(Press-News.org) How One Flu Virus Can Hamper the Immune Response to Another
Prior exposure to one strain of influenza virus may weaken children’s ability to mount an effective antibody response against their subsequent exposure to a different flu strain, according to a study led by Weill Cornell Medicine investigators. The analysis of the pediatric response to H3N2 and H1N1 influenza A viruses, two of the most common causes of flu, provides insight into the concept of “immune imprinting,” and supports the idea that childhood vaccination, if properly designed, may be able to mitigate its adverse effects.
Immune imprinting, first described in 1960, refers to a long-term bias or skew in the immune response that a first viral exposure can introduce, with potentially serious impairment of subsequent responses to closely related viruses. Imprinting has been difficult to research and is far from being well understood. However, in the study, published March 11 in Nature, the researchers were able to analyze antibodies from participants, including children 2 to 6 years old who had their sequential first exposures to the two types of influenza A viruses circulating in humans. They determined that following an initial H3N2 exposure, antibodies generated that could bind both H3N2 and H1N1 were ineffective at stopping most H1N1 strains.
Structural analyses and other experiments linked this imprinting effect to a key site on the viral antigen that is similar on H3N2 and H1N1. However, by first shaping the immune response to the H3N2 virus, the children became unable to properly adapt to this site on the H1N1 virus. The researchers also found evidence that simultaneous vaccination in infancy against H3N2 and H1N1 may eliminate this imprinting problem.
“These findings are a reminder that the effectiveness of a vaccine against a given virus may be impacted by a past exposure to a related virus, which can make vaccine design a lot tougher,” said senior author Dr. Patrick Wilson, the Anne E. Dyson Professor of Pediatric Research and a member of the Gale and Ira Drukier Institute for Children’s Health at Weill Cornell Medicine.
The study was highly collaborative, with contributions from many institutions including Scripps Research, St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital, and the University of Michigan School of Public Health.
Shaping the Immune Response Over Time
A first exposure to a virus induces an initial, “de novo” B cell response, including secretion of serum antibodies along with the creation of a long-lived pool of memory B cells, which can produce antibodies rapidly if they ever encounter the virus again. The imprinting problem is thought to arise when a related virus triggers this memory response, creating a surge of antibodies that may not be capable of effectively neutralizing the new threat—and may even hinder the immune system’s ability to mount a robust de novo response. The problem is thought to be directly linked to the immunity elicited by initial exposures in early childhood.
The new study covered 40 participants, half of whom were young children with confirmed first exposures to H3N2 then H1N1, or vice versa. Participants came from two larger, clinic-based studies that enrolled children with flu symptoms and analyzed their immune responses—and often those of other household members—for years, to better understand the development of immunity to flu viruses.
“This was a really unique cohort of participants providing us an opportunity to study imprinting of influenza virus through a relatively clean analysis,” said first author Dr. Jiayi Sun, a postdoctoral associate in pediatrics in the Wilson laboratory.
As expected, the adult participants showed signs of having built up stronger and more versatile immunity through a lifetime of exposures. In some of the children, however, imprinting that impaired immunity was evident.
A Tiny Difference Makes a Big Impact
The children who had encountered the two flu subtypes sequentially over time ended up inducing “cross-reactive” antibodies capable of binding both subtypes at the stalk region of the flu virus’s main outer envelope protein hemagglutinin—a site that is almost the same in both subtypes and therefore of major interest to improve future influenza vaccines that might protect against all influenza strains. In children with H3N2-then-H1N1 exposures, compared to the other groups, these cross-reactive antibodies generally bound much better to the H3N2 stalk than to H1N1’s, and were relatively ineffective against the encountered H1N1 strain. Experiments also showed that these H3-imprinted antibodies, binding weakly to the H1N1 stalk region, could block binding by an anti-H1 stalk antibody that more potently neutralized the virus.
The H3N2-imprinted antibodies that appeared after H1N1 exposure were also strikingly ineffective against older H1N1 strains, which may pose a threat in the future. The researchers, using cryo-electron microscopy-based analyses, determined that this loss of activity was likely due to a single amino-acid change differing by only an atomic group in the stalk region in these older H1N1 strains, compared to more recent H1N1 and H3N2 strains. The impact of such a minute molecular difference on the activity of nearly all antibodies to the shared stalk epitope from seven different children was surprising.
“This shows that it doesn't take much to render your memory antibody response ineffective,” Dr. Wilson said.
The good news was that B cells from infants vaccinated simultaneously against H1N1 and H3N2—with a seasonal flu vaccine that typically contains both—showed no sign of this deleterious imprinting.
Currently the American Academy of Pediatrics and other public health authorities recommend the seasonal flu vaccine for all children age six months and older.
Many Weill Cornell Medicine physicians and scientists maintain relationships and collaborate with external organizations to foster scientific innovation and provide expert guidance. The institution makes these disclosures public to ensure transparency. For this information, see profile for Dr. Patrick Wilson.
END
How one flu virus can hamper the immune response to another
2026-03-11
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Researchers uncover distinct tumor “neighborhoods”, with each cell subtype playing a specific role, in aggressive childhood brain cancer
2026-03-11
New research published today in Nature finds that tumor cells within supratentorial ependymomas (SE) – an aggressive childhood brain cancer – cluster into distinct tumor cell populations. Much like a neighborhood in your hometown, each cell subtype within these “communities” has a specific (and previously unappreciated) role to play. Understanding how SE tumor cells form neighborhoods and the function of each cell type could help better predict how these tumor cell subtypes will respond to treatment.
The research team, led by Mariella Filbin, MD, PhD, Co-Director of the Brain Tumor Center at Dana Farber/Boston Children’s Cancer ...
Researchers develop new way to safely insert gene-sized DNA into the genome
2026-03-11
Genome editing-based therapies typically aim to treat disease by correcting underlying genetic mutations in patient’s cells. However, most genetic disorders are caused by dozens or even thousands of unique mutations spread across a gene; this diversity results in challenges of scale when it comes to developing customized therapies for many individuals. A more universal strategy could involve the precise insertion of an entire copy of a healthy gene into a specific location in the genome, which could, in principle, provide a single, widely applicable treatment for all patients irrespective of their mutation ...
Astronomers capture birth of a magnetar, confirming link to some of universe’s brightest exploding stars
2026-03-11
Astronomers have for the first time seen the birth of a magnetar — a highly magnetized, spinning neutron star — and confirmed that it’s the power source behind some of the brightest exploding stars in the cosmos.
The finding corroborates a theory proposed by a UC Berkeley physicist 16 years ago and establishes a new phenomenon in exploding stars: supernovae with a “chirp” in their light curve that is caused by general relativity. A paper describing the phenomenon was published today ...
New photonic device, developed by MIT researchers, efficiently beams light into free space
2026-03-11
CAMBRIDGE, MA -- Photonic chips use light to process data instead of electricity, enabling faster communication speeds and greater bandwidth. Most of that light typically stays on the chip, trapped in optical wires, and is difficult to transmit to the outside world in an efficient manner.
If a lot of light could be rapidly and precisely beamed off the chip, free from the confines of the wiring, it could open the door to higher-resolution displays, smaller Lidar systems, more precise 3D printers, or larger-scale quantum computers.
Now, researchers from MIT and elsewhere have developed a new class ...
UCSB researcher bridges the worlds of general relativity and supernova astrophysics
2026-03-11
(Santa Barbara, Calif.) — For decades, astronomers have used distant supernovae as cosmic lighthouses to test fundamental physics and to measure the universe. For Joseph Farah, a fifth-year graduate student at UC Santa Barbara, one particular supernova began to signal something never seen before: a “chirp.”
In a groundbreaking paper accepted to the journal Nature, Farah and a team of international researchers, including his advisor Andy Howell, who leads the supernova group at Las Cumbres Observatory (LCO), announce the discovery of a superluminous supernova (SN 2024afav) whose erratic behavior has confirmed a long-standing theory ...
Global exchange of knowledge and technology to significantly advance reef restoration efforts
2026-03-11
Coral reefs are being hit hard by the climate crisis, and timely interventions for their survival are a top priority. The Global Coral Tech Transfer Project enables SECORE International and the Australian Institute of Marine Science (AIMS) to implement the latest scientifically developed coral breeding techniques on a large scale across regions. The practical implementation of the project is carried out jointly and in close cooperation with Dominican Republic-based partner FUNDEMAR, combining Australian technology, Caribbean coral breeding science, and in-depth experience in implementing restoration efforts successfully. ...
Vision sensing for intelligent driving: technical challenges and innovative solutions
2026-03-11
In the rapidly evolving landscape of automotive technology, vision sensing has emerged as a crucial component for intelligent driving systems. A recent article published in Engineering, titled “Vision Sensing for Intelligent Driving: Technical Challenges and Innovative Solutions,” offers an in-depth analysis of the current state of vision sensing technology and explores potential solutions to enhance its performance.
The authors, Xinle Gong from the School of Mechanical Engineering at Beijing ...
To attempt world record, researchers will use their finding that prep phase is most vital to accurate three-point shooting
2026-03-11
LAWRENCE — To be an excellent three-point shooter, you can be Stephen Curry. Or failing that, you can rely on sound biomechanics in the preparatory phase of a shooting motion from behind the arc.
New research from the University of Kansas has found that proper elbow positioning — along with greater flexion in the hips, knees and ankles prior to initiating the shooting motion — is one of the key determinants of successful long-range shooting efficiency. That science will now be used in an attempt to set a new world record for most consecutive made three-point shots.
Researchers at KU’s Jayhawk Athletic Performance Laboratory, ...
AI is homogenizing human expression and thought, computer scientists and psychologists say
2026-03-11
AI chatbots are standardizing how people speak, write, and think. If this homogenization continues unchecked, it risks reducing humanity’s collective wisdom and ability to adapt, computer scientists and psychologists argue in an opinion paper publishing March 11 in the Cell Press journal Trends in Cognitive Sciences. They say that AI developers should incorporate more real-world diversity into large language model (LLM) training ...
Severe COVID-19, flu facilitate lung cancer months or years later, new research shows
2026-03-11
Severe COVID-19 and influenza infections prime the lungs for cancer and can accelerate the disease’s development, but vaccination heads off those harmful effects, new research from UVA Health’s Beirne B. Carter Center for Immunology Research and UVA Comprehensive Cancer Center indicates.
UVA School of Medicine researcher Jie Sun, PhD, and colleagues found that serious viral infections “reprogrammed” immune cells in the lungs to facilitate the growth of cancer tumors months or even years later. Based on their findings, the scientists are urging doctors to closely monitor patients who have recovered from severe ...