(Press-News.org) Despite claims by the Obama administration that the Affordable Care Act will reduce health insurance companies' spending on overhead, thereby channeling a greater share of consumers' premium dollars into actual patient care, insurers' financial filings show the law had no impact on the percentage of insurer expenditures on such things as administration, marketing and profits.
That's the chief finding of a team of researchers, including two prominent physicians on the faculties of the City University of New York's School of Public Health and Harvard Medical School, in an article published Wednesday in the peer-reviewed International Journal of Health Services.
Examining U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission filings of nine large insurers, and using a constant definition of what constitutes an insurer's "medical loss ratio" or MLR - i.e. actual spending on payments to doctors, hospitals, pharmacies, etc. - the researchers found that the weighted average MLR in the three years after the new ACA regulations took effect (2011-2013) was 83.05 percent, compared to 83.04 percent in the three years prior to the reform.
The ACA sets limits on insurers' overhead, mandating an MLR of at least 80 percent in small-group markets and 85 percent in the large group market. However, the Obama administration changed the traditional yardstick by which the MLR is measured.
The new way of calculating the MLR allows insurers to classify most expenditures on "quality improvement" initiatives and the updating of coding systems as medical expenditures, and allows them to subtract most taxes, regulatory fees and "community benefit" spending.
"Rather than go along with the administration's moving of the goal posts to the apparent advantage of the insurers, we stuck with the traditional way financial analysts and insurance firms calculate MLR, namely, by dividing total medical payments by total premium income," said Benjamin Day, the study's lead author.
"What we found is that there's been no significant change in the insurers' MLR since the implementation of the new regulations."
MLRs fell at four firms - UnitedHealth, Humana, Aetna and WellCare - and increased slightly at four others and markedly at one (Centene, a major managed Medicaid contractor).
Day continued: "Although the MLR requirements forced insurers to pay rebates of $1.1 billion in 2011 and $504 million in 2012 - payments that were touted by the Department of Health and Human Services as a major boon to consumers - these rebates constituted less than 0.1 percent of private insurance company revenues and appear to have had no overall impact on MLRs."
Day, whose published research includes articles on labor history and health care reform, currently serves as executive director at Healthcare-NOW, a national coalition of groups advocating for a single-payer health care system.
Senior author Dr. Steffie Woolhandler, professor at the City University of New York's School of Public Health at Hunter College and co-founder of Physicians for a National Health Program, said a number of factors might explain why the ACA hasn't raised MLRs.
"Most plans already met the MLR requirement from 2007-2009, even without the MLR redefinition in the ACA," Woolhandler said. "Moreover, self-insured employer plans, which accounted for 60 percent of all covered workers in 2011, were entirely exempt from the MLR requirement. In addition, a number of exemptions and adjustments were granted to a wide spectrum of plans and to several states, temporarily nullifying the new mandate."
Woolhandler observed that traditional Medicare's overhead is about 2 percent, i.e. 98 percent of Medicare's spending goes toward medical care. "The ACA is too lenient on private insurers, sets too low a bar for their payments for actual care, and provides them with too many loopholes.
"The lesson is clear," she said. "We need to adopt a publicly financed, improved Medicare for All."
INFORMATION:
"The Affordable Care Act and Medical Loss Ratios: No Impact in First Three Years," Benjamin Day, M.A., David U. Himmelstein, M.D., Michael Broder, B.A., Steffie Woolhandler, M.D., M.P.H. International Journal of Health Services, Vol. 45, No. 1 (January 2015).
The International Journal of Health Services contains articles on health and social policy, political economy and sociology, history and philosophy, ethics and law in the areas of health and health care.
Physicians for a National Health Program is a nonprofit research and education organization of more than 19,000 doctors who support single-payer national health insurance. PNHP had no role in funding or otherwise supporting the study described above.
Observe whether two people use metaphors in conversation with each other if you want to guess how close they are as friends. Or sharpen your ability to tune into other people's emotional or mental states by observing the metaphors they use. Why is this? Because metaphors can in fact help one to 'mind read,' report Andrea Bowes and Albert Katz of the University of Ontario in Canada in Springer's journal Memory & Cognition.
Metaphor is a type of language that forms part of our daily conversations and communication. In this type of language, the literal or usual meaning ...
EAST LANSING, Mich. - High social status has its privileges -- when it comes to aging -- even in wild animals.
In a first-of-its-kind study involving a wild species, Michigan State University researchers have shown that social and ecological factors affect animal health. The results, published in the current issue of Biology Letters, focused on spotted hyenas in Kenya.
"High-ranking members in hyena clans reproduce more, they live longer and appear to be in better overall health," said Nora Lewin, MSU doctoral student of zoology and co-lead author. "If you want to see ...
WASHINGTON - Two patient groups created by the Affordable Care Act (ACA) - Medicare patients enrolled in federally designated patient-centered medical homes and people under age 26 who are allowed to remain on their parents' health insurance - had slightly fewer emergency department visits than they had before health care reform. However, there was no change in the rate of the most expensive types of emergency visits: those that lead to hospitalization.
One study examined the rate of emergency department visits and hospitalizations for Medicare patients treated by ...
Hurricanes require moisture, the rotation of the earth, and warm ocean temperatures to grow from a mere atmospheric disturbance into a tropical storm. But where do these storm cells originate, and exactly what makes an atmospheric disturbance amp up full throttle?
A new study published in Geophysical Research Letters by Tel Aviv University's Prof. Colin Price and his graduate student Naama Reicher of the Department of Geosciences at TAU's Faculty of Exact Sciences finds most hurricanes over the Atlantic that eventually make landfall in North America actually start as ...
WASHINGTON, March 12, 2015--Borrowing a trick from nature, engineers from the University of California at Berkeley have created an incredibly thin, chameleon-like material that can be made to change color -- on demand -- by simply applying a minute amount of force.
This new material-of-many-colors offers intriguing possibilities for an entirely new class of display technologies, color-shifting camouflage, and sensors that can detect otherwise imperceptible defects in buildings, bridges, and aircraft.
"This is the first time anybody has made a flexible chameleon-like ...
A QUT scientist has helped unravel the way in which plants regulate their levels of vitamin C, the vitamin essential for preventing iron deficiency anaemia and conditions such as scurvy.
Professor Roger Hellens, working with Dr William Laing from New Zealand's Plant and Food Research, has discovered the mechanism plants use to regulate the levels of Vitamin C in each of their cells in response to the environment.
"Understanding these mechanisms may help in plant breeding programmes to produce hardier plant crops and improve human health because iron deficiency anaemia ...
This news release is available in German. Simulations of impressive landscapes and alien creatures have become commonplace, especially in fantasy and science fiction films. But simulations are also appearing in ever more medical and engineering applications. However, the road to a perfect illusion is complex and time-intensive. Nils Thürey, professor at the Technische Universität München and his colleagues have developed a methodology that could accelerate these calculations.
The attack takes place at the climax of the blockbuster "Avatar": Rockets slam ...
"When I interviewed inspectors they are surprisingly open about this. They tell me that they get a box of fish or just some money from fishermen in exchange for being allowed to break the rules that apply to protected areas or catches," says Aksel Sundström.
Many of South Africa's marine fish stocks are overexploited. At the same time, the government actors that are meant to ensure that fishers abide to rules may be a part of the problem.
For example, one anonymous inspector is quoted to say: "A Chinese captain that was arrested last week called someone who arrived ...
CHICAGO (March 12, 2015): A surgical approach in which a surgeon removes less than a lobe of the liver in a patient undergoing an operation for liver cancer is associated with lower mortality and complication rates, according to new study results published online as an "article in press" in the Journal of the American College of Surgeons (JACS). The article will appear in print in the April issue of the Journal.
Historically, the most common surgical method of treatment for liver cancer was a major hepatectomy in which a lobe (hemi-liver) is removed in order to remove ...
Very low mammographic breast density worsens the prognosis of breast cancer, according to a recent study from the University of Eastern Finland. Disease free survivals as well as overall life expectancies were significantly shorter in women with very low-density breasts in comparison to women with high density breast tissue. The lower the breast tissue density, the less fibroglandular tissue there is compared to fat tissue.
In the future, these findings may prove significant for the assessment of breast cancer prognosis and treatment planning.
The study involved 270 ...
