(Press-News.org) On September 11, 2001, the air was sizzling with anger—and the anger got hotter as the hours passed. That, anyway, was one finding of a 2010 analysis by Mitja Back, Albrecht Küfner, and Boris Egloff of 85,000 pager messages sent that day. The researchers employed a commonly used tool called Linguistic Inquiry and Word Count, or LIWC, which teases out information from the frequency of word usages in texts.
But were Americans really so angry? Clemson University psychologist Cynthia L. S. Pury wasn't out to answer that question when she made the discovery that was just published online in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science.
A researcher on courage, Pury thought the data set would be "ideal" to unearth signs of that virtue during those terrible hours—either of people springing to action or praising others who did. "I downloaded the whole thing and started playing around with it in Excel," she says. But because that program shows the messages line by line, instead of aggregating it as LIWC does, Pury quickly saw that Back and his colleagues had drawn inaccurate conclusions: "The apparent rise in anger was due to a single message repeated thousands of times. It contained the word 'critical,' which LIWC read as indicating anger. However, in this case it meant 'urgent' or 'very important.' In fact, the message did not even seem to be from a person, but rather from a computer system indicating that critical maintenance was needed."
Eliminating those repetitions, the dramatic rise in anger disappeared over time.
Comments Pury, "LIWC can be quite sophisticated in looking for words," but without a way to read and analyze content for meaning, it can lead users far astray.
The experience compelled Pury to publish her findings in a letter warning other researchers to be wary of LIWC and similar tools "before they find a way of cleaning the data" of redundancies and other glitches.
While the discovery put the kibosh on one line of inquiry for the time being, it also made Pury feel better about her fellow Americans. "The anger findings made sense to me when I read them," she says, "but thinking back to 2001, it was not how the situation seemed at the time." All around Pury, "people were sad and scared. But they were also incredibly considerate and warm and appreciative of each other." Indeed, the data revealed those feelings. Among the most frequent messages that showed up in Excel was one expressing a fierce need to connect: "Call me."
###
For more information about this study, please contact: Cynthia L. S. Pury, Clemson University, at cpury@clemson.edu.
The APS journal Psychological Science is the highest ranked empirical journal in psychology. For a copy of the article "Automation Can Lead to Confounds in Text Analysis: Back, Küfner, and Egloff (2010) and the Not-So-Angry Americans" and access to other Psychological Science research findings, please contact Divya Menon at 202-293-9300 or dmenon@psychologicalscience.org.
On 9/11, Americans may not have been as angry as you thought they were
2011-05-11
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
A new study on self-injury behavior encourages quick and targeted intervention
2011-05-11
While the disturbing act of self-injury is nothing new to adolescents, researchers and physicians at Nationwide Children's Hospital have identified a more severe type of behavior that is raising some concern among medical professionals. Often misdiagnosed, ignored and under-reported, Self-Embedding Behavior (SEB) is a form of self-injurious behavior that involves inserting foreign objects into soft tissue – either under the skin or into muscle. A recent study, published in the June issue of Pediatrics, stresses the importance of quickly identifying this dangerous behavior ...
New American Chemical Society podcast: 2-in-1 explosive detector and neutralizer
2011-05-11
WASHINGTON, May 10, 2011 — A two-in-one material that can both detect and neutralize explosives of the type favored by Richard Reid, the notorious shoe bomber who tried to blow-up a commercial airliner in 2001, is the topic of the latest episode in the American Chemical Society's (ACS) award-winning "Global Challenges/Chemistry Solutions" podcast.
The podcast explains that the detector/neutralizer is a material made of metal oxide nanoparticles so small that 50,000 could fit across the width of a single human hair. It changes color in the presence of certain explosives, ...
Student, 16, invents new drug cocktail to fight cystic fibrosis, wins Canadian biotech challenge
2011-05-11
While many 16-year-olds are content with PlayStation, Toronto-area student Marshall Zhang used the Canadian SCINET supercomputing network to invent a new drug cocktail which could one day help treat cystic fibrosis.
The Grade 11 student at Bayview Secondary School in Richmond Hill so impressed eight eminent scientists at the National Research Council of Canada laboratories in Ottawa they awarded him first prize today in the 2011 Sanofi-Aventis BioTalent Challenge.
Jonathan Khouzam, Simon Leclerc, Francis Marcogliese, all 19, of Montreal's CÉGEP Collège Jean-de-Brébeuf, ...
Getting along with co-workers may prolong life, researchers find
2011-05-11
WASHINGTON -- People who have a good peer support system at work may live longer than people who don't have such a support system, according research published by the American Psychological Association.
This effect of peer social support on the risk of mortality was most pronounced among those between the ages of 38 and 43. Yet similar support from workers' supervisors had no effect on mortality, the researchers found.
In addition, men who felt like they had control and decision authority at work also experienced this "protective effect," according to the study, published ...
Genomic test shows promise as chemotherapy response, survival predictor for women with breast cancer
2011-05-11
HOUSTON — A new genomic test combining multiple signatures – a patient's estrogen receptor status, endocrine therapy response, chemotherapy resistance and sensitivity – shows promise as a predictor of chemotherapy response and survival benefit in women with invasive breast cancer, according to research led by The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center.
The findings, published in the May 11 issue of JAMA, also may determine those for whom standard therapy alone might not offer enough, and/or for whom an appropriate clinical trial in the adjuvant setting could provide ...
'Surrogates' aid design of complex parts and controlling video games
2011-05-11
WEST LAFAYETTE, Ind. - Researchers have defined a new class of software, calling it "surrogate interaction," which enables designers and video gamers to more easily change features of complex objects like automotive drawings or animated characters.
The new interactive approach is being used commercially and in research but until now has not been formally defined, and doing so could boost its development and number of applications, said Ji Soo Yi, an assistant professor of industrial engineering at Purdue University.
Conventional computer-aided design programs often ...
Genetic defects hold clues to risk for sudden cardiac death
2011-05-11
Sudden cardiac death is always a shocking, tragic event, especially when it occurs at a young age. But, for the first time, scientists are unraveling how genetic defects can help predict the risk of dying suddenly in individuals with one of the leading causes of this unfortunate phenomenon.
This knowledge could guide treatment and potentially lessen the occurrence of sudden cardiac death in patients with Long QT syndrome, a rare, inherited heart rhythm disorder. It could also provide insight into the assessment and treatment of the millions of people who experience cardiac ...
Wayne State researchers find new way to examine major depressive disorder in children
2011-05-11
DETROIT — A landmark study by scientists at Wayne State University published in the May 6, 2011, issue of Archives of General Psychiatry, the most prestigious journal in the field, has revealed a new way to distinguish children with major depressive disorder (MDD) from not only normal children, but also from children with obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD).
MDD is a common, debilitating disease prevalent in childhood and adolescence. Examination of cortical thickness in patients with MDD has not been widely studied, and WSU's team of researchers set out to determine ...
Brazil's health care system vastly expands coverage, but universality, equity remain elusive
2011-05-11
Two decades after Brazil's constitution recognized health as a citizen's right and a duty of the state, the country has vastly expanded health care coverage, improved the population's health, and reduced many health inequalities, but universal and equitable coverage remains elusive, experts from four major Brazilian universities and New York University have concluded.
According to their analysis—one of six articles published in the medical journal The Lancet as a special series on health in Brazil—while federal expenditures have nearly quadrupled over the past 10 years, ...
High-tech approach uses lights, action and camera to scrutinize fresh produce
2011-05-11
This release is available in Spanish.
High-tech tactics to carefully examine apples and other fresh produce items as they travel along packinghouse conveyor belts will help ensure the quality and safety of these good-for-you foods.
U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) scientists in Beltsville, Md., have developed and patented an experimental, cutting-edge optical scanning system that would use two different kinds of lighting, a sophisticated camera and other pieces of equipment to scrutinize produce-section favorites while they are still at the packinghouse.
The ...