December 20, 2012 (Press-News.org) One Pennsylvania worker recently found out the hard way that violating a company policy can have real world consequences. In the case Dougherty v. Philadelphia Newspapers, a truck driver lost his workers' comp wage replacement benefits when his employer discovered he had been carrying a loaded handgun in his work truck in violation of company policy.
Violating the company's weapons policy was deemed "willful misconduct." But, willful misconduct is just one of several excuses workers' comp insurers often turn to in an attempt to avoid paying you in the wake a workplace injury.
Willful Misconduct as an Excuse to Deny Workers' Comp Benefits
Workers' compensation is meant to provide medical treatment for on-the-job injuries and occupational illnesses and to give workers financial support during the recovery process. Workers' comp is paid regardless of fault, meaning that an employer's negligence does not have to have caused the injury in order for the worker to recover benefits.
Yet, workers' compensation is ultimately paid by an insurer, and insurance companies typically seek to avoid paying claims whenever possible. One common dispute in workers' comp cases is whether the injury occurred on-the-job or outside the work environment. Even it is undisputed that the injury happened in the workplace, however, the employee's behavior in certain circumstances may be used to justify a denial of benefits.
Willful misconduct is one of the key defenses insurance companies use to avoid paying injury claims. In the case mentioned above, willful misconduct was an adequate defense for the workers' comp insurer because the employee was violating a clear, substantive workplace policy by keeping the loaded pistol in his truck, and he did not provide adequate justification for his actions.
However, you can always contest that your performance rose to the level of "willful misconduct." Willful misconduct involves insubordination, violation of a work rule, excessive absenteeism or other activity that indicates the employee is intentionally disregarding the employer's interest. On the other hand, if the employee does not live up to the employer's standards because of inexperience, incompetence, inability to perform the work or due to honest mistakes, the employee's behavior does not qualify as willful misconduct.
Denial Based On Other Behavioral Justifications: Horseplay, Self-Infliction and Intoxication
Horseplay, the intentional self-infliction of injuries and intoxication are all also defenses that the workers' compensation insurer may raise based on an employee's behavior.
In Pennsylvania, a worker may still be eligible for workers' compensation if the injury arose out of horseplay. Workers' compensation may be denied only if the horseplay was so disconnected from the injured employee's regular work duties as to make the worker essentially a trespasser at the workplace.
If an injury is intentionally self-inflicted, the workers' comp insurer is never obligated to provide benefits under Pennsylvania law. However, the burden is on the employer and/or the insurer to prove that an injury was both intentional and self-inflicted if these grounds are to be used to deny workers' comp benefits.
Intoxication or illegal drug use can also be grounds to deny an employee workers' compensation benefits. Under Pennsylvania law, if an injury would not have occurred but for an employee's intoxication or illegal drug use, that employee is not eligible for workers' compensation. This does not mean that any employee who was intoxicated or had used illegal drugs is always automatically ineligible for workers' comp -- for instance, if an injury would have happened whether the employee was impaired or not, intoxication or illegal drug use may not be relevant in terms of workers' compensation.
Talk To a Pittsburgh Workers' Compensation Attorney to Get Full Benefits
If you are facing a denial or undervaluing of your workers' compensation claim, don't be afraid to fight back. You are entitled to workers' compensation benefits for a job-related injury or illness, and your employer is always prohibited by law from retaliating against you for making a workers' compensation claim.
Get the benefits you deserve: talk to a Pennsylvania workers' compensation attorney today.
Article provided by Dugan & Associates, P.C.
Visit us at www.dugan-associates.com
Conduct at Issue: Pennsylvania Workers' Comp Denial Based On Behavior
If you've been injured at work, your employer's insurer will likely try to deny you benefits. Learn more about some of the justifications workers' comp insurers use to try to fight claims.
2012-12-20
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Tips to Spot and Prevent Financial Elder Abuse
2012-12-20
Few of us want to admit it, but nearly everyone who lives to see old age will reach a point where they are unable to manage their affairs. In some cases, the issue is short-term and related to a temporary illness or hospitalization. In other instances, the problem is a permanent consequence of Alzheimer's disease or another form of dementia.
When this happens, most people end up having their affairs managed by a friend or relative. Unfortunately, financial misdeeds are one of the most common forms of elder abuse. Too often, the person entrusted to manage the elder's ...
Florida Snowbirds May Have to Reexamine Their Car Insurance Needs
2012-12-20
Around this time every year the great migration begins - and no, I am not referring to the v-formation exodus of geese flying south for winter, but instead the countless retired "snowbirds" who flock to warmer locales such as Florida in order to avoid the frosty northern weather. And while the gentle warm Florida breezes are usually a welcomed relief from the bitterly cold winds of the north, there are many logistical hurdles snowbirds have to deal with when managing their two different households.
For example, snowbirds need to make arrangements for someone ...
Surrendering Your Home in Bankruptcy: What About HOA Dues?
2012-12-20
Sometimes, what you thought was your dream home can turn into a nightmare. Excessive heating and cooling costs, high property taxes, oppressive mortgage payments; the expenses associated with homeownership can quickly spiral out of control.
Bankruptcy can be a great way to get out from under oppressive debt, and many consumers choose to surrender their home during bankruptcy in order to completely wipe the financial slate clean. But, even if you surrender your home, it will likely take weeks or months before the eventual sheriff's sale. While you are trying to get your ...
Child Support Enforcement Effort Nets 36 in Hidalgo County
2012-12-20
When a child's parents do not live together -- either because they have divorced or because they were never married -- the noncustodial parent will usually be required to make regular child support payments. Child support is designed to ensure that the child has the support and care of both parents, even if he or she only lives with one of them.
Child support payments can be expensive, but parents who are considering missing payments really should think twice. Missed child support payments don't just hurt the child -- they can also subject the parent to severe criminal ...
Sinkhole Opens Up in Florida Front Yard
2012-12-20
A Florida family experienced quite a surprise one recent Monday morning: a large gaping sinkhole in their front yard.
Although the homeowner claims the sinkhole was only 25 feet wide when first noticed, it enlarged to nearly 60 feet wide and ten feet deep before engineers believed it was done growing. It should come as some relief that it is believed that the roots of nearby trees were the only thing that stopped the sinkhole from swallowing up the whole sidewalk.
Unfortunately however, the Daily Mail reports that the Florida homeowner has no sinkhole insurance, meaning ...
Federal Employment Protection for Disabled Veterans
2012-12-20
Every year, thousands of military personnel leave active duty to return to jobs that they held before they entered the service or search for new jobs. During their time in the service, many veterans suffered disabilities such as missing limbs, post-traumatic stress disorder or traumatic brain injuries. Unfortunately, because of this, it is not uncommon for servicemen and servicewomen to be discriminated against in in their current job or when searching for another job.
Fortunately, two federal laws protect veterans from employment discrimination based on their physical ...
Thoughts On the Newtown Incident
2012-12-20
Like all of you, I was shocked and saddened by the events in Newtown, Connecticut at Sandy Hook Elementary. I listened to President Obama speak at the memorial service and I was disappointed in what I did not hear him say. There were no specifics. After considering the amount of gun violence in this country, the awful mass shootings of the last four years, and terrible incidents like the Trayvon Martin shooting. The President of the United States did not specifically state that we need stricter gun control laws, up to and including a ban private ownership of assault rifles ...
What is Hypoxic-Ischemic Encephalopathy (HIE)?
2012-12-20
Hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy (HIE) is a condition in which the brain does not receive enough oxygen. There are a variety of causes of HIE. Any injury and many health conditions can potentially cause oxygen deprivation to the brain. Most often, however, HIE is sustained by newborns during a birth injury or complication. While most of HIE's victims are infants, HIE is used to describe any brain injury that occurs from oxygen deprivation.
What are the dangers of HIE?
Within as little as five minutes of oxygen deprivation brain cells begin to die; causing serious and ...
California DUI Enforcement Grants Issued; is San Mateo County Next?
2012-12-20
Driving under the influence is a major concern for the police departments in San Mateo County and across California. Authorities are determined to crack down on drunk drivers.
To aid in these concentrated efforts, new grants have been awarded to several California police departments. However, residents express concern over these initiatives and some believe that they may simply encourage police to overreach their authority.
The new grants
Thus far, DUI grants have been awarded to two counties in California.
The Elk Grove Police Department recently received ...
Child Relocation Laws in Illinois
2012-12-20
Divorces and separations are emotionally turbulent times, particularly when a child is involved. Because of this, disputes regarding child custody, child support or even where the child will live can easily arise between parents. And, even if these specific issues have been resolved by an Illinois court order, other subsequent problems can quickly surface.
For instance, given today's tumultuous economy many parents are discovering that they need to move great distances in order to find work - sometimes across state lines. However, before a parent can remove a child from ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Will the U.S. have enough pain specialists?
Stronger stress response in monkeys helps them survive
Using infrared heat transfer to modify chemical reactions
Being a ladies' man comes at a price for alpha male baboons
Study shows anti-clotting drug reduced bleeding events in patients with atrial fibrillation
UMaine-led team develops more holistic way to monitor lobster industry
Antiviral protein causes genetic changes implicated in Huntington’s disease progression
SwRI-led PUNCH spacecraft make final pit stop before launch
Claims for the world’s deepest earthquake challenged by new analysis
MSU study finds children of color experience more variability in sleep times
Pregnancy may increase risk of mental illness in people with MS
Multiple sclerosis linked to higher risk of mental illness during and after pregnancy
Beyond ChatGPT: WVU researchers to study use and ethics of artificial intelligence across disciplines
Ultrasensitive test detects, serially monitors intact virus levels in patients with COVID-19
mRNA-activated blood clots could cushion the blow of osteoarthritis
Three rockets will ignite Poker Flat’s 2025 launch season
Jared M. Kutzin, DNP, MS, MPH, RN, named President of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare
PET probe images inflammation with high sensitivity and selectivity
Epilepsy patient samples offer unprecedented insights on brain ‘brakes’ linked to disorders
Your stroke risk might be higher if your parents divorced during your childhood
Life satisfaction measurement tool provides robust information across nations, genders, ages, languages
Adult children of divorced parents at higher risk of stroke
Anti-climate action groups tend to arise in countries with stronger climate change efforts
Some coral "walk" towards blue or white light, using rolling, sliding or pulsing movements to migrate, per experiments with free-living mushroom coral Cycloseris cyclolites
Discovery of the significance of birth in the maintenance of quiescent neural stem cells
Severe weather and major power outages increasingly coincide across the US
Bioluminescent cell imaging gets a glow-up
Float like a jellyfish: New coral mobility mechanisms uncovered
Severe weather and major power outages increasingly coincide across the U.S.
Who to vaccinate first? Penn engineers answer a life-or-death question with network theory
[Press-News.org] Conduct at Issue: Pennsylvania Workers' Comp Denial Based On BehaviorIf you've been injured at work, your employer's insurer will likely try to deny you benefits. Learn more about some of the justifications workers' comp insurers use to try to fight claims.