(Press-News.org) Key Takeaways
A new study finds little evidence that hospital mergers and acquisitions reduce costs or improve quality of care.
More strategic quality improvement efforts are needed for patients to benefit from health care integration.
CHICAGO (December 30, 2024) — Mergers and acquisitions of U.S. hospitals and health systems rarely improve the quality of care delivered or result in lower health care costs and prices, according to a study published in the Journal of the American College of Surgeons (JACS).
The study, a systematic review of hundreds of published studies, comes amid accelerating health care integration, sometimes called consolidation. Nearly 70 percent of U.S. hospitals are now affiliated with a health system.
“Proponents of health care integration have claimed it controls costs and enhances care quality,” said lead study author Bhagwan Satiani, MD, MBA, FACS, professor of surgery emeritus at The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, Columbus, Ohio. “But we found that evidence is lacking that integration alone is an effective strategy for improving the value of health care delivery.”
The study results send a clear message to health care leaders, Dr. Satiani said.
“These findings provide an opportunity to better define value with a focus on benefiting patients while balancing the financial stability of the health care industry,” he said. “Quality improvement in health care cannot be achieved by mergers and acquisitions alone.”
Effects of Health Care Integration
The authors’ systematic review included studies published from 2000-2024. Of these, 37 met inclusion criteria. Among the 26 studies that measured quality of care, nearly 77 percent (20 studies) showed reduced quality or no change due to integration, the investigators reported. Only 23 percent (six studies) showed improved quality, primarily due to better care management processes rather than outcomes. Just one study found fewer patient deaths after integration.
Hospital charges increased with integration 93 percent of the time, according to 13 of 14 studies measuring price changes. Of 16 studies assessing health care spending, 81 percent (13 studies) showed higher costs or no change.
The researchers also reported the net impact of integration on quality, price, and spending:
Only eight of 37 studies (22 percent) showed that health care integration had a positive (improved) net impact.
More than half (54 percent, 20 studies) showed a negative (worse) net impact.
In noting limitations of their review, Dr. Satiani said none of the reviewed studies used standard measures of quality, price, or spending. Also, most studies did not explore reasons for a lack of change in health care value after integration.
How this Study Differs from Previous Research
Although other researchers have reached similar conclusions, Dr. Satiani said their study differed in two ways. First, most studies of health care integration appear in health policy and economics publications and do not reach many surgeons, he noted. Yet, surgical services affect health organizations’ bottom line, accounting for about one third of U.S. health care expenditures.
“Surgical outcomes also have a direct impact on overall health care quality,” he said.
Second, Dr. Satiani said few of the published studies were systematic reviews, which are intended to reduce bias.
In this study, after screening 1,297 U.S. articles published from 1990 to 2024, the investigators systematically reviewed 384 of them that discussed either horizontal or vertical health care integration. They defined horizontal integration as two or more hospitals merging and vertical integration as hospitals acquiring independent physician practices.
To be included in the review, articles must have reported at least one of three measures of value: quality, price, and spending. Quality referred both to patient outcomes, such as the number of 30-day readmissions or deaths, and to care management processes. Such processes included staffing levels and use of nurse care managers. Price denoted the amount the organization charges the consumer per hospitalization, and spending was the organization’s costs per patient.
Focus on Quality Improvement
Dr. Satiani said health care leaders should delineate organizational resources and infrastructure to quality improvement efforts and standardize quality metrics. As a model for quality improvement, he suggested the American College of Surgeons Quality Verification Program as a model improving surgical quality.
Study coauthors are David Way, MEd; David Hoyt, MD, FACS; and E. Christopher Ellison, MD, FACS.
The study authors have no relevant disclosures.
This study is published as an article in press on the JACS website.
Citation: Satiani B, Way DP, Hoyt DE, Ellison EC. A Systematic Review of Integration Strategies Across the U.S. Healthcare System Shows No Consistent Improvement in Price, Cost Reduction, or Quality of Care. Journal of the American College of Surgeons. DOI: 10.1097/XCS.0000000000001229
# # #
About the American College of Surgeons
The American College of Surgeons is a scientific and educational organization of surgeons that was founded in 1913 to raise the standards of surgical practice and improve the quality of care for all surgical patients. The College is dedicated to the ethical and competent practice of surgery. Its achievements have significantly influenced the course of scientific surgery in America and have established it as an important advocate for all surgical patients. The College has approximately 90,000 members and is the largest organization of surgeons in the world. "FACS" designates that a surgeon is a Fellow of the American College of Surgeons.
Follow the ACS on social media: X | Instagram | YouTube | LinkedIn | Facebook
END
Improved health care value cannot be achieved by hospital mergers and acquisitions alone
New study finds that only about one in five health care integrations leads to improved value of care delivery
2024-12-30
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
People who are immunocompromised may not produce enough protective antibodies against RSV after vaccination
2024-12-30
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Johns Hopkins Medicine researchers have shown that people 60 years or older with weakened immunity — primarily organ transplant recipients who take immunosuppressive medications to reduce the risk of rejection and others with immune system disorders — do not respond as strongly to vaccines against the respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) as people in the same age group with normal immune function.
The study, conducted by a research team at the Johns Hopkins Transplant Research Center, was published today in the Journal of the American ...
Does coffee prevent head and neck cancer?
2024-12-30
In a new analysis of data from more than a dozen studies, coffee and tea consumption was linked with lower risks of developing head and neck cancers, including cancers of the mouth and throat.
Cancers of the head and neck are the seventh most common forms of cancer worldwide, and rates are rising in low- and middle-income countries. Many studies have assessed whether drinking coffee or tea is associated with head and neck cancer, with inconsistent results.
To provide additional insight, investigators led by the University of Utah’s Huntsman Cancer Institute examined data from ...
AI replaces humans in identifying causes of fuel cell malfunctions
2024-12-30
Dr. Chi-Young Jung's research team from the Hydrogen Research & Demonstration Center at the Korea Institute of Energy Research (KIER) has successfully developed a method to analyze the microstructure of carbon fiber paper, a key material in hydrogen fuel cells, at a speed 100 times faster than existing methods. This was achieved by utilizing digital twin technology and artificial intelligence (AI) learning.
Carbon fiber paper is a key material in hydrogen fuel cell stacks, playing a crucial role in facilitating water discharge ...
Pitfalls of FDA-approved germline cancer predisposition tests
2024-12-30
“The FDA approval on September 29, 2023, for ‘class III de novo’ blood tests to assess hereditary cancer risk make widely available tests that may be obtained through a Direct to Consumer (DTC) path.”
BUFFALO, NY – December 30, 2024 – A new editorial was published in Oncotarget’s Volume 15 on December 24, 2024, titled “Pitfalls and perils from FDA-approved germ-line cancer predisposition tests.“
Authored by Dr. Wafik S. El-Deiry, Editor-in-Chief of Oncotarget, and Dr. Eli Y. Adashi from Brown University, the article highlights concerns about the risks ...
A rising trend of 'murderous verbs' in movies over 50 years
2024-12-30
The amount of murdering and killing in movies has increased overall over the past 50 years, according to a new study that analyzed a massive database of film dialogue.
Researchers used machine learning to search a database of subtitles from more than 160,000 English-language movies produced from 1970 to 2000. They calculated the amount of dialogue from characters using variations of the words “murder” or “kill” in each of the films.
While the total use of these “murderous verbs” varied widely from year to year, there was a clear increasing trend over the five-decade ...
Brain structure differences are associated with early use of substances among adolescents
2024-12-30
A study of nearly 10,000 adolescents funded by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) has identified distinct differences in the brain structures of those who used substances before age 15 compared to those who did not. Many of these structural brain differences appeared to exist in childhood before any substance use, suggesting they may play a role in the risk of substance use initiation later in life, in tandem with genetic, environmental, and other neurological factors.
“This adds to some emerging evidence ...
Pain coping skills training for patients receiving hemodialysis
2024-12-30
About The Study: In this randomized clinical trial of patients undergoing maintenance hemodialysis, pain coping skills training had benefits on pain interference and other pain-associated outcomes. While the effect on the overall cohort was of modest magnitude, the intervention resulted in a clinically meaningful improvement in pain interference for a substantial proportion of participants.
Corresponding Author: To contact the corresponding author, Laura M. Dember, MD, email ldember@pennmedicine.upenn.edu.
To ...
Trends of violence in movies during the past half century
2024-12-30
About The Study: The results of this study suggest that speech about committing murder in movies is increasing over time, even in non-crime movies, regardless of character gender. These results are consistent with previous findings that highlighted increasing trends of violence using smaller datasets.
Corresponding Author: To contact the corresponding author, Brad J. Bushman, PhD, email bushman.20@osu.edu.
To access the embargoed study: Visit our For The Media website at this link https://media.jamanetwork.com/
(doi:10.1001/jamapediatrics.2024.5741)
Editor’s Note: Please see the article for additional information, including other authors, ...
Major depressive disorder and driving behavior among older adults
2024-12-30
About The Study: In this longitudinal cohort study of older drivers, adults with major depressive disorder demonstrated distinct and riskier driving behaviors than those in the control group without depression, with higher rates of hard braking, cornering, and unpredictability in driving patterns over time. Routine depression screening and tailored interventions are essential for enhancing driving safety and maintaining independence among older adults with major depressive disorder.
Corresponding Author: To contact the corresponding author, Ganesh M. Babulal, PhD, OTD, email babulalg@wustl.edu.
To access the ...
John Howington, MD, MBA, FCCP, to become the 87th President of the American College of Chest Physicians
2024-12-30
Glenview, IL– Effective January 1, John Howington, MD, MBA, FCCP, is the new President of the American College of Chest Physicians® (CHEST). Neil S. Freedman, MD, FCCP, steps into the role of President-Elect; Lisa Moores, MD, FCCP, is the new President-Designate; and Jack D. Buckley, MD, MPH, FCCP, completes his term as President to become Immediate Past President of CHEST.
John Howington, MD, MBA, FCCP, is a practicing thoracic surgeon currently at Virginia Mason Franciscan Health, St. Michael Medical Center, in Silverdale, Washington.
Dr. Howington ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Study unexpectedly finds living in rural, rather than urban environments in first five years of life could be a risk factor for developing type 1 diabetes
Editorial urges deeper focus on heart-lung interactions in pulmonary vascular disease
Five University of Tennessee faculty receive Fulbright Awards
5 advances to protect water sources, availability
OU Scholar awarded Fulbright for Soviet cinema research
Brain might become target of new type 1 diabetes treatments
‘Shore Wars:’ New research aims to resolve coastal conflict between oysters and mangroves, aiding restoration efforts
Why do symptoms linger in some people after an infection? A conversation on post-acute infection syndromes
Study reveals hidden drivers of asthma flare-ups in children
Physicists decode mysterious membrane behavior
New insights about brain receptor may pave way for next-gen mental health drugs
Melanoma ‘sat-nav’ discovery could help curb metastasis
When immune commanders misfire: new insights into rheumatoid arthritis inflammation
SFU researchers develop a new tool that brings blender-like lighting control to any photograph
Pups in tow, Yellowstone-area wolves trek long distances to stay near prey
AI breakthrough unlocks 'new' materials to replace lithium-ion batteries
Making molecules make sense: A regional explanation method reveals structure–property relationships
Partisan hostility, not just policy, drives U.S. protests
The Journal of Nuclear Medicine Ahead-of-Print Tip Sheet: August 1, 2025
Young human blood serum factors show potential to rejuvenate skin through bone marrow
Large language models reshape the future of task planning
Narrower coverage of MS drugs tied to higher relapse risk
Researchers harness AI-powered protein design to enhance T-cell based immunotherapies
Smartphone engagement during school hours among US youths
Online reviews of health care facilities
MS may begin far earlier than previously thought
New AI tool learns to read medical images with far less data
Announcing XPRIZE Healthspan as Tier 5 Sponsor of ARDD 2025
Announcing Immortal Dragons as Tier 4 Sponsor of ARDD 2025
Reporting guideline for chatbot health advice studies
[Press-News.org] Improved health care value cannot be achieved by hospital mergers and acquisitions aloneNew study finds that only about one in five health care integrations leads to improved value of care delivery