Coroners wrong to say no to post-mortem tissue collection, academics argue

The Coroner's Society 'failed' in its duty to protect public health by refusing to take part in vCJD study

2011-05-10

(Press-News.org) The creation of a post-mortem tissue archive for a study of the human form of mad cow disease failed because of a "misguided" refusal by coroners to participate. The Coroners' Society of England and Wales (CSEW) did not recognise its "moral obligation to protect public health" from potential new risks associated with variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (vCJD) when it decided not to allow the collection of tissue from autopsies. That is the conclusion of a paper co-written by a researcher at the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, which has been published online and is set to appear in a forthcoming edition of the journal Public Health. The authors say they believe the reasons given by the CSEW were insufficient to justify not taking part in the study and call for a wider review of the role of coroners in future public health measures. They also criticise the move by the Government to abolish the proposed position of Chief Coroner as part of the Public Bodies Bill which is set to have its final reading in the House of Lords on Monday May 9. Until 2003, all cases of vCJD – a fatal brain-wasting disease – in humans were caused by exposure to bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) in the diet. More recently a small number of infections are thought to have resulted from blood transfusions from donors who did not know they were infected with vCJD. It is also believed that iatrogenic transmission may occur as a result of contaminated surgical instruments – a concern which prompted hospitals in Essex and Wales to contact patients earlier this year. In response to the evidence that vCJD has the potential to emerge as a second-wave infection resulting from human-to-human transmission, the Health Protection Agency (HPA) attempted to create a post-mortem tissue archive. Its aim was to determine the prevalence of abnormal prion protein, which is a marker for vCJD infection, in the UK in order to determine the efficacy of current precautionary measures and to determine if further measures might be necessary. But following a protracted correspondence with the Chief Medical Officer, the CSEW declined to participate, citing issues including its legality, cost and feasibility, concluding that taking part would "adversely affect the independence of the coronial service and would further erode public confidence". According to the authors of the paper, "declining to participate in this study was misguided and illustrates a considerable failure by the CSEW to recognise coroners' moral obligation to protect public health". They add: "The protection of public health is an appropriate and vital obligation of government officials as such protection helps to ensure the conditions necessary for individuals and groups to live healthy and safe lives." Lead author Catherine McGowan, based in the Faculty of Public Health and Policy at LSHTM, said: "A Chief Coroner – one with a clear understanding of the role of the coroner's service in protecting the public good – should be able to facilitate this type of public health survey in the future". "Despite the valiant attempts of the House of Lords to save the proposed position of Chief Coroner from abolition under the Public Bodies Bill, the position is now likely to be axed by the House of Commons. This seems a grave mistake." ### Notes to Editors: :: McGowan CR, Viens AM, Coroners and the obligation to protect public health: The case of the failed UK vCJD study, Public Health (2011), doi:10.1016/j.puhe.2010.12.001 :: For more information on the Public Bodies Bill visit http://services.parliament.uk/bills/2010-11/publicbodieshl.html :: To interview Catherine McGowan, please contact the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine press office on 0207 927 2802 or email paula.fentiman@lshtm.ac.uk

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

A study analyzes the legal problems of social networks

2011-05-10

This release is available in Spanish. This study, published in the journal El Profesional de la Información by the Universidad Complutense de Madrid professor, Antonia Salvador and the UC3M professor, Maria Estrella Gutiérrez, deals with how traditional communication media are implementing applications based on Internet, built upon the ideological and technological basics of the Web 2.0, which allows forms of interaction based on collaborative participation and on the contents generated by the user himself. "Using these social media is a way to capture an audience ...

RakeTheRake Unveils its New Re-branded Site!

2011-05-10

RakeTheRake.com has today re-branded and re-launched its website to offer its online poker players a highly improved user experience and a wealth of new features and functionality. The new site provides players with a simplified sign up process, an enhanced Your Account area, in-depth rakeback and referral statistics, video tutorials to key areas of the site, and launches two brand new functions; the RakeTheRake forum and free poker training. RakeTheRake, founded seven years ago, has always prided itself on providing the highest levels of customer service in conjunction ...

Sexy clothes: Too much, too young

2011-05-10

Are clothing manufacturers helping to turn young girls into sex objects? According to a new study, up to 30 percent of young girls' clothing available online in the US is 'sexy' or sexualizing. The study was carried out by Samantha Goodin, a former Kenyon College (Ohio, USA) student and a research team led by Dr. Sarah Murnen, Professor of Psychology at Kenyon College. In their view, this has serious implications for how girls evaluate themselves according to a sexualized model of feminine physical attractiveness. It makes them confront the issue of sexual identity at a ...

NIH study describes fast, sensitive blood test for human prion disease

2011-05-10

WHAT: Scientists from the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID), part of the National Institutes of Health (NIH), report that they have developed a method—10,000 times more sensitive than other methods—to detect variant Creutzfeldt-Jacob disease (vCJD) in blood plasma. vCJD is a type of prion disease in humans that leads to brain damage and death. The NIAID researchers also used the test to rapidly detect scrapie, a prion disease of sheep, in infected hamsters, some pre-symptomatic. Prion diseases, also known as transmissible spongiform encephalopathies, ...

New test could give SLE patients a more tolerable life

2011-05-10

"At present, it can take up to a year before a patient is diagnosed with SLE. This is because the symptoms are diffuse and are often mistaken for other diseases. However, with this blood-based test, it is possible to determine quickly whether someone has the disease or not", says Christer Wingren, associate professor in Immunotechnology at CREATE Health, Lund University. The test can also determine how far the disease has progressed. There are three different variants of SLE, and all require different treatment. With current methods, it is often difficult to find out ...

Raging storms sweep away galactic gas

2011-05-10

ESA's Herschel infrared space observatory has detected raging winds of molecular gas streaming away from galaxies. Suspected for years, these outflows may have the power to strip galaxies of gas and halt star formation in its tracks. The winds that Herschel has detected are extraordinary. The fastest is blowing at a speed of more than 1000 km/s, or about 10 000 times faster than the wind in a terrestrial hurricane. This is the first time that such molecular gas outflows have been unequivocally observed in a sample of galaxies. This is an important discovery because ...

Smokers undergo the same changes in gene expression as patients with COPD

2011-05-10

'Healthy' smokers experience changes in the gene expression of their lungs similar to that suffered by smokers who have developed Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD). This is the conclusion of a new study, led by Catalan researchers, which confirms the crucial role that smoking plays in causing these alterations. "Our objective was to analyse the expression of a range of genes in the pulmonary tissue samples of patients with COPD, whether smokers or not, and people who had undergone operations for cancer or lung transplants", Ricardo Bastos, lead author of the ...

Statutory Rape Charge Reduced by Challenging Witness' Credibility

2011-05-10

A Roberts Law Group PLLC client was facing a serious statutory rape charge when attorney Patrick Roberts stepped in to defend against the charge. By challenging the credibility of the accuser, criminal lawyer Roberts was able to negotiate a reduction in the statutory rape charge to indecent liberties with a minor. This reduction led to a decrease in the amount of possible prison time from nearly 25 years to 10 to 12 months. The facts of the case aren't all that uncommon in North Carolina because many don't realize the consequences stemming from sex with a minor. In this ...

Post-traumatic stress disorder common following significant orthopedic trauma

2011-05-10

Although most commonly associated with military combat, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) can occur in civilians, too – and with consequences that are just as serious, according to a new review article in the Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (JAAOS). PTSD is a type of anxiety disorder that occurs after a person experiences a traumatic event involving physical injury, and occurs in 20 to 51 percent of patients with an orthopaedic injury. "PTSD occurs with a significant frequency in civilian patients who have sustained an orthopaedic trauma, and ...

One-third of Spanish children do not wake up feeling refreshed

2011-05-10

Children have poor quality sleep. A new study carried out in Valencia shows that 37.4% of children aged from 6 to 8, 25.3% of those aged between 9 and 11, and 31.8% of those aged from 12 to 15 wake up feeling refreshed only once a week, or even not at all. The results also show that 4.26% of them fall asleep in class more than three times per week. "It is important to point out that the way we sleep throughout our lives depends on how we learn to sleep as children", Gonzalo Pin Arboledas, lead author of this study and a doctor at the Valencian Sleep Unit at the Quirón ...