(Press-News.org) Philadelphia, PA, May 7, 2015 - Current U.S. health policy requires Medicaid beneficiaries to wait 30 days before tubal sterilization. Ob/gyn experts argue that this violates health care justice as elective tubal sterilization is readily available to women with a private source of payment. Writing in the American Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology, they urge obstetricians to advocate for change to eliminate health care injustice in women's access to elective tubal sterilization.
One of the most common forms of contraception in the U.S. is tubal sterilization after childbirth, which accounts for about half of the half million female sterilization procedures done every year. The timing has the advantage of one-time hospitalization, which results in ease and convenience for the woman. The U.S. Collaborative Review of Sterilization Study indicates the high efficacy and effectiveness of postpartum tubal sterilization.
But while elective tubal sterilization is readily available to women with a private source of payment, this is not the case for Medicaid beneficiaries who are required to wait 30 days, which can be impractical unless the paperwork is concluded well in advance of the birth. "Regardless of who pays, the ethical and legal standard for the performance of elective tubal sterilization for permanent contraception for all patients is oral and written informed consent," stated senior author Lawrence McCullough, PhD, of the Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy, Baylor College of Medicine.
The authors explain that compulsory sterilization programs existed in the U.S. until the middle decades of the 20th century. Initially, these programs targeted intellectually disabled and mentally ill patients; however, many African American women and deaf, blind, epileptic, physically deformed, and low-income women were sterilized against their will. In 1979, U.S. federal legislation was enacted that aimed to enhance women's health rights by regulating the process of consent and documentation before receiving surgical sterilization (both tubal sterilization and hysterectomy) that is publicly funded.
"The intent was good, but the unintended consequence four decades later is to restrict access based on source of payment," noted lead author Amirhossein Moaddab, MD, Visiting Post-Doctoral Fellow in the Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Baylor College of Medicine. "The reality of clinical practice is that nearly 50% of annual deliveries are paid for by Medicaid and therefore necessitate the signed federal consent form and waiting period."
The authors discuss the concept of health care justice in professional obstetric ethics and explain how it originates in the ethical concepts of medicine as a profession and of being a patient. They also explore its deontologic and consequentialist dimensions. The "deontologic" or "rule"-based dimension judges the morality of an action based on its adherence to a rule or rules. The "consequentialist" dimension judges the morality of an action on its consequences.
"We conclude that Medicaid policy allocates access to elective tubal sterilization differently, based on source of payment and gender, which violates health care justice in both its deontologic and consequentialist dimensions," said senior author Frank A. Chervenak, MD, of the Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Weill Medical College of Cornell University/New York-Presbyterian Hospital. "Obstetricians should invoke health care justice in women's health care as the basis for advocacy for needed change in law and health policy, to eliminate health care injustice in women's access to elective tubal sterilization."
Commenting on the article, noted expert Philip Darney, MD, MSc, Distinguished Professor of Obstetrics, Gynecology, and Reproductive Sciences at the University of California, San Francisco and Director of the Bixby Center for Global Reproductive Health, added, "Childbirth provides a convenient and economical opportunity for permanent contraception. This opportunity is denied to about 60,000 of the women who select it every year because of rules that the public insurance consent process applies to those who need their post-partum sterilizations paid for by Medicaid."
Dr. Darney emphasized that when women cannot present evidence of having met the 30-day requirement the consequences to them can be severe: half of those who never intended to become pregnant again do so, nearly 20% within a year. Some of these women have pregnancy-associated illnesses like diabetes and hypertension that make subsequent pregnancies risky. "A 'post-partum tubal' is the easiest (and cheapest) way for them to avoid recurring illness. Individual obstetricians and their professional organizations should protest the injustice, describe the health and financial costs of the current consent process, and prevail on government health care officials to change the regulations. The arguments of McCullough, Chervenak, and colleagues will provide excellent background for official deliberations," he concluded.
INFORMATION:
San Francisco, May 7, 2015 - Detailed gait analysis reveals that people with clogged leg arteries rely more on muscles in the back of the calf when they walk to compensate for weakness in certain hip muscles, according to a new study presented at the American Heart Association's Arteriosclerosis, Thrombosis and Vascular Biology/Peripheral Vascular Disease Scientific Sessions 2015.
This suggests that exercise training to strengthen hip flexor muscles may increase how far patients can walk without calf pain.
Peripheral artery disease (PAD) is a narrowing of the arteries ...
A group of leading soil scientists, including the University of Delaware's Donald L. Sparks, has summarized the precarious state of the world's soil resources and the possible ramifications for human security in a paper published Thursday, May 7, in the journal Science.
In a review of recent scientific literature, the article, titled "Soil and Human Security in the 21st Century," outlines threats to soil productivity -- and, in turn, food production -- due to soil erosion, nutrient exhaustion, urbanization and climate change.
"Soil is our planet's epidermis," said Sparks, ...
Crigler-Najjar syndrome is a rare autosomal recessive disorder caused by mutations in the UGT1A1 gene, which result in the toxic accumulation of bilirubin, a substance made by the liver in the body. Indeed, when the UDP-glucuronosyltransferase 1 isotype A1 (UGT1A1), the enzyme responsible for removing bilirubin, doesn't work, the substance accumulates, causing a severe and chronic jaundice, and becoming toxic for the brain and leading to lethality.
Gene therapy has allowed the restoration of an equivalent level of bilirubin to those found in healthy animals
Federico ...
Luring longtime and new customers to try online shopping, and retaining them in a competitive and crowded marketplace, is the challenge of the day for established offline retailers. A study of the multichannel UK grocery shopping environment recently yielded insights that will be useful for retailers with an online channel or considering adding one to their customers' options.
A team of researchers from Belgium's KU Leuven (University of Leuven), led by doctoral candidate Kristina Melis, investigated purchasing behavior and the adoption of an online grocery shopping ...
Researchers at the University of Illinois at Chicago have determined the molecular structure of one of the proteins in the fine fibers of the brain plaques that are a hallmark of Alzheimer's disease. This molecule, called amyloid beta-42, is toxic to nerve cells and is believed to provoke the disease cascade.
The study is online in the journal Nature Structural and Molecular Biology.
Knowing the physical structure of the 42 amino acid-long form of amyloid beta in the fibers is key to understanding how it folds up improperly and aggregates into toxic plaques, says Yoshitaka ...
This news release is available in Spanish. (SACRAMENTO, Calif.) -- Researchers at UC Davis have developed a new intervention that identifies potentially depressed mothers and encourages them to seek treatment. The Motivating our Mothers (MOM) program takes a unique approach, relying on pediatricians rather than the mother's doctor for diagnosis. In the study, mothers were given a short survey to assess whether they needed additional care. Those who identified depression symptoms were then coached by a research assistant to seek further help.
The program had a remarkable ...
A new study shows that it is possible to use an imaging technique called cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) to view, in near-atomic detail, the architecture of a metabolic enzyme bound to a drug that blocks its activity. This advance provides a new path for solving molecular structures that may revolutionize drug development, noted the researchers.
The protein imaged in this study was a small bacterial enzyme called beta-galactosidase; the drug to which it was bound is an inhibitor called phenylethyl-beta-D-thiogalactopyranoside (PETG), which fits into a pocket in the ...
Messenger RNA (mRNA) levels dictate most differences protein levels in fast-growing cells when analyzed using statistical methods that account for noise in the data, according to a new study by researchers from the University of Chicago and Harvard University.
The research, published May 7, 2015 in the journal PLOS Genetics, counters widely reported studies arguing that the correlation between mRNA transcript levels and protein levels is relatively low, and that processes acting after mRNA transcription override mRNA levels. Instead, the authors argue, these conclusions ...
Boston, MA -- Researchers at Harvard T. H. Chan School of Public Health and the Broad Institute have identified a protein on the surface of human red blood cells that serves as an essential entry point for invasion by the malaria parasite. The presence of this protein, called CD55, was found to be critical to the Plasmodium falciparum parasite's ability to attach itself to the red blood cell surface during invasion. This discovery opens up a promising new avenue for the development of therapies to treat and prevent malaria.
"Plasmodium falciparum malaria parasites have ...
Hereditary blindness caused by a progressive degeneration of the light-sensing cells in the eye, the photoreceptors, affects millions of people worldwide. Although the light-sensing cells are lost, cells in deeper layers of the retina, which normally cannot sense light, remain intact. A promising new therapeutic approach based on a technology termed "optogenetics" is to introduce light-sensing proteins into these surviving retinal cells, turning them into "replacement photoreceptors" and thereby restoring vision. However, several factors limit the feasibility of a clinical ...
