US Supreme Court says dog's alert enough to search vehicle

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled that a dog's alert is sufficient to provide probable cause to search a vehicle in a traffic stop.

2013-03-26

March 26, 2013 (Press-News.org) US Supreme Court says dog's alert enough to search vehicle

The U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments in two cases involving drug-sniffing dogs this term. Recently, Justice Elena Kagan issued the unanimous decision for the court for one of the cases. The decision for the second case is expected later this year.

Writing for the majority, Justice Kagan overturned the decision of the Florida Supreme Court and placed a certain degree of trust in the abilities of drug-detection dogs and their handlers. The case involves the right of Americans to be free from "unreasonable searches and seizures," as spelled out in the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.

The facts of the case

The case, Florida v. Harris, arose when a police officer pulled over a motorist who was driving a vehicle with an expired license plate tag. The law enforcement officer believed the driver was exhibiting strange behavior, possibly indicating he was under the influence of drugs.

The officer asked to search the vehicle, but the driver refused. The police officer then used a drug-sniffing dog to determine whether there were substances inside the vehicle. The officer reported that the dog alerted to drugs near the driver's door. Consequently, the police officer conducted a search of the vehicle.

Although the officer did not find any illegal substances in the car, he found materials used to manufacture methamphetamine. The dog had not been trained to detect the materials found in the vehicle. Nevertheless, the driver was convicted of a drug crime.

The Florida Supreme Court later reversed the conviction, though, finding that there was not sufficient evidence of the dog's ability to detect drugs. The Florida high court provided a long list of information that should be provided to prove a dog's capabilities.

The US Supreme Court's decision

The U.S. Supreme Court reversed the Florida Supreme's Court decision. Justice Kagan found that the police officer had probable cause to search the vehicle, based on the dog's alert.

The decision stated that there was enough evidence of the dog's "reliability in detecting drugs," based on "training and testing records." The court held that the Florida Supreme Court's decision was "inconsistent with the 'flexible, common-sense standard' of probable cause." Therefore, the dog's handler was not required to present all of the information set forth in the Florida high court's decision to prove the drug-sniffing dog's qualifications.

If you have been accused of a drug crime, consulting with a knowledgeable criminal defense attorney is a wise step to ensure a strong defense is established on your behalf.

Article provided by Paoletti & Gusmano, Attorneys at Law
Visit us at www.paolettilaw.net/

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Bayer sets aside $1 billion to settle Yasmin and Yaz claims

2013-03-26

Bayer sets aside $1 billion to settle Yasmin and Yaz claims Yasmin, the oral contraceptive, was introduced to the market in 2001. The drug's manufacturer, Bayer, marketed the drug as a treatment for acne and severe premenstrual symptoms, in addition to its birth control benefits. The drug was a hit, bringing in $1.47 billion in sales during 2010 alone. Although the drug was a financial success, it came with a price--deadly side effects. The drug has been linked to an increased risk of blood clots that often result in heart attacks and strokes. As a result, since 2009, ...

Michigan's no-fault insurance reform, good for insurers, bad for accident victims

2013-03-26

Michigan's no-fault insurance reform, good for insurers, bad for accident victims In Michigan, drivers injured in automobile accidents have been able to receive lifetime benefits for their injuries regardless of who was at fault for the accident. Insurance reform has been a hot topic of late and proponents of reform seem to have made gains in a recently proposed Senate bill, SB 251. The bill seeks to eliminate uncapped medical benefits for motor vehicle accident victims and dissolve the association that funds these benefits. Michigan PIP benefits and proposed changes Currently ...

Use Chapter 13 bankruptcy to help manage student loan debt

2013-03-26

Use Chapter 13 bankruptcy to help manage student loan debt In 2012 the Federal Reserve Bank of New York announced that student loan debt in the U.S. was over $1 trillion and had exceeded the total amount of credit card debt in the country for the first time. The situation is only getting worse as 2013 continues on. Many people have experienced the crushing burden of student loan debt while being unable to find employment in the underperforming economy. Those with student loans often feel like they have no options for debt relief, since student loans are not usually dischargeable ...

Division of property in Illinois divorces

2013-03-26

Division of property in Illinois divorces No marriage is perfect. Even the happiest couples will have the occasional disagreement, but in most cases, these arguments are resolved before they become major problems. However, these disagreements may increase over time, leading the spouses to spend less time together. This can place a great deal of stress on the marriage, and the couple may decide that getting a divorce may be the best thing for their situation. In Illinois, when a spouse files for divorce, there will be several issues that will need to be addressed before ...

What options are available to those struggling with medical expenses?

2013-03-26

What options are available to those struggling with medical expenses? Financial problems can impact even the best planners when they least expect it. Unforeseen events arise and significantly drain any resources available. Because of the most recent recession, many people do not have enough savings to overcome any of these unplanned emergencies. When an individual experiences health problems, this can often lead to costly medical care and treatments. While many people have health insurance to defray some of the costs that arise, it may not cover all of the expenses ...

The Jones Act protects seamen

2013-03-26

The Jones Act protects seamen Admiralty law has traditionally considered seamen "wards of admiralty," and deserving of the protection of the law. As such, admiralty law imposed an obligation on vessel owners to care for seamen who sustained injuries while working. If a seaman was injured during a voyage, the ship owner had to provide transportation and wages until the end of the trip. Additionally, the owner had to provide "maintenance and cure" to the seaman after the voyage ended -- payment for medical care and a small stipend for living expenses ...

Report shows credit card debt rising across the US

2013-03-26

Report shows credit card debt rising across the US Earlier this year, the Federal Reserve Bank of New York issued a report regarding our collective debt as a nation. According to the report, in the third quarter of 2012, our overall debt in the U.S. fell by $74 billion. During the same period, though, the amount of credit card debt across the country actually increased by $2 billion. According to TransUnion, a credit bureau, from July through September 2012, the average credit card holder in the United States had $4,996 in credit card debt. The credit bureau has predicted ...

Pedestrian accidents still a problem in New York City

2013-03-26

Pedestrian accidents still a problem in New York City New York City is filled with pedestrians and bicyclists. Residents rely upon alternate means of transportation simply because it makes getting around that much easier when traffic is backed up. Even though the city has made improvements to pedestrian and cyclist safety, many of these people know that they need to remain alert to avoid potential bicycle or pedestrian accidents. Those pedestrians or cyclists involved in collisions with motor vehicles will often be the ones absorbing the full impact of the crash, ...

The top ten speeding ticket cities in Dallas County

2013-03-26

The top ten speeding ticket cities in Dallas County Dallas County has seen a significant amount of growth over the past decade. According to United States Census numbers, the region is home to over six million people. Many businesses and industries have headquarters within one of the cities located in the county, and the area is also very popular with tourists. With so many people living and working in the region, area highways are often filled with motorists headed to their destinations. More traffic means more accidents, and more accidents means that law enforcement ...

Stopping Speeding Means Stopping Serious Car Accidents

2013-03-26

Speeding is one of the prevailing factors in traffic crashes and serious car accidents, according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. Serious car accidents affect victims, the perpetrators, and society for years after the event; our Miami car accident attorneys have helped clients who suffered from head trauma, spinal cord injuries, amputations, and other life-altering effects gain justice, but the damage done in split seconds is often irreversible. In 2005, the cost of crash-related deaths and injuries among drivers and passengers was $70 billion, ...