The Negative Impact of Tort Reform

Most tort reform acts could increase injury rates among Americans. Tort law was originally developed specifically to decrease injury rates by holding the responsible party legally liable.

2010-11-04

November 04, 2010 (Press-News.org) The View From Our South Florida Personal Injury Law Firm

"Tort law" is the legal term for personal injury law. Tort law is the body of law that dictates what obligations a person has when he or she causes injury to another person. Tort liability has two primary functions within our civil legal system:
- To encourage individuals and companies to act with special care when their actions may affect the safety of another person, by making carelessness punishable by payments to the injured person
- To provide a measure of justice for a person injured through no fault of his or her own, in the form of financial compensation from the responsible person or company

What Is Tort Reform?

Tort reform occurs when the legislature passes a law or a court issues a ruling that limits in some way the rights of an injured person to seek compensation -- via a personal injury lawsuit -- from the person who caused the accident. For example, in 1996 the United States Supreme Court engaged in tort reform when it ruled that excessively high punitive damages violate the substantive due process clause of the Constitution.

Closer to home, the Florida legislature engaged in tort reform in 2003, when it passed a law limiting the amount of financial compensation that medical malpractice victims can seek.

Legislatures around the country have engaged in all types of tort reform. Some common types of tort reform include shortening the time frames within which an injured person must file a lawsuit; making it more difficult for an injured person to get a trial by jury; and limiting attorneys' fees in tort cases.

What Are the Negative Effects of Tort Reform

Looking at the big picture, most tort reform acts have the potential to increase injury rates among Americans. Tort law was originally developed specifically to decrease injury rates by holding the responsible party legally liable.

Time and again in our nation's history, individual and class action tort cases have uncovered life-threatening hazards that otherwise would have remained undetected.
- If it wasn't economically feasible for a tort lawyer to investigate the Ford Motor Company, Ford Pintos would possibly still be exploding.
- If tort attorneys had never sued Bridgestone/Firestone, perhaps the tire company would have delayed its recall of dangerous tires.
- Tort lawyers discovered the negative health consequences of the diet drug Fen-phen and countless other prescription medications and over-the-counter remedies.

Moving from the big picture to the level of the individual who has suffered serious injury because of someone else's careless or reckless behavior -- no reliable data exists on the number of accident victims who choose not to file a lawsuit because tort reform laws obstruct their opportunity to get fair financial compensation. How many people have been driven out of work, into bankruptcy, and had their families destroyed because the American legal system did not support them when they needed financial support?

Article provided by Greenberg & Stone, P.A.
Visit us at www.sgglaw.com

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Inmate Abuse by Corrections Officers and the Legal Recourse Available

2010-11-04

Contrary to popular belief, inmate abuse is not a thing of the past. Misconduct and excessive force against inmates still occur today in New York and throughout the country. Correctional facilities such as Rikers Island Prison have recently landed in the news for the egregious inmate abuse occurring within their walls. Rikers Island Inmate Abuse Lloyd Nicholson, a former corrections officer at the Rikers Island Prison Complex, was recently sentenced to six years in prison for a series of assaults that occurred while he worked as a guard. A jury found Nicholson guilty ...

Medical Malpractice Cases Do Not Affect Health Care Costs

2010-11-04

In 2003, when Jeb Bush was governor, Florida passed a law to limit allowable financial compensation in medical malpractice lawsuits. According to those in favor of medical malpractice caps, a flood of high awards in medical malpractice cases forced health care costs to rise. Limiting the maximum possible medical malpractice award would result in lower health care costs, so the argument went. Why? At the time, Florida medical malpractice insurance rates were the highest in the nation. According to proponents of medical malpractice caps, doctors and hospitals were passing ...

DUI Repeat Offenders Could Lose License for 10 Years under New CA Law

2010-11-04

According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, there are over 310,000 individuals with three or more DUIs (driving under the influence) convictions in California today. If a bill recently signed by Governor Schwarzenegger had been in effect when they received their third conviction, most of those people would have no driver's license today. The bill, AB 1601, was signed into law on September 25, 2010 and on January 1, 2012 will officially give judges the authority to revoke an individual's driver's license for ten years if he or she receives his or ...

Product Scares Bring Attention to FDA's Lack of Recall Power

2010-11-04

Every week there is seemingly a new product recall of some sort in the news. Whether it's automobiles or baby toys, a product is being removed from market shelves across the country. Many people may fail to realize, however, that when it comes to pulling defective food and drugs off market shelves, the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) has no authority to order companies to recall their products. In light of two recent recalls, Congress is proposing bills to reconsider this. Eggs and Motrin This past summer, news of eggs tainted with salmonella erupted nationwide. ...

Americans and Debt: The Downward Spiral of Default

2010-11-04

Easy access to credit through the past decade is now catching up with many Americans. In prosperous times, Americans were borrowing enormous amount of money but still getting by making their monthly car, student loan, and mortgage payments. But since the economic downturn, millions of Americans are now defaulting on these loans and finding out the dangers that go along with evading their loan obligations. Money Judgments and Home Equity Loans Some housing experts say the number of shoddy home equity loans issued during the housing boom is incalculable. The housing ...

Florida's HTO Amnesty Program

2010-11-04

In Florida, a person designated as a Habitual Traffic Offender (HTO) loses their license to drive for a period of five years. You may be given that designation by the Department of Highway Safety Motor Vehicles (DHSMV) by having three convictions for any of the following offenses within a five year period: - Voluntary or involuntary manslaughter resulting from the operation of a motor vehicle - Any violation of 316.193 (driving under the influence or DUI) - Any felony in the commission of which a motor vehicle is used - Driving a motor vehicle while your license is ...

Avoiding Potential Pitfalls in Nursing Home Admissions Paperwork

2010-11-04

Be on the Lookout for Arbitration Agreements That Could Jeopardize Your Rights The decision to admit yourself or a vulnerable loved one to a nursing home, residential care center or assisted living facility is a difficult one. Admission may be precipitated by a sudden downturn in health, the loss of a trusted at-home caregiver or other emotion-laden situations. Nursing home admissions come not only with a multitude of stresses to be felt and decisions to be made; they also come with a lot of paperwork. Hidden deep within admission forms is likely to be a provision ...

Nursing Home Bed Rails Pose a Danger to Vulnerable Patients

2010-11-04

Harry Griph Sr. was expected to die. The 75-year-old retired phone company worker was in an assisted living facility as a hospice patient. The prognosis was grim: his chronic diseases and functional impairments indicated he was very near the end of life. The New York Times reports that a staff member found him dead on Christmas morning. But Griph hadn't died of natural causes. His neck was trapped between the bed rail and the mattress. He had died of suffocation. Griph's three children and his estate sued the nursing home where he died, the hospice provider, the maker ...

Domestic Violence Issues in a Child Custody Context

2010-11-04

As another National Domestic Violence Awareness Month comes to a close, there are millions of people around the country who are suffering in silence. Domestic abuse is one of the most underreported crimes in the nation, due in part because there is no clear-cut definition of what it is. California's laws governing domestic violence are very broad, something that victim advocates applaud and anyone who has been falsely accused laments. Contrary to popular belief, "abuse" does not have to result in physical injury to be considered as contributing to an environment of violence ...

Schillings Hails Radmacher Ruling as More Than Just Financial Opportunity

2010-11-04

Schillings has revealed that a landmark legal ruling made by the Supreme Court has given significant strength to the rights of couples ahead of marriage to divide their assets in the event that the marriage breaks down. The Supreme Court decided that prenuptial agreements should be given 'decisive weight' in divorce proceedings, rather than merely being taken into account alongside a number of other factors such as the standard of life enjoyed during the marriage and the earning capacity of the parties. Commenting on the ruling, Keith Schilling, founder and senior ...