(Press-News.org) The average physician can expect to spend nearly 11 per cent of his or her career with a malpractice claim waiting to be resolved. Some specialists will spend nearly a third of their careers with open claims.
The length of time it takes to resolve a malpractice claim is a stress on patients, physicians and the legal system. The time spent with open claims may be even more distressing for physicians than the financial costs of malpractice claims.
"We believe that the time required to resolve malpractice claims may be a significant reason that physicians are so vocal about malpractice reform, and that any attempt at malpractice reform will need to take the speed with which cases are resolved into account," said corresponding author Anupam Jena, assistant professor of health care policy at Harvard Medical School and general internist at Massachusetts General Hospital.
Using a database from a large national malpractice insurance agency, Jena, along with Seth Seabury, senior economist at RAND Corporation, analyzed the amount of time physicians spend with open claims. Claims were broken down by the specialty of the practitioner, severity of injury and on whether or not malpractice was found. The results will be reported in the January issue Health Affairs, which is being released today.
Two factors contribute to the amount of time a given physician spends with pending claims: the likelihood of a claim in any given year, and the length of the legal process. The typical medical malpractice claim isn't filed until almost two years after the incident occurred, and isn't resolved until forty-three months post-incident. When dealing with open claims, physicians spend up to 70 percent of that time with claims that never result in a payment.
Neurosurgeons, who on average will spend nearly 131 months— 27 per cent of their careers—with an open malpractice claim ranked highest. Psychiatrists spent the least amount of their careers with an open claim at nearly 16 months, and just over 3 percent of their careers.
The study is part of a larger project to understand how malpractice works and to investigate possible improvements to the system. In a 2011 New England Journal of Medicine article, Jena and colleagues first published their findings about the variation of risk of malpractice among specialties.
The researchers recommend exploring policy strategies for speedier resolution, including tort reform and alternative dispute management tools that can expedite the process and help limit meritless claims.
Even cases that are dismissed before trial take a long time. In previous studies, the researchers found that dismissed cases take 18 months to two years, cases that are settled take two to three years, and cases that go to jury take approximately four years to adjudicate.
"That's a very long time for a patient or a physician to have to wait for resolution," Jena said.
The researchers noted that the stress of enduring numerous lengthy lawsuits may not only explain why malpractice reform is so staunchly advocated by physicians but may also lead to expensive defensive medicine which contributes to high health care costs.
The best remedy would be to have a system in place where the judicial and health care system could more easily screen out cases that don't meet the legal or medical standards for malpractice, the researchers said. In cases where malpractice occurs, compensation should be fair and swift, and in cases where there is no merit to the claim, rapid dismissal of the case would prevent significant resources from being wasted.
"Our sense is that we are probably spending too long to resolve many of these cases and that lengthy time to resolution has many unanticipated costs to patients, physicians, and the health care system as a whole," said Seabury.
###
Seth Seabury received support from the RAND Institute for Civil Justice and National Institute on Aging (NIA) Grant No. 7R01AG031544. Darius Lakdawalla received support from NIA Grant No. 7R01AG031544, NIA Grant No. 1RC4AG039036-01, and the NIA Roybal Center at the University of Southern California (5P30AG024968). Amitabh Chandra was supported by NIA Grant No. P01 AG19783-02.
Additional authors of the study include Amitabh Chandra, Professor and Director of health policy research at Harvard University's Kennedy School of Government and Darius Lakdawalla, Quintiles Chair in Pharmaceutical Development and Regulatory Innovation at the University of Southern California.
Looming malpractice
Waiting for claims resolution takes up more than ten per cent of the average medical career
2013-01-08
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Centralization to fewer surgeons results in better survival after esophageal cancer surgery
2013-01-08
Patients who undergo surgery for oesophageal cancer have a much greater chance of long term survival if the operation is carried out by a surgeon who has performed this particular operation many times before. This according to a new, large-scale study conducted by researchers at Karolinska Institutet in Sweden, and published in the Journal of Clinical Oncology. In their article, the researchers conclude that oesophageal cancer surgery should be concentrated – or centralised – to fewer surgeons.
Surgery is the most widely established curative treatment for oesophageal ...
The reason we lose at games
2013-01-08
Writing in PNAS, a University of Manchester physicist has discovered that some games are simply impossible to fully learn, or too complex for the human mind to understand.
Dr Tobias Galla from The University of Manchester and Professor Doyne Farmer from Oxford University and the Santa Fe Institute, ran thousands of simulations of two-player games to see how human behaviour affects their decision-making.
In simple games with a small number of moves, such as Noughts and Crosses the optimal strategy is easy to guess, and the game quickly becomes uninteresting.
However, ...
High salt intake linked to social inequalities
2013-01-08
People from low socio-economic positions in Britain eat more salt than the well off, irrespective of where they live, states a paper led by Warwick Medical School published on Tuesday in the BMJ Open journal .
The research was carried out by the World Health Organization Collaborating Centre for Nutrition , based in the Division of Mental Health & Wellbeing of Warwick Medical School at the University of Warwick.
The study looked at the geographical distribution of habitual dietary salt intake in Britain and its association with manual occupations and educational attainments, ...
Modified antibodies trigger immune response, point to novel vaccine design strategies
2013-01-08
CAMBRIDGE, Mass. (January 7, 2013) – In an approach with the potential to aid therapeutic vaccine development, Whitehead Institute scientists have shown that enzymatically modified antibodies can be used to generate highly targeted, potent responses from cells of the immune system.
The approach, referred to as "sortagging," relies on the bacterial enzyme sortase A to modify antibodies to carry various payloads, such as peptides, lipids, fluorophores, and proteins. In this case, the scientists, whose findings are reported online this week in the journal PNAS, attached ...
Untreated Parkinson's disease patients no more likely to have impulse control disorders
2013-01-08
PHILADELPHIA - While approximately one in five Parkinson's disease patients experience impulse control disorder symptoms, the disease itself does not increase the risk of gambling, shopping, or other impulsivity symptoms, according to research from the Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania. A new study is the first to show in a large sample that people with untreated Parkinson's were no more likely to have an increased impulsivity than people without the disease. Published in the January 8, 2013, print issue of Neurology®, the medical journal of ...
Comprehensive public health approach urged to curb gun violence in US
2013-01-08
Boston, MA -- In the wake of the horrific school shootings in Newtown, Conn. in December, three Harvard experts say the best way to curb gun violence in the U.S. is to take a broad public health approach, drawing on proven, evidence-based strategies that have successfully reduced other public health threats like smoking, car crashes, and accidental poisonings.
The authors make the case for a comprehensive public health approach to gun violence in a viewpoint article published online January 7, 2013 in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA).
For instance, ...
Molecular '2-way radio' directs nerve cell branching and connectivity
2013-01-08
Working with fruit flies, Johns Hopkins scientists have decoded the activity of protein signals that let certain nerve cells know when and where to branch so that they reach and connect to their correct muscle targets. The proteins' mammalian counterparts are known to have signaling roles in immunity, nervous system and heart development, and tumor progression, suggesting broad implications for human disease research. A report of the research was published online Nov. 21 in the journal Neuron.
To control muscle movements, fruit flies, like other animals, have a set of ...
UI researcher learns mechanism of hearing is similar to car battery
2013-01-08
University of Iowa biologist Daniel Eberl and his colleagues have shown that one of the mechanisms involved in hearing is similar to the battery in your car.
And if that isn't interesting enough, the UI scientists advanced their knowledge of human hearing by studying a similar auditory system in fruit flies—and by making use of the fruit fly "love song."
To see how the mechanism of hearing resembles a battery, you need to know that the auditory system of the fruit fly contains a protein that functions as a sodium/potassium pump, often called the sodium pump for short, ...
AMSSM issues position statement on sport-related concussions
2013-01-08
Philadelphia, Pa. (January 7, 2013) - Athletes with concussions must be held out of practice or play until all symptoms have resolved, to avoid the risk of further injury during the vulnerable period before the brain has recovered. That's among the key recommendations in the new American Medical Society for Sports Medicine (AMSSM) position statement on concussions in sport, which appears in the January issue of Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine. The journal is published by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, a part of Wolters Kluwer Health.
At a time of increased concern ...
Penn researchers show new level of control over liquid crystals
2013-01-08
PHILADELPHIA — Directed assembly is a growing field of research in nanotechnology in which scientists and engineers aim to manufacture structures on the smallest scales without having to individually manipulate each component. Rather, they set out precisely defined starting conditions and let the physics and chemistry that govern those components do the rest.
An interdisciplinary team of researchers from the University of Pennsylvania has shown a new way to direct the assembly of liquid crystals, generating small features that spontaneously arrange in arrays based on ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
New “bone-digesting” cell type discovered in pythons
New study points to Skagerrak as nursery area for the enigmatic Greenland shark
Are sewage spills and coastal winds contributing to airborne microplastics?
Which factors affect the success of popular prescription weight loss drugs in individuals?
Do renter protection policies reduce rental housing discrimination?
Does grading students at earlier ages increase the risk of mental disorders in adolescents?
New artificial intelligence–based test detects early signs of osteoporosis from X-ray images
Can eating a healthy plant-based diet help protect against inflammatory bowel disease?
Do local voting rights affect migrants’ participation in protests?
Mysterious ‘Dark Dwarfs’ may be hiding at the heart of the Milky Way
Real-world data shows teclistamab can benefit many multiple myeloma patients who would have been ineligible for pivotal trial
Scientists reveal how a key inflammatory molecule triggers esophageal muscle contraction
Duration of heat waves accelerating faster than global warming
New mathematical insights into Lagrangian turbulence
Clinical trials reveal promising alternatives to high-toxicity tuberculosis drug
Artificial solar eclipses in space could shed light on Sun
Probing the cosmic Dark Ages from the far side of the Moon
UK hopes to bolster space weather forecasts with Europe's first solar storm monitor
Can one video change a teen's mindset? New study says yes - but there’s a catch
How lakes connect to groundwater critical for resilience to climate change, research finds
Youngest basaltic lunar meteorite fills nearly one billion-year gap in Moon’s volcanic history
Cal Poly Chemistry professor among three U.S. faculty to be honored for contributions to chemistry instruction
Stoichiometric crystal shows promise in quantum memory
Study sheds light on why some prostate tumors are resistant to treatment
Tree pollen reveals 150,000 years of monsoon history—and a warning for Australia’s northern rainfall
Best skin care ingredients revealed in thorough, national review
MicroRNA is awarded an Impact Factor Ranking for 2024
From COVID to cancer, new at-home test spots disease with startling accuracy
Now accepting submissions: Special Collection on Cognitive Aging
Young adult literature is not as young as it used to be
[Press-News.org] Looming malpracticeWaiting for claims resolution takes up more than ten per cent of the average medical career