(Press-News.org) Contact information: Annmarie Christensen
annmarie.christensen@dartmouth.edu
603-653-0897
Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center
Transforming the physician workforce through competitive graduate education funding
LEBANON, NH – Graduate Medical Education (GME) has fallen short in training physicians to meet changes in the U.S. population and health care delivery systems. But a new proposed funding mechanism coupled to a competitive peer-review process may be the best way to reform the process, according to an analysis and commentary in the November issue of Health Affairs.
Dr. David Goodman, professor at The Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy & Clinical Practice, and Dr. Russell G. Robertson, dean of the Chicago Medical School, note in their analysis that resistance to change is a long-standing problem in Graduate Medical Education. "The current system is remarkably inflexible – a place where good ideas for improving the physician workforce go to perish," they said.
Graduate Medical Education is the three-to-eleven-year period of physician training that follows medical school, commonly known as a residency or fellowship training. The number of training positions and the content of the graduate education determine the number, specialty mix, and competencies of physicians entering the workforce, for example cardiologists, pediatricians, radiologists.
"Progress by teaching hospitals, accreditation organizations, and Congress has been too slow to meet the workforce challenges of our changing and aging population and our health care delivery system," the authors said. "If teaching program performance is not linked to funding, recommendations to reform GME will likely remain in a state of inertia."
GME is primarily paid for with more than $13 billion in public money, with the bulk of it coming from Medicare through complex funding formulas. And, the funding mechanism is tied primarily to hospital-based services, ignoring the growing need for competencies that extend beyond acute patient care to improving clinical systems, team-based care, and longitudinal management of patients in the community.
Another deficiency in the funding mechanism is the "inflexible GME pipeline" that is anchored to the number of residents funded at the time of the passage of the Balanced Budget Act of 1997. Some expansion has occurred but mainly in subspecialties, ignoring the need for additional primary care physicians.
To improve the physician workforce, the authors recommend a new system of funding that is responsive to workforce needs, rewards innovation, and uses explicit outcome objectives to evaluate training programs. The funding would be publicly guided and awarded through competitive funding, similar to the process of awarding National Institute of Health peer-reviewed research grants.
"For the physician workforce to change and improve, there must be a trusted public entity that regularly sets overall goals for training direction and pipeline size," the authors said. The entity should be a federal advisory committee composed of the public, public health experts, health care systems, payers and medical educators.
These goals would guide the development of annual requests for funding proposals. Residency programs would be required to apply and compete for GME funding once every 10 years. This means that each year 10 percent of the nation's training programs would be reviewed. New programs would compete for funding. Existing programs that score poorly would receive reduced funding, while meritorious programs could grow. Awards would be for 10 years to enable teaching organization stability.
Applications would be reviewed through study sections. Programs would also need to report performance measures that include educational capacity, processes and outcomes. These measures would be available to the public including fourth year medical students who are choosing residency programs.
Funding would no longer be linked to residents' time caring for Medicare beneficiaries in acute care settings. "Indirect GME funding would no longer reward the very inefficiencies that health care reform is intended to remedy," the authors said.
This new funding mechanism would be an opportunity to transform the health care workforce by incentivizing innovation and a physician specialty mix that responds to the health care needs of the U.S. population. It would also provide financial and educational stability to graduate programs by instituting changes incrementally.
###
The full article may be found at Health Affairs at http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/32/11/1887.abstract
The Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy & Clinical Practice was founded in 1988 by Dr. John E. Wennberg as the Center for the Evaluative Clinical Sciences (CECS). Among its 25 years of accomplishments, it has established a new discipline and educational focus in the Evaluative Clinical Sciences, introduced and advanced the concept of shared decision-making for patients, demonstrated unwarranted variation in the practice and outcomes of medical treatment, developed the first comprehensive examination of US health care variations (The Dartmouth Atlas), and has shown that more health care is not necessarily better care.
Transforming the physician workforce through competitive graduate education funding
2013-11-11
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
How sleep aids visual task learning
2013-11-11
How sleep aids visual task learning
Research presented at SfN Neuroscience 2013
PROVIDENCE, R.I. [Brown University] — As any indignant teacher would scold, students must be awake to learn. But what science is showing with increasing sophistication is how the ...
Exercise during pregnancy gives newborn brain development a head start
2013-11-11
Exercise during pregnancy gives newborn brain development a head start
As little as 20 minutes 3 times per week is enough to enhance brain activity
This news release is available in French. MONTREAL and SAN DIEGO, NOVEMBER 10, 2013 – As little ...
Single-cell genome sequencing gets better
2013-11-11
Single-cell genome sequencing gets better
Most complete genome sequences from single E. coli cells and individual neurons from the human brain generated by new sequencing approach from UC San Diego bioengineers and colleagues
Researchers led by bioengineers ...
Racial difference in blood clotting warrants a closer look at heart attack medications
2013-11-11
Racial difference in blood clotting warrants a closer look at heart attack medications
(PHILADELPHIA) Thomas Jefferson University researchers have discovered that the formation of blood clots follows a different molecular route in African Americans ...
Research by Saint Louis University scientists offers way to disrupt fibrosis
2013-11-11
Research by Saint Louis University scientists offers way to disrupt fibrosis
Nature Medicine paper pinpoints where, how to intervene
ST. LOUIS – A team of scientists that includes Saint Louis University researchers has identified a new way to intervene in the molecular ...
The contribution of coding variants to psoriasis much smaller than thought
2013-11-11
The contribution of coding variants to psoriasis much smaller than thought
The latest study was published online in Nature Genetics
November 10, 2013, Shenzhen, China - Coding variants in immune disease-related genes play only a small part in the overall genetic risk for psoriasis, according ...
Hope for transplant patients as study finds key to organ scarring
2013-11-11
Hope for transplant patients as study finds key to organ scarring
Uni of Edinburgh news release
Patients with damaged organs could be helped by new treatments after scientists have discovered how tissues scar.
Researchers say that the finding could pave ...
Cause of genetic disorder found in 'dark matter' of DNA
2013-11-11
Cause of genetic disorder found in 'dark matter' of DNA
For the first time, scientists have used new technology which analyses the whole genome to find the cause of a genetic disease in what was previously referred to as 'junk DNA'
For the first time, scientists ...
All aboard the nanotrain network
2013-11-11
All aboard the nanotrain network
VIDEO:
Nanotrain transport system created by Oxford University scientists in action: The time-lapse ...
'Saving our fish' needs more than a ban on discarding
2013-11-11
'Saving our fish' needs more than a ban on discarding
Banning the practice of throwing unmarketable or over-quota fish back into the sea is just one of the measures needed to deliver sustainable fisheries according to new research from the University of East Anglia ...