(Press-News.org) Trolling and extreme levels of abuse can kill an online campaign but momentum can be maintained, and the energy and morale of exhausted activists effectively restored, by tactical retreat and taking time out, new research into the landmark 'No More Page 3' campaign in the United Kingdom shows.
Dr. Sarah Glozer of the University of Bath School of Management and Dr. Lauren McCarthy of the Royal Holloway University of London School of Business and Management studied the 'No More Page 3' campaign, which from 2012 lobbied The Sun mass-circulation newspaper to stop publishing a photo of a topless woman on page 3, a daily feature launched in 1970. Page 3, the No More Page 3 campaign argued, was a symbol of institutionalised sexism. The Sun removed the Page 3 feature in 2015.
Glozer and McCarthy found the campaigners were subjected to extreme levels of abuse and hate-speech online, leading to considerable stress and exhaustion, but had developed effective measures to mitigate against these risks to their ultimately successful campaign. Key amongst those was simply retreating.
"It seems counter-intuitive - to urge campaigners to step back from the front line, take time out, perhaps retreat to silence, when campaigning seems to be so much about keeping the fight going. But our study shows it paid dividends, both for the individual's welfare and the effectiveness of the campaign itself," Glozer said.
Glozer said the No More Page 3 campaigners adopted different forms of sensory retreat - some went silent on social media or observed campaign efforts rather than participating actively. Some withdrew temporarily and deleted their accounts. Glozer said that these tactics, in most cases, ensured that most of the campaigners would return rejuvenated to the front line.
"This retreat tactic, which could have been an hour, a day or weeks at a time, allowed the campaigners to recover their emotional energy and heal - we heard the word 'healing' a lot," Glozer said.
Importantly, the campaign group's core activists, rather than demanding more and more from each other, were understanding and supportive of the need for retreat.
"They reported finding solace and taking strength in acting together. They understood the need for retreat and saw this not as a sign of weakness or flagging commitment to the cause", a lesson Glozer said could be helpful to corporates or governmental organisations wrestling with 'burn-out' cases.
McCarthy added that campaigner exhaustion was especially common when causes were directly related to individuals' identity.
"Women drew on their experiences of teenage shame about their bodies, or sexual harassment, as a kind of fuel for their campaigning. But at the same time, these experiences and continued abuse online, can lead to burnout. It's a Catch 22 situation," she said.
A key tactic in dealing with the 24/7 onslaught of social media abuse was a relay system. An exhausted campaigner wrestling with a hostile social media feed or forum would 'pass the baton' to another campaigner via a system of online messaging or 'tagging' across platforms, ensuring that campaign's momentum was unaffected.
Glozer noted that the No More Page 3 campaigners sought out their most vehement opponents to try to convince them of their argument and win their support; a brave tactic in the world of 'toxic Twitter'.
"While social media can cosset the user, surrounding us with like-minded people in a filter bubble or echo chamber, the NMP3 campaigners chose to actively enter the Lion's Den. We were struck by their tactics and how resilient they were, impressed by their rationality in the face of rude, abusive and downright abhorrent behaviour. But that takes an emotional toll," she said.
This experience in the virtual world also adversely affected the campaigners' expectations of public behaviour in the physical world.
"They became terrified they would face the same level of vitriol on the streets. Their online experience exaggerated their fears - in fact, this proved not to be the case when people were unable to hide behind their online identities," Glozer said.
Glozer said the research pointed to the need for digital platforms to do more to address the trolling and hate-speech that are still tolerated and excused in some social media channels.
"Women continue to experience inequality offline, and such tensions are only amplified online. Feminist environs provide safe spaces, and social media can help to mobilise - and has proven its value in campaigning - but there is more platforms can do to police hate-speech," she said.
McCarthy added that whilst looking to business to do more was appropriate, it was clear that campaigning organisations were taking action on their own.
"During the pandemic we saw the rise of mutual-aid groups organising on social media, far in advance of any governmental or corporate help. Similarly, campaigning groups are utilising the tools they have at their fingertips to protect and sustain their members. As we emerge from this pandemic, which has rolled the clock back on so many hard-won gains for women's equality, and only exasperated incidences of trolling and 'networked misogyny', more action is needed to fight inequality in both online and offline worlds," she said.
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TAm0gW5v90E&ab_channel=UniversityofBathSchoolofManagement
INFORMATION:
The earliest multicellular organisms may have lacked heads, legs, or arms, but pieces of them remain inside of us today, new research shows.
According to a UC Riverside study, 555-million-year-old oceanic creatures from the Ediacaran period share genes with today's animals, including humans.
"None of them had heads or skeletons. Many of them probably looked like three-dimensional bathmats on the sea floor, round discs that stuck up," said Mary Droser, a geology professor at UCR. "These animals are so weird and so different, it's difficult to assign them to modern categories of living organisms just by looking at them, and it's not like we can extract their DNA -- we can't."
However, well-preserved fossil records ...
Over 10,000 people in Europe use an assistance dog; think of guide dogs for people with a visual impairment, hearing dogs for people with a hearing impairment, medical response service dogs and psychiatric service dogs.
According to a UN-agreement and the Dutch law, these dogs are welcome in stores, hospitals and other public places. However, in practice, many assistance dog users and their dogs are regularly refused entry. In the Netherlands, four out of five assistance dog users indicate that they regularly experience problems with this.
Often, hygiene reasons are ...
Researchers at the UAB have designed minimalist biostructures that imitate natural enzymes, capable of carrying out two differentiated and reversibly regulated activities thanks to a unique combination of structural and functional properties. The strategy used opens the door to the creation of "intelligent" nanomaterials with tailor-made combinations of catalytic functions.
There is an increasing interest in synthetic systems that can execute bioinspired chemical reactions without requiring the complex structures that characterise enzymes in their components. One of the most explored approaches is the self-assembly of peptides - molecules smaller than proteins - due to their biocompatibility and how their structural and functional properties can be controlled.
Researchers from the ...
Several processes in the human body are regulated by biochemical reactions involving hydrogen peroxide (H2O2). Although it can act as a 'secondary messenger', relaying or amplifying certain signals between cells, H2O2 is generally toxic because of its oxidant character. The latter means that it converts (oxidizes) biochemical molecules like proteins and DNA. The oxidizing property of H2O2 is of potential therapeutic relevance for cancer, though: deliberately causing tumor cells to increase their H2O2 concentration would be a way to destroy them. In light of this, but also for monitoring pathologies associated with H2O2 overproduction, it is crucial to have a means to reliably quantify hydrogen peroxide concentrations in the extracellular environment. Now, Leonardo Puppulin ...
A team of researchers from the CHUM Research Centre has identified new biomarkers associated with the severity of COVID-19 in infected patients.
Recent scientific literature has shown that the immune response plays a central part in the severity of COVID-19 disease. Understanding the immune responses generated during the course of the disease is therefore essential to determine which patients are at highest risk for serious complications and death from the disease.
In a new study published in the Journal of Clinical Investigation, scientists and clinicians led by Dr.?Catherine Larochelle, researcher at the CHUM Research Centre, have ...
Bacteria integrate genetic material from other bacterial strains more easily than previously thought, which can lead to improved fitness and accelerated evolution. This is shown in a recent study by biophysicists at the University of Cologne. The team analysed genome transfer between bacteria of different lineages. The study was published in the journal PNAS.
In the experiment, the team brought one strain of bacteria into contact with DNA fragments from another strain. The uptake of foreign genetic material is known as horizontal gene transfer -- in contrast to vertical gene transfer, by which genes are inherited from a parent cell of the same lineage. The results show that ...
DES PLAINES, IL - A Boston violence intervention advocacy program is effectively engaging the client population that hospital-based violence intervention programs (HVIPs) have been designed to support. This is the conclusion of a study titled Boston Violence Intervention Advocacy Program: Challenges and Opportunities for Client Engagement and Goal Achievement, to be published in the March 2021 issue of Academic Emergency Medicine (AEM), a journal of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine (SAEM).
According to the study, HVIPs should consider which types of client needs prove most challenging to address and which novel strategies will engage vulnerable populations not typically targeted by intervention programs. ...
The sensor network MUCCnet (Munich Urban Carbon Column network) consists of five high-precision optical instruments that analyze the sun's light spectra. They measure the concentration of the gases carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4) and carbon monoxide (CO). Since each gas has its own unique spectral "fingerprint", concentrations of these gases can be determined in the columns of air between the instruments and the sun.
"By measuring a vertical column of the atmosphere, local disturbances, such as the disproportionate influence of neighboring stacks, can be removed. Therefore, this type of greenhouse gas balancing is considered particularly robust and accurate," says Prof. Jia Chen.
Measurements at five locations in and around Munich
One of MUCCnet's measurement devices is ...
A new study by the international network Women In Supramolecular Chemistry (WISC) has highlighted the equality, diversity and inclusion (EDI) issues faced by women and marginalised groups working within that field.
The network has also set out a 'calling in' approach to address these issues.
The study, led by Dr Jennifer Leigh and Dr Jennifer Hiscock (both University of Kent) alongside WISC's wider team of international researchers, found that both men and women in the supramolecular community wanted to see more mentoring opportunities and more visibility for women and marginalised groups. There is a desire for more guidance during the transition from postdoctoral researcher to independent Principal Investigator, to ensure women can be retained ...
(COLUMBUS, Ohio) - Concussion, a form of traumatic brain injury, is a common injury among children and teens. Concussions can have adverse effects on physical, cognitive, emotional and sleep health. Clinical guidelines for managing concussion in children and teens traditionally recommend complete physical and cognitive rest until symptom resolution, followed by a gradual return to activities like school and sports. These guidelines are often disputed and based on expert consensus as opposed to strong evidence. The challenge has been how to quantify the amount of physical and cognitive activity that children and teens should engage in during recovery. A new study by researchers at the Center for ...
