PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Study shows 'readability' scores are largely inaccurate

2014-01-08
(Press-News.org) Contact information: Matt Shipman
matt_shipman@ncsu.edu
919-515-6386
North Carolina State University
Study shows 'readability' scores are largely inaccurate Teachers, parents and textbook companies use technical "readability" formulas to determine how difficult reading materials are and to set reading levels by age group. But new research from North Carolina State University shows that the readability formulas are usually inaccurate and offer little insight into which age groups will be able to read and understand a text.

"Teachers often use readability levels when giving reading assignments to students," says Dr. John Begeny, an associate professor of psychology at NC State and lead author of a paper describing the work. "We wanted to know if the readability formulas are valid, or if teachers who think they're assigning a simpler book to struggling readers, for example, may actually be assigning a more difficult one."

For the study, researchers had 360 students – ranging from second to fifth grade – read six written passages out loud. The researchers assessed the students' performance, giving each student an "oral reading fluency" score, which is considered a good metric for measuring reading ability.

The researchers then used eight different readability formulas to see which level each formula gave to the six written passages. Results varied widely, with one passage being rated from first grade to fifth grade level.

The levels assigned by the readability formulas were then compared with researchers' assessments of each student's actual ability to read the material. Seven of the eight readability formulas were less than 49 percent accurate, with the worst formula scoring only 17 percent accuracy. The highest-rated formula was accurate 79 percent of the time.

"Overall, this work shows that teachers and parents should be very cautious about using readability levels when giving reading assignments to students," Begeny says.

### The paper, "Can Readability Formulas Be Used to Successfully Gauge Difficulty of Reading Materials?" is published in the January issue of the journal Psychology in the Schools. The paper was co-authored by Diana Greene, a former graduate student at NC State.


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Scientists find a new mechanism underlying depression

2014-01-08
Scientists find a new mechanism underlying depression Hebrew University research could lead to efficient and fast-acting antidepressant drugs The World health Organization calls depression "the leading cause of disability worldwide," causing more years ...

Lower fat content and exercise for the diet of adolescents

2014-01-08
Lower fat content and exercise for the diet of adolescents A study by the UPV/EHU-University of the Basque Country links dietary fat content with the excess of abdominal fat in adolescents, irrespective of the physical exercise they do This news release is available ...

Study explains origins of giant underwater waves

2014-01-08
Study explains origins of giant underwater waves Large-scale tests in the lab and the South China Sea reveal the origins of underwater waves that can tower hundreds of feet CAMBRIDGE, Mass-- Their effect on the surface of the ocean is negligible, producing ...

Older firefighters may be more resilient to working in heat

2014-01-08
Older firefighters may be more resilient to working in heat FALLS CHURCH, Va. (January 8, 2014) — Older firefighters who are chronically exposed to heat stress on the job could be more heat resilient over time. A recent study published in the December ...

Scientists make your stomach turn bright green if you have an ulcer

2014-01-08
Scientists make your stomach turn bright green if you have an ulcer Doctors may soon be able to diagnose stomach ulcers without taking tissue samples from the stomach. Researchers from the University of Southern Denmark now report to have developed a new, safer and noninvasive ...

Does the body's immune response to viral vector delivery systems affect the safety or efficacy of gene therapy?

2014-01-08
Does the body's immune response to viral vector delivery systems affect the safety or efficacy of gene therapy? New Rochelle, NY, January 7, 2014—Packaging replacement genes in viruses is an effective method to deliver them to target ...

Research reveals new therapeutic target for Huntington's disease

2014-01-08
Research reveals new therapeutic target for Huntington's disease

Geography has impact on grapevine moth's success in French vineyards

2014-01-08
Geography has impact on grapevine moth's success in French vineyards Study sheds light on how regional differences, local temperatures influence immune function of pests 'Location, location, location' is an adage also true for the European grapevine moth, it seems. Research ...

Laundering money -- literally -- could save billions of dollars

2014-01-08
Laundering money -- literally -- could save billions of dollars A dollar bill gets around, passing from hand to hand, falling on streets and sidewalks, eventually getting so grimy that a bank machine flags it and sends it to the shredder. Rather than destroying ...

Newly discovered celestial object defies categories

2014-01-08
Newly discovered celestial object defies categories Scientists asking if it is a new kind of planet or a rare kind of failed star TORONTO, ON – An object discovered by astrophysicists at the University of Toronto (U of T) nearly 500 light years away from the Sun ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Do fitness apps do more harm than good?

Can blood analyses in dogs provide insights into human aging?

Do some antihistamines increase dementia risk in older hospitalized patients?

How do land use policies contribute to racial segregation in communities?

New method noninvasively measures Achilles tendon structure and function in professional dancers

Does floral scent affect insect visitors and bacterial strains on flowers?

How is radiation therapy portrayed in art?

Emotional strain of fitness and calorie counting apps revealed

Uncovering the biology of growing old

Why do so many pro soccer players develop osteoarthritis?

Successful ground-to-satellite laser communications applying next-generation error correction codes, mitigating atmospheric turbulence

Photosynthesis without the burn

Not hunters but collectors: the bone that challenges the ‘humans wiped out Australian megafauna’ theory

Discovery of new mechanism concerning plasma confinement performance

Humans evolved fastest amongst the apes

Biochar and wetter soils offer breakthrough path to slash farm emissions without cutting crop yields

New biochar-enhanced cement could lock away more carbon dioxide

Strong evidence supports skin-to-skin contact after birth as standard care

Why it’s not just about money: Who goes to the ballet, opera and symphony

Daily step counts of 4,000 or more tied to reduced risk of heart disease, mortality in older women

Number of steps taken matters more for better health in older women than the frequency

Less than half of schoolkids at risk of food anaphylaxis in England prescribed adrenaline ‘antidote’

The Lancet: Antidepressants vary widely in their physical side effects, highlighting the need for personalised prescribing, says major meta-analysis

Scientists discover clean and green way to recycle Teflon®

‘Messy’ galaxies in the early universe struggled to settle

Global supply chains benefit most from who you know

While searching for the world’s oldest ice, scientists find sediment sneaking under the Antarctic ice sheet

Contrasting risk profiles for suicide attempt and suicide

Future-focused conservation index identifies reptiles as highest conservation priority

Ideological polarization and the spread of biased or fake news on Facebook are on the rise, according to a study by the UPF

[Press-News.org] Study shows 'readability' scores are largely inaccurate