April 16, 2014 (Press-News.org) In a criminal trial, the prosecution must prove the defendant's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. If something happens during a trial which appears to change this required burden of proof, a defendant's conviction must be reversed.
The Maryland Court of Appeals wrestled with this issue in a burglary case, where a jury instruction was given--inspired, in part, by a popular television show.
An alleged burglary . . . with no scientific evidence?
In the case of Robinson v. State, police officers were called to a scene, where the defendant and another man were detained on suspicion of burglary. Allegedly, someone had tried to break into an apartment building in Montgomery County, Maryland, but had been unsuccessful. The suspects then allegedly crossed Route 355, broke into a second building, and tried unsuccessfully to enter an apartment within that building. When police arrived, the defendant and the other man were leaving the area.
During the trial, defense counsel asked the officers whether casting for tool mark impressions, indicating an attempted forced entry, or any fingerprints or DNA testing had been completed, and the officers admitted such tests had not been performed. In his opening statement, the defense counsel had also noted the prosecution had no scientific evidence such as fingerprints or DNA from the scene.
At the close of the trial, the judge offered an instruction to the jury which, in part, stated that there was no legal obligation in Maryland that the prosecution use any particular investigative technique or scientific test to prove its case. The defendant objected to this instruction, but the jury convicted him of conspiracy to commit first-degree burglary. The defendant appealed this result.
Was giving the jury instruction an error?
The Maryland Court of Appeals noted that this jury instruction existed to counteract what has been referred to as the "CSI effect"--that is, to deal with the heightened expectations of jurors for scientific evidence in light of many popular forensic television shows. However, legal and empirical proof of the existence of such an effect was still lacking.
The prosecution argued that the use of the jury instruction in this case was appropriate, to counteract the defense counsel's comments during the proceedings regarding the lack of scientific evidence. However, while counsel did refer to fingerprints and DNA, a mere reference to the lack of evidence did not trigger the need for an "anti-CSI effect" jury instruction.
The defense merely pointed out what procedures were available to the police but not used. The comments did not misstate the law or the burden of proof the prosecution had to meet and did not insinuate that the prosecution was obligated to perform the tests.
Thus, the trial judge erred in giving the jury instruction, effectively relieving the prosecution of the burden to prove the defendant's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt in the criminal proceedings. The defendant's conviction was reversed and remanded to the lower court for a new trial.
Unwavering protection of your rights
Whether you are accused of burglary, theft or any other crime, the prosecution must meet its burden of proof to convict you. Considering the serious implications of a criminal charge, it is crucial that you seek an experienced criminal defense attorney to represent you, who will take an unwavering approach to protecting your rights and freedom.
Article provided by Saller & Bishop
Visit us at www.sblawmd.com/
"Anti-CSI effect" jury instruction leads to reversal of burglary conviction
In a criminal trial, the prosecution must prove the defendant's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
2014-04-16
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Third party's right to be beneficiary of IRA owned as community property
2014-04-16
In the case of In re Estate of Kirkes, the Supreme Court of Arizona decided that a departed individual could designate more than 50 percent of an individual retirement account held as a community property asset to a third party, but only where the living spouse receives at least 50 percent of the worth of the estate and the distribution is not otherwise fraudulent or unjust.
Background
The decedent held the IRA in his name. He named his son from an earlier marriage as a beneficiary to receive 83 percent of the IRA. Under a previous designation, the decedent's widow ...
More than 300 deaths linked to recalled GM cars
2014-04-16
There have been several news stories recently about faulty ignition switches in General Motors (GM) vehicles, such as Chevy Cobalts manufactured from 2005 to 2010, as well as Saturn Ions made from 2003 to 2006. Keys can fall out of the ignition, causing the vehicle to lose their power steering and brakes. The engines shut down completely, and this can leave the motorists in a very vulnerable position.
According to GM, the ignition problems in the vehicles have been connected to at least 13 deaths in motor vehicle accidents. However, U.S. safety regulators have recorded ...
Reducing risk of dangerous drivers: Head-on crashes and truck accidents
2014-04-16
Sharing the road with dangerous drivers can have dire consequences. Even the safest of drivers have no control over the way others operate their vehicles. The chances of walking away from a motor vehicle accident unharmed are slim, particularly when the crash involves a large vehicle or a tractor-trailer.
AlaskaDispatch.com reports that Anchorage Police have identified the victim of a recent head-on collision. The accident took place near Potter Marsh, on Alaska's Seward Highway. Around 7:00 p.m. a 29-year-old Whittier firefighter's car crashed into a tractor-trailer. ...
InterSystems Seeing the Most Worldwide Growth, While Siemens Continues to Dominate Market Share
2014-04-16
InterSystems is gaining the most ground in signing new hospitals outside the United States, while Siemens continues to have the largest EMR market share. This and other key findings were released in the latest KLAS report, Global EMR Market Share 2014: Vendor Momentum outside the United States
"The global EMR landscape continues to grow at an increasing rate," said report author Chris Brown. "The vendors who are winning the most market share are the ones who are best adapting to country-specific requirements and providing integrated solutions."
The report looked at ...
Jason A. Brodie, Esq., is a Recipient of the Client Distinction Award, Martindale-Hubbell Honor of Distinction
2014-04-16
Brodie & Friedman, P.A., is pleased to announce that Jason A. Brodie, Esq., is a recipient of the Client Distinction Award -- the Martindale-Hubbell honor of distinction that is awarded to fewer than 4 percent of the 900,000 or more lawyers listed on lawyers.com and martindale.com.
Martindale-Hubbell -- one of the country's most-notable attorney rating services -- put together satisfaction ratings, provided by clients, to help distinguish and recognize superior lawyers in the U.S. Mr. Brodie received top rankings for excelling in the areas of responsiveness, communication, ...
Al Carlson Guest Lectures Villanova Class
2014-04-16
Partner Alfred J. Carlson of the Workers' Compensation, Social Security/Long Term Disability and Veterans Benefits law firm of Martin, LLC recently served as a guest lecturer to the Workers' Compensation Class of Villanova Law School professor Hon. Todd B. Seelig.
In his April 8th talk, Carlson focused on the subject of settling a Workers' Compensation case, helping students understand what factors should be considered, including Medicare, Social Security Disability and Subrogation issues.
Carlson has been a litigator in Pennsylvania workers' compensation law since ...
Fast Haul Announces Publication of 2014 Earth Day Infographic
2014-04-16
Fast Haul, a green junk hauling and trash removal company servicing the San Francisco Bay Area, has announced the publication of a new infographic commemorating this year's Earth Day (April 22, 2014). The infographic, titled "Growth of the Green Movement", highlights the roots and development of the green movement in the United States, popular environmental ordinances that have been enacted in certain regions and are now spreading across the nation, and the top ranked "greenest" cities in the U.S. today. To view the "Growth of the Green Movement" infographic, visit: http://www.fasthaul.com/ecoblog/2014/03/27/growth-of-the-green-movement-infographic. ...
Davies Chibale Celebrated for Excellence in Human Resources
2014-04-16
Davies Chibale, Human Resources Consultant of Engineered For Success has been recognized for showing dedication, leadership and excellence in human resources.
Mr. Chibale has eight years of professional experience, with three years as a human resources consultant of Engineered for Success. On a daily basis, he is responsible for helping clients draft, submit and obtain approval of enterprise bargaining agreements for use as terms and conditions of employment. He also provides workforce planning and remuneration advice on strategic people issues to directors and senior ...
John A. Gregg Showcases Professional Accomplishments through Worldwide Branding
2014-04-16
John A. Gregg, Vice President of the American Christian International Foundation, has been recognized by Worldwide Branding for showing dedication, leadership and excellence in agriculture.
Mr. Gregg has a great many years of professional experience, with two years as a vice president of the American Christian International Foundation. Over the years, he has established himself as an expert in food, nutrition, farming, and co-ops. On a daily basis, he is responsible for working in a non-salaried volunteer position, and as a treasurer. He also manages website development ...
Stephanie Kyra Honored for Success in Facilities Management
2014-04-16
Stephanie Kyra, Facilities Operation Manager at Sydney-based building company Ultra Building Works, has been recognised by Worldwide Branding for her dedication, leadership and excellence in helping build her business' reputation as an unbeatable force in the construction industry.
Ms Kyra has managed the Facilities Division of Ultra Building Works for the past 14 years and is crucial to the smooth running of the business. She has successfully managed multiple maintenance projects simultaneously including contracts with the University of Sydney, NSW Public Works and ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Scientists uncover immune cells that help prostate cancer resist treatment — and reveal a way to stop them
Cellulose instead of crude oil: team with participation of Graz University of Technology develops sustainable foams
New fossils from Earth’s most famous extinction show climate tipping point was crossed
AI predicts patients likely to die of sudden cardiac arrest
Double detonation: New image shows remains of star destroyed by pair of explosions
Gene therapy restored hearing in deaf patients
Survey finds Trump losing favor, Newsom gaining
Religion, politics and war drive urban wildlife evolution
Peeking inside AI brains: Machines learn like us
A map for single-atom catalysts
What about tritiated water release from Fukushima? Ocean model simulations provide an objective scientific knowledge on the long-term tritium distribution
Growing crisis of communicable disease in Canada in tandem with US cuts
Women get better at managing their anger as they age
Illegal shark product trade evident in Australia and New Zealand
New search tool brings 21% better accuracy for robotics developers
New model extracts sentence-level proof to verify events, boosting fact-checking accuracy for journalists, legal teams, and policymakers
Efficient carbon integration of CO₂ in propane aromatization over acidic zeolites
FPGA-accelerated AI for demultiplexing multimode fiber towards next-generation communications
Vitamin D3 nanoemulsion significantly improves core symptoms in children with autism: A clinical trial
Microfluidic point-of-care device accurately measures bilirubin in blood serum: A pilot study
Amygdalin shows strong binding and stabilizing effects on HER2 receptor: A computational study for breast cancer therapy
Bond behavior of FRP bars in concrete under reversed cyclic loading: an experimental study
Milky Way-like galaxy M83 consumes high-speed clouds
Study: What we learned from record-breaking 2021 heat wave and what we can expect in the future
Transforming treatment outcomes for people with OCD
Damage from smoke and respiratory viruses mitigated in mice via a common signaling pathway
New software tool could help better understand childhood cancer
Healthy lifestyle linked to lower diverticulitis risk, irrespective of genetic susceptibility
Women 65+ still at heightened risk of cervical cancer caused by HPV
‘Inflammatory’ diet during pregnancy may raise child’s diabetes type 1 risk
[Press-News.org] "Anti-CSI effect" jury instruction leads to reversal of burglary convictionIn a criminal trial, the prosecution must prove the defendant's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.