(Press-News.org) A new study, published in Addiction, shines a light on how industries associated with health harms—such as tobacco, fossil fuels, and in this case, alcohol—can distort the evaluation of scientific research through industry-friendly commentary.
A team of researchers led by UVic’s Canadian Institute for Substance Use Research (CISUR), analyzed 268 critiques of alcohol and health studies published online since 2010 by the International Scientific Forum on Alcohol Research, or ISFAR.
ISFAR describes themselves as an international group of “invited physicians and scientists who are specialists in their fields and committed to balanced and well researched analysis regarding alcohol and health.” However, members have continuing alcohol-industry connections, says Tim Stockwell, CISUR scientist, professor emeritus at UVic’s psychology department, and co-author of the study.
“Although ISFAR has long-standing ties to the alcohol industry, it is still frequently quoted in the media as an authoritative voice on matters relating to alcohol and health,” says Stockwell. “We had observed their critiques seemed to favour studies finding health benefits from alcohol, and to be critical of those that said otherwise. We set out to test this impartially and comprehensively.”
The researchers’ hypotheses were confirmed, whether using data generated by human coders or by computer-based text analysis of the ISFAR critiques. The team found studies supporting an industry-friendly narrative were ten times more likely to receive a positive review from ISFAR than those suggesting otherwise. Notably, ISFAR’s favorability ratings were completely unrelated to the studies’ level of scientific merit as assessed by an independent expert who was not otherwise involved in the project.
“This analysis confirms the impression that ISFAR is an industry-friendly echo chamber whose critiques are determined more by whether they like the conclusions contained in research papers than by scientific merit,” says Stockwell. “We’ve seen this playbook before with the tobacco industry trying to discredit science around smoking’s harms.”
It’s a reminder that we need to be mindful of where our information is coming from and who is paying for its creation, says Stockwell.
Read the study The International Scientific Forum on Alcohol Research (ISFAR) critiques of alcohol research: Promoting health benefits and downplaying harms
END
Forum with alcohol industry ties shows significant bias in reviews of health research
A new study, published in Addiction, shines a light on how industries associated with health harms—such as tobacco, fossil fuels, and in this case, alcohol—can distort the evaluation of scientific research through industry-friendly commentary.
2025-07-09
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Underestimated sources of marine pollution
2025-07-09
Plastic waste pollutes oceans across all regions of the world. Marine animals may become entangled in larger plastic debris such as nets and bags or mistake smaller pieces for food. Ingested plastic can block or injure the gastrointestinal tract. The smallest plastic particles in the micro and nano range are mostly excreted, but a small proportion can pass through the intestinal wall and enter the bloodstream.
So how much nanoplastic is actually present in the oceans? Most scientific attention has so far been focussed ...
IPK research team unlocks potential of barley’s closest wild relative, Hordeum bulbosum
2025-07-09
Wild relatives of cultivated plants are a vital source of genetic diversity for improving crops and provide a valuable reservoir of resistance against biotic and abiotic stressors. Although their value has been recognised for decades, technological obstacles have long hindered their exploration. Thanks to advances in high-throughput genomic research, the same tools can now be used in crops and their wild relatives.
An international research team led by the IPK Leibniz Institute studied structural genome evolution in barley (Hordeum vulgare) and Hordeum bulbosum. For this study, Dr. Frank Blattner collected H. bulbosum ...
Study reveals the hidden benefits of weight loss on fat tissue
2025-07-09
Scientists have produced the first detailed characterisation of the changes that weight loss causes in human fat tissue by analysing hundreds of thousands of cells. They found a range of positive effects, including clearing out of damaged, ageing cells, and increased metabolism of harmful fats.
The researchers say the findings help to better understand how weight loss leads to health improvements at a molecular level, which in the future could help to inform the development of therapies for diseases such as type 2 diabetes.
The study, published in the journal Nature, compared samples ...
Gut microbes key to understanding how exercise boosts cancer immunity
2025-07-09
A new study from the University of Pittsburgh shows for the first time how exercise improves cancer outcomes and enhances response to immunotherapy in mice by reshaping the gut microbiome.
The research, published in the journal Cell, found that these benefits are driven by a specific compound called formate, which is produced by gut bacteria in exercised mice and was also associated with better outcomes in patients with melanoma.
“We already knew that exercise increases the effectiveness of cancer immunotherapies, and we separately knew that exercise changes the microbiome in mice and humans,” said ...
Morning vs bedtime dosing and nocturnal blood pressure reduction in patients with hypertension
2025-07-09
About The Study: In this randomized clinical trial of antihypertensive chronotherapy, bedtime dosing provided better control of nocturnal blood pressure and improved the circadian rhythm, without reducing the efficacy on mean daytime or 24-hour blood pressure, or increasing the risk of nocturnal hypotension. These findings support the potential advantages of bedtime administration and offer new evidence to guide future research on antihypertensive chronotherapy.
Corresponding Author: To contact the corresponding author, Xiaoping Chen, MD, email xiaopingchen15@126.com.
To access the embargoed study: Visit our For The Media website at this link https://media.jamanetwork.com/
(doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2025.19354)
Editor’s ...
BMI in children before, during, and after the COVID-19 pandemic
2025-07-09
About The Study: This cross-sectional study including 426,000 children in Denmark found that body mass index (BMI) outcomes of COVID-19 pandemic–related control policies and restrictions were not exclusively observed among children with obesity, which suggests that pandemic-related mitigation policies targeting children and adolescents in all BMI categories are warranted. The findings of this study highlight differences among children of varying ages and BMI classes.
Corresponding Author: To contact ...
Branching out: Tomato genes point to new medicines
2025-07-09
Picture juicy red tomatoes on the vine. What do you see? Some tomato varieties have straight vines. Others are branched. The question is why. New research from Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory (CSHL) provides the strongest evidence to date that the answer lies in what are called cryptic mutations. The findings have implications for agriculture and medicine, as they could help scientists fine-tune plant breeding techniques and clinical therapeutics.
Cryptic mutations are differences in DNA that don’t affect physical traits unless certain other genetic changes occur at the same time. CSHL Professor & HHMI Investigator Zachary Lippman has ...
Charité study analyzes 400 million years of enzyme evolution
2025-07-09
Enzymes catalyze chemical reactions in organisms - without which life would not be possible. Leveraging AlphaFold2 artificial intelligence, researchers at Charité – Universitätsmedizin Berlin have now succeeded in analyzing the laws of their evolution on a large scale. In the journal Nature*, they describe the parts of enzymes that change comparatively quickly and the parts that remain practically unchanged over time. These findings are relevant to the development of new antibiotics, for example.
Enzymes resemble ...
Large-scale DNA study maps 37,000 years of disease history
2025-07-09
A research team led by Eske Willerslev, professor at the University of Copenhagen and the University of Cambridge, has recovered ancient DNA from 214 known human pathogens in prehistoric humans from Eurasia.
The study shows, among other things, that the earliest known evidence of zoonotic diseases – illnesses transmitted from animals to humans, like COVID in recent times – dates back to around 6,500 years ago, with such diseases becoming more widespread approximately 5,000 years ago. It is ...
Results from largest review of its kind on antidepressant withdrawal symptoms
2025-07-09
The largest review of ‘gold standard’ antidepressant withdrawal studies to date has identified the type and incidence of symptoms experienced by people discontinuing antidepressants, finding most people do not experience severe withdrawal.
In a systematic review and meta-analysis of previous randomised controlled trials relating to antidepressant withdrawal, a team of researchers led by Imperial College London and King’s College London concluded that, while participants who stopped antidepressants did experience an average of one more symptom than those who continued or were taking ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Eye for trouble: Automated counting for chromosome issues under the microscope
The vast majority of US rivers lack any protections from human activities, new research finds
Ultrasound-responsive in situ antigen "nanocatchers" open a new paradigm for personalized tumor immunotherapy
Environmental “superbugs” in our rivers and soils: new one health review warns of growing antimicrobial resistance crisis
Triple threat in greenhouse farming: how heavy metals, microplastics, and antibiotic resistance genes unite to challenge sustainable food production
Earthworms turn manure into a powerful tool against antibiotic resistance
AI turns water into an early warning network for hidden biological pollutants
Hidden hotspots on “green” plastics: biodegradable and conventional plastics shape very different antibiotic resistance risks in river microbiomes
Engineered biochar enzyme system clears toxic phenolic acids and restores pepper seed germination in continuous cropping soils
Retail therapy fail? Online shopping linked to stress, says study
How well-meaning allies can increase stress for marginalized people
Commercially viable biomanufacturing: designer yeast turns sugar into lucrative chemical 3-HP
Control valve discovered in gut’s plumbing system
George Mason University leads phase 2 clinical trial for pill to help maintain weight loss after GLP-1s
Hop to it: research from Shedd Aquarium tracks conch movement to set new conservation guidance
Weight loss drugs and bariatric surgery improve the body’s fat ‘balance:’ study
The Age of Fishes began with mass death
TB harnesses part of immune defense system to cause infection
Important new source of oxidation in the atmosphere found
A tug-of-war explains a decades-old question about how bacteria swim
Strengthened immune defense against cancer
Engineering the development of the pancreas
The Journal of Nuclear Medicine ahead-of-print tip sheet: Jan. 9, 2026
Mount Sinai researchers help create largest immune cell atlas of bone marrow in multiple myeloma patients
Why it is so hard to get started on an unpleasant task: Scientists identify a “motivation brake”
Body composition changes after bariatric surgery or treatment with GLP-1 receptor agonists
Targeted regulation of abortion providers laws and pregnancies conceived through fertility treatment
Press registration is now open for the 2026 ACMG Annual Clinical Genetics Meeting
Understanding sex-based differences and the role of bone morphogenetic protein signaling in Alzheimer’s disease
Breakthrough in thin-film electrolytes pushes solid oxide fuel cells forward
[Press-News.org] Forum with alcohol industry ties shows significant bias in reviews of health researchA new study, published in Addiction, shines a light on how industries associated with health harms—such as tobacco, fossil fuels, and in this case, alcohol—can distort the evaluation of scientific research through industry-friendly commentary.