(Press-News.org) People make dramatically different decisions about who should receive hypothetical transplant organs depending on whether the potential recipients are presented as individuals or as part of a larger group, according to new research published in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science. The findings show that when recipients are considered in groups, people tend to allocate organs equally across the groups, ignoring information about the patients' chances of success.
"This is important because public policies about prioritizing resources are framed at the group level -- for example, younger recipients are prioritized for the best transplant organs -- and yet actual allocation decisions are often made at the individual level," explains psychological scientist and senior study author Gretchen Chapman of Rutgers University.
"The intuitions that guide people's discussions about the policies might not be the same as the intuitions that are most salient when it comes time to take an individual allocation action."
In collaboration with first author Helen Colby (Anderson School of Management, University of California, Los Angeles) and co-author Jeff DeWitt (Rutgers University), Chapman asked 470 participants in an online study to allocate six kidneys across a total of 12 hypothetical patients.
Headshot-style photos of the patients were presented in a grid that had a vertical line running down the middle, with 6 patients on either side of the line. Some participants saw "Chance of Success: High" written over top of the right side and "Chance of Success: Low" over the left. For other participants, the same information about chance of success was written instead under each individual patient photo. Also, some participants made a decision about how many kidneys to allocate per group, while others had to decide whether to allocate a kidney to each individual patient.
The most medically efficient decision -- the one with the likelihood of saving the most lives -- would be to allocate all 6 kidneys to the patients with a high chance of success. But the researchers hypothesized that presenting the patients in groups might lead people to make less efficient decisions.
As expected, participants made more efficient decisions when the chance of success was presented for each patient compared to when it was presented for the two groups; patient-by-patient allocation decisions were also more efficient than those made by group.
In two additional online studies, some participants saw a unified group of 12 patients, while others saw two groups of six patients divided by a line (as in the first study). Again, presenting patients as part of groups had a noticeable impact on participants' allocation decisions:
"It's surprising how such a subtle manipulation shifted participants' responses," says Chapman. "Just drawing a line down the middle of the screen to separate the 12 recipients into two groups of six and putting a label over each group was enough to make participants less efficient in their allocation."
The findings showed a robust grouping effect, regardless of the types of labels used to identify the groups and the amount of information provided about the potential recipients.
"The grouping effect was resistant to a number of different variations in the procedure that we tried," says Chapman. "We used different type of group labels, we used group labels that were completely uninformative, and we removed the identifying information about the recipients, but none of these procedures reduced the grouping effect."
Together, these findings suggest that people have a strong bias toward equality when it comes to divvying up limited resources, even if equality doesn't ultimately lead to the most logical or effective decisions. There are some contexts, however, in which the grouping effect could be helpful:
"If managers making decisions about hiring or promoting employees were to have candidates grouped by gender instead of presented as individuals, they might be prompted to spread jobs across the groups more evenly, which would lead to the hiring or promotion of more women," explains Chapman.
The researchers plan on exploring the potential positive outcomes of grouping in future studies.
INFORMATION:
This research was supported by National Institute on Aging Grant Grant 1R01-AG037943-01 (to G. B. Chapman).
All data and materials have been made publicly available via Open Science Framework and can be accessed at https://osf.io/wk3ve/. Study 3 was preregistered at https://osf.io/k29e6/. The complete Open Practices Disclosure for this article can be found at http://pss.sagepub.com/content/by/supplementaldata. This article has received badges for Open Data, Open Materials, and Preregistration. More information about the Open Practices badges can be found at https://osf.io/tvyxz/wiki/1.%20View%20the%20Badges/ and http://pss.sagepub.com/content/25/1/3.full.
For more information about this study, please contact: Gretchen B. Chapman at gretchen.chapman@rutgers.edu.
The article abstract is available online: http://pss.sagepub.com/content/early/2015/06/15/0956797615583978.abstract
The APS journal Psychological Science is the highest ranked empirical journal in psychology. For a copy of the article "Grouping Promotes Equality: The Effect of Recipient Grouping on Allocation of Limited Medical Resources" and access to other Psychological Science research findings, please contact Anna Mikulak at 202-293-9300 or amikulak@psychologicalscience.org.
June 17, 2015 (Washington, D.C.) - Whether sealed with a handshake, a million-dollar contract, or a string of curses, every business deal is a reflection of trust. Both parties trust that the other will hold up their end of the bargain. Good negotiators have a store of social capital before bargaining begins; built up through interactions outside the negotiations that establish trust. Working with a team of researchers from Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität and Technische Universität in Munich, Germany, American University's Kogod School of Business professor of ...
Someday, treating patients with nanorobots could become standard practice to deliver medicine specifically to parts of the body affected by disease. But merely injecting drug-loaded nanoparticles might not always be enough to get them where they need to go. Now scientists are reporting in the ACS journal Nano Letters the development of new nanoswimmers that can move easily through body fluids to their targets.
Tiny robots could have many benefits for patients. For example, they could be programmed to specifically wipe out cancer cells, which would lower the risk of complications, ...
Needle injections have been around since 1657 and remain a key delivery method for many drugs, including vaccines that have prevented countless illnesses. But for patients that require daily pricks or for people in remote locations, the syringe model has major drawbacks. An article in Chemical & Engineering News looks at potential alternatives, their successes and their roadblocks.
Alex Scott, a senior editor at C&EN, explains that many pharmaceuticals, particularly large-molecule drugs such as insulin, are not good candidates for oral delivery. If swallowed, they would ...
A new approach to skin rejuvenation developed at Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) may be less likely to have unintended side effects such as scarring and altered pigmentation. In the online journal Scientific Reports, an MGH research team reports that treatment with pulsed electric fields - a noninvasive procedure that does not involve the generation of heat - removed skin cells in an animal model without affecting the supporting extracellular matrix, eventually leading to renewal of the skin surface.
"We showed that non-thermal pulsed electric field or PEF treatment ...
ANN ARBOR--A University of Michigan researcher and his colleagues are forecasting an average but still large "dead zone" in the Gulf of Mexico this year.
The forecast calls for an oxygen-depleted, or hypoxic, region of 5,483 square miles, roughly the size of Connecticut. It was announced today by the U.S. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, which sponsors the work.
Farmland runoff containing fertilizers and livestock waste, much of it from as far away as the Corn Belt, is the main source of the nitrogen and phosphorus that cause the annual Gulf of Mexico ...
A NASA animation of imagery from NOAA's GOES-East satellite shows the progression of Tropical Storm Bill through the western Gulf of Mexico, landfall in east Texas and weakening into a depression west of Dallas.
A GOES-East animation of infrared and visible imagery from June 15 through June 17 shows Tropical Storm Bill's movement and landfall. The animation was created by NASA/NOAA GOES Project at the NASA Goddard Space Flight Center in Greenbelt, Maryland.
At 5 a.m. EDT 0900 UTC), the center of Tropical Depression Bill was located near latitude 31.0 North, longitude ...
The words 'yes' and 'no' may seem like two of the easiest expressions to understand in any language, but their actual behavior and interpretation are surprisingly difficult to pin down. In a paper published earlier today in the scholarly journal Language, two linguists examine the workings of 'yes' and 'no' and show that understanding them leads to new insights concerning the understanding of questions and statements more generally.
Floris Roelofsen (University of Amsterdam) and Donka F. Farkas (UC - Santa Cruz) provide a comprehensive account of 'polarity particles', ...
ITHACA, N.Y. - To sort out the biological intricacies of Earth-like planets, astronomers have developed computer models that examine how ultraviolet radiation from other planets' nearby suns may affect those worlds, according to new research published June 10 in Astrophysical Journal.
"Depending on the intensity, ultraviolet radiation can be both useful and harmful to the origin of life," says Lisa Kaltenegger, Cornell associate professor of astronomy and the director of Cornell's new Carl Sagan Institute: Pale Blue Dot and Beyond. "We are trying to ascertain how much ...
CHICAGO --- Consumers may need more help navigating the sunscreen aisle. A new Northwestern Medicine study found that many people seem to be confused by sunscreen terminology.
Only 43 percent of people surveyed understood the definition of sun factor protection (SPF) and only seven percent knew what to look for on a label if they wanted a sunscreen that offers protection against early skin aging.
Details of the study were published June 17, in the journal JAMA Dermatology.
"We need to do a better job of educating people about sun protection and make it easier for ...
To move the world toward sustainability, scientists are continuing to explore and improve ways to tap the vast power of sunlight to make fuels and generate electricity. Now they have come up with a brand-new way to use light -- solar or artificial -- to drive battery power safely. Their "photo battery," reported in ACS' The Journal of Physical Chemistry C, uses light and titanium nitride for the anode.
Metal-ion batteries such as those based on lithium ions run most of our gadgets. But they take a long time to charge. They can also overheat and catch fire if they're ...
