Blind(fold)ed by science: Study shows the strategy humans use to chase objects

Vision and hearing work together in the brain to help us catch a moving target

2013-06-26

(Press-News.org) COLUMBUS, Ohio—A new study has found that chasing down a moving object is not only a matter of sight or of sound, but of mind.

The study found that people who are blindfolded employ the same strategy to intercept a running ball carrier as people who can see, which suggests that multiple areas of the brain cooperate to accomplish the task.

Regardless of whether they could see or not, the study participants seemed to aim ahead of the ball carrier's trajectory and then run to the spot where they expected him or her to be in the near future. Researchers call this a "constant target-heading angle" strategy, similar to strategies used by dogs catching Frisbees and baseball players catching fly balls.

It's also the best way to catch an object that is trying to evade capture, explained Dennis Shaffer, assistant professor of psychology at The Ohio State University at Mansfield.

"The constant-angle strategy geometrically guarantees that you'll reach your target, if your speed and the target's speed stay constant, and you're both moving in a straight line. It also gives you leeway to adjust if the target abruptly changes direction to evade you," Shaffer said.

"The fact that people run after targets at a constant angle regardless of whether they can see or not suggests that there are brain mechanisms in place that we would call 'polymodal'—areas of the brain that serve more than one form of sensory modality. Sight and hearing may be different senses, but within the brain the results of the sensory input for this task may be the same."

The study appears in the journal Psychonomic Bulletin and Review.

Nine people participated in the study—mainly students at Ohio State and Arizona State University, where the study took place. Some had experience playing football, either at a high school or collegiate intramural level, while others had limited or no experience with football.

The nine of them donned motion-capture equipment and took turns in pairs, one running a football across a 20-meter field (nearly 22 yards), and one chasing. They randomly assigned participants to sighted and blindfolded conditions. In the blindfolded condition, participants wore a sleep mask and the runner carried a foam football with a beeping device inside, so that the chaser had a chance to locate them by sound. The runners ran in the general direction of the chasers at different angles, and sometimes the runner would cut right or left halfway through the run.

The study was designed so that the pursuer wouldn't have time to consciously think about how to catch the runner.

"We were just focused on trying to touch the runner as soon as possible and before they exited the field," Shaffer said. "The idea was to have the strategy emerge by instinct."

About 97 percent of the time, the person doing the chasing used the constant-angle strategy—even when they were blindfolded and only able to hear the beeping football.

The results were surprising, even to Shaffer.

"I knew that this seemed to be a universal strategy across species, but I expected that people's strategies would vary more when they were blindfolded, just because we aren't used to running around blindfolded. I didn't expect that the blindfolded strategies would so closely match the sighted ones."

The findings suggest that there's some common area in the brain that processes sight and sound together when we're chasing something.

There is another strategy for catching moving targets. Researchers call it the pursuit or aiming strategy, because it involves speeding directly at the target's current location. It's how apex predators such as sharks catch prey.

"As long as you are much faster than your prey, the pursuit strategy is great. You just overtake them," Shaffer said.

In a situation where the competition is more equal, the constant-angle strategy works better—the pursuer doesn't have to be faster than the target, and if the target switches direction, the pursuer has time to adjust.

The study builds on Shaffer's previous work with how collegiate-level football players chase ball carriers. He's also studied how people catch baseballs and dogs catch Frisbees. All appear to use strategies similar to the constant target-heading angle strategy, which suggests that a common neural mechanism could be at work.

### Coauthors on the paper included Igor Dolgov of New Mexico State University; Eric McManama, Charles Swank, Andrew B. Maynor and Kahlin Kelly of The Ohio State University at Mansfield; and John G. Neuhoff of the College of Wooster. The motion-capture trials took place in the laboratory of Michael McBeath at Arizona State University. Contact: Dennis Shaffer, (216) 513-1982; Shaffer.247@osu.edu

Written by Pam Frost Gorder, (614) 292-9475; Gorder.1@osu.edu END

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Immunohistochemistry effectively detects ALK rearrangement

2013-06-26

DENVER – ALK rearrangement has been demonstrated to be a potent oncogenic driver and a promising therapeutic target in non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). It defines a distinct molecular subset of NSCLC, in particular adenocarcinoma that can benefit by the treatment of ALK-inhibitors. Development of robust and reliable laboratory tests for predictive biomarkers is essential to select appropriate patients for targeted therapy. Researchers from the Chinese University of Hong King evaluated the practical usefulness of immunohistochemistry to detect ALK expression as a reliable ...

Continued research needed on treatment for women with lung cancer who are never smokers

2013-06-26

DENVER – The incidence of lung cancer in women affects an estimated 516,000 women worldwide, of which 100,000 are in the United States and 70,000 in Europe. Until now, lung cancers occurring in women have been treated similarly to lung cancers in men. However, numerous studies have highlighted different characteristics of lung cancer in women. Researchers at the University of Toulouse III in France aim to compare clinical, pathological and biological characteristics of lung cancer in cohorts of women smokers and women never-smokers. They looked at a total of 140 women, ...

PET-CT improves care of limited-stage small-cell lung cancer patients

2013-06-26

DENVER – Each year, 13 percent of all newly diagnosed lung cancer patients are diagnosed with small-cell lung cancer (SCLC). Approximately 39 percent of patients with SCLC are diagnosed with limited-stage disease, meaning the cancer is only present in one lung, but may have spread to lymph nodes or tissue between the lungs. These patients are often treated with chemotherapy and definitive radiation therapy. Staging information is essential because of the high propensity for metastatic disease in SCLC, and the identification of metastases can spare patients from the toxicity ...

Study details cancer-promoting mechanisms of overlooked components in secondhand smoke

2013-06-26

Tobacco smoke, diesel exhaust and oil combustion carry polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons – PAHs that are known to cause cancer. But of these PAHs, the obviously dangerous high-molecular-weight PAHs like benzo[a]pyrene (BaP) have received the vast majority of research attention. Their low-molecular-weight cousins have been largely overlooked, in part because studies have shown that these compounds alone aren't very successful at mutating genes in cancer-causing ways. A University of Colorado Cancer Center study published in the journal PLoS One explores two of these low-molecular-weight ...

Vietnam vets with PTSD more than twice as likely to have heart disease

2013-06-26

Male twin Vietnam veterans with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) were more than twice as likely as those without PTSD to develop heart disease during a 13-year period, according to a study supported by the National Institutes of Health. This is the first long-term study to measure the association between PTSD and heart disease using objective clinical diagnoses combined with cardiac imaging techniques. "This study provides further evidence that PTSD may affect physical health," said Gary H. Gibbons, M.D., director of the NIH's National Heart, Lung, and Blood ...

'Active surveillance' may miss aggressive prostate cancers in black men

2013-06-26

A Johns Hopkins study of more than 1,800 men ages 52 to 62 suggests that African-Americans diagnosed with very-low-risk prostate cancers are much more likely than white men to actually have aggressive disease that goes unrecognized with current diagnostic approaches. Although prior studies have found it safe to delay treatment and monitor some presumably slow-growing or low-risk prostate cancers, such "active surveillance" (AS) does not appear to be a good idea for black men, the study concludes. "This study offers the most conclusive evidence to date that broad application ...

Hiding in plain sight: New species of bird discovered in capital city

2013-06-26

A team of scientists with the Wildlife Conservation Society, BirdLife International, and other groups have discovered a new species of bird with distinct plumage and a loud call living not in some remote jungle, but in a capital city of 1.5 million people. Called the Cambodian tailorbird (Orthotomus chaktomuk), the previously undescribed species was found in Cambodia's urbanized capitol Phnom Penh and several other locations just outside of the city including a construction site. It is one of only two bird species found solely in Cambodia. The other, the Cambodian laughingthrush, ...

USC research IDs potential treatment for deadly, HIV-related blood cancer

2013-06-26

LOS ANGELES — Researchers at the USC Norris Comprehensive Cancer Center have discovered a promising new way to treat a rare and aggressive blood cancer most commonly found in people infected with HIV. The USC team shows that a class of drugs called BET bromodomain inhibitors effectively targets primary effusion lymphoma (PEL), a type of cancer for which those drugs were not expected to be effective. "It's a reversal of the paradigm," said Preet Chaudhary, MD, PhD, chief of the Nohl Division of Hematology and Blood Diseases at the Keck School of Medicine of USC and ...

Telecoupling pulls pieces of sustainability puzzle together

2013-06-26

Global sustainability is like a high-stakes jigsaw puzzle – and an international group of scientists have created a new framework to assemble the big picture without losing pieces. Scientists led by Jianguo "Jack" Liu, Michigan State University's Rachel Carson Chair in Sustainability, have built an integrated way to study a world that has become more connected – with faster and more socioeconomic and environmental interactions over distances. They say "telecoupling" describes how distance is shrinking and connections are strengthening between nature and humans. In Ecology ...

Human and canine lymphomas share molecular similarities, first large-scale comparison shows

2013-06-26

CHAPEL HILL, N.C. - Humans and their pet dogs are close, so close that they both develop a type of cancer called diffuse large B-cell lymphoma. In humans it's the most common lymphoma subtype while in dogs, it's one of the most common cancers in veterinary oncology. A team of scientists from the University of North Carolina School of Medicine, North Carolina State University's College of Veterinary Medicine and Duke University have conducted one of the first studies to directly compare canine and human B-cell lymphoma by examining molecular similarities and differences ...

Blind(fold)ed by science: Study shows the strategy humans use to chase objects

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES: