Great British Bake Off Christmas desserts not as naughty as you may think

Analysis suggests a guilt-free Christmas is possible (if concerns about observational nutrition research can be set aside)

2023-12-21

(Press-News.org) Christmas desserts from The Great British Bake Off are more likely to use ingredients that are associated with reductions, rather than increases, in the risk of death or disease, suggests research published in the Christmas issue of The BMJ.

As the holiday season approaches, the age-old debate resurfaces: can we indulge in Christmas desserts without feeling the pang of guilt? Can we look past the negative headlines of what butter and sugar do to our bodies, and enjoy a piece of Christmas cake in heavenly peace?

To answer this Christmas conundrum, researchers set out to determine the health benefits and harms of various ingredients in festive desserts from The Great British Bake Off, a show which the team believe is “the greatest television baking competition of all time.”

They said “bah Humbug” to the design flaws of nutritional observational research and conducted an umbrella review of umbrella reviews of meta-analyses of observational studies evaluating the associations between ingredients in 48 Christmas dessert recipes on the Great British Bake Off website (cakes, biscuits, pastries, puddings and desserts) and the risks of dying or developing various diseases.

Umbrella reviews synthesise previous meta-analyses and provide a high-level summary of evidence on a particular topic.

From each recipe, they recorded the ingredients and put them into 17 groups: baking soda, powder, and other ingredients; butter; chocolate; cheese and yogurt; coffee; eggs; food colouring, flavourings, and extracts; fruit; milk; nuts (general or tree, excluding peanuts); peanuts or peanut butter; refined flour; salt; spices; sugar; and vegetable fat.

The team conducted a comprehensive literature search, screened 7008 records, and ultimately identified 46 umbrella reviews that evaluated the associations between these ingredients and the risks of dying or developing various diseases.

They found 363 associations between ingredients and risk of death or disease, of which 149 were statistically significant, including 110 (74%) that estimated that the ingredient groups reduced the risk of death or disease and 39 (26%) that increased the risk.

The most common ingredient groups associated with a reduced risk of death or disease were fruit (44 of 110, 40%), coffee (17 of 110, 16%), and nuts (14 of 110, 13%).

Sadly, for Prue Leith (the Great British Bake Off judge who enjoys a spot of alcohol in her bakes), alcohol (20 of 39, 51%) was the most common ingredient group associated with increased risk of death or disease, alongside sugar (5 of 39, 13%).

Alcohol was also associated with an increased risk of developing colon cancer, gastric cancer, gout, and irregular heart rate (atrial fibrillation). The researchers suggest that Prue’s chocolate yule log may not be the ideal Christmas dessert because it is described as being “subtly laced with Irish cream to add to the festive spirit.”

However, the researchers identified Paul Hollywood’s Stollen as a potential option, with 82 significant associations, of which 70 suggested the ingredient groups decreased the risk of disease. The recipe contained ingredients such as almonds, milk and dried fruits and “overall, without the eggs, butter and sugar, this dessert is essentially a fruit salad with nuts. Yum!”, the researchers say.

The researchers point to several limitations. For example, the study relies on evidence from observational studies, which have inherent limitations that are difficult or impossible to address, focuses on specific ingredient groups rather than broader dietary exposures, and did not capture all ingredients in these Christmas desserts, such as food colouring.

What’s more, they did not account for the amount of each ingredient in the recipes, admitting that “any recipe with fruit, even if it was only one berry, was weighted equally in terms of its protective effect in relation to the harmful effect of butter.” They acknowledge that a weighted analysis “would have been informative, but less fun.”

Nevertheless, they conclude that “this Christmas, if concerns about the limitations of observational nutrition research can be set aside, we are pleased to report that everyone can have their cake and eat it too.”

END

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Spike in morning after pill sales in the U.S. after New Year celebrations

2023-12-21

Sales of emergency contraception are estimated to rise by around 10% in the US in the week after the New Year holiday, suggesting that this period is associated with increased risks of unprotected sex compared with other holidays, finds a study published in the Christmas issue of The BMJ. Other holidays such as Valentine’s Day and Independence Day were also associated with an increase in sales, but to a lesser extent. Although this annual spike in sales might seem humorous, the researchers point out that as many US states have increased restrictions on abortion ...

The evolutionary timeline of diminished boric acid and urea transportation in aquaporin 10

2023-12-21

Aquaporin (Aqp) 10 water channels in humans allow the free passage of water, glycerol, urea, and boric acid across cells. However, Aqp10.2b in pufferfishes allows only the passage of water and glycerol and not urea and boric acid. Researchers from the Tokyo Institute of Technology sought to understand the evolutionary timeline that resulted in the variable substrate selection mechanisms among Aqp10s. Their results indicate that Aqp10.2 in ray-finned fishes may have reduced or lost urea and boric acid permeabilities through evolution. Aquaporins ...

Wildflowers increasingly doing without insect pollinators

2023-12-21

Scientists at the CNRS and the University of Montpellier1 have discovered that flowering plants growing in farmland are increasingly doing without insect pollinators. As reproduction becomes more difficult for them in an environment depleted in pollinating insects, the plants are evolving towards self-fertilisation. These findings are published in a paper in the journal New Phytologist dated December 20, 2023. By comparing field pansies growing in the Paris region today with pansies from the same localities resurrected in the laboratory from seeds collected2 between 1992 and 2001, the research team found that today's flowers are 10% smaller, produce 20% less nectar, and are less ...

Blue PHOLEDs: Final color of efficient OLEDs finally viable in lighting

2023-12-21

Dec. 20, 2023 Contact: Derek Smith, 734-546-3632, smitdere@umich.edu; Nicole Casal Moore, 734-709-1651, ncmoore@umich.edu ANN ARBOR—Lights could soon use the full color suite of perfectly efficient organic light-emitting diodes, or OLEDs, that last tens of thousands of hours, thanks to an innovation from physicists and engineers at the University of Michigan. The U-M team's new phosphorescent OLEDs, commonly referred to as PHOLEDs, can maintain 90% of the blue light intensity for 10-14 times longer than other designs that emit similar deep blue colors. That kind ...

Multitasking microbes: UW–Madison scientists engineer bacteria to make two valuable products from plant fiber

2023-12-20

We often look to the smallest lifeforms for help solving the biggest problems: Microbes help make foods and beverages, cure diseases, treat waste and even clean up pollution. Yeast and bacteria can also convert plant sugars into biofuels and chemicals traditionally derived from fossil fuels — a key component of most plans to slow climate change. Now University of Wisconsin–Madison researchers have engineered bacteria that can produce two chemical products at the same time from underutilized plant fiber. And unlike humans, these ...

And now, your community health forecast…

2023-12-20

In the not-so-distant future, people might be able to tune in to their favorite news source for an update on their community health status, just as they check on the local weather forecast. The community health status is similar to the color-coded Doppler weather data that provides meteorologists with information about rain, snow or hail, its motion and intensity, which they can use to determine specific areas where dangerous weather conditions exist. Having this information has proven to be a valuable tool to protect life and property. “The new community ...

A framework in your brain for organising the order of things

2023-12-20

Scientists at NTNU’s Kavli Institute for Systems Neuroscience in Norway have discovered a pattern of activity in the brain that can serve as a template for building sequential experiences. “I believe we have found one of the brain’s prototypes for building sequences” says Professor Edvard Moser.He describes the activity pattern as “a fundamental algorithm that is intrinsic to the brain and independent of experience.” The breakthrough discovery was published in Nature 20. December 2023. The ability to organise elements into sequences ...

Benidipine calcium channel blocker improves cigarette smoke-induced lung emphysema

2023-12-20

A new research paper was published in Aging (listed by MEDLINE/PubMed as "Aging (Albany NY)" and "Aging-US" by Web of Science) Volume 15, Issue 23, entitled, “Benidipine calcium channel blocker promotes the death of cigarette smoke-induced senescent cells and improves lung emphysema.” Smoking is the main risk factor for many lung diseases including chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Cigarette smoke (CS) contains carcinogenic and reactive oxygen species that favor DNA mutations and perturb the homeostasis and environment of cells. CS induces lung cell senescence resulting in a stable proliferation arrest and a senescence-associated ...

Researchers uncover on/off switch for breast cancer metastasis

2023-12-20

Despite their promise, immunotherapies fail to treat many cancers, including over 80% of some of the most advanced breast cancers. And many of those patients who do respond still experience metastases eventually. New research from Stanford University and the Arc Institute has revealed a better way to predict and improve patient responses. A team led by Lingyin Li, associate professor of biochemistry at Stanford and Arc Core Investigator, found that a protein called ENPP1 acts as an on/off switch that controls breast cancer’s ability to both resist immunotherapy and metastasize. The study, published on ...

Tracking roadway savings from coast to coast

2023-12-20

Oak Ridge National Laboratory researchers have identified the most energy-efficient 2024 model year vehicles available in the United States, including electric and hybrids, in the latest edition of the Department of Energy’s Fuel Economy Guide. The annual online resource compares fuel costs for two-seaters up to large sedans, small and midsize station wagons, minivans, small and standard sport utility vehicles and small and standard pickup trucks. A quick reference top 10 list is searchable for make, model and class, too. “With the national average of gasoline over $3 per gallon, drivers need to know how much they can save by ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Deforestation in the Amazon raises the surface temperature by 3 °C during the dry season

Model more accurately maps the impact of frost on corn crops

How did humans develop sharp vision? Lab-grown retinas show likely answer

Sour grapes? Taste, experience of sour foods depends on individual consumer

At AAAS, professor Krystal Tsosie argues the future of science must be Indigenous-led

From the lab to the living room: Decoding Parkinson’s patients movements in the real world

Research advances in porous materials, as highlighted in the 2025 Nobel Prize in Chemistry

Sally C. Morton, executive vice president of ASU Knowledge Enterprise, presents a bold and practical framework for moving research from discovery to real-world impact