(Press-News.org) Copenhagen, Denmark: Women are just as likely to give birth to live babies after fertility treatment if embryos are transferred to their wombs three days after fertilisation in the laboratory rather than five. However, the women’s age can affect the outcomes, according to new research presented to the 39th annual meeting of the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology (ESHRE) [1].
Dr Simone Cornelisse, a researcher and resident in obstetrics and gynaecology at Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen (The Netherlands), told the conference that among 1202 women from 21 Dutch fertility centres who were randomly assigned to have embryos transferred to their wombs after three or five days, there was no difference in the cumulative live birth rate – the birth rate derived from transferring fresh and frozen embryos following a single round of egg retrieval.
Until now, there has been no evidence about whether the cumulative live birth rate differed depending on how long embryos were cultured in the laboratory before being transferred to the womb. There has been a trend among fertility centres towards transferring embryos when they have reached the blastocyst stage (after five days) rather than the cleavage stage (after three days). It was thought that it was easier to select the most viable embryos if they had reached the blastocyst stage. It was also thought that the womb was more receptive after five days. However, culturing embryos for longer outside the womb carries risks, and the effects on the offspring in later life are still unclear.
The study presented today is the first large randomised controlled trial to provide ‘gold standard’ evidence focusing on the outcome that parents care most about: will it result in the birth of a live baby?
Dr Cornelisse said: “Most studies have focused on the outcome of transferring fresh embryos, but they do not have data on the cumulative live birth rate of all transfers from one egg collection, including embryos that have been frozen and stored for later use. Therefore, it is still not clear whether patients benefit from the recent change of policy to blastocyst-stage transfers. The cumulative live birth rate is undoubtedly the most relevant outcome for parents, and for researchers who are evaluating the success of IVF programmes.”
Among 603 women who had blastocyst-stage embryos transferred, the cumulative live birth rate was 58.9% (355 live births). If cleavage-stage embryos were transferred, the live birth rate was 58.4% (350 live births out of a total of 599 women). There was no difference in the time it took women to achieve a pregnancy that resulted in a live birth.
The women all had good prognoses, which was defined as having at least four embryos available to be transferred after two days of culturing in the laboratory.
The researchers also looked at the cumulative live birth rates by age, dividing the women into those aged younger than 36 and those who were 36 or older. “We found a potential benefit from transferring cleavage-stage embryos in women who were aged up to 36 years, but the difference was not statistically significant: a 67% cumulative live birth rate for cleavage-stage embryos compared to a 63% rate for blastocyst-stage embryos,” said Dr Cornelisse. “This was in contrast to women aged 36 years or older, in whom we found a potential, but not statistically significant benefit from transferring blastocyst-stage embryos: a 52% cumulative live birth rate for these versus a 43% rate for cleavage-stage embryos.”
The researchers suggest that although some of these results are not statistically significant, they are still clinically significant. “If we look at this in a larger group of women, the results would probably reach statistical significance,” said Dr Cornelisse.
When the researchers looked at the live birth rate following the transfer of fresh embryos only, they found a significant difference in favour of blastocyst-stage transfer: 37% (223 live births among 603 women) compared to 29.5% (177 births among 599 women) for cleavage-stage embryos. Previous studies have also had similar results.
This difference was even more marked when they looked at the live birth rates by age. In women aged 36 years or older, the live birth rate was 35% for blastocyst-stage fresh embryos compared to 18.5% for cleavage-stage embryos (76 births among 215 women compared to 40 births among 216 women). For women aged younger than 36 years, the difference was not statistically significant: 38% for blastocyst-stage embryos versus 36% for cleavage-stage embryos (147 births among 388 women versus 137 births among 383 women).
“Our study shows that the cumulative live birth rate is similar between women who have embryos transferred at the blastocyst stage or the cleavage stage. However, clinicians and their patients should consider the effects of age,” said Dr Cornelisse.
“In women aged 36 years or older, with a good prognosis, we saw a clinically relevant higher cumulative live birth rate and live birth rate after transferring fresh embryos, when the embryos were transferred at the blastocyst stage. It is noteworthy that in younger women with a good prognosis, cleavage-stage transfer is a good strategy and just as successful as blastocyst-stage transfer.”
She concluded: “In assisted reproduction, many new developments and techniques are often introduced into clinical practice, as with blastocyst-stage transfers, with little or no evidence. Furthermore, the final benefit for the patients, data on cumulative live births, is often not reported. It is important that new fertility developments and treatments are first properly evaluated in clinical trials before being introduced into clinical practice, in order to allow clinics and patients to make a balanced choice based on solid data.”
Dr Cornelisse and her colleagues are now conducting a cost-benefit analysis of the study to see if one option is more cost effective than another and for which age groups. They will also analyse potential risks and the burden of treatment on patients.
The researchers emphasise that their findings are applicable only for women with good prognoses (at least four embryos available) and may not hold true for all women undergoing fertility treatment.
The chair of ESHRE, Professor Carlos Calhaz-Jorge from the Northern Lisbon Hospital Centre and the Hospital de Santa Maria in Lisbon (Portugal), was not involved in this research. He commented: “The results from this randomised controlled trial are very important and may have significant implications for patients. This study provides relevant data to support evidence-based decisions in an area where the current options lack some structured, long-term evidence. The current trend towards extending the time that embryos are cultured in the laboratory has occurred without sufficient evidence to support it. The study by Dr Cornelisse and her colleagues shows that it may not always be the best strategy for all patients.
“It will be interesting to see the results from larger groups of patients, and also the cost-benefit analysis, when it may be possible to see the different effects of three-day and five-day transfers on patients, both financially and in terms of their mental and physical health.”
(ends)
[1] Presentation no: O-005, “The ToF-study – comparing the cumulative live birth rate of blastocyst-stage versus cleavage-stage embryo transfers in good prognosis IVF patients: a multicenter randomized controlled trial”, presented by Dr Simone Cornelisse et al, Session 02: New insights into embryo development, Hall A, 10.30 hrs CEST, Monday 26 June 2023.
Notes for editors
According to the UK Academy of Medical Science’s press release labelling system, this is a non-peer reviewed, randomised controlled trial in people.
Funding: This study was funded by LeadingtheChange/ZonMw and the Dutch Research Council.
When obtaining outside comment, journalists are requested to ensure that their contacts are aware of the embargo on this release.
For further information, contact:
Emma Mason
Email: wordmason@mac.com
Mobile: +44 (0)7711 296986
Kerry Noble
Email: kerry_noble@hotmail.com
Mobile: +44 (0)7446 869 433
Sophie Goodchild
Email: goodchildsophie@hotmail.com
Mobile: +44 (0)7767 325595
Laura Rossignoli at ESHRE
Email: Laura@eshre.eu
Mobile: +32 (0)499 92 32 49
The European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology (ESHRE) is a European non-profit organisation with international membership, whose main mission is to promote the study and research of reproductive science and medicine as well as the treatment of infertility. Established in 1984, the Society now comprises more than 9.000 members and has become the leading Society in reproductive science and medicine worldwide. Our members are medical professionals, scientists and researchers working in reproductive science, reproductive medicine and embryology. We work in close partnership with the patient organisation Fertility Europe. The ESHRE annual meeting attracts over 11,000 clinicians, researchers, scientists, exhibitors. In 2022, participants from 130 countries attended. Seven of the top ten countries represented were European.
END
Are more babies born if embryos are cultured for three or five days in the lab? Largest randomised clinical trial to date suggests that age matters
2023-06-26
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Cancer risk among women with polycystic ovary syndrome doubles after menopause
2023-06-26
Copenhagen, Denmark: Women with polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) are not at any greater risk of ovarian cancer than those without the common hormone condition, say researchers. However, those with PCOS who have been through the menopause are more than twice as likely to be diagnosed with ovarian cancer.
The data based on nearly two million women is presented today (Monday) at the 39th annual meeting of the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology (ESHRE) [1]. The research is also published simultaneously in the International Journal of Cancer [2].
This ...
Humans’ evolutionary relatives butchered one another 1.45 million years ago
2023-06-26
Researchers from the Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History have identified the oldest decisive evidence of humans’ close evolutionary relatives butchering and likely eating one another.
In a new study published today, June 26, in Scientific Reports, National Museum of Natural History paleoanthropologist Briana Pobiner and her co-authors describe nine cut marks on a 1.45 million-year-old left shin bone from a relative of Homo sapiens found in northern Kenya. Analysis of 3D models of the fossil’s surface revealed ...
Childhood cancer: Vulnerability in the immune response against metastases discovered
2023-06-26
Scientists led by Sabine Taschner-Mandl, PhD, St. Anna Children's Cancer Research Institute, and Nikolaus Fortelny, PhD, Paris Lodron University of Salzburg, are the first to analyze bone marrow metastases from childhood tumors of the nervous system using modern single-cell sequencing analysis. It turns out that cancer cells prevent cells in their environment from fighting the tumor – a process that could be reversed with medication. The findings were published in the renowned journal Nature Communications.
Neuroblastoma is the most ...
Novel study deepens knowledge of treatment-resistant hypertension
2023-06-26
For many patients with hypertension—an elevated blood pressure that can lead to stroke or heart attack—medication keeps the condition at bay. But what happens when medication that physicians usually prescribe doesn’t work? Known as apparent resistant hypertension (aRH), this form of high blood pressure requires more medication and medical management.
Novel research from investigators in the Smidt Heart Institute at Cedars-Sinai, published today in the peer-reviewed journal Hypertension, found that aRH prevalence was lower in ...
Progesterone decreases night sweats & improves sleep in perimenopausal women
2023-06-26
New controlled trial research documents that Progesterone (micronized, oral) is effective at decreasing night sweats and improving sleep in perimenopausal women who have menstruated in the last 1-year. Perimenopausal women most want treatment for these two symptoms.
Current guidelines prescribe Menopausal Hormone Therapy (MHT) for disturbing hot flushes/flashes or night sweats (vasomotor symptoms, VMS) in all women younger than 60 years.
“This guideline assumes that hormone levels and symptoms are the same in the early years of ...
What are the endometrial cancer risks and trends among different African descent populations?
2023-06-26
Study reveals some distinctions between Black women in the US and the French Caribbean but increasing trends for aggressive forms in both regions.
Compared with white women, Black women have elevated risks of being diagnosed with advanced uterine cancer—also known as endometrial cancer—and of developing aggressive tumors. Researchers recently compared the incidence and trends for endometrial cancer, both overall and by subtype, between African descent women in Florida and women in the French Caribbean—specifically, the islands of Martinique and Guadeloupe. The findings are published by Wiley online ...
Endometrial cancer risk and trends among distinct African-descent populations
2023-06-26
MIAMI, FLORIDA (EMBARGOED UNTIL 3:01 AM ET Monday, June 26, 2023) – Current evidence indicates Black women in the U.S. are at greater risk of developing advanced uterine cancer, also known as endometrial cancer, and of developing its more aggressive form – non-endometroid cancer – than white women.
But research to date has mostly studied Black women as a homogenous group, and there is limited data about specific African-descent subpopulations worldwide. That is until now.
A new study by researchers with Sylvester Comprehensive Cancer Center and the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine compared both the overall incidence and trends for endometrial ...
New Orleans infection preventionists adapt adult protocols to reduce infections in babies
2023-06-26
Orlando, Fla., June 26, 2023 – Facing persistent cases of hospital-onset Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) during the pandemic, the infection prevention and control (IPC) team at Children’s Hospital New Orleans developed an inexpensive nasal decolonization regimen previously used only in their adult patients that decreased rates of MRSA by 50 percent. Their results are being presented at the Association for Professionals in Infection Control and Epidemiology’s (APIC’s) Annual Conference in Orlando Florida, June 26-28.
Without a lot of scientific literature on nasal decolonization in the pediatric population to guide them, Infection Preventionist ...
Neurosurgical infections drop more than 80% in two years at Pittsburgh hospital
2023-06-26
Neurosurgical Infections Drop More Than 80% in Two Years at Pittsburgh Hospital
Readmissions, patient satisfaction scores improve through infection preventionist-led, multidisciplinary collaboration
Orlando, Fla. June 26, 2023 – When excess surgical site infections (SSIs) were detected among neurosurgery patients at University of Pittsburgh Medical Center (UPMC) Mercy in 2019, infection preventionist Katie Palladino, MPH, CPH, CIC, partnered with a hospital neurosurgeon on a multidisciplinary quality and process improvement initiative that ...
Collect race, Indigenous identity on health card renewal to address health inequities
2023-06-26
To address health inequities that Indigenous and racialized patients can experience, collect data on racial and Indigenous identity at health card application and renewal, suggests a group of authors in CMAJ (Canadian Medical Association Journal) https://www.cmaj.ca/lookup/doi/10.1503/cmaj.221587.
"Although race is a social construct that uses perceived physical differences to create and maintain power differentials and the existence of discrete racial groups has not been shown to have any biological basis, perceived race influences how people are treated by individuals and institutions," ...