(Press-News.org) New York City's 2019 ride-hailing surcharge cut overall taxi and ride-share trips by 11 percent in Manhattan but failed to reduce traffic congestion, a key goal of the policy, according to a new NYU Tandon School of Engineering study published in Transportation Research Part A.
“While this surcharge differs from the MTA's proposed congestion pricing plan, the study's findings can contribute to the current discourse,” said Daniel Vignon – assistant professor of Civil and Urban Engineering (CUE) and member of C2SMARTER, a U.S. Department of Transportation Tier 1 University Transportation Center – who led the research with CUE PhD student Yanchao Li. “Indeed, the research reveals how pricing policies can disproportionately affect different communities and emphasizes that accessible transit alternatives play a crucial role in shaping how such policies impact travel behavior.”
Using a Difference-in-Differences framework - a statistical method that compares changes in outcomes between locations subject to a policy and those that are not - researchers isolated the impact of the $2.50 to $2.75 fee imposed below 96th Street by analyzing patterns both inside and outside the surcharge zone, while also comparing the same areas before and after the policy took effect.
"We were not necessarily surprised by the findings," explained Vignon. "The City claims that Uber, Lyft and taxis increase congestion, but we would say that they are not the major contributors," noting that research from other cities has also found ride-hailing services don't significantly contribute to traffic congestion. “In general, most cities experience a reduction in travel speed between 2% to 8% following the entry of Uber/Lyft.”
While traffic speeds remained virtually unchanged after the surcharge, Lyft experienced a 17 percent decrease in trips, and Uber and yellow cabs saw drops of 9 percent and 8 percent respectively, the research showed.
The policy's impact varied based on available transportation alternatives. Areas without subway or Citi Bike access saw only a 1.6 percent reduction in rides, while neighborhoods with both options experienced a 7.4 percent decrease. Areas with Citi Bike alone showed a 6.8 percent reduction.
The study revealed a complex relationship between income and transit access. Higher-income neighborhoods, despite typically having better transit options, showed minimal reduction in ride-hailing use. In contrast, lower-income areas saw sharp declines even though they often had fewer transit alternatives.
"When policymakers plan for any type of congestion pricing, it's critical they account for the alternative transportation options available at a granular level. A policy that works well in one neighborhood may impose a very high cost in areas where people live with far fewer resources and choices," said Vignon, noting that the street-hailing industry saw an 8 percent decrease in revenue after implementation. “It seems that this policy resulted in a net welfare loss for the city, at least in the shorter term, when considering all factors, such as abandoned rides and the decrease in driver revenues. In the longer term, to determine whether the policy is a net positive, one would have to account for how the collected fees are spent.”
This study is part of Vignon’s body of work examining how regulatory policies affect transportation systems. His research interests span ride-hailing regulations, autonomous vehicles, and infrastructure investment, analyzing how agencies can improve system performance while considering that users and transportation service providers will adapt their behavior based on policy changes.
The research also contributes to the portfolio of C2SMARTER, a consortium of seven universities led by NYU Tandon that is pursuing an ambitious research, education, training, and technology transfer program agenda to address the U.S. DOT priority area of Congestion Reduction. It received its most recent Tier 1 UTC designation in early 2023, providing it $15 million in funding for five years and extending its first such designation that came in 2016.
In this study, Vignon and Li analyzed over 300,000 ride-hailing records from NYC's Taxi and Limousine Commission, along with nearly 1 million traffic speed measurements from Uber Movement, incorporating data from Citi Bike, subway locations, household income statistics, and weather patterns.
About the New York University Tandon School of Engineering
The NYU Tandon School of Engineering is home to a community of renowned faculty, undergraduate and graduate students united in a mission to understand and create technology that powers cities, enables worldwide communication, fights climate change, and builds healthier, safer, and more equitable real and digital worlds. The school’s culture centers on encouraging rigorous, interdisciplinary collaboration and research; fostering inclusivity, entrepreneurial thinking, and diverse perspectives; and creating innovative and accessible pathways for lifelong learning in STEM. NYU Tandon dates back to 1854, the founding year of both the New York University School of Civil Engineering and Architecture and the Brooklyn Collegiate and Polytechnic Institute. Located in the heart of Brooklyn, NYU Tandon is a vital part of New York University and its unparalleled global network. For more information, visit engineering.nyu.edu.
END
NYC's ride-hailing fee failed to ease Manhattan traffic, new NYU Tandon study reveals
2024-11-13
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Meteorite contains evidence of liquid water on Mars 742 million years ago
2024-11-13
An asteroid struck Mars 11 million years ago and sent pieces of the red planet hurtling through space. One of these chunks of Mars eventually crashed into the Earth somewhere near Purdue and is one of the few meteorites that can be traced directly to Mars. This meteorite was rediscovered in a drawer at Purdue University in 1931 and therefore named the Lafayette Meteorite.
During early investigations of the Lafayette Meteorite, scientists discovered that it had interacted with liquid water while on Mars. Scientists have long wondered when that interaction with liquid water took place. ...
Self-reported screening helped reduce distressing symptoms for pediatric patients with cancer
2024-11-13
TORONTO – Regular, self-reported symptom screening was associated with reduced symptom burden when compared with usual care for pediatric patients with cancer, according to new research led by scientists at the University of Toronto and The Hospital for Sick Children (SickKids).
The study, published today in JAMA, reported results of a randomized control trial of 445 participants aged 8 to 18 years receiving cancer treatment from across 20 pediatric cancer centres in the U.S. Half of the centres participating implemented the screening intervention while ...
Which risk factors are linked to having a severe stroke?
2024-11-13
EMBARGOED FOR RELEASE UNTIL 4 P.M. ET, WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 13, 2024
MINNEAPOLIS – People with conditions or habits such as high blood pressure, an irregular heartbeat called atrial fibrillation, or smoking, not only have a higher risk of stroke, they may also have more severe strokes than people without these risk factors, according to a study published in the November 13, 2024, online issue of Neurology®, the medical journal of the American Academy of Neurology.
“Stroke can lead to disability or even death, yet there are a number of risk factors that people can modify with a change ...
Opening borders for workers: Abe’s profound influence on Japan’s immigration regime
2024-11-13
Japan grapples with labor shortage due to low birth rates and an aging population, prompting recent governments to bring in more foreign workers. Under the leadership of the late Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, significant immigration reforms were introduced between 2012 and 2020, aiming to alleviate these challenges by increasing the foreign population. However, despite these efforts, the government has continued to uphold the long-standing status quo of not having a formal immigration policy, mainly to balance business and nationalist interests.
This status ...
How skills from hospitality and tourism can propel careers beyond the industry
2024-11-13
Far from the stereotype of low-wage, low-skill positions, hospitality and tourism jobs could be powerful launchpads for broader career success, according to a new study from the University of Surrey. Researchers believe that working in these roles cultivates a wealth of transferable skills that can lead to lucrative opportunities in sectors like finance, healthcare, and technology.
In a study published in the Annals of Tourism Research, a team led by Dr Brigitte Stangl identified 116 unique transferable skills that employees gain while working in these sectors, highlighting the industry’s role as a vital training ground for essential skills.
The study found that employees ...
Research shows managers of firms handling recalls should review media scrutiny before deciding whether to lobby
2024-11-13
Lobbying can help companies reduce costs related to product recall, but it can also have a negative impact on the firm’s image. Research published in Strategic Management Journal offers clear data on the phenomenon, suggesting that managers should pay careful attention to the reputational cues from the media to determine when lobbying may be problematic and to refrain from the practice.
Firms can use lobbying to influence the government, which in turn potentially limits their costs during product recall crises. Previous research has shown that when a firm increases its lobbying spending by approximately $417,014, which has been found to ...
New model system for the development of potential active substances used in condensate modifying drugs
2024-11-13
The origin of many diseases such as Alzheimer's or Parkinson's can be found at the molecular level in our body, in other words, in proteins. In a healthy system, these proteins are responsible for numerous physiological functions. In order to carry out certain tasks, they may also assemble in groups consisting of numerous proteins. Once that job is done, they split up again and go their own ways. However, if larger clusters of a hundred or more proteins form so-called fibrils, which are bundles of long, filament-like accumulations of proteins, the ...
How to reduce social media stress by leaning in instead of logging off
2024-11-13
Young people’s mental health may depend on how they use social media, rather than how much time they spend using it, according to a new study by University of B.C. researchers.
The research, led by psychology professor Dr. Amori Mikami (she/her) and published this week in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, examined the effects of quitting social media versus using it more intentionally.
The results showed that users who thoughtfully managed their online interactions, as well as those who abstained from social media entirely, saw mental health benefits—particularly in reducing symptoms ...
Pioneering research shows sea life will struggle to survive future global warming
2024-11-13
A new study highlights how some marine life could face extinction over the next century, if human-induced global warming worsens.
The research, led by the University of Bristol and published today in Nature, compares for the first time how tiny ocean organisms called plankton responded, when the world last warmed significantly in ancient history with what is likely to happen under similar conditions by the end of our century.
Findings revealed the plankton were unable to keep pace with the current speed of temperature rises, putting huge swathes ...
In 10 seconds, an AI model detects cancerous brain tumor often missed during surgery
2024-11-13
Researchers have developed an AI powered model that — in 10 seconds — can determine during surgery if any part of a cancerous brain tumor that could be removed remains, a study published in Nature suggests.
The technology, called FastGlioma, outperformed conventional methods for identifying what remains of a tumor by a wide margin, according to the research team led by University of Michigan and University of California San Francisco.
“FastGlioma is an artificial intelligence-based diagnostic system that has the potential to change the field of neurosurgery ...