PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Study finds piece-by-piece approach to emissions policies can be effective

2013-12-16
(Press-News.org) Contact information: Sarah McDonnell
s_mcd@mit.edu
617-253-8923
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Study finds piece-by-piece approach to emissions policies can be effective CAMBRIDGE, Mass. — Discussions on curbing climate change tend to focus on comprehensive, emissions-focused measures: a global cap-and-trade scheme aimed at controlling carbon, or a tax on all carbon emissions. But a new study by researchers at MIT finds that a "segmental" approach — involving separate targeting of energy choices and energy consumption through regulations or incentives — can play an important role in achieving emission reductions.

The new study, by assistant professor of engineering systems Jessika Trancik, is being published this week in the journal Environmental Science and Technology. Trancik is joined on the paper by three MIT graduate students: Michael Chang and Christina Karapataki of the Engineering Systems Division and Leah Stokes of the Department of Urban Studies and Planning.

"A policy that's focused on controlling carbon emissions is a different kind of policy than one that's focused on the underlying demand-side and supply-side technology drivers," Trancik says. And while those calling for sweeping, emission-focused policies have often faced uphill battles in regions, states, and nations, a wide variety of segmental policies have been adopted by such jurisdictions, making it important to understand the effectiveness of such approaches, she says.

"There are some things that these segmental policies do very well," Trancik says — in particular dealing with the inertia associated with existing infrastructure. "It will be expensive to retire new power plants early, and so with each power plant built we are committing to emissions not just today, but in future years," she says.

"Compliance with a carbon-focused policy can come either from changes in energy consumption levels or technological change, and a set of segmental policies can ensure that both types of change happen concurrently," Trancik says. Comprehensive, carbon-limiting policies would not allow that kind of targeted approach, she adds.

The issue is urgent, Trancik says: The paper shows that when accounting for infrastructural inertia, the carbon intensity of new plants built over the coming decade — that is, the amount of carbon dioxide emitted per megawatt of power produced — will need to be reduced by 50 percent, as compared to today's levels, in order to meet emissions-reduction commitments that have been made by most nations.

"Many nations are generally moving in the direction of segmental policies," Trancik says, so it is important to understand how effective these policies can be.

The study found pluses and minuses to both segmental and carbon-focused approaches to reducing emissions, Trancik says, adding that what may ultimately be needed is a carefully planned combination of both. The ideal may be a hierarchical approach, she says, "that would involve capping carbon dioxide emissions, but then using these segmental policies to address particular areas of concern, where the market alone may not have sufficient foresight."

These issues are at the heart of climate negotiations. Trancik notes that "understanding the various drivers of emissions, and how influencing each can affect overall emissions, is important to moving these discussions forward. A global agreement on carbon emissions would be most effective at reducing the risks of climate change, but in the meantime a segmental approach can be helpful."

An added benefit, Trancik notes, is that discussing segmental approaches is likely to lead to a greater understanding of where emissions reductions might come from, which may eventually make it easier to reach an agreement on limiting carbon emissions directly.

Decisions made over the next decade will have long-lasting effects on overall emissions, Trancik says, so it's important to perform such analysis now. "Can we control emissions sufficiently through these segmental policies?" she asks. "How might approaches focused on new technologies and on energy efficiency work together?" ### The research was funded by the Solomon Buchsbaum Research Fund.

Written by David Chandler, MIT News Office


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

SOFS take to water

2013-12-16
SOFS take to water Researchers at Berkeley Lab's Molecular Foundry create first soluble 2D supramolecular organic frameworks Supramolecular chemistry, aka chemistry beyond the molecule, in which molecules and molecular complexes are held together by ...

Penn-led team reduces toxicity associated with Lou Gehrig's disease in animal models

2013-12-16
Penn-led team reduces toxicity associated with Lou Gehrig's disease in animal models Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, better known as Lou Gehrig's disease, is a devastating illness that gradually robs sufferers of muscle strength and eventually causes ...

SMA reveals giant star cluster in the making

2013-12-16
SMA reveals giant star cluster in the making W49A might be one of the best-kept secrets in our galaxy. This star-forming region shines 100 times brighter than the Orion nebula, but is so obscured by dust that very little visible or ...

Affordable Care Act offers opportunities to strengthen trauma systems

2013-12-16
Affordable Care Act offers opportunities to strengthen trauma systems Traumatic injuries are the leading cause of death and disability for people under the age of 45 and the fourth-leading cause of death for people of all ages. ...

Deep-sea corals record dramatic long-term shift in Pacific Ocean ecosystem

2013-12-16
Deep-sea corals record dramatic long-term shift in Pacific Ocean ecosystem Changes at the base of the food web in the North Pacific Subtropical Gyre, Earth's largest contiguous ecosystem, may be linked to warming and expansion of open ocean gyres Long-lived ...

Researchers split water into hydrogen, oxygen using light, nanoparticles

2013-12-16
Researchers split water into hydrogen, oxygen using light, nanoparticles Technology potentially could create a clean, renewable source of energy Researchers from the University of Houston have found a catalyst that can quickly generate hydrogen from water using sunlight, ...

Virus grows tube to insert DNA during infection then sheds it

2013-12-16
Virus grows tube to insert DNA during infection then sheds it WEST LAFAYETTE, Ind. — Researchers have discovered a tube-shaped structure that forms temporarily in a certain type of virus to deliver its DNA during the infection process and then dissolves after its ...

Nanoscale friction: High energy losses in the vicinity of charge density waves

2013-12-16
Nanoscale friction: High energy losses in the vicinity of charge density waves In collaboration with the University of Basel, an international team of researchers has observed a strong energy loss caused by frictional effects in the vicinity of charge density waves. ...

Climate change will endanger caribou habitat, study says

2013-12-16
Climate change will endanger caribou habitat, study says Global reindeer and caribou population analysis co-authored by University of Calgary professor Reindeer, from Northern Europe or Asia, are often thought of as a domesticated animal, one that may pull Santa's ...

Silencing signals sent by parasite could aid sleeping sickness fight

2013-12-16
Silencing signals sent by parasite could aid sleeping sickness fight A new discovery by scientists could help combat the spread of sleeping sickness A new discovery by scientists could help combat the spread of sleeping sickness. Insights into how ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Heat and heavy metals are changing the way that bees buzz

What’s behind the enormous increase in early-onset gastrointestinal cancers?

Pharmacogenomics expert advances precision medicine for bipolar disorder

Brazilian researcher explores centenarian stem cells for aging insights

Dr. Xuyu Qian's breakthrough analysis of 18 million brain cells advances understanding of human brain development

Gene networks decode human brain architecture from health to glioma

How artificial light at night damages brain health and metabolism

For ultrasound, ultra-strength not always a good thing

Matching your workouts to your personality could make exercising more enjoyable and give you better results

Study shows people perceive biodiversity

Personality type can predict which forms of exercise people enjoy

People can accurately judge biodiversity through sight and sound

People diagnosed with dementia are living longer, global study shows

When domesticated rabbits go feral, new morphologies emerge

Rain events could cause major failure of Waikīkī storm drainage by 2050

Breakthrough in upconversion luminescence research: Uncovering the energy back transfer mechanism

Hidden role of 'cell protector' opens cancer treatment possibilities

How plants build the microbiome they need to survive in a tough environment

Depression due to politics and its quiet danger to democracy addressed in new book 'The Sad Citizen'

International experts and patients unite to help ensure all patients are fully informed before consenting to new surgical procedures

Melting glaciers could trigger more explosive eruptions globally, finds research

Nearly half of U.S. grandchildren live within 10 miles of a grandparent

Study demonstrates low-cost method to remove CO₂ from air using cold temperatures, common materials

Masonic Medical Research Institute (MMRI) welcomes 13 students to prestigious Summer Fellowship program

Mass timber could elevate hospital construction

A nuanced model of soil moisture illuminates plant behavior and climate patterns

$2.6 million NIH grant backs search for genetic cure in deadly heart disease

Pennsylvania’s medical cannabis program changed drastically when anxiety was added as a qualifying condition

1 in 5 overweight adults could be reclassified with obesity according to new framework

Findings of study on how illegally manufactured fentanyl enters U.S. contradict common assumptions, undermining efforts to control supply

[Press-News.org] Study finds piece-by-piece approach to emissions policies can be effective