PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Are scare tactics off the table for public health campaigns targeting HIV?

Columbia scholars highlight potential and pitfalls of health campaigns that can frighten, disgust, and stigmatize

2015-05-04
(Press-News.org) Over the last ten years, public health campaigns in New York City around smoking, obesity, and HIV underwent a dramatic shift to use fear and disgust to spur behavior change, sometimes with the unintended consequence of stigmatizing affected populations. In a new article published in the May issue of the journal Health Affairs, scholars at Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health explore the implications of this shift to fear-based campaigns in the present public health environment.

Beginning in 2005, the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene mounted fear-based campaigns around smoking and obesity that were largely embraced by the public, with largely positive feedback to the Department. But in 2010, the fear-based "It's Never Just HIV" campaign targeting young men of color who have sex with men erupted into a firestorm of controversy with the sharpest criticism from those who viewed themselves as socially vulnerable. The experience has lasting consequences for public health campaigns around HIV, argue authors Amy L. Fairchild, PhD, Ronald Bayer, PhD, and James Colgrove, PhD, professors of Sociomedical Sciences. "Although the Department of Health has continued with its fear-based obesity and tobacco efforts, as of 2015 the hard-hitting approach seems to have been shelved for HIV," they write.

During this period smoking declined precipitously and some data suggests that childhood obesity may have turned a corner, but HIV infections in young men of color who have sex with men continue to rise. It is difficult to measure to what extent these successes and failures can be attributed to fear-based campaigns, in part, because the campaigns were accompanied by other interventions like a cigarette tax and the distribution of free condoms. The authors note that scientific studies of fear-based campaigns around the world draw mixed conclusions: some reject the approach; others conclude that "the stronger the fear appeal the better."

180 on Fear

For generations of health educators, public health campaigns around health issues emphasized positive messages and highlighted healthy behaviors; the use of fear in was seen as counterproductive. Beginning in the early 2000s, in the face of increased marketing by tobacco companies and stalled smoking cessation rates, New York City Health Commissioner Thomas Frieden, today director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, embraced hard-hitting tactics employing fear and graphic imagery.

A 2006 Health Department campaign titled "Cigarettes Are Eating You Alive," featured posters and television spots with close-ups of a diseased heart, lung, mouth, teeth, and throat. Similar imagery was printed on matchbooks distributed at cigarette retailers. Health department officials reported immediate, marked declines in smoking. And public reaction was mainly positive: one observer at the time commented about the ads, "They are disgusting, horrible, and distasteful; and they helped."

Fear-based campaigns were attractive because they were seen as neither as restrictive as bans nor as burdensome as high taxes. They were also politically palatable, the authors write, because smoking had become "denormalized" as deviant or antisocial and its use concentrated among low-income groups. "Fear was a socially acceptable response to smoking," the authors write. "This would not hold true in the case of either obesity or HIV."

Thomas Farley, who succeeding Frieden as Health Commissioner, expanded the fear-based tactics to obesity prevention with efforts like the 2009 viral video, "Man Drinking Fat," which showed a white man attempting to drink semi-congealed fat poured from a can of soda. A 2013 campaign against sports drinks featuring African-American and Hispanic men and women was seen by some as stigmatizing.

Controversy

In 2010, Health Department concluded they needed to apply fear-based techniques to HIV. "Longstanding efforts using humor or affirmation--known as 'sex positive' approaches--had failed to reduce HIV incidence among young men who had sex with men, especially among blacks and Latinos," the authors write. Focus groups with black and Latino men reinforced the notion that a hard-hitting tactics were needed. Before launching the campaign, the Department reviewed the initiative with opinion leaders in the affected community.

"It's Never Just HIV" evoked a horror movie style, interposing images of young gay men who "glance fearfully (even shamefully) at the camera," intercut with grizzly depictions of osteoporosis, dementia, and anal cancer. Controversy erupted soon after the campaign launched. Critics like Francisco Rogue of Gay Men's Health Crisis argued, "It really paints this picture of gay men as these sort of disease-ridden vessels." Others like HIV/AIDS activist Larry Kramer condoned the fear-based messaging, saying, "This ad is honest and true and scary, all of which it should be." Mainstream media were uncritical of the campaign, which ran in subways and on television for a month, exceeding its original budget.

Controversy returned several years later when the Human Resources Administration released a campaign against teen pregnancy that many felt stigmatized young mothers. While Mayor Michael Bloomberg defended the effort, arguing that it was "past time" for a "value neutral" approach, the Department of Health stated that stigma was not "an effective way to communicate these issues."

Political Calculation

"Relying on fear is risky business," the authors write. For the Health Department, the lesson was that "the use of fear could not be measured simply in terms of efficacy. Behavioral achievements came with a political price. Some saw stigma as a "health promotion profanity."

Yet, as consequence of New York City's experience with fear tactics, the approach remains in the public health toolbox today. "It is no longer possible to assert that fear-based efforts can never serve the interests of public health," the authors write.

"There's a reason we see public health turning to fear. We live in a culture that bombards people with incentives to consume products that are clearly unhealthy. It is a duty of public health to sound a meaningful warning," says Dr. Fairchild. "You can't fight unhealthy seductions with abstract odds and probabilities. It's like trying to put out a fire with a water pistol," adds Dr. Bayer.

INFORMATION:

About Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health

Founded in 1922, Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health pursues an agenda of research, education, and service to address the critical and complex public health issues affecting New Yorkers, the nation and the world. The Mailman School is the third largest recipient of NIH grants among schools of public health. Its over 450 multi-disciplinary faculty members work in more than 100 countries around the world, addressing such issues as preventing infectious and chronic diseases, environmental health, maternal and child health, health policy, climate change & health, and public health preparedness. It is a leader in public health education with over 1,300 graduate students from more than 40 nations pursuing a variety of master's and doctoral degree programs. The Mailman School is also home to numerous world-renowned research centers including ICAP (formerly the International Center for AIDS Care and Treatment Programs) and the Center for Infection and Immunity. For more information, please visit http://www.mailman.columbia.edu.



ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Green tea extract and exercise hinder progress of Alzheimer's disease in mice

2015-05-04
COLUMBIA, Mo. -- According to the National Institutes of Health (NIH), Alzheimer's disease (AD) may affect as many as 5.5 million Americans. Scientists currently are seeking treatments and therapies found in common foods that will help stave off the disease or prevent it completely. Now, University of Missouri researchers have determined that a compound found in green tea, and voluntary exercise, slows the progression of the disease in mice and may reverse its effects. Further study of the commonly found extract could lead to advancements in the treatment and prevention ...

Enhancing emergency medical care for seniors could reduce hospital admissions

2015-05-04
(NEW YORK - May 4) Applying palliative care principles to emergency departments may reduce the number of geriatric patients admitted to intensive care units, possibly extending lives and reducing Medicare costs, according to a three-year analysis by Mount Sinai researchers set to be published in the May edition of Health Affairs, which can be found online. "Data show that more than half of Americans ages 65 and older are seen in the emergency department in the last month of their lives, and that the number and rate of admissions to intensive care units among older adults ...

'Fuzzy thinking' in depression & bipolar disorder: New research finds effect is real

2015-05-04
ANN ARBOR, Mich. -- People with depression or bipolar disorder often feel their thinking ability has gotten "fuzzy", or less sharp than before their symptoms began. Now, researchers have shown in a very large study that effect is indeed real - and rooted in brain activity differences that show up on advanced brain scans. What's more, the results add to the mounting evidence that these conditions both fall on a spectrum of mood disorders, rather than being completely unrelated. That could transform the way doctors and patients think about, diagnose and treat them. In ...

Premature birth alters brain connections

2015-05-04
Premature birth can alter the connectivity between key areas of the brain, according to a new study led by King's College London. The findings should help researchers to better understand why premature birth is linked to a greater risk of neurodevelopmental problems, including autistic spectrum disorders and attention deficit disorders. The NIHR-funded study, published in the journal PNAS, used functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to look at specific connections in the brains of 66 infants, 47 of whom were born before 33 weeks and were therefore at high risk ...

Pitt team follows zinc to uncover pathway that fine-tunes brain signaling

2015-05-04
PITTSBURGH, May 4, 2015 -- A study team led by researchers at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine who used specially developed technologies to "follow the zinc" have uncovered a previously unknown pathway the brain uses to fine-tune neural signaling -- and that may play a role in Alzheimer's and other diseases. Their findings appear online this week in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Scientists have long observed the presence of bubble-like vesicles that contain the neurotransmitter glutamate and zinc at the synapses, specialized contacts ...

Virginia Tech researcher shines light on origin of bioluminescence

Virginia Tech researcher shines light on origin of bioluminescence
2015-05-04
In the mountains of Virginia, millipedes have bright yellow and black colors to warn enemies that they are toxic and not worth eating. Their cousins in California convey this warning in a very different way -- by glowing in the dark. But bioluminescence at least in one millipede may have evolved as a way to survive in a hot, dry environment, not as a means to ward off predators, according to scientists publishing this week (Monday, May 4) in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. The discovery, based on a millipede that hadn't been seen in 50 years, shows ...

May 2015 Gastrointestinal Endoscopy highlights

2015-05-04
DOWNERS GROVE, Ill. - May 4, 2015 - The May issue of GIE: Gastrointestinal Endoscopy, the monthly peer-reviewed scientific journal of the American Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy (ASGE), features a meta-analysis pointing to botulinum toxin A as a possible obesity treatment; a study reporting that, in some cases, it may be safe to store endoscopes longer than five days after reprocessing; and an article reviewing a promising group of procedures for patients with advanced illness from gastric obstruction. "Effect of intragastric injection of botulinum toxin A for ...

Puget Sound's clingfish could inspire better medical devices, whale tags

Puget Sounds clingfish could inspire better medical devices, whale tags
2015-05-04
Scooting around in the shallow, coastal waters of Puget Sound is one of the world's best suction cups. It's called the Northern clingfish, and its small, finger-sized body uses suction forces to hold up to 150 times its own body weight. These fish actually hold on better to rough surfaces than to smooth ones, putting to shame industrial suction devices that give way with the slightest uneven surface. Researchers at the University of Washington's Friday Harbor Laboratories on San Juan Island are studying this quirky little fish to understand how it can summon such massive ...

Recurrence of prostate cancer detected earlier with innovative PSMA-ligand PET/CT

2015-05-04
A recent study reported in The Journal of Nuclear Medicine compared use of the novel Ga-68-PSMA-ligand PET/CT with other imaging methods and found that it had substantially higher detection rates of prostate-specific membrane antigen (PSMA) in patients with biochemical recurrence after radical prostatectomy. Discovering a recurrence early can strongly influence further clinical management, so it is especially noteworthy that this hybrid PSMA-ligand identified a large number of positive findings in the clinically important range of low PSA-values ( END ...

New climate projections paint bleak future for tropical coral reefs

2015-05-04
ITHACA, N.Y. - As greater atmospheric carbon dioxide boosts sea temperatures, tropical corals face a bleak future. New climate model projections show that conditions are likely to increase the frequency and severity of coral disease outbreaks, reports a team of researchers led by Cornell University scientists, published today (May 4) in Nature Climate Change. Download study, FAQ and photos: https://cornell.box.com/coral-disease Conserving coral reefs is crucial to maintaining the biodiversity of our oceans and sustaining the livelihoods of the 500 million people that ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Are lifetimes of big appliances really shrinking?

Pink skies

Monkeys are world’s best yodellers - new research

Key differences between visual- and memory-led Alzheimer’s discovered

% weight loss targets in obesity management – is this the wrong objective?

An app can change how you see yourself at work

NYC speed cameras take six months to change driver behavior, effects vary by neighborhood, new study reveals

New research shows that propaganda is on the rise in China

Even the richest Americans face shorter lifespans than their European counterparts, study finds

Novel genes linked to rare childhood diarrhea

New computer model reveals how Bronze Age Scandinavians could have crossed the sea

Novel point-of-care technology delivers accurate HIV results in minutes

Researchers reveal key brain differences to explain why Ritalin helps improve focus in some more than others

Study finds nearly five-fold increase in hospitalizations for common cause of stroke

Study reveals how alcohol abuse damages cognition

Medicinal cannabis is linked to long-term benefits in health-related quality of life

Microplastics detected in cat placentas and fetuses during early pregnancy

Ancient amphibians as big as alligators died in mass mortality event in Triassic Wyoming

Scientists uncover the first clear evidence of air sacs in the fossilized bones of alvarezsaurian dinosaurs: the "hollow bones" which help modern day birds to fly

Alcohol makes male flies sexy

TB patients globally often incur "catastrophic costs" of up to $11,329 USD, despite many countries offering free treatment, with predominant drivers of cost being hospitalization and loss of income

Study links teen girls’ screen time to sleep disruptions and depression

Scientists unveil starfish-inspired wearable tech for heart monitoring

Footprints reveal prehistoric Scottish lagoons were stomping grounds for giant Jurassic dinosaurs

AI effectively predicts dementia risk in American Indian/Alaska Native elders

First guideline on newborn screening for cystic fibrosis calls for changes in practice to improve outcomes

Existing international law can help secure peace and security in outer space, study shows

Pinning down the process of West Nile virus transmission

UTA-backed research tackles health challenges across ages

In pancreatic cancer, a race against time

[Press-News.org] Are scare tactics off the table for public health campaigns targeting HIV?
Columbia scholars highlight potential and pitfalls of health campaigns that can frighten, disgust, and stigmatize