Anti-trust regulators should consider their options carefully when start-ups are acquired, new study suggests

Less blunt options than banning acquisitions may help preserve innovation and competition

2024-06-20

(Press-News.org) June 20, 2024

Anti-Trust Regulators Should Consider Their Options Carefully When Start-Ups are Acquired, New Study Suggests

Less Blunt Options than Banning Acquisitions May Help Preserve Innovation and Competition

Toronto - Promoting a competitive marketplace has been the main focus for regulators concerned with “killer acquisitions” -- when big companies swallow small startups to eliminate a potential rival.

But researchers and other observers point out that blocking these purchases puts something else important at risk – innovation. Startups are sometimes driven to come up with a new process or product precisely because they hope to be bought by a big player who will reward them handsomely for their work without having to bring it to market themselves.

“Banning these types of acquisitions may in turn lead to many startups not being there in the first place,” points out Regina Seibel, an assistant professor of economics analysis and policy at the University of Toronto’s Rotman School of Management.

That doesn’t mean the acquisitions field should be left wide open. To find out when and how innovation might be stifled through antitrust measures, Prof. Seibel and two other researchers created mathematical models using game theory to test how innovation is affected under a host of scenarios.

It turns out that innovation may be depressed when acquisitions are banned because there is a lower variety of projects, they found. Besides discouraging startups who want to be bought, larger companies are motivated to duplicate their innovation, since they can’t just buy it, instead of exclusively pursuing their own ideas.

But that’s only in general. Looking at particular cases, innovation can be minimally or even not affected by a ban. If the startup doesn’t have much bargaining power and won’t significantly profit from a buyout, a ban can boost competition with a small impact on innovation.

The same goes for blocking a larger company from buying a smaller one so it can commercialize the startup’s invention. If the creation is a potential blockbuster, the startup “can go on the market with very similar profits,” compared to what it would reap from being bought, Prof. Seibel says. In this case there may be even no impact on innovation whatsoever. And while killer acquisitions have received more attention, letting these so-called “genuine” acquisitions to go ahead unfettered can be even more problematic from a competition perspective, because they can allow big companies to get bigger, crowding out the space for future startups.

In the real world though, it’s tricky for regulators to know what’s going on in an acquisition deal. That’s why Prof. Seibel and her colleagues recommend regulators consider less blunt tools than outright bans. Taxing an acquisition reduces the profits that can be made by both sides “but it’s less extreme than completely shutting the acquisition down,” she says.

Subsidies can also be offered to startups who want to launch on the stock market, improving their profitability. “I think that’s a very attractive way to go forward to foster innovation and also decrease the rate of these acquisitions,” Prof. Seibel says.

The research was co-authored with Igor Letina of the University of Bern and the Centre for Economic Policy Research, and Armin Schmutzler of the University of Zurich and the Centre for Economic Policy Research. It will appear in the International Economic Review.

Bringing together high-impact faculty research and thought leadership on one searchable platform, the Rotman Insights Hub offers articles, podcasts, opinions, books and videos representing the latest in management thinking and providing insights into the key issues facing business and society. Visit www.rotman.utoronto.ca/insightshub.

The Rotman School of Management is part of the University of Toronto, a global centre of research and teaching excellence at the heart of Canada’s commercial capital. Rotman is a catalyst for transformative learning, insights and public engagement, bringing together diverse views and initiatives around a defining purpose: to create value for business and society. For more information, visit www.rotman.utoronto.ca

-30-

For more information:

Ken McGuffin

Manager, Media Relations

Rotman School of Management

University of Toronto

E-mail: mcguffin@rotman.utoronto.ca

END

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Family conditions may have more of an impact on upward social mobility than gender inequality

2024-06-20

Family conditions—specifically, how similar one’s social status and background is to one’s parents’ status—may play a bigger role in determining how easily an individual can shift into a wealthier socioeconomic class than gender inequality, according to a study of 153 countries published June 20, 2024 in the open-access journal PLOS ONE by Khanh Duong from Maynooth University, Ireland. As global inequality increases, researchers have found that countries with higher levels of income inequality tend to experience lower rates of class mobility (in other words, individuals in a lower socioeconomic ...

People with higher weight, and those who have high-quality experiences with higher-weight people, report less weight bias, per social psychology study of US adults

2024-06-20

People with higher weight, and those who have high-quality experiences with higher-weight people, report less weight bias, per social psychology study of US adults ### Article URL: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0305080 Article Title: The role of social norms, intergroup contact, and ingroup favoritism in weight stigma Author Countries: USA Funding: The authors received no specific funding for this work. END ...

In two separate clinical studies, combined immunotherapy approach enhances cancer patient response

2024-06-20

Because not all cancer patients respond to a leading type of cancer immunotherapy drug, known as an immune checkpoint inhibitor, scientists explored whether adding janus kinase (JAK) inhibitors – drugs that treat chronic inflammation – could help. In two separate clinical studies, researchers found that adding JAK inhibitors did improve patients’ responses to cancer checkpoint inhibitor immunotherapies. “Aside from the exciting findings of the early phase trials reported by [both groups], they provide a great deal of data with complex analyses of immune ...

Airborne mapping reveals roles for biogenic sources and temperature in air pollution emissions in Los Angeles

2024-06-20

Airborne observations over California have revealed that biogenic sources of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) – blooming trees and growing plants – dominate summertime air pollutant formation in Los Angeles, in a way that increases with temperature. Future air pollution regulations thus need to consider that only 40% of urban VOC emissions (those not tied to biogenic sources) can be mitigated through regulations, say the authors. Ambient air pollution – the fourth-leading global ...

Old bombs reveal new insights: Plants store more carbon, but for a shorter time frame, than we thought

2024-06-20

Analysis of radiocarbon produced during nuclear bomb testing in the 1960s suggests that current Earth system models underestimate carbon uptake into terrestrial vegetation and soils. But, say the study’s authors, this storage is more short-lived than previously thought. The findings suggest that anthropogenic carbon dioxide will not reside as long in the terrestrial biosphere as models currently predict. Accurate climate predictions, crucial for developing effective climate policies, require a robust representation of the global carbon cycle. It’s thought that vegetation and soils account for taking up approximately 30% of anthropogenic carbon dioxide (CO2) ...

The time it takes a person to decide can predict their preference

2024-06-20

Researchers led by Sophie Bavard at the University of Hamburg, Germany, found that people can infer hidden social preferences by observing how fast others make social decisions. Publishing June 20th in the open-access journal PLOS Biology, the study shows that when someone knows the options being considered by another person, and they know how long it takes them to reach their decisions, they can use this information to predict the other person’s preference, even if they do not know what the actual choices were. How do we know what someone’s social preferences ...

Hurricane changed ‘rules of the game’ in monkey society

2024-06-20

A devastating hurricane transformed a monkey society by changing the pros and cons of interacting with others, new research shows. Hurricane Maria hit Puerto Rico in 2017, killing more than 3,000 people. It also destroyed 63% of vegetation on Cayo Santiago (also known as Monkey Island), which is home to a population of rhesus macaques. Even now, tree cover remains far below pre-hurricane levels and – in this hot part of the world – that makes shade a scarce and precious resource for the macaques. The new study, led by the universities of Pennsylvania and Exeter and published in the journal Science, shows the storm ...

Researchers widely observe yet seldom publish about same-sex sexual behavior in primates and other mammals - often because it is perceived to be rare

2024-06-20

Researchers widely observe yet seldom publish about same-sex sexual behavior in primates and other mammals - often because it is perceived to be rare ### Article URL: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0304885 Article Title: Same-sex sexual behaviour among mammals is widely observed, yet seldomly reported: Evidence from an online expert survey Author Countries: Canada, USA Funding: The authors received no specific funding for this work. END ...

Wild chimpanzees seek out medicinal plants to treat illness and injuries

2024-06-20

Chimpanzees appear to consume plants with medicinal properties to treat their ailments, according to a study publishing on June 20 in the open-access journal PLOS ONE by Elodie Freymann from the University of Oxford, UK, and colleagues. Many plants produce compounds that have medicinal effects on humans and other animals. Wild chimpanzees eat a variety of plant matter, including some that is nutritionally poor but may treat or lessen the symptoms of illness. However, it is hard to determine whether chimpanzees self-medicate, by intentionally seeking out plants with properties that help their specific ailments, or passively consume plants ...

New catalyst unveils the hidden power of water for green hydrogen generation

2024-06-20

Hydrogen is a promising chemical and energy vector to decarbonize our society. Unlike conventional fuels, hydrogen utilization as a fuel does not generate carbon dioxide in return. Unfortunately, today, most of the hydrogen that is produced in our society comes from methane, a fossil fuel. It does so in a process (methane reforming) that leads to substantial carbon dioxide emissions. Therefore, the production of green hydrogen requires scalable alternatives to this process. Water electrolysis offers a path to generate green hydrogen which can be ...

Anti-trust regulators should consider their options carefully when start-ups are acquired, new study suggests

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES: