US Supreme Court to decide if warrantless blood draws OK in DWI cases

The U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments in a case regarding whether warrantless blood draws should be allowed in suspected DWI cases.

2013-03-23

March 23, 2013 (Press-News.org) US Supreme Court to decide if warrantless blood draws OK in DWI cases

Earlier this year, the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments in a case involving the right of those suspected of driving while under the influence to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures.

The case before the Supreme Court stemmed from an incident in which a driver was pulled over by a police officer for speeding. The law enforcement official believed the driver was under the influence of alcohol and performed field sobriety tests.

The motorist refused a request to take a breathalyzer, which led the police officer to take him to a local hospital. At the hospital, the driver refused to allow a blood test to determine his blood alcohol content. Nevertheless, the police officer ordered a medical professional to perform the blood draw. The test revealed that the driver's blood alcohol content was nearly two times the legal limit -- 0.15.

At no point during the process did the police officer make any efforts to obtain a warrant for the blood test. He simply ordered the test to be completed when the driver refused consent. Later, the officer told authorities that he did not think he was required to obtain a warrant prior to ordering the blood draw.

The U.S. Supreme Court has since been left with the question of whether the circumstances justified the failure to obtain a warrant prior to ordering the blood test.

During oral arguments for the case -- Missouri v. McNeely -- the justices appeared hesitant to concede that warrants should never be required before ordering blood draws in suspected DWI cases.

The government argued that requiring warrants in such situations would allow time for alcohol to dissipate in the motorist's blood. Nevertheless, it was acknowledged that in some circumstances, warrants can be obtained in a matter of minutes.

Some of the justices expressed concern about ignoring the protections provided in the Fourth Amendment when such an intrusive procedure -- drawing blood -- is at issue. The Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution provides that people have the right "to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures."

The justices noted that breathalyzer tests would not pose the same level of intrusion; however, attorneys for the government stated it was a difficult proposition to force an individual to submit to a breathalyzer.

Protect your rights when facing a DWI charge

When facing criminal charges, it is important to be aware of your rights. If you are currently facing driving while intoxicated charges, consulting with a skilled, criminal defense attorney will ensure a strong defense is established on your behalf.

Article provided by Kyle Simpson & Charles Gold
Visit us at www.yourtexasdwi.com/

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

First U.S. Actos trial underway in California Superior Court

2013-03-23

First U.S. Actos trial underway in California Superior Court In early March 2013, the first trial of a lawsuit involving the diabetes drug, Actos, began in a Los Angeles courtroom. The case involves a type 2 diabetes patient who took Actos to treat his diabetes symptoms and then developed bladder cancer. The plaintiff sued Takeda Pharmaceuticals, the drug manufacturing giant based in Osaka, Japan, alleging that the company hid evidence of a dangerous link between its drug and a heightened chance of developing bladder cancer. A Bloomberg article details early testimony ...

U.S. Supreme Court decides one of two drug-sniffing dog cases

2013-03-23

U.S. Supreme Court decides one of two drug-sniffing dog cases The use of drug-sniffing dogs seems commonplace to police work these days, but certain constitutional issues regarding the Fourth Amendment's protection from unreasonable search and seizure involving drug-sniffing dogs have not yet been resolved. The resolution of these issues is profound for criminal defense purposes. Near the end of last year, the U.S. Supreme Court heard two cases on the potential limits to police using drug-sniffing dogs. The first dealt with the reasonableness of a warrantless search ...

Child pornography cases increasing in Washington

2013-03-23

Child pornography cases increasing in Washington Few crimes receive as much attention in the media as child pornography charges. If the offender has any occupation that provides access to children, there will be additional pressure on prosecutors to obtain a conviction. Because these cases have such a high-profile, many of the suspects are presumed guilty before they have an opportunity to offer a defense against the accusations. This can impact a person's entire life - families can be ruined, jobs and professional licenses may be in jeopardy, and this is before any ...

Wisconsin's new child pornography law faces criticism

2013-03-23

Wisconsin's new child pornography law faces criticism In 2012, a new law was enacted in Wisconsin that imposes a mandatory prison sentence for individuals convicted of the charge of possessing child pornography. In an attempt to ensure consistency in sentencing, the law requires individuals to be sentenced to three years in prison in almost all circumstances. As the new law is being applied to new cases, however, some judges and other members of the court system say this one-size-fits-all approach is not appropriate. Under the old law, judges had the discretion to ...

Defending theft crimes - a look beyond the legal system

2013-03-23

Defending theft crimes - a look beyond the legal system Theft crimes often have a mental health connection. Studies have shown that addictive/compulsive behaviors like those present in substance abuse cases are often seen in those who compulsively commit theft crimes such as shoplifting. For others, there may be some traumatic event that contributes to the urge to steal. Recognizing that theft is not just a legal issue changes the focus to a holistic approach in the defense of this criminal charge. Competing considerations Obviously, anyone facing theft charges ...

When prescription medicine hurts instead of helps the patient

2013-03-23

When prescription medicine hurts instead of helps the patient Doctors, nurses, hospitals and pharmacists have the duty to see that medication is prescribed carefully and appropriately, filled accurately and administered correctly. The stakes couldn't be higher: prescription mistakes can cause injury, death and addiction. Medical professionals are expected to adhere to the reasonable standards and practices of others within in their specialties in their communities. Failure to do so may open them up to medical malpractice liability. Patient screening In contemplation ...

No criminal charges in fatal ski collision, prosecutors say

2013-03-23

No criminal charges in fatal ski collision, prosecutors say A Colorado ski trip took a deadly turn recently when two skiers collided on Aspen Mountain. After an investigation of the incident, prosecutors have decided not to press criminal charges against the surviving skier, CBS News reported. The collision occurred on February 4, 2013, when a 48-year-old woman was struck by another skier while standing on lower Spar Gulch, the mountain's main run. The woman had reportedly come to a stop after skiing down an expert trail when she was struck by another skier who merged ...

Studies show head injuries more serious than suspected

2013-03-23

Studies show head injuries more serious than suspected According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, about 1.7 million people in the U.S. suffer traumatic brain injuries each year. Medical professionals classify TBI as an acquired form of brain damage where sudden trauma to the head causes damage to the brain. TBI can range from mild, such as when people get struck in the head and sustain a momentary loss of consciousness, to severe injuries where an object pierces the skull and penetrates brain tissue. Three studies published in March 2013 reveal that ...

Switch And Save On Energy Bills With Comparethemarket.com

2013-03-23

With 1 in 5 households in Britain spending more than 10% of their income on gas and electricity according to new research, many consumers are looking for ways to make savings on their utility bills . Using a price comparison site such as comparethemarket.com is one way of making sure you have the most affordable deal on the market. Russell Davis, Director of Utilities at comparethemarket.com explains: "With gas and electricity bills taking up a significant percentage of household income for so many people, making a saving can make a big difference to the household ...

Online Pawnshop PawnUp.com is Increasing their List of Accepted Items - Again

2013-03-23

"It is not a secret that many online pawn stores keep on limiting the list of valuables they accept. The reasoning behind this business model, I believe, is their inability to move these types of items and or make big profits on them. Here, at PawnUp.com, we want to make a difference and help more people get more cash for their items as often as possible. For these reasons, we decided to increase our list of accepted items again." - said Jay Martin, a spokesperson for PawnUp.com. Online pawnshop PawnUp.com has helped thousands of people to get cash for their ...