Use of Drug-Detecting Dog at Issue in Supreme Court Case

Supreme Court is considering allowing the warrantless use of drug-detecting dogs. This could have a major impact upon those facing drug charges.

2013-01-29

January 29, 2013 (Press-News.org) Seemingly each session, the Supreme Court will hear cases regarding actions by law enforcement personnel in their investigations into drug crimes. The Court is asked to determine if these procedures infringe upon our constitutional rights. Often, the decisions expand the use of police power, making it more difficult for those accused of crime to present a strong defense against the accusations.

Recently, the Court heard a case concerning the use of a drug-detecting dog during a Florida traffic stop. This case could lead to many more people being charged with drug crimes.

A man was observed driving a vehicle that had expired license plate tags. The police officer, on patrol with his drug-detecting dog, believed that the man was exhibiting signs that indicated drug use. He asked the man for permission to search the vehicle.

The man refused consent, and the officer led the dog around the vehicle to determine if the dog could detect any drugs present in a free-air sniff. The dog indicated a hit on the vehicle's door handle. Based upon the dog's alert, the officer conducted a search of the man's vehicle, and did so without obtaining a warrant. The search turned up chemicals used to make methamphetamines.

The issue that the Court is considering concerns whether or not the dog's indication was enough to give the officer probable cause to perform a warrantless search. The Florida Supreme Court excluded the evidence, because there was not enough information to determine if the dog was reliable in tracking down illegal drugs, and this ruling was appealed.

There is no standard test or criteria that must be used to train these dogs. In this case, the officer had spent a significant amount of time working with and training the dog, but only recorded the dog's successes. If the officer made an arrest, it was credited as a successful alert by the dog. If the dog alerted to drugs, but none were found, it was not reported in the dog's results.

The Supreme Court must determine if using the dogs to run a probable cause search would violate the Fourth Amendment's protections against illegal searches and seizures. If the Court rules that the police properly followed procedures in this instance, it could lead to many more searches of vehicles if a dog alerts to the presence of drugs.

If you have been charged with a drug crime, it is important to offer a strong defense against these accusations. A conviction can carry penalties that can impact your entire life. Speak to an experienced criminal defense attorney to understand how to protect your rights.

Article provided by Borsberry Law Offices, P.C.
Visit us at www.borsberrylaw.com

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Another Florida Car Accident Death Likely from Texting Behind the Wheel

2013-01-29

Unfortunately, the news is becoming all too common of Floridians who die because they or someone else uses cell phones to text behind the wheel. Only 29 years old, a Tampa man died in a single-vehicle crash on a Tuesday evening in November 2012 near the Gandy Bridge in St. Petersburg. His cell phone was found in the front seat displaying an incomplete text message, suggesting that the driver had probably been texting when he lost control of his speeding car. The driver apparently overcorrected after having veered onto the median and hit a power pole and palm trees. He ...

Study Shows "Never Events" in Surgery Actually Occur Quite Often

2013-01-29

It is a truth universally acknowledged that surgery is something no one wants to go through. However, if it is necessary, patients rightfully expect that the surgeon will exhibit the level of vigilance and competence necessary to make the operation go smoothly and error-free. Unfortunately, a recent study confirms that certain types of surgical errors that surgeons agree should never happen--called "never events"--actually happen more often than you would believe. Never events include egregious mistakes such as accidentally leaving medical tools or equipment ...

Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy Syndrome Overpowers Victims of the Illness

2013-01-29

It may be one of the most agonizing physical diseases. The pain is more than twice as distressing as a broken bone. It is more excruciating than childbirth or having a limb amputated. The condition is reflex sympathetic dystrophy syndrome (RSD), otherwise known as complex regional pain syndrome. There is very little known about the disease; yet, researchers suspect that the disorder commences with a traumatic injury, such as a car accident. It is estimated 50,000 people develop RSD each year. Research suggests that cause is not only neurological, but also inflammatory ...

Snowmobile Accidents: A Potential Danger to Minnesota Sled Enthusiasts

2013-01-29

There's no feeling like gliding across an open field or tearing over a frozen lake on your favorite snowmobile. For many Minnesotans, snowmobiling is the recreational activity that defines winter, something to look forward to during the long months of cold temperatures and early darkness. Yet, thrilling as it is, snowmobiling can be a dangerous activity; Minnesota snowmobile accidents are all too common. From defective sleds to carelessness by fellow riders, the potential risks to snowmobilers are vast. Defective sleds, reckless snowmobilers, road traffic all serious ...

The Distribution of Inherited Property in a Divorce

2013-01-29

In September 2012, the Court of Appeals of Oregon opined on issues relating to the division of inherited property pursuant to a divorce. The case sheds light on some important property division issues. Morton v. Morton began when Wife filed for divorce. A lower court awarded Wife spousal support and allocated the couple's property and debts between Husband and Wife. After the case, Husband appealed the property division. The crux of the appeal was Wife's inheritance from her father during the last years of the couple's marriage. In the Court of Appeals, Husband challenged ...

Truck Accidents Take a Toll on Florida's Commuters

2013-01-29

Trucks can be dangerous on Florida's roads and streets. Recently, the city of Tampa was considering a settlement in a lawsuit filed on behalf of a child who was seriously injured by a utility truck driven by a city employee. Child struck by a city truck In November 2009, a four-year-old was riding his tricycle near his home in unincorporated Hillsborough County. This area receives water service from the city of Tampa, and a meter reader for the city was in the neighborhood to check water meters. The meter reader was using a city truck and had been out of the truck ...

Even With Homicides Up in Chicago, Evidence Falls Short in Murder Cases

2013-01-29

According to Chicago police officials, the city ended 2012 with a total of 506 homicides. This number represented an increase of 15 percent from 2011. In the first 16 days of 2013, Chicago logged 25 homicides -- on pace to overtake the 40 homicides recorded a year ago in January of 2012. Yet, even with homicides on the rise, murder convictions are down in the Windy City. Some experts believe that one of the primary reasons is that fewer people have been willing to come forward as witnesses. Witnesses reluctant to talk to Chicago police Twenty years ago, the clearance ...

Eyeglasses Retailer America's Best Encourages Cataract Awareness

2013-01-29

America's Best understands that most people only think about their eye health if they can't see or if the need a new pair of glasses. But for people over 50, cataracts may be an issue that can cause a deterioration in vision. Understanding the risks and how to detect cataracts can help people over 50 to protect their vision. Cataracts are a clouding of the lens of the eye that can be caused by age, exposure to sunlight, certain medications or injury. Some health conditions may also contribute to the development of cataracts. Cataracts are like a filmy haze that cover ...

Atlanta Pest Control Company, Team Pest USA, Encourages Referrals Through Its New Referral Program

2013-01-29

Team Pest USA, an Atlanta pest control company, is pleased to announce that it is now offering money back on services for any customer who refers a new customer through its new referral program. Existing customers will receive a $100 credit or discount on their current Team Pest USA account when they refer other homeowners who ultimately become Atlanta termite control, pest control and/or wildlife/exclusion customers with Team Pest USA. Customers can submit referrals by filling out a convenient form online or calling the Team Pest USA office at 770-985-4444. Customers ...

Atlanta Worker's Comp Lawyer Experts, Cummings & Middlebrooks, Manages Twitter Account

2013-01-29

Atlanta workers' compensation attorneys are on Twitter. If there is one website that has exploded in growth in the last couple of years, it is Twitter. This social media platform has experienced unparalleled expansion since it started just a few years ago. Sites like Facebook and Pinterest are noteworthy competitors, but Twitter seems to be in a league of its own. This is why the Atlanta workers' compensation attorneys at Cummings & Middlebrooks decided to create an account for their business. Specializing in Atlanta workers' compensation law, the firm knew there ...