Guidelines on rare diseases: Methods on handling evidence neither identified nor required
Manuals and methods papers provide only isolated references; different requirements than those for more common diseases do not seem meaningful
2011-04-29
(Press-News.org) People with rare diseases have the same right to high-quality health care in line with current medical knowledge as other patients do. However, relevant and reliable clinical studies on rare diseases are often lacking. Among other things, this makes the development of corresponding guidelines more difficult, but precisely such guidelines could help improve treatment quality.
The German Federal Ministry of Health therefore commissioned the Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG) to answer the following question: What methodological approaches are used by guideline developers and health technology assessment (HTA) agencies in the handling of evidence (clinical study results) for the development of guidelines on rare diseases? In addition, IQWiG was to investigate whether physicians and researchers pose different requirements for the evidence in guidelines on rare diseases than for guidelines on other, more common diseases.
Methodological approach hardly addressed
For this purpose, IQWiG systematically searched for and evaluated manuals on the development of treatment guidelines, methods papers by important HTA agencies, as well as guidelines on selected rare diseases. The findings show that the handling of evidence on rare diseases is hardly addressed in these documents. Explicit references to or instructions on the handling of such evidence was found only sporadically; in any case, uniform methodological requirements cannot be inferred from the information retrieved. However, neither do the manuals, methods papers, and guidelines analysed provide indications that a fundamentally different approach and different requirements should be adopted for rare diseases than for more common ones.
Evidence on more common diseases is also often poor
"Little or no evidence is not only a problem of rare diseases," explains IQWiG's Director Jürgen Windeler. "It is still possible to develop guidelines, and in principle there is no good reason to adopt a different approach or pose different requirements for rare diseases than for more common ones. This applies to the handling of evidence (as investigated in the report) as well as to the planning and conduct of the clinical studies themselves. If people with rare diseases are to be provided with high-quality health care, then studies of high methodological quality are required. The number of patients affected is usually large enough to enable such studies - even if in some cases international cooperation is needed."
INFORMATION:
Procedure of report production
The Federal Ministry of Health commissioned IQWiG in August 2010. The report was to be prepared in an accelerated procedure as a "rapid report". In contrast to the usual procedure, no preliminary reports are published here. Although a preliminary version of the rapid report is reviewed externally, no hearing is conducted in which all interested parties can submit comments. The report was prepared in collaboration with external experts and sent to the contracting agency at the end of March 2011.
An overview of the background, methods and further results of the final report is provided in the executive summary.
END
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
2011-04-29
Neural tube defects in neonates are common in Germany compared with the rest of Europe. Extensive folic acid fortification of foods in Germany might prevent these in 85-100% of cases, Wolfgang Herrmann and Rima Obeid argue in this issue of Deutsches Ärzteblatt International (Dtsch Arztebl Int 2011; 108[15]; 249-54).
A woman's folic acid intake before and during early pregnancy ensures that the fetus does not develop the neural tube defect commonly known as spina bifida. Every year, 800 pregnancies in Germany are diagnosed with a neural tube defect. Most of those pregnancies ...
2011-04-29
Montreal, April 28, 2011 – A program which combines interval training and healthy eating practices seems to be perfectly indicated for those suffering from obesity, according to the results of a new study from the Montreal Hearth Institute's centre for preventive medicine and physical activity (ÉPIC Centre). Results of the study were announced at the National Obesity Summit, currently taking place in Montreal.
Within the framework of this study, researchers analyzed the track record of 62 participants in Kilo-Actif, a 9-month program intended for obesity sufferers that ...
2011-04-29
DETROIT – A new Henry Ford Hospital study takes a closer look at one of the lesser known, but potential most serious side-effects of ACE inhibitor use – facial, tongue and airway swelling – and identifies a successful and less invasive course of treatment.
Using a treatment protocol developed by Henry Ford, patients' symptoms were quickly diagnosed and promptly treated to reduce swelling, resulting in no tracheotomies to open the airway or reported deaths, says study author Samer Al-Khudari, M.D.
"This side-effect is rare, but when it happens, it can be anxiety-provoking ...
2011-04-29
A new study shows for the first time that monkeys can recall and reproduce simple shapes from memory. Identifying this recall ability is critical to our understanding of the evolution of memory and other cognitive abilities, and it could be applied to better diagnosing and treating memory impairments in humans.
The finding by Emory University psychologists and Yerkes National Primate Research Center researchers Ben Basile and Robert Hampton was published today (April 28) in the journal Current Biology. The psychologists developed a computer touchscreen method to test ...
2011-04-29
Stronger and tougher body armor to shield the chest, abdomen and back may be just what soldiers fighting in the Afghanistan and Iraq wars need to better protect their brains from mild injuries tied to so-called "shell shock," results of a Johns Hopkins study in mice suggest. Such mild trauma, resulting from the initial shock of exploding mines, grenades and improvised explosive devices (IEDs) now accounts for more than 80 percent of all brain injuries among U.S. troops. Some 160,000 American veteran men and women are estimated to have sustained this kind of trauma.
"Protecting ...
2011-04-29
INDIANAPOLIS – The largest study of its type has found that neither vitamin E, which is an antioxidant, nor the diabetes drug metformin, successfully reduced liver enzymes in nonalcoholic fatty liver disease in children or teens, according to a paper published in the April 27, 2011 issue of Journal of the American Medical Association. The study also found that in patients with a severe type of fatty liver disease, a biopsy of the liver showed improvement in the injury pattern with vitamin E therapy.
Nonalcoholic fatty liver disease is the most common cause of chronic ...
2011-04-29
University of Granada researchers have proven that melatonin –a natural hormone produced by the body– helps in controlling weight gain –even without reducing the intake of food–, improves blood lipid profile –as it reduces triglicerids–, increases HDL cholesterol and reduces LDL cholesterol.
Melatonin is found in small quantities in some fruits and vegetables as mustard, Goji berries, almonds, sunflower seeds, cardamom, fennel, coriander and cherries. Thus, the intake of this kind of food might help in controlling weight gain and preventing heart diseases associated to ...
2011-04-29
(WASHINGTON, April 28, 2011) – Researchers have developed an effective technique that uses gene therapy on stem cells to correct chronic granulomatous disease (CGD) in cell culture, which could eventually serve as a treatment for this rare, inherited immune disorder, according to a study published in Blood, the Journal of the American Society of Hematology.
CGD prevents neutrophils, a type of white blood cell of the immune system, from making hydrogen peroxide, an essential defense against life-threatening bacterial and fungal infections. Most cases of CGD are a result ...
2011-04-29
TORONTO, On – April 28, 2011 – Immigrants living less than five years in Canada are less likely than their Canadian-born counterparts to have premature babies regardless of where they live, according to a new study by St. Michael's Hospital.
"Living in poor neighbourhoods has been linked with poor health outcomes, but this study shows that this is not always the case for new Canadians," says Dr. Marcelo Urquia, epidemiologist at the Centre for Research on Inner City Health at St. Michael's Hospital. "For new immigrants, while they have an advantage on avoiding premature ...
2011-04-29
Researchers at the Center for Translational Social Neuroscience (CTSN) at Emory University are focusing on prairie voles as a new model to screen the effectiveness of drugs to treat autism.
They are starting with D-cycloserine, a drug Emory researchers have shown enhances behavioral therapy for phobias and also promotes pair bonding among prairie voles. Giving female voles D-cycloserine, which is thought to facilitate learning and memory, can encourage them to bond with a new male more quickly than usual.
The results are published online and will appear in a future ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
[Press-News.org] Guidelines on rare diseases: Methods on handling evidence neither identified nor required
Manuals and methods papers provide only isolated references; different requirements than those for more common diseases do not seem meaningful