonville Hotel was recently appointed to The Board of Director's for the for Greenville Hospital System's Freedom Weekend Aloft, presented by BiLo. The annual Memorial weekend event will take place at Heritage Park in Simpsonville, SC from May 24-27, 2013. Freedom Weekend Aloft is a popular hot air balloon festival that has been a tradition in the Greenville area for over 30 years. Past festivals has also included amphitheatre concerts, family fun zone, 5K walk/run, artist showcase, and a lacrosse tournament. ...

Hampton Inn & Suites Scottsboro Hotel Announces Special Holiday Rates for Guests to Enjoy

2012-12-19

The Hampton Inn & Suites Scottsboro AL Hotel is offering special holiday rates. Available now through December 31, 2012, guests will receive room rates starting at: - $89 per night, weekdays (Sunday - Thursday) - $79 per night, weekend (Friday - Saturday) Holiday rates are subject to availability. Select "Best Available Rate" when booking. This property is part of the Hilton Honors program, which lets guests earn rewards for stays. "Perfect for business and leisure travelers alike, the Hampton Inn & Suites is the ideal place to stay in the ...

Spending Too Much this Holiday Season Can Lead to Bankruptcy, Notes Chattanooga Bankruptcy Attorneys

2012-12-19

Clark & Washington, Chattanooga bankruptcy attorneys, note that the holiday season is one of the easiest times of the year to rack up massive amounts of debt, which could lead residents to bankruptcy and other financial troubles. The desire to give great gifts this holiday season can cause many Chattanooga residents to amass debt that they had not planned for, and can often be the first step to financial troubles, like bankruptcy. Great sales and nifty gift ideas can play on shoppers' passions and keep them from considering the bottom line. Once January hits, so ...

US Supreme Court to Review State DNA Testing Law

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES: