(Press-News.org) Whether it's being outbid at the last second in an online auction or missing the winning lottery number by one digit, we often come so close to something we can "almost taste it" only to lose out in the end. These "near wins" may actually boost our motivation to achieve other wins, leading us to pursue totally unrelated rewards, according to new research in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science.
"Our research suggests that at least in some cases, losing has positive power. While we often think of motivation as being targeted to a specific reward or goal, these findings support the notion that motivation is like energy and reward is like direction -- once this motivational energy is activated, it leads an individual to seek out a broad range of goals and rewards," says lead researcher Monica Wadhwa of INSEAD.
While it may seem like losing might put a damper on motivation, Wadhwa and co-author JeeHye Christine Kim hypothesized that losing out by only a narrow margin might have the opposite effect. A near win, they speculated, intensifies but doesn't satisfy our motivational state, and so the drive to win is extended to the next task or goal we encounter.
In one study, the researchers recruited 50 undergraduate students to evaluate a phone game that was supposedly in development.
In the game, students saw a grid of 16 tiles; half of the tiles covered a rock and half of the tiles covered a diamond. The goal of the game was to click on the tiles one by one to find 8 diamonds without uncovering a single rock. What the students didn't know was that the game was carefully rigged by the experimenters. Some of the students were set up to experience a near win, uncovering 7 diamonds in a row only to uncover a rock on their final tile. Another group of students was also set up to uncover 7 diamonds and 1 rock, but this time the rock was uncovered on the second click; thus, these students had no anticipation of winning after they turned over the second tile.
After playing, the participants completed surveys evaluating the game and were asked to drop the surveys off at a booth at the end of the hallway, where they could pick up a chocolate bar as a thank-you gift.
The researchers surreptitiously recorded how long it took the students to walk to the second booth -- they wanted to see if a near miss in the game might influence how eager participants were to get to the second reward, the chocolate bar.
The results were clear: Students who lost the game on the last tile walked significantly faster, reaching the booth about 12 seconds sooner, than those who lost the game on the second tile.
And the near-win effect was confirmed in another, real-world experiment. Shoppers who had near wins with scratch-off lottery tickets handed out next to a store in a shopping mall subsequently spent more money in the store than those who had clearly lost or clearly won.
Interestingly, the findings indicate that a near win may actually provide a stronger motivational boost than an actual win.
While this research could help explain our reward-seeking behavior in a variety of real-life situations, it has specific applications in sales and marketing:
"The current research suggests that managers who want to motivate their salespeople to perform better should think about giving feedback that highlights the individual's performance compared to someone only slightly better," Wadhwa explains. "It also impacts marketers who want to design effective promotions -- our field study shows that nearly winning a lottery is better than clearly losing or winning."
The researchers plan to delve deeper into the near-win effect, exploring its potential negative side and how it relates to brain's dopamine system, which is thought to underlie reward processing.
INFORMATION:
For more information about this study, please contact: Monica Wadhwa at monica.wadhwa@insead.edu.
The article abstract is available online at http://pss.sagepub.com/content/early/2015/04/30/0956797614568681.abstract
The APS journal Psychological Science is the highest ranked empirical journal in psychology. For a copy of the article "Can a Near Win Kindle Motivation? The Impact of Nearly Winning on Motivation for Unrelated Rewards" and access to other Psychological Science research findings, please contact Anna Mikulak at 202-293-9300 or amikulak@psychologicalscience.org.
Irvine, Calif., May 11, 2015 - Driving down a dimly lit road at midnight can tax even those with 20/20 vision, but according to a recent UC Irvine study, the brain processes the experience no differently than if it were noon. The same study also reveals how quickly the brain adapts to vision loss, contradicting earlier research and opening the door to novel treatments.
The findings, which appear in the April 21 edition of Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, are significant for those who have suffered retinal damage or disease, said cognitive scientist Alyssa ...
The increase in atmospheric CO2 concentration has allowed trees across Europe to use their available water resources more efficiently, new research has shown.
Over the course of the 20th century, the so-called water use efficiency has risen nearly 20% from the increase in atmospheric CO2 concentrations.
These results, produced by an international research team, including experts from the University of Exeter, are reported in leading scientific journal Nature Climate Change.
Trees take up carbon dioxide from the air through tiny pores on their leaves called stomata and ...
Corporate communicators and marketing teams are often in direct competition to be in the "C-suite" -- the coveted boardroom seats -- according to a study by a Baylor University researcher.
"So few seats are available that it's often an 'either/or' for PR and marketing," said study author Marlene Neill, Ph.D., assistant professor of journalism, public relations and new media in Baylor's College of Arts & Sciences. "People perceive them as quite similar," although their responsibilities are distinctly different.
The research indicates that both groups' focus on the C-suite, ...
Ground-breaking research has successfully created the world's first truly electronic textile, using the wonder material Graphene.
An international team of scientists, including Professor Monica Craciun from the University of Exeter, have pioneered a new technique to embed transparent, flexible graphene electrodes into fibres commonly associated with the textile industry.
The discovery could revolutionise the creation of wearable electronic devices, such as clothing containing computers, phones and MP3 players, which are lightweight, durable and easily transportable.
The ...
Researchers map regional droughts from space which can affect the livelihood of millions of people in West Africa
Soil moisture observations can map land degradation with more accuracy than typical rainfall data as soil moisture directly leads to plant growth
Study shows that the land conditions across much of West Africa have improved between 1982-2012 based on soil moisture observations
A group of international researchers led by the Centre for Landscape and Climate Research at the University of Leicester have used space satellite technology to identify regions ...
PITTSBURGH--We know that bacteriophages are viruses that infect and replicate within bacteria. We know that they are the most abundant organisms on Earth. But we don't know much about their genetic architecture.
A team of professional scholars and budding scientists--chiefly college freshmen--have joined forces under the aegis of SEA-PHAGES (Science Education Alliance-Phage Hunters Advancing Genomics and Evolutionary Science), which is run jointly by the University of Pittsburgh and the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, to study the little-known genetics of bacteriophages. ...
May 11, 2015--With rates of prescription drug overdose at an all-time high, researchers at Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health found that among individuals who visited the emergency department, the risk of subsequently dying from prescription drug overdose increased markedly based on how many times they visited the ER. Relative to patients with one or fewer trips to the ER in the previous year, the risk of dying from prescription drug overdose was five times the rate for those with two visits, 17 times for those with three visits, and 48 times for those ...
A research collaboration between the universities of Oslo and Aarhus has resulted in the development of a new method with diagnostic potential. The new method that combines phase extraction with an enzymatic reaction may eventually be used for an improved and faster screening analysis of isatin as a potential indicator of stress and neurological disorders.
Isatin is a small organic molecule found in low concentrations in different tissues and is excreted with the urine via the blood stream. Isatin is supposedly a degradation product from the neurotransmitters, e.g. dopamine ...
WASHINGTON, May 11, 2015 -- More than 25 million people rely on Adderall™ and other similar drugs to help treat narcolepsy, depression and attention deficit and hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). But how does amphetamine, the active ingredient in Adderall™, work? This week, Reactions explains how amphetamine helps you focus. Check out the video here: https://youtu.be/MeJRBsghMt8.
INFORMATION:Subscribe to the series at http://bit.ly/ACSReactions, and follow us on Twitter @ACSreactions to be the first to see our latest videos.
The American Chemical Society is ...
Physicians treating hospitalized patients for conditions unrelated to the kidneys should pay close attention to common blood and urine tests for kidney function in order to prevent incidental injury to the organs that help cleanse the body of toxins, new Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health-led research suggests.
The findings, published this month in two studies in the American Journal of Kidney Diseases, suggest that while being older, male, African-American or having diabetes are risk factors for developing acute kidney injury, the strongest risk factor is ...
