(Press-News.org) A new Cochrane systematic review published today of surgery for stress urinary incontinence makes an important contribution to an ongoing debate and will help women to make more informed choices about treatment. Inserting a 'mid-urethral sling', a type of tape, to support the muscles of the bladder by either the groin or abdomen results in similar cure rates. However, differences in complications and the long term need for repeat surgery mean that women will need to balance a number of different factors when choosing an operation.
Stress urinary incontinence (SUI) is the involuntary loss of urine that occurs with coughing, sneezing or physical exertion. It is a common problem, particularly in women who have had children, and affects millions of people worldwide. It happens due to weaknesses in the structures supporting the bladder and bladder outlet (urethra), mainly the pelvic floor muscles, which then fail to stop urine leaking out when the bladder is under stress, such as when laughing or sneezing, or because of a weakness in the sphincter muscle which normally holds the urethra closed.
Women whose symptoms persist despite trying non-surgical approaches such as pelvic floor exercises may be suitable for surgery in order to improve bladder control. Surgery uses one of two common operations to insert a sling under the urethra in an effort to keep it supported. One approach is the insertion of a sling behind the pubic bone coming out via the abdomen (the bottom-to-top 'retropubic' route), or alternatively from side-to-side coming out through the groin (the 'transobturator' route).
The team of researchers included information from 81 trials in total, of which 55 made the direct comparison between the retropubic and transobturator routes. They found moderate quality evidence that at around 12 months, both routes had successfully cured symptoms in 80% of women. From the few studies that had reported 5 year data, rates of cure in both groups had fallen to around 70%.
Transobturator insertion seemed to carry a lower risk of bladder damage during the operation with around 6 women in 1000 experiencing this compared with 50 in 1000 in the retropubic groups, and fewer women (40 in 1000) in the transobturator group had persistent difficulty in being able to empty their bladder completely compared with around 70 in 1000 in the retropubic group.
In contrast, the transobturator operation led to more short-term groin pain and there is some limited evidence that women who undergo transobturator route insertion are more likely to need a repeat operation later on than women who had a retropubic insertion. The overall rate of erosion of the tape into the vagina was 2% following either surgery when the studies had completed follow-up at between 1 and 5 years. The rate of pain during sexual intercourse was also low in both groups.
Over the last few years many questions have been raised about the safety of continence surgery because it involves implanting a sling made of an artificial mesh. There have been a number of reports of women suffering pain and injury after surgery, thought to be due to the sling which is made of non-absorbable plastic. This has led to many court actions worldwide, with cases already under way in the UK, the USA and Canada. In Scotland, the Health minister called for hospitals to consider the suspension of mesh operations until more evidence is available. An independent review set up in Scotland in 2014 to review the safety of these operations will publish its findings later this year. This latest Cochrane Review is one of a number of sources of evidence which will inform the findings of that independent review.
Lead Author, Abigail Ford from the Bradford Teaching Hospitals says, "This is a very significant review informing women about the minimally invasive surgical options available for the treatment of this very debilitating condition. It helps to clarify the pre-existing evidence on the effectiveness of these approaches and their side effects in the short term, as well as introducing longer term evidence of efficacy and safety. It helps to give women more information to make an informed choice."
Dr Ford continues, "Understanding this evidence in context is really important for women. They need to be aware of less invasive alternatives such as pelvic floor exercises which should be tried first before contemplating any type of surgery. As all surgery carries some risk women must weigh up carefully how much they are troubled by their urine leakage against taking a small chance that things may go wrong as a result of surgery."
Joseph Ogah, Consultant Gynaecologist says, "We need to know more about what happens to women in the long term. This review found 35 trials carried out more than five years ago: if all the women in these trials were followed up we would know much more about how long the operations last and, crucially, whether they had developed late but important side effects. Rather than starting any new trials in this area we need to obtain long-term follow up from the existing trials."
Mr Ogah also says, "Although this review compares the two most common operations in current practice in the developed world, we need more robust evidence about how well they compare with the older types of surgery that they have superseded: it may be helpful to look at indirect comparisons if direct evidence is not available or reliable enough."
INFORMATION:
BLOOMINGTON, Ind.--A new study from Indiana University provides evidence in mice that males may play a positive role in the development of offspring's brains starting before pregnancy.
The research, reported July 30 in the Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences, found that female mice exposed to male pheromones gave birth to infants with greater mental ability.
"This is the first study to show that pheromone exposure exerts an influence across generations in mammals," said Sachiko Koyama, an associate research scientist at the IU Bloomington ...
DARIEN, IL - A new study suggests that there may be a reciprocal, causal pathway between job strain and disturbed sleep, implying that interventions to treat sleep problems may improve work satisfaction.
Results show that higher work demands predicted subsequent sleep disturbances at the two-year follow-up. Similarly, sleep disturbances predicted a higher perception of stress, higher work demands, a lower degree of control, and less social support at work two years later. No relationship was found between disturbed sleep and physical work environment, shift work schedules ...
An international research team led by the University of Colorado Boulder and the University of Witwatersrand in Johannesburg, South Africa has discovered a milk-and ochre-based paint dating to 49,000 years ago that inhabitants may have used to adorn themselves with or to decorate stone or wooden slabs.
While the use of ochre by early humans dates to at least 250,000 years ago in Europe and Africa, this is the first time a paint containing ochre and milk has ever been found in association with early humans in South Africa, said Paola Villa, a curator at the University ...
NASA's Swift satellite detected a rising tide of high-energy X-rays from the constellation Cygnus on June 15, just before 2:32 p.m. EDT. About 10 minutes later, the Japanese experiment on the International Space Station called the Monitor of All-sky X-ray Image (MAXI) also picked up the flare.
The outburst came from V404 Cygni, a binary system located about 8,000 light-years away that contains a black hole. Every couple of decades the black hole fires up in an outburst of high-energy light, becoming an X-ray nova. Until the Swift detection, it had been slumbering since ...
June 30, 2015 - Two migraine surgery techniques targeting a specific "trigger site" are both highly effective in reducing the frequency and severity of migraine headaches, according to a randomized trial in the July issue of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery®, the official medical journal of the American Society of Plastic Surgeons (ASPS).
Patients with temporal-type migraine derive similar and significant improvement from techniques that relieve pressure on (decompression) or remove a portion of (neurectomy) the nerve responsible for triggering their headaches, ...
A new University of Colorado Boulder framework used to screen hundreds of organic chemical compounds used in hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, shows that 15 may be of concern as groundwater contaminants based on their toxicity, mobility, persistence and frequency of use.
Using a fast groundwater transport scenario, the team predicted that 41 of the 659 organic compounds screened would have 10 percent or more of their initial concentrations remaining at a transport distance of roughly 300 feet. That is the average state "setback" distance in the United States between ...
Researchers at University of California, San Diego School of Medicine have discovered a cell signaling pathway that appears to exert some control over initiation and progression of colorectal cancer, the third leading cause of cancer-related death in the United States. A key protein in the pathway also appears to be predictive of cancer survival rates.
The study is reported in the June 30 issue of eLife.
The protein, known as Dishevelled-associating protein with a high frequency of leucine residues or Daple, is produced by nearly all healthy cells in the body and is ...
Brigham and Women's Hospital finds that developing and implementing an interdisciplinary care improvement initiative improves outcomes.
Approximately 20 percent of all patients admitted to a hospital have a mental health condition, either as a primary or a secondary diagnosis, and a recent report by the Institute of Medicine warned that there is a critical shortage of health care professionals who are equipped to provide mental health and geriatric care to these patients in the hospital setting. Often, these patients experience delirium, alcohol withdrawal and suicide ...
The universe can be a very sticky place, but just how sticky is a matter of debate.
That is because for decades cosmologists have had trouble reconciling the classic notion of viscosity based on the laws of thermodynamics with Einstein's general theory of relativity. However, a team from Vanderbilt University has come up with a fundamentally new mathematical formulation of the problem that appears to bridge this long-standing gap.
The new math has some significant implications for the ultimate fate of the universe. It tends to favor one of the more radical scenarios ...
MAYWOOD, IL - In recent years, there has been widespread media coverage of studies purporting to show that radiation from X-rays, CT scans and other medical imaging causes cancer.
But such studies have serious flaws, including their reliance on an unproven statistical model, according to a recent article in the journal Technology in Cancer Research & Treatment. Corresponding author is Loyola University Medical Center radiation oncologist James Welsh, MS, MD.
"Although radiation is known to cause cancer at high doses and high-dose rates, no data have ever unequivocally ...
