(Press-News.org) Selling one's body to provide another person with sexual pleasure and selling organs to restore another person's health are generally prohibited in North America on moral grounds, but two new University of Toronto Mississauga studies illustrate how additional information about the societal benefits of such transactions can have an impact on public approval.
The research, conducted by Professor Nicola Lacetera of the University of Toronto (Institute for Management and Innovation, U of T Mississauga, with a cross-appointment to the Rotman School of Management) and his colleagues Julio Elias from Universidad del CEMA in Argentina and Mario Macis from Johns Hopkins University in the United States and adds to our understanding of how moral considerations affect markets and business decisions.
A shortage of organ donors is a serious problem in the United States and Canada. South of the border, 120,000 people are on the waiting list for an organ transplant. Every year, only about 29,000 transplants are performed, and over 10,000 people die -- or become too sick for a transplant -- while on the waitlist. Americans view financial transactions to increase the supply of organs as immoral, even though previous research has indicated that payments of between $15,000 and $30,000 would close the gap between demand and supply and would have the added benefit of cost savings for stopgap treatments, such as kidney dialysis.
Lacetera and his colleagues surveyed 3,400 United States residents and chose to test assumptions about organ donation and indoor prostitution, because both were morally controversial and had similar baseline approval rates, and they assumed there might be spillover in approval from one to the other.
In a recent article published in the Papers and Proceedings of the 2015 Meetings of the American Economic Association (American Economic Review, May 2015), the researchers show that providing additional information about the lifesaving and cost-saving benefits of an organ market increased the approval rating of some form of payment by 20 percent to 70 percent from 50 percent, with no significant variation across age or gender.
'Attitudes toward organ payments may therefore not be completely fixed, given the response to evidence,' says Lacetera.
Yet the same can't be said for attitudes toward allowing indoor prostitution. When survey respondents learned that legalized indoor prostitution reduces violence against women and cuts the rates of sexually transmitted diseases, this didn't have much of an impact on their acceptance of the idea. In fact, among women, having more information led to a decrease in approval rates.
'Because values are so ingrained and so specific, you can't generalize from situation to situation,' Lacetera says.
A second study, appearing in PLOS ONE, demonstrated this inability to assume that acceptance of one morally controversial market transaction naturally means acceptance of all. The researchers used again a survey instrument to test blanket acceptance by providing them with information about one type of transaction (e.g., prostitution), then testing their acceptance of another (e.g., organ donation).
Approval ratings for legalizing indoor prostitution didn't change, even when paired with information about the value of organ donations. These results suggest that U.S. residents' opinions regarding indoor prostitution are relatively stable, and are not affected by cost-benefit considerations; they are based on deeply held moral values.
However, among women, any mention of the benefits of indoor prostitution paired with questions about organ donation led to a radical drop -- 30 percent -- in their approval for the latter type of transaction, leading to a statistically significant drop in approval overall. The researchers noted that this isn't surprising, given the 'existing literature documenting the deep opposition of women toward a market for sex, plausibly triggered by associations of prostitution with stigmatization, sexual dominance and women's oppression.'
'These results imply that the provision of well-supported information can change attitudes toward the acceptance of morally charged market trades but the information has to be context-specific,' Lacetera says. 'Information about the benefits of paying for such transactions must be directly relevant to the transaction, and even then, a change in attitude depends on the type of transaction being discussed.'
'Our research should provide information to policymakers as they devise ways to solve shortages of goods and services whose trades is morally charged, and should also remind companies that attitudes toward certain trades are also affected by moral considerations,' he says. 'This, in turn, may affect the economic prospects of a company in a given context.'
INFORMATION:
Contact:
Nicola Lacetera
nicola.lacetera@utoronto.ca
905-569-4466
Department of Management
Nicolle Wahl
nicolle.wahl@utoronto.ca
905-569-4656
UTM Communications
Going into space might wreak havoc on our bodies, but a new set of microgravity experiments may help shed light on new approaches for treating cartilage diseases on Earth. In a new research report published in the June 2015 issue of The FASEB Journal, a team of European scientists suggests that our cartilage--tissue that serves as a cushion between bones--might be able to survive microgravity relatively unscathed. Specifically, when in a microgravity environment, chondrocytes (a main component of cartilage) were more stable and showed only moderate alterations in shape ...
There's an urgent demand for new antimicrobial compounds that are effective against constantly emerging drug-resistant bacteria. Two robotic chemical-synthesizing machines, named Symphony X and Overture, have joined the search. Their specialty is creating custom nanoscale structures that mimic nature's proven designs. They're also fast, able to assemble dozens of compounds at a time.
The machines are located in a laboratory on the fifth floor of the Molecular Foundry, a DOE Office of Science User Facility at Berkeley Lab. They make peptoids, which are synthetic versions ...
GAINESVILLE, Fla. -- If a picture is worth a thousand words, UF Health Type 1 diabetes researchers and their colleagues have tapped into an encyclopedia, revealing new insights into how young people cope with the disease.
The sophisticated scientific instrument? A camera.
More than 13,000 children and teens are diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes each year. To find out more about their experiences as they live with this chronic disorder, a group of diabetes researchers from three universities, including the University of Florida, gave 40 adolescents disposable cameras and ...
People with achromatopsia, an inherited eye disorder, see the world literally in black and white. Worse yet, their extreme sensitivity to light makes them nearly blind in bright sunlight. Now, researchers at University of California, San Diego School of Medicine and Shiley Eye Institute at UC San Diego Health System have identified a previously unknown gene mutation that underlies this disorder.
The study published online June 1 in the journal Nature Genetics.
"There are whole families with this sort of vision problem all over the world," said Jonathan Lin, MD, ...
Researchers at the U.S. Department of Energy's Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory (PPPL) have for the first time simulated the formation of structures called "plasmoids" during Coaxial Helicity Injection (CHI), a process that could simplify the design of fusion facilities known as tokamaks. The findings, reported in the journal Physical Review Letters, involve the formation of plasmoids in the hot, charged plasma gas that fuels fusion reactions. These round structures carry current that could eliminate the need for solenoids - large magnetic coils that wind down the center ...
There is a wealth of published information describing interactions between drugs used to treat cardiovascular disease and the genetic variations that can affect how patients respond to them. But few heart specialists make routine use of this potentially life-saving data.
To help physicians make better-informed clinical decisions, researchers from the University of Chicago and Stanford University combed through scientific literature on the pharmacogenomics of 71 leading cardiovascular drugs and compiled summaries, published in the June issue of the Mayo Clinic Proceedings.
"Tens ...
Academic programs that provide alternatives to traditional remedial education help students succeed at community colleges, but different programs result in a range of outcomes for various sub-populations of students. Drew Allen, a New York University doctoral student and director of the Office of Research, Evaluation, and Program Support at the City University of New York (CUNY), devoted his doctoral research to the evaluation of three current programmatic approaches at CUNY community colleges.
Entering community college students are often required to take remedial, ...
Some female members of a critically endangered species of sawfish are reproducing in the wild without sex. The discovery, reported in the Cell Press journal Current Biology on June 1, marks the first time living offspring from "virgin births" have been found in a normally sexually reproducing vertebrate in the wild, the researchers say.
Earlier evidence that vertebrates might sometimes reproduce via a process called parthenogenesis had primarily come from isolated examples of captive animals--including birds, reptiles, and sharks. In those instances, the animals in question ...
Despite guideline recommendations to limit medical tests before low-risk surgeries, electrocardiograms (ECGs) and chest x-rays are still performed frequently, found a study in CMAJ (Canadian Medical Association Journal).
Evidence indicates that for patients undergoing low-risk surgery, routine testing does not improve outcomes and can actually lead to surgical delays, patient anxiety and other issues. The Choosing Wisely campaign, which started in the United States and spread to Canada and other countries, aims to raise awareness of unnecessary tests and procedures among ...
Radon gas is a silent health threat, and Canada needs to align its guidelines for acceptable radon levels with World Health Organization (WHO) limits, argues an editorial in CMAJ (Canadian Medical Association Journal).
"We are left in an odd situation in Canada," writes Dr. Diane Kelsall, Deputy Editor, CMAJ. "Drivers and passengers are required to wear seat belts, which are estimated to save about 1000 lives per year. Smoke alarms are required in most jurisdictions, reducing the annual rate of fire-related deaths from 130 per million households by about two-thirds. Yet, ...
