(Press-News.org) Mental illness is a major public health issue. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, more than 20% of U.S. adults live with a mental illness, like depression and anxiety. For perspective, this is more than all adults with coronary heart disease (5%) and diabetes (14.7%) combined. Yet, understanding and addressing mental illness remains very challenging.
A team of UC Davis experts were tasked with evaluating the services of 15 mental health crisis programs in California. These programs designed for adult and transitional age youth (ages 16-25) were funded between 2018 and 2021 by state mental health legislation called SB-82.
The goal of the evaluation was to draw lessons learned from investing in these programs that could help inform crisis intervention development in California.
The team interviewed program providers, users of mental health services and law enforcement officers. They also reviewed grant proposals, census data and agreements with community partner, and conducted two surveys with grant recipients. They presented their report to the Mental Health Services Oversight and Accountability Commission.
Their evaluation highlighted ways to promote better mental health crisis management in California and the need for consistent funding and community engagement.
Diversity of mental health services and infrastructure
Over $33 million was distributed to 15 recipients to fund programs for adult and transitional age youth. The report showed that 14 of the 15 programs provided a total of 81,643 services from the start of funding through December 21, 2021. These services were offered during 23,485 encounters with 17,408 individual clients. The services fit into four main categories:
1) prevention
2) crisis access and lifeline
3) mobile crisis assessment and triage
4) post-crisis follow-up
Some of the benefits of delivering these services included less psychiatric hospitalizations and involuntary holds, referrals to psychiatric hospitals from the emergency department, and law enforcement involvement in crisis care.
The programs operated in very diverse counties in terms of infrastructure and geography. For example, the population size ranged from 45,670 in Calaveras County to 10.2 million in Los Angeles County. This diversity led to a variety of services provided.
“What works in one county may not be suitable for another. Flexibility and understanding that a small rural county may have very different needs than a large urban county is a really important starting place for allocating funds,” said co-lead author Joy Melnikow, a professor emeritus of family and community medicine.
The researchers found that giving programs flexibility in how they used the funds was critical. Much of the money was used on triage, mobile crisis assessment and following up with individuals after a crisis.
They also found that it was important for programs to offer extended hours.
“A lot of the crisis events we see are late nights and weekends and when these crisis services aren't here, that falls on emergency departments and law enforcement officers afterwards, neither of which is necessarily better to deal with that,” said co-lead author Mark Savill, assistant professor in the Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences.
The report highlighted the role of community partnerships and the need for crisis services and law enforcement coordination.
“Every law enforcement officer we interviewed was incredibly supportive and recognized the real key impact of having mental health professionals in this crisis space. A lot of these officers’ time went into engaging in crisis care interactions. They don't have the adequate training and resources to deal with such situations. Having an allyship with these programs was critical to better serving the public they're engaging with,” Savill said.
The need for long-term support and a continuum of care
The report also showed that the funding enabled counties to develop new and useful strategies and collaborations. Some of these efforts allowed for much-needed longer term follow up.
“When we spoke to providers, family members and key partners, we were really hearing how it's critical to think about supporting that transition towards longer term recovery, so they don't have another crisis,” Savill said.
According to the report, looking into where the money was spent could point to the gaps in the system.
“By following the money, we identified where the gaps in the system tend to be at this point,” said Cameron Carter, co-lead author on the report and chair of the Department of Psychiatry and Human Behavior at the University of California, Irvine. “The need is really in preventing future crises, getting people out of that crisis cycle by having them linked to ongoing care. Clients shared how some services were transformative in their lives, such as having that support afterward and some continuity of someone to speak to.”
He noted that there is a revolving door phenomenon where clients cycle through the system and eventually lose trust in finding help.
“A lot of the services that were delivered related to follow up. I think the reason for that was a gap in the system. You have to link people with follow up care and help support them so that the things that precipitated the initial crisis don't just keep repeating themselves,” Melnikow commented.
The need for a sustainable funding strategy to support mental health programs
A major issue for program planning was the inconsistent funding.
“As you identify things that work, how do we shift from a cyclic funding strategy?” Melnikow asked. “There should be a way to make successful programs more sustainable. It is hard to plan and build on success when the grant ends, and you have to find another source of funding. This is really important because that insecurity just doesn't allow counties to build systems that can be durable.”
Ideally, she said, there would be a coordinated policy that would be sustained over time.
Demanding job that needs support, recognition and promotion
Melnikow also raised the issue of appreciation and compensation for those working in the mental health field.
“It is important to recognize that this kind of crisis care is really demanding and hard on the people who deliver it. It's hard to find people who want to do it. They may not feel supported in what they're trying to do with the clients, making it difficult to recruit and retain staff.”
Mentoring and a career path for mental health crisis team members are also important.
“They're being asked to work under difficult conditions, after hours, in a mobile way. They need supervision and support. That's essential in all areas of mental health care, but the biggest is for those who are out in the field. They need a career path,” Carter explained. “They need to have a place in the system where they can do what they're doing but also develop and move on to more responsible, better compensated roles within the system.”
Other recommendations
The success of mental health crisis programs also depends on community organizations working together.
“It is critical to meet the people where they are. Working on mental health crises needs to be community based. You need to foster very strong links with your community. That includes the Sheriff's Department, law enforcement, housing, other mental health services, and charities. These community connections are critical to getting referrals in, providing effective care, and supporting longer-term recovery-oriented services later,” Savill explained.
About the Investment in Mental Health Wellness Act of 2013
The funds provided by the legislation were intended to improve access to and delivery of crisis triage services across California. These services focused on increasing capacity along the spectrum of care for mental crises. This included crisis prevention, intervention, stabilization, mobile crisis support and connection with post-crisis mental health services.
The goals of SB-82 are to:
- meet the needs of individuals in crisis in the least restrictive manner
- reduce the costs of avoidable emergency department use
- reduce law enforcement involvement
- reduce inpatient hospitalizations
Read the full final report and recommendations: California State Evaluation and Learning Support for SB-82 Triage Grants. (pdf)
UC Davis coauthors of this report are Bethney Bonilla-Herrera and Katrine Padilla of the Center for Healthcare Policy and Research and Jamie Mouzoon of the Behavioral Health Center of Excellence. Other coauthors are Lindsay Banks and Matthew L. Goldman.
END
Review of California's mental health crisis programs identified gaps and needs for consistent funding, community engagement
2024-03-19
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Disrupting Wnt signaling in the junctional epithelium stem cell niche causes periodontitis
2024-03-19
Alexandria, VA, USA – A study aiming to evaluate how biochemical inhibition of endogenous Wnt signaling affects barrier functions of the junctional epithelium was presented at the 102nd General Session of the IADR, which was held in conjunction with the 53rd Annual Meeting of the American Association for Dental, Oral, and Craniofacial Research and the 48th Annual Meeting of the Canadian Association for Dental Research, on March 13-16, 2024, in New Orleans, LA, USA.
The abstract, “Disrupting Wnt Signaling in the Junctional Epithelium ...
Targeting Extracellular Vesicles, organized by the World Mitochondria Society and the International Society of Microbiota, is scheduled for October 17-18, 2024 in Malta
2024-03-19
The World Mitochondria Society (WMS) and the International Society of Microbiota (ISM) are proud to announce their collaboration in organizing the inaugural Conference on Targeting Extracellular Vesicles, to be held on October 17-18, 2024, at Corinthia Palace in Malta.
This groundbreaking event will delve into the multifaceted roles of extracellular vesicles (EVs), particularly their interactions with mitochondria and microbiota, shaping the future of EV-based medicine.
The scientific board - composed of Ramaroson Andriantsitohaina, Marvin Edeas, Carla Lopes, Devika Manickam, Didier Serteyn, and Volkmar Weissig stated: “WMS and ISM will jointly spotlight EVs. Tailored discussions on ...
Icariin-releasing 3D-printed scaffolds for in situ regeneration of cleft bone
2024-03-19
Alexandria, VA, USA – A study exploring the potential of 3D-printed scaffolds with controlled delivery of small molecule, icariin (ICA), to promote cleft bone regeneration through recruitment and activation of endogenous stem/progenitor cells was presented at the 102nd General Session of the IADR, which was held in conjunction with the 53rd Annual Meeting of the American Association for Dental, Oral, and Craniofacial Research and the 48th Annual Meeting of the Canadian Association for ...
ChatGPT and large language models in dental education and research
2024-03-19
Alexandria, VA, USA – A Hands-on Workshop exploring the evidence and applications of Chat GPT in dental education was presented at the 102nd General Session of the IADR, which was held in conjunction with the 53rd Annual Meeting of the American Association for Dental, Oral, and Craniofacial Research and the 48th Annual Meeting of the Canadian Association for Dental Research, on March 13-16, 2024, in New Orleans, LA, USA.
The presenters discussed the evidence supporting the use of Chat GPT in health education and research, and examined its effectiveness in improving learning outcomes ...
New study finds significant differences in intimate partner violence injury patterns across age groups
2024-03-19
Intimate partner violence (IPV) disproportionately impacts women and younger populations, with incidences peaking between adolescence and young adulthood. Alarmingly, a strong correlation exists between IPV experienced in adolescence and its persistence into adulthood.
Radiologists can play a key role in identifying physical signs of IPV, since specific fracture patterns detected in imaging have been shown to be predictive of abuse in children and adults. However, limited information is available about injury patterns in IPV-exposed adolescents and emerging adults despite their vulnerability. In a recent study, researchers from Brigham and ...
In the fight against breast cancer, UMass Amherst researchers identify malignancy hibernation as the next battleground
2024-03-19
AMHERST, Mass. – There is a surprising dearth of research about how breast cancer cells can go dormant, spread and then resurface years or even decades later, according to a new review of in vitro breast cancer studies conducted by researchers at the University of Massachusetts Amherst.
“[Our review found that] less than 1% of all these studies that combine cells with designer environments look at dormancy,” says Shelly Peyton, Provost Professor of Chemical Engineering. “It’s ...
The heat index — how hot it really feels — is rising faster than temperature
2024-03-19
Texans have long endured scorching summer temperatures, so a global warming increase of about 3 degrees Fahrenheit (1.5 Celsius) might not sound like much to worry about.
But a new study concludes that the heat index — essentially how hot it really feels — has increased much faster in Texas than has the measured temperature: about three times faster.
That means that on some extreme days, what the temperature feels like is between 8 and 11 F (5 to 6 C) hotter than it would without climate change.
The study, using ...
Medications for Type 2 diabetes, weight loss & kidney health not always provided as needed
2024-03-19
Research Highlights:
Three independent, preliminary research studies have found that new Type 2 diabetes and weight-loss medications are often not prescribed or provided to patients as needed.
One study of adults who had insurance covering the cost of obesity medications found that their likelihood of being prescribed the medications differed based on racial, demographic and medical factors.
A second study determined that not all patients with Type 2 diabetes were equally likely to use the newest medications.
A ...
Study details effects of heat-related emergencies; vulnerable populations found to be most at risk
2024-03-19
Boston, MA – In the first national estimate of county-level disparities in heat-related emergencies, a new study led by investigators from the Harvard Pilgrim Health Care Institute found that vulnerable communities were at high risk.
The study, “County-Level Disparities in Heat-Related Emergencies,” was published in the March 19 edition of JAMA Network Open.
Climate change has led to significant heat waves with increasing frequency and intensity; the hottest on record occurred in July 2023. Prior studies have highlighted the role of extreme heat waves on significant health-related outcomes including cardiovascular and all-cause mortality ...
Research spotlight: Stem-immunity hubs associated with response to immunotherapy
2024-03-19
Jonathan Chen, MD, PhD, an investigator in the department of Pathology at Massachusetts General Hospital and Nir Hacohen, PhD, director of the Center of Cancer Immunology at Massachusetts General Hospital, are co-authors of a recently published study in Nature Immunology, Human Lung Cancer Harbors Spatially-organized Stem-immunity Hubs Associated with Response to Immunotherapy.
What Question Were You Investigating?
Multicellular networks are critical in mediating immune responses. How do immune cells organize within tumors to effectively eliminate malignant cells?
We recently reported the discovery of a network of immune cells ...