PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

NLST data highlight probability of lung cancer overdiagnosis with low-dose CT screening

2013-12-10
(Press-News.org) Contact information: Shawn Farley
PR@acr.org
703-648-8936
American College of Radiology
NLST data highlight probability of lung cancer overdiagnosis with low-dose CT screening Philadelphia, PA—Data from the National Lung Cancer Screening Trial (NLST)—conducted by the American College of Radiology Imaging Network and National Cancer Institute Lung Screening Study—provided researchers the opportunity to investigate the probability that a cancer detected with screening low-dose computed tomography (LDCT) would not have progressed to become life threatening. The results of this investigation published online today in JAMA Internal Medicine suggest that up to 18 percent of the cancers detected by LDCT may not have progressed enough to affect patient health if left undetected.

"This is another piece of important information that helps us to better understand the benefits and risks of lung cancer screening," says the study's lead author, Edward F. Patz, Jr., M.D., a professor of radiology, and pharmacology and cancer biology at Duke University School of Medicine.

"The NLST provided encouraging data demonstrating that lung cancer screening with CT reduces death from the disease. However, there are inherent risks with any mass screening program, and this paper investigates the probability of overdiagnosis—meaning, if some patients never would have been screened for lung cancer, they would never have known they had the disease because it would never have caused symptom."

The specific negative consequences of overdiagnosis described by the authors include unnecessary invasive diagnostic procedures, treatment, morbidity (and mortality in rare cases), follow-up, cost, patient anxiety, and labeling of patients with a disease that otherwise would never have been detected.

Using NLST data, the authors determined an "upper bound to true overdiagnosis rate" because the post-screening follow-up period in NLST may not have been long enough to totally differentiate overdiagnosis from the effects of lead time—the length of time a diagnosis was moved up due to early detection by screening. The probability that any lung cancer (all types and stages) detected by screening with LDCT is an overdiagnosis was reported as 18.5 percent. The probability that an LDCT-detected non-small cell lung cancer—by far the most frequently diagnosed lung cancer type—represents an overdiagnosis was found to be 22 percent. The overdiagnosis rate for bronchioloalveolar lung cancer was 78.9 percent.

Patz explains that the problem clinicians face is not knowing which patients are among the approximate 18 percent who have indolent disease. "Patients with these nonaggressive cancers are treated the same as any other patient with lung cancer, because it is generally not possible to distinguish indolent lesions from more aggressive tumors," says Patz. The authors emphasize the need for better biomarkers and imaging techniques to determine which lung cancers are more or less aggressive so as to optimize patient care and enhance the value of screening programs.

"Overdiagnosis is something we don't commonly think exists in lung cancer as compared with, for example, prostate cancer," says Patz. "Most often, when patients are diagnosed with lung cancer, it's viewed as a fatal disease. However, these data confirm that's not necessarily the case with screening programs, which is important information for clinicians to discuss with their patients."

"The relatively modest rate of overdiagnosis with low-dose CT compared with the overdiagnosis rate projected for other cancer screenings programs, further supports the implementation of lung cancer screening programs. Of course, it's important that we work to further drive down overdiagnosis rates across all screening programs," says Mitchell D. Schnall, M.D., Ph.D., Co-Chair of the ECOG-ACRIN Cancer Research Group and the Radiology Department Chair at the University of Pennsylvania's Perelman School of Medicine.

### About the NLST The NLST randomly assigned 53,454 individuals at high risk for lung cancer to receive either three annual LDCT or chest radiograph (CXR) studies at one of 33 U.S. medical centers. Study participants were followed up to five years. The primary trial objective was to determine the effect of LDCT screening vs. CXR screening on lung cancer mortality. Results published in the New England Journal of Medicine (June 2010) demonstrated a 20 percent relative reduction in lung cancer-specific mortality rates with LDCT.


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Study suggests overdiagnosis in screening for lung cancer with low-dose CT

2013-12-10
Study suggests overdiagnosis in screening for lung cancer with low-dose CT More than 18 percent of all lung cancers detected by low-dose computed tomography (LDCT) appeared to represent an overdiagnosis, according to a study published by JAMA Internal Medicine, ...

Cardiovascular complications, hypoglycemia common in older patients with diabetes

2013-12-10
Cardiovascular complications, hypoglycemia common in older patients with diabetes Cardiovascular complications and hypoglycemia (low blood sugar) were common nonfatal complications in adults 60 years of age and older with diabetes, according to a study published ...

Study examines drug labeling and exposure in infants

2013-12-10
Study examines drug labeling and exposure in infants Federal legislation encouraging the study of drugs in pediatric patients has resulted in very few labeling changes that include new infant information, according to a study by Matthew M. Laughon, ...

The smoking gun: Fish brains and nicotine

2013-12-10
The smoking gun: Fish brains and nicotine Baltimore, MD—In researching neural pathways, it helps to establish an analogous relationship between a region of the human brain and the brains of more-easily studied animal species. New work from a team led by Carnegie's ...

35 year study finds exercise reduces risk of dementia

2013-12-10
35 year study finds exercise reduces risk of dementia The study identifies five healthy behaviours as being integral to having the best chance of leading a disease-free lifestyle: taking regular exercise, non-smoking, a low bodyweight, a healthy diet and a ...

CWRU engineering researchers report nanoscale energy-efficient switching devices at IEDM 2013

2013-12-10
CWRU engineering researchers report nanoscale energy-efficient switching devices at IEDM 2013 By relentlessly miniaturizing a pre-World War II computer technology, and combining this with a new and durable material, researchers at Case Western Reserve ...

Balancing old and new skills

2013-12-10
Balancing old and new skills CAMBRIDGE, MA -- To learn new motor skills, the brain must be plastic: able to rapidly change the strengths of connections between neurons, forming new patterns that accomplish a particular task. However, if the brain were ...

Story tips from the Department of Energy's Oak Ridge National Laboratory, December 2013

2013-12-10
Story tips from the Department of Energy's Oak Ridge National Laboratory, December 2013 NONPROLIFERATION – Tell-tale seals . . . Using an Oak Ridge National Laboratory technology, inspectors of containers of nuclear material will be able to know with unprecedented ...

Marketing loans for fertility treatments raises ethical concerns

2013-12-10
Marketing loans for fertility treatments raises ethical concerns What some doctors call a 'win-win situation' may 'encourage interventions that hold little chance at success, exacerbating the anguish of infertility,' says new commentary An increase in ...

Better guidelines, coordination needed for prostate cancer specialists

2013-12-10
Better guidelines, coordination needed for prostate cancer specialists UC Davis experts cite new drug therapies as rationale for improvements (SACRAMENTO, Calif.) — With a deluge of promising new drug treatments for advanced ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Health and economic air quality co-benefits of stringent climate policies

How immune cells deliver their deadly cargo

How the brain becomes a better listener: How focus enhances sound processing

Processed fats found in margarines unlikely to affect heart health

Scientists discover how leukemia cells evade treatment

Sandra Shi MD, MPH, named 2025 STAT Wunderkind

Treating liver disease with microscopic nanoparticles

Chemicals might be hitching a ride on nanoplastics to enter your skin

Pregnant patients with preexisting high cholesterol may have elevated CV risk

UC stroke experts discuss current and future use of AI tools in research and treatment

The Southern Ocean’s low-salinity water locked away CO2 for decades, but...

OHSU researchers develop functional eggs from human skin cells

Most users cannot identify AI bias, even in training data

Hurricane outages: Analysis details the where, and who, of increased future power cuts

Craters on surface of melanoma cells found to serve as sites for tumor killing

Research Spotlight: Mapping overlooked challenges in stroke recovery

Geographic and temporal patterns of screening for breast, cervical, and colorectal cancer in the US

Cannabis laws and opioid use among commercially insured patients with cancer diagnoses

Research Spotlight: Surprising gene mutation in brain’s immune cells linked to increased Alzheimer’s risk

Missing molecule may explain Down syndrome

Donor diabetes and 1-year Descemet membrane endothelial keratoplasty success rate

Endothelial cell loss 1 year after successful DMEK in the diabetes endothelial keratoplasty study

Overactive Runx1 gene triggers early disc degeneration linked to aging

NYU Langone Health chair of ophthalmology, Dr. Kathryn Colby, honored with Castroviejo Medal at AAO 2025

Chemotherapy combination boosts overall survival in patients with EGFR-mutant non-small cell lung cancer

FAU’s Queen Conch Lab receives prestigious international award

Post-traumatic vasospasm: An overlooked threat after brain injury

Scientists smash record in stacking semiconductor transistors for large-area electronics

Large language models prioritize helpfulness over accuracy in medical contexts

In a surprising discovery, scientists find tiny loops in the genomes of dividing cells

[Press-News.org] NLST data highlight probability of lung cancer overdiagnosis with low-dose CT screening