(Press-News.org) Researchers from Duke University, University of Notre Dame, and Microsoft published a new Journal of Marketing article that examines using “true normal prices” during a sale as a way to reduce deceptive pricing tricks.
The study, forthcoming in the Journal of Marketing, is titled “Competition and the Regulation of Fictitious Pricing” and is authored by Richard Staelin, Joel E. Urbany, and Donald Ngwe.
Does competition make firms more honest? Over 50 years ago, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) assumed the answer was yes when it stopped enforcing its deceptive pricing regulations. Since that time, competition has increased significantly, particularly in the crowded U.S. retail trade. However, contrary to the FTC’s hypothesis, deceptive pricing has proliferated during the same period.
This new article explains why competition is more likely to encourage rather than discourage deception. The researchers propose a possible solution: require firms using reference prices during a sale to also provide information on the true normal price of the on-sale item.
The study starts by critically evaluating two assumptions that underlie the FTC’s “competition discourages deception” theory:
The first assumption is that inflated reference prices are largely ignored by consumers, who focus primarily on evaluating the actual selling price in a promoted deal. As such, price competition pushes selling prices lower and renders reference prices harmless.
However, empirical research gives a different picture. A robust finding in the marketing literature is that the addition of a high regular price stated in a price promotion increases consumer willingness to pay. The research illustrates how much consumers value “getting a good deal,” leading to greater sales for the retailer when comparative prices are used.
The FTC’s second assumption is that competition drives out economic incentives to cheat. The theory is that, as competition heats up, firms have an economic incentive to be truthful and that any temptation to stray will be constrained by natural market forces.
However, a number of recent economic models show the opposite; that is, the greater the competition, the more likely the firm will offer “noisy” information in an attempt to shield itself from this competition and in the process increase its profits.
Three recent empirical examples provide consistent support for model development, each finding:
consistent seller use of high reference prices at which products are never or rarely sold,
consumer choice being altered by these often fictitious reference prices, and
firms experiencing financial gains from posting inflated reference prices.
All this leads to the conclusion that there is a substantial negative impact of fictitious reference pricing on consumer welfare.
The Value of Firms Telling the Truth
“After evaluating several regulatory options, we conclude the best way to create real change in firms’ behavior is to require them to tell the truth. Our proposal is to require firms to disclose an item’s true normal price (TNP) whenever comparative prices are used in price communications,” says Staelin.
To illustrate, say that a furniture retailer puts a sofa on sale as follows:
Regular Price $1399
Sale Price $599
Also assume, as is common, that in the past three months the retailer has offered the sofa for sale at a price of $1399 for just two weeks. For the other 10 weeks, the sofa was offered at $599. So, $599 is actually the price usually charged for the product.
This “most regular” price would be posted alongside the other two prices as a legally required disclosure when a firm wishes to have a comparative price promotion.
That is:
Regular Price $1399
Sale Price $599
True Normal Price $599*
*Legal Disclosure. True Normal Price = the price most often charged by this retailer in the past three months.
The leads to a question: Does providing TNP moderate the effect of a promoted Advertised Regular Price (ARP)? Urbany says, “We examine this question through a controlled experiment with 900 participants, where the participants’ choices in the study determined their total expected compensation. We find that the presence of an ARP with a sale price significantly raises the chance that a consumer will buy. However, adding TNP information drives out this effect of ARP.”
Our results support the premise that TNP provision would reduce or eliminate firms’ incentives to give anything but honest information to consumers in their price promotions and it would have an impact on average market prices, promotions, frequencies, and firm profits. We hope this study leads to a lively debate on the topic,” concludes Ngwe.
Full article and author contact information available at: https://doi.org/10.1177/00222429231164640
About the Journal of Marketing
The Journal of Marketing develops and disseminates knowledge about real-world marketing questions useful to scholars, educators, managers, policy makers, consumers, and other societal stakeholders around the world. Published by the American Marketing Association since its founding in 1936, JM has played a significant role in shaping the content and boundaries of the marketing discipline. Shrihari (Hari) Sridhar (Joe Foster ’56 Chair in Business Leadership, Professor of Marketing at Mays Business School, Texas A&M University) serves as the current Editor in Chief.
https://www.ama.org/jm
About the American Marketing Association (AMA)
As the largest chapter-based marketing association in the world, the AMA is trusted by marketing and sales professionals to help them discover what is coming next in the industry. The AMA has a community of local chapters in more than 70 cities and 350 college campuses throughout North America. The AMA is home to award-winning content, PCM® professional certification, premiere academic journals, and industry-leading training events and conferences.
https://www.ama.org
END
How to protect consumers from deceptive comparison pricing
News from the Journal of Marketing
2023-05-03
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Astronomers find distant gas clouds with leftovers of the first stars
2023-05-03
Using ESO’s Very Large Telescope (VLT), researchers have found for the first time the fingerprints left by the explosion of the first stars in the Universe. They detected three distant gas clouds whose chemical composition matches what we expect from the first stellar explosions. These findings bring us one step closer to understanding the nature of the first stars that formed after the Big Bang.
“For the first time ever, we were able to identify the chemical traces of the explosions of the first stars in very distant ...
Sleep phase can reduce anxiety in people with PTSD
2023-05-03
A new study shows that sleep spindles, brief bursts of brain activity occurring during one phase of sleep and captured by EEG, may regulate anxiety in people with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
The study shines a light on the role of spindles in alleviating anxiety in PTSD as well as confirms their established role in the transfer of new information to longer-term memory storage. The findings challenge recent work by other researchers that has indicated spindles may heighten intrusive and violent thoughts in people with PTSD.
The final draft of the preprint publishes in Biological Psychiatry: Cognitive Neuroscience and Neuroimaging on ...
New investigators join Stowers Institute for Medical Research
2023-05-03
KANSAS CITY, MO—May 3, 2023—The Stowers Institute for Medical Research announced the hiring of three principal investigators to further expand its team of scientists who seek to answer life’s biggest mysteries through foundational research. Siva Sankari, Ph.D., from Massachusetts Institute for Technology, Neşet Özel, Ph.D., from New York University, and Ameya Mashruwala, Ph.D., from Princeton University, will join the Institute’s current team of 17 principal investigators and staff of 500. The addition of these scientists ...
The biophysicist names Padmini Rangamani as new Editor-in-Chief
2023-05-03
ROCKVILLE, MD – The Biophysical Society is pleased to announce that Padmini Rangamani of the University of California, San Diego has been named as the new Editor-in-Chief of the The Biophysicsist, the Society’s open access education journal. The journal was developed under the leadership and vision of founding and current Editor-in-Chief, Sam Safran of the Weizmann Institute of Science in Rehovot, Israel, to highlight and nurture biophysics education and its scholarship and development.
“Now, more than ever, is the time for an education journal such as The Biophysicist to steer the ...
Gender gap found in research grant award amounts, re-applications
2023-05-03
VANCOUVER, Wash. – Women researchers received substantially less funding in grant awards than men—an average of about $342,000 compared to men’s $659,000, according to a large meta-analysis of studies on the topic.
Women were also less likely to receive second grants to continue their research. In first-time grant applications, proportional numbers of women and men scientists were approved for funding, but for re-applications, 9% fewer women who applied were approved than their male ...
Steep 66% drop in party registration with Automatic Voter Registration
2023-05-03
In 2016, Oregon became the first state to adopt and implement an Automatic Voter Registration (AVR) system. Now, twenty-two states, plus Washington D.C., have such systems in place. Early research on the impacts of this innovation has shown an increase in the number of people registered, and greater diversity among the registrants.
Now, a researcher using Oregon voter data has identified an unintended consequence of Automatic Voter Registration: a steep drop in party registration. These results have been published in the journal Electoral Studies ...
New insights into liver cancer using organoids
2023-05-03
PRESS RELEASE: PRINCESS MÁXIMA CENTER FOR PEDIATRIC ONCOLOGY
EMBARGO: WEDNESDAY 3 MAY 2023 AT 10:00AM BST (11:00AM CEST)
Scientists of the Princess Máxima Center for pediatric oncology and Hubrecht Institute in the Netherlands have revealed new scientific insights into the features of fibrolamellar carcinoma (FLC), a rare type of childhood liver cancer. Their findings, published today in Nature Communications, may help in developing new drug therapies in the future. Mini organs and the ‘molecular scissor’ system CRISPR-Cas9, allowed the researchers to better understand tumor biology and biological ...
Can low-carbohydrate or low-fat diets prolong life in middle-aged and older adults?
2023-05-03
Short-terms clinical trials have demonstrated the health benefits of low-carbohydrate diets (LCDs) and low-fat diets (LFDs) for weight loss and heart protection. Now a study published in the Journal of Internal Medicine looks at the effects of these diets on mortality in middle-aged and older adults.
In the study of 371,159 individuals aged 50 to 71 years, 165,698 deaths occurred over a median follow-up of 23.5 years.
A healthy LFD—characterized by low intake of saturated fat and high intakes of plant protein and high-quality carbohydrates—was related to fewer deaths from all causes, from cardiovascular diseases, and from cancers. In ...
Research reveals an increase in the range of invasive American mink in Europe
2023-05-03
The American mink Neogale vison is an invasive species in Europe introduced for fur farming in the 1920s and later established in the wild after escapes and illegal releases. As a feral species, it threatens native species and biodiversity, and poses a risk for boosting disease circulation, including mink-related strains of COVID-19. New research published in Mammal Review provides information on the presence of the species in Europe over the past 15 years.
The study, which was conducted by an international team of scientists, compiled a diverse set of data resources covering 32 nations. The work uncovers a progressive spread of the American mink in most ...
Can internet usage help protect against dementia?
2023-05-03
New research published in the Journal of the American Geriatrics Society found a link between regular use of the internet and a lower risk of dementia.
For the study, investigators followed 18,154 dementia-free adults aged 50 to 64.9 years for a median of 7.9 years and a maximum of 17.1 years. During follow-up, 4.68% of participants were diagnosed with dementia.
Regular internet usage was associated with approximately half the risk of dementia compared with non-regular usage. This link was found regardless of educational attainment, race-ethnicity, sex, and generation.
“Online engagement may help to develop and maintain cognitive reserve, which ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
New partnerships to provide travel grants, coursework in genomic approaches to infectious disease for underrepresented aspiring physicians
Off the clothesline, on the grid: MXene nanomaterials enable wireless charging in textiles
How COVID-19 transformed family dinners
New ESO image captures a dark wolf in the sky
New research reveals delayed evolutionary origin of Asteriidae sea stars
A paper-aluminum combo for strong, sustainable packaging
A novel neural network for preserving cultural heritage via 3D image reconstruction
Sleep apnea contributes to dementia in older adults, especially women
The silk thread that can turn clothes into charging stations
Glaucoma drug shows promise against neurodegenerative diseases, animal studies suggest
Human proteins identified that explain inter-individual differences in functional brain connectivity
A newly developed algorithm shows how a gene is expressed at microscopic resolution
Why elephants never forget but fleas have, well, the attention span of a flea
Childhood neglect associated with stroke, COPD, cognitive impairment, and depression
Landmark 20-year study of climate change impact on permafrost forests
Researchers take broadband high-resolution frequency combs into the UV
Not going out is the “new normal” post-Covid, say experts
Study shows broader screening methods help prevent spread of dangerous fungal pathogen in hospitals
Research spotlight: Testing a model for depression care in Malawi using existing medical infrastructure
Depression care in low-income nations can improve overall health
The BMJ investigates dispute over US group’s involvement in WHO’s trans health guideline
Personal info and privacy control may be key to better visits with AI doctors
NIH study demonstrates long-term benefits of weight-loss surgery in young people
Sustained remission of diabetes and other obesity-related conditions found a decade after weight loss surgery in adolescence
Low-level lead poisoning is still pervasive in the US and globally
How researchers can maximize biological insights using animal-tracking devices
Research shows new method helps doctors safely remove dangerous heart infections without surgery
Rapid horizontal eye movement can improve stability in people with Parkinson’s
Study finds COVID-19 pandemic worsened patient safety measures
Costs still on the rise for drugs for neurological diseases
[Press-News.org] How to protect consumers from deceptive comparison pricingNews from the Journal of Marketing