(Press-News.org) When a pregnant person declines a recommended treatment such as prenatal testing or an epidural, tension and strife may ensue between the patient and provider, according to a new analysis by researchers at NYU Rory Meyers College of Nursing and the University of British Columbia.
"People should feel safe, respected, and engaged in their maternity care, but our findings suggest that when providers do not listen to patients, it can foster mistrust and avoidance," said P. Mimi Niles, PhD, MPH, CNM, assistant professor at NYU Rory Meyers College of Nursing and the lead author of the study, which is published in the journal PLOS ONE. "These situations deprioritize a person's autonomy and preferences."
In recent years, the World Health Organization and the Lancet have published frameworks about quality of care during pregnancy, birth, and the period after birth. Notably, they emphasize not just physical outcomes, but also a person's psychosocial experiences. These experiences are greatly influenced by interactions with healthcare providers--including physicians, midwives, and nurses--and factors such as respect, trust, agency, and autonomy have emerged as critical aspects of maternity care.
"Providing care is an act of respect and regard, and how we provide care is just as important as what care we provide," said Niles, a practicing midwife.
But many times, healthcare interactions fall short--or worse--and patients report dismissive, disrespectful behavior by providers. Participants in the study described not having choice in their treatment and experiencing a lack of respect when asserting their autonomy, which can hurt their self-efficacy, mental health, and willingness to engage with healthcare in the future.
These interactions are particularly fraught when a pregnant person declines or refuses care that is offered or recommended by healthcare providers. In maternity care, this may include foregoing certain prenatal testing (e.g. gestational diabetes or genetic testing), medications (e.g. epidural or other pain relief), or childbirth interventions (e.g. inducing labor), as University of British Columbia researchers and Niles demonstrated in a recent study in Reproductive Health.
To better understand the experience of childbearing women, Niles and her colleagues conducted a qualitative content analysis of 1,540 written accounts from more than 1,000 women in the Canadian province British Columbia. The accounts were part of the Changing Childbirth in British Columbia study, conducted in 2014 using an online survey with open-ended questions, including those about the experience of declining care.
Four themes emerged:
Contentious interactions: In interactions fraught with tension, participants described "fighting" for the kind of care they wanted and the right to refuse a procedure or intervention.
Knowledge as control and power: Knowledge was viewed as a source of power both for providers, considered keepers of medical knowledge, and for patients, who found strength in knowing about the procedures or interventions they were declining.
Morbid threats: Providers made extreme threats--for instance, "Do you want your baby to die?"--when pregnant people declined interventions. These were particularly powerful during labor and were often experienced as coercion or manipulation to accept the procedures being offered.
Compliance as valued: Many recounted the sense that obedience to clinical recommendations--being a "good client"--was valued in their healthcare experience, but it could also suppress their questions or desire to decline care.
"Our findings demonstrate the complex experiences that patients have when declining care in a traditional, gendered healthcare system," said Niles. "As providers, learning how to support our patients' autonomy and decision-making process means that we must understand how to interact and continue to provide care when what we suggest is not in alignment with what the patient wants."
The researchers write that supporting patient autonomy requires bringing their values into care planning--not as an event, but as an ongoing process reflected in the idea of person-centered care.
While the study focused on childbearing people in British Columbia, the researchers note that their findings are part of a global phenomenon and likely translate to other populations.
"In the U.S., one in six people report being mistreated during childbirth, which includes feeling threatened or coerced in their care. Among women of color, this increases to one in three," added Niles, citing the Giving Voice to Mothers study. "Healthcare exists in relationships, not just as a service. We're not auto mechanics. The same things we value in our relationships--trust, autonomy, respect--are what should be valued and supported by providers and the healthcare system."
INFORMATION:
In addition to Niles, study authors include Kathrin Stoll, Jessie J. Wang, Stéphanie Black, and Saraswathi Vedam of the University of British Columbia. The analysis was supported by the Michael Smith Foundation for Health Research.
About NYU Rory Meyers College of Nursing (@NYUNursing)
NYU Rory Meyers College of Nursing is a global leader in nursing and health. Founded in 1932, the College offers B.S., M.S., DNP and Ph.D. degree programs providing the educational foundation to prepare the next generation of nursing leaders and researchers. NYU Meyers has several programs that are highly ranked by U.S. News & World Report and is among the top 10 nursing schools receiving NIH funding, thanks to its research mission and commitment to innovative approaches to health care worldwide.
Middle school, a time when children's brains are undergoing significant development, is often also a time of new challenges in navigating the social world. Recent research from the Center for BrainHealth at UT Dallas demonstrates the power of combining a virtual platform with live coaching to help students enhance their social skills and confidence in a low-risk environment.
In this study, BrainHealth researchers partnered with low-income public middle schools in Dallas. Teachers recommended 90 students to participate in virtual training sessions via ...
Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) reactivation resulting from the inflammatory response to coronavirus infection may be the cause of previously unexplained long COVID symptoms -- such as fatigue, brain fog, and rashes -- that occur in approximately 30% of patients after recovery from initial COVID-19 infection. The first evidence linking EBV reactivation to long COVID, as well as an analysis of long COVID prevalence, is outlined in a new long COVID study published in the journal Pathogens.
"We ran EBV antibody tests on recovered COVID-19 patients, comparing EBV reactivation rates of those with long COVID symptoms to those without ...
Niigata, Japan - An estimated 1.13 billion people worldwide have hypertension or high blood pressure, and two-thirds of these individuals are living in low- and middle-income countries. Blood pressure is the force manifested by circulating blood against the walls of the body's arteries, the major blood vessels in the body. Hypertension is when blood pressure is too high.
Blood pressure is written as two numbers. The first (systolic) number represents the pressure in blood vessels when the heart contracts or beats. The second (diastolic) number represents the pressure in the vessels when the heart rests between beats. Hypertension is diagnosed if, when it is measured on two different days, the systolic blood pressure (SBP) readings on both days is ≥140 mmHg and/or the diastolic ...
Supercomputers could find themselves out of a job thanks to a suite of new machine learning models that produce rapid, accurate results using a normal laptop.
Researchers at the ARC Centre of Excellence in Exciton Science, based at RMIT University, have written a program that predicts the band gap of materials, including for solar energy applications, via freely available and easy-to-use software. Band gap is a crucial indication of how efficient a material will be when designing new solar cells.
Band gap predictions involve quantum and atomic-scale chemical calculations ...
It's one of the iconic images of early Antarctic exploration: the heroic explorer sledging across the icy wastes towed by his trusty team of canine companions.
But new research analysing a century-old dog biscuit suggests the animals in this picture were probably marching on half-empty stomachs: early British Antarctic expeditions underfed their dogs.
In a paper just published in Polar Record, researchers from Canterbury Museum, Lincoln University and University of Otago in New Zealand analysed the history and contents of Spratt's dog cakes, the chow of choice for the canine members of early Antarctic expeditions.
Lead author, ...
Two mRNA vaccines against COVID-19 have proven safe and effective in clinical trials, as well as in the millions of people who have been vaccinated so far. But how prior SARS-CoV-2 infection affects vaccine response, and how long that response lasts, are still uncertain. Now, a new study in ACS Nano supports increasing evidence that people who had COVID-19 need only one vaccine dose, and that boosters could be necessary for everyone in the future.
In clinical trials, the Pfizer-BioNTech and Moderna COVID-19 vaccines were about 95% effective in protecting against symptomatic infections. Both mRNA vaccines trigger the immune system to produce antibodies against the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein receptor binding domain (RBD), and two doses are necessary to provide immunity in people ...
CHAMPAIGN, Ill. -- Researchers report that they have developed a method to combine three brain-imaging techniques to more precisely capture the timing and location of brain responses to a stimulus. Their study is the first to combine the three widely used technologies for simultaneous imaging of brain activity. The work is reported in the journal Human Brain Mapping.
The new "trimodal" approach combines functional MRI, electroencephalography and a third technique, called EROS, that tracks the activity of neurons near the surface of the brain using near-infrared light.
"We know that fMRI is very good at telling us where in the brain things are happening, but the signal is quite slow," said postdoctoral researcher Matthew Moore, the first ...
A potent greenhouse gas, methane is released by many sources, both human and natural. Large cities emit significant amounts of methane, but in many cases the exact emission sources are unknown. Now, researchers reporting in ACS' Environmental Science & Technology have conducted mobile measurements of methane and its sources throughout Paris. Their findings suggest that the natural gas distribution network, the sewage system and furnaces of buildings are ideal targets for methane reduction efforts.
In cities, major sources of atmospheric methane include heating systems, landfills, wastewater ...
Rare-earth elements are in many everyday products, such as smart phones, LED lights and batteries. However, only a few locations have large enough deposits worth mining, resulting in global supply chain tensions. So, there's a push toward recycling them from non-traditional sources, such as waste from burning coal -- fly ash. Now, researchers in ACS' Environmental Science & Technology report a simple method for recovering these elements from coal fly ash using an ionic liquid.
While rare-earth elements aren't as scarce as their name implies, major reserves are either in politically ...
A new United Nations report calls for an urgent change in the way the world's oceans are managed.
The report from the International Resource Panel, hosted by the UN Environment Programme, raises concerns that if changes are not made quickly, the consequences will be dire.
The Governing Coastal Resources Report was launched today at an event addressed by Ambassador Peter Thomson, UN Secretary-General's Special Envoy for the Ocean. It outlines the effect land-based human activities have on the marine environment.
Put into context - 80 per cent of marine and coastal pollution originates on land, but there are very few, if any, truly effective governance mechanisms that manage land-ocean ...
