Blinding idea evaluation? New experiment reveals little bias in the innovation process
2023-05-19
(Press-News.org)
Innovation and implementation of new ideas can directly influence organizational outcomes. Thus, organizations often dedicate significant time to the assessment of countless new ideas through myriad idea evaluation systems. However, the evaluation process is often distorted by various biases arising from hierarchy, sequence, and nepotism. Data on evaluation studies show that evaluators can be biased toward specific idea proposers.
In a new study published in the Strategic Management Journal, a research team sought evidence for the bias claim by employing a blinding approach for evaluating ideas and diagnosing biases in the process. The study focused on three potential biases. It tested whether lower evaluations are given to ideas coming from: (1) female idea proposers; (2) idea proposers from other office units; and (3) idea proposers from other locations.
Authors Linus Dahlander, Arne Thomas, Martin W. Wallin, and Rebecka C. Angstrom conducted a field experiment at a top multinational technology corporation. Innovation managers were asked to evaluate 48 random ideas from the company’s idea management system, doing both blind and non-blind evaluations. While the managers received no information about the idea proposer during blind evaluations, they were provided with the proposer’s name, unit, and location in the non-blind evaluations.
Much to their own surprise, the researchers could not find bias in idea evaluation due to gender, location, or organizational structure. This shows that evaluators separate ideas from proposers, and hiding the identity of idea proposers from evaluators might not necessarily improve idea evaluation.
“A follow-up online experiment with a larger sample size and more statistical capacity replicated the results of the field experiment. Moreover, an additional study showed that people overestimated the magnitude of the biases,” Dr. Thomas said.
The Strategic Management Journal, published by the Strategic Management Society, is the world’s leading mass impact journal for research in strategic management.
END
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
2023-05-19
Key Takeaways
Researchers have discovered that stimulating cells’ DNA repair mechanisms may correct the inherited genetic defect that defines fragile X syndrome, a leading cause of autism spectrum disorders.
The method involves enhanced production of special nucleic acid structures called “R-loops” that cells see as DNA damage.
BOSTON – New research has identified a potential method for treating fragile X syndrome, a leading cause of autism spectrum disorders that is characterized ...
2023-05-19
Evidence indicates a thick ice sheet, not annual sea ice and icebergs, covered the Arctic Ocean at some point during the last 140,000 years. Now, University of Alaska Fairbanks scientists will be looking for more geologic proof of the ice sheet’s existence, sources, behavior and extent.
UAF Geophysical Institute scientists will focus on the Beaufort and Chukchi seas region, both offshore and onshore.
They hope to discover the extent of glaciation and improve understanding of the timing of glacial advances and retreats. Those cycles are thought to have occurred approximately 140,000 to 70,000 years ago, a period known as the ...
2023-05-19
ITHACA, N.Y. -- Humidity is as important as scent in attracting pollinators to a plant, new Cornell-led research finds, advancing basic biology and opening new avenues to support agriculture.
In a study published May 7 in Current Biology, a team of Cornell researchers and colleagues at Harvard University and the Montgomery Botanical Center found that the weevil responsible for pollinating the plant Zamia furfuracea was just as sensitive to humidity as to scent.
“The world of plant-insect interactions was drastically changed by the work that was done on visual and scent cues,” ...
2023-05-19
In a new study published in eLife, lead author Carolyn Elya, postdoctoral researcher in the Department of Organismic and Evolutionary Biology at Harvard, reveals the molecular and cellular underpinnings behind the parasitic fungus, Entomophthora muscae’s (E. muscae), ability to manipulate the behavior of fruit flies.
Elya first described the manipulated behavior, called summiting, in a study published in eLife in 2018. Elya, who was studying microbes carried by fruit flies while a graduate student ...
2023-05-19
PHOENIX, AZ (May 19, 2023) – The latest analysis from The North American COVID-19 STEMI (NACMI) was presented today as late-breaking clinical research at the Society for Cardiovascular Angiography & Interventions (SCAI) 2023 Scientific Sessions. The findings show patients with an ST-elevated myocardial infarction, or STEMI, and COVID-19 had a significant amount of clotting in their arteries both before and after intervention. Importantly, clots were seen in multiple arteries in close to 30% of patients, a phenomenon observed in less than 5% of patients with heart attacks who do not ...
2023-05-19
The course of human history has been marked by complex patterns of migration, isolation, and admixture, the latter a term that refers to gene flow between individuals from different populations. Admixture results in a blending of genetic lineages, leading to increased genetic diversity within populations. In addition to admixture among modern human populations, ancient humans reproduced with other hominin groups, such as Neanderthals and Denisovans. This resulted in fragments of DNA from these ancient lineages being passed down to modern humans in a process known as introgression. Two ...
2023-05-19
WASHINGTON, May 19, 2023 — Chemical & Engineering News (C&EN), an independent news outlet of the American Chemical Society (ACS), has unveiled its annual “Talented 12” list. The list highlights early-career researchers in the chemical sciences who are fearlessly tackling difficult global problems. These intrepid innovators in chemistry are featured in the May 19 issue of C&EN; read about the impressive class by visiting https://cenm.ag/t12-2023.
Using a rigorous review process, C&EN selected this year’s Talented 12 from a highly competitive pool. The world-changing work by this year’s group includes research with ...
2023-05-19
HOUSTON – (May 19, 2023) – Rice University chemist Raúl Hernández Sánchez is one of 12 early-career scientists named to C&EN’s 2023 Talented 12 cohort for his research in inorganic and supramolecular chemistry.
Awardees are scientists engaged in world-changing work who are at an early stage in their career – pre-tenure if working in academia and 10 years or less from the completion of their postdoctoral studies if working in industry or government. The members of this year’s C&EN ...
2023-05-19
BOSTON – The Bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) vaccine—which prevents tuberculosis—offers multiple beneficial effects, and it’s currently a recommended therapy for non–muscle-invasive bladder cancer. In a new study led by investigators at Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) and Brigham and Women’s Hospital (BWH), treatment with the BCG vaccine was associated with a reduced risk of Alzheimer’s disease and related dementias. The findings are published in JAMA Network Open.
Although previous research has suggested a link between the BCG vaccine and a lower risk of dementia, studies were limited by size, study design, ...
2023-05-19
Reforms to New Jersey’s Medicaid program successfully spurred ongoing increases in buprenorphine prescriptions for the treatment of opioid addiction, according to a Rutgers analysis.
Although medications such as buprenorphine effectively combat opioid addiction, less than 30 percent of potential users receive them nationwide. New Jersey sought to increase prescription numbers with three Medicaid reforms that took effect in 2019. The reforms:
Removed prior authorization requirements for buprenorphine prescriptions
Increased reimbursement rates for in-office opioid addiction treatment
Established regional centers of excellence for addiction ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
[Press-News.org] Blinding idea evaluation? New experiment reveals little bias in the innovation process
