September 16, 2010 (Press-News.org) Any person accused of a crime in the United States has the right "to be confronted with the witnesses against him." It is one of the fundamental protections of the U.S. Constitution, written into the Confrontation Clause of the Sixth Amendment and guaranteed since the Bill of Rights took effect in 1791. However, our understanding of this right has evolved with time.
Last year in the case of Melendez-Diaz v. Massachusetts, the U.S. Supreme Court considered the protections of the Confrontation Clause with regard to the introduction of forensic evidence in a trial.
Prior to this case, it had become routine practice for crime labs to submit forensic reports for use in criminal trials without the testimony of those who prepared the reports. For example, prosecutors would use lab reports to assert that a white powdery substance was actually cocaine or that a driver arrested for DUI had a Blood Alcohol Content level above the legal limit.
In Melendez-Diaz, the defendant challenged this practice. Melendez-Diaz was accused of distribution and drug trafficking of cocaine. When the prosecutor sought to admit three Certificates of Analysis confirming that the substance police found was cocaine, Melendez Diaz argued that these certificates could not be admitted without the testimony of the person who prepared them. He argued that admitting these certificates violated his rights under the Confrontation Clause.
The Supreme Court agreed.
The Court held that the certificates could only be admitted if the person responsible for the certificates appeared at trial or if the defendant had another opportunity to cross-examine the witness. In this case, Melendez-Diaz had not been allowed to cross-examine the forensic analyst who determined that the substance was cocaine, and therefore the admission of the certificates violated his right of confrontation.
The Consequences of Melendez-Diaz
For those accused of many crimes, this ruling has significant implications. Many types of cases rely on scientific evidence to prove an element of the crime. For example, when someone is stopped for DUI, a machine may indicate that the driver was legally intoxicated. DNA evidence may be used to link a sexual assault victim to the person allegedly responsible for the attack.
Fundamentally the ruling increases the burden of prosecuting crimes involving scientific evidence. If a forensic analyst must be available to testify for every trial involving DUI or drug charges, pursuing the charges becomes more burdensome for the state. Every hour a state forensics analyst spends in a courtroom is an hour the analyst is away from his or her lab work. Accordingly, prosecutors have added incentives to avoid full-blown trials, which may benefit those accused of crimes.
On a more abstract level, though, the ruling serves as recognition that laboratory work is not infallible and that the results presented in a lab report are not just a restatement of objective facts. People responsible for handling forensic evidence can and do make mistakes; this ruling acknowledges this, and gives a person accused of a crime greater opportunity to challenge the findings.
Thus far this ruling has had the most obvious effects for drug charges and DUI allegations. However, the ruling is still relatively recent from a legal standpoint, meaning that the full implications are not yet known. Quite likely the requirement that testimony accompany lab reports and scientific evidence will have even more wide-ranging effects than can possibly be known at this point, affecting many types of criminal allegations.
To reach this point, though, criminal defense attorneys must be willing to push the boundaries of these arguments. It is easy to accept the well-trodden path, but to help define the full contours of the protections afforded by the confrontation clause, it is important that defense lawyers reach beyond the obvious arguments. For more information about the protections afforded by the confrontation clause, speak with a knowledgeable criminal defense attorney.
Article provided by Miller Reagan & Associates PC
Visit us at www.legaldefense.com
The Confrontation Clause: New Meaning for The Twenty-First Century
Any person accused of a crime in the United States has the right "to be confronted with the witnesses against him." However, our understanding of this right has evolved with time.
2010-09-16
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
The Pressure is On: Medical Professionals Standing Up For Patient Rights
2010-09-16
Medical Whistleblowers and the Sovereign Immunity Roadblock
The heroic actions of two individuals recently brought the little town of Kermit, Texas, into the limelight. Two nurses at Winkler County Memorial Hospital found themselves in an astonishing situation after reporting suspected ethical violations of a doctor. Not only were they fired but also indicted on felony charges. Both nurses beat the indictments and later settled a civil lawsuit against the hospital, but the unexpected scenario has sparked public debate about laws protecting medical whistleblowers.
Anne ...
Shorter Sentences for Viewing Child Porn
2010-09-16
Worried parents and law enforcement officials are driving an increase in child pornography cases across the U.S. Sentences for viewing child porn range from probation to 20 years in prison, but judges are leaning toward lower sentences.
The Wall Street Journal analyzed four years of data and found a significant reduction in jail time. In 2006, about 20 percent of child porn possession and distribution cases brought sentences that fell below federal guidelines. By 2009, more than 40 percent of sentences brought such sentences, according to the Journal. In the same period, ...
Common Defenses to Workers' Compensation Claims in Pennsylvania
2010-09-16
When a worker is injured on the job, the workers' compensation system is intended to ensure that the worker receives the medical treatment necessary to recover and financial support for the resulting time away from work. However, this compensation is ultimately provided by an insurance company -- and insurance companies generally seek to avoid paying out claims when possible. Accordingly, these companies rely on a number of common, well-established defenses to avoid paying claims.
Workers' compensation claims fall into two categories: accidental-injury claims and occupational-disease ...
Debenhams Breaks New Ground with National Disabled Model Campaign
2010-09-16
Debenhams has become the first retailer on the British high street to launch a national window campaign featuring a disabled model in all of its 160 stores in the UK and the Republic of Ireland.
The ground breaking imagery features disabled model Shannon Murray, along with additional photography, mannequins and products in a display to launch the Debenhams autumn winter womenswear.
The innovative display follows an approach by Nikki Fox and Natasha Wood, both disability campaigners and presenters of the hit TV show, How to Look Good Naked, which led to a trial using ...
npower Celebrates 'Consumer Supplier of the Year' Award Win
2010-09-16
npower is celebrating after being presented with 'The Consumer Supplier of the Year' award at the first ever Energy Event Awards. The award recognises the supplier that has excelled in providing industrial and commercial consumers with an outstanding service, product or innovation.
The awards are a new addition to the annual Energy Event, which took place at the National Motorcycle Museum in Birmingham on 8-9th September 2010. The awards recognise and reward achievements in the energy industry, celebrating the suppliers and businesses that are bringing new ideas and ...
Door2Tour.com Launches 2011 Events Programme
2010-09-16
Door2Tour.com has launched its range of popular events for 2011 with a selection of breaks available, incorporating flower shows, sporting events, concerts and exhibitions. The latest programme now includes trips to over 30 events throughout the UK alone, offering traditional events like the Edinburgh Tattoo, Chelsea Flower Show and Wimbledon among newcomers like the NBA Basketball, National Brass Band Championships, Cirque du Soleil and Barry Manilow in concert.
Fresh from a hugely successful year for events where sales were up 37% on 2009, and with sales for events ...
Stena Line Announces New Onboard Children's Menu from Annabel Karmel
2010-09-16
Stena Line has announced the launch of a new menu by Annabel Karmel MBE, one of the world's most successful writers on children's food and nutrition.
Annabel has sold over 4 million books worldwide and has become the expert in getting children, no matter how fussy, to follow a healthier diet. A selection of little people's favourite dishes including Fruity Chicken Curry, Fish Pie, Spaghetti Bolognaise with hidden vegetables, Chilli Con Carne, Macaroni Cheese and Chocolate Sponge with chocolate sauce will initially be sold in all food outlets onboard Stena Line's routes ...
npower Announces the Big Turn On
2010-09-16
npower has revealed that Tuesday 14 September is officially the day of The Big Turn On; when the majority of Brits awaken their heating from its summer slumber.
Statistics from npower hometeam, which installs, services and repairs boilers, show that Tuesday 14 September is the day when boilers across the country will whir back into action.
It's easy to forget about boilers during the Great British Summer in all its varied and inconsistent glory, but as Brits make the move and flick that switch, npower hometeam reveals that it experienced a significant increase in ...
Internet Entrepreneur Turned Philanthropist Jesse Willms Sponsors 135 Children Through World Vision
2010-09-16
As of Thursday Sept. 16, Jesse Willms has helped 135 children facing poverty in third-world countries through the renowned World Vision charitable organization.
Perhaps, even more importantly, Willms says he's not done yet - and hopes to have sponsored 200 or more children by the end of the year.
"I am proud to be able to partner with World Vision and do my small part in helping them in their goal to make poverty a thing of the past for children whose lives are endangered every day by their economic conditions," Willms said.
World Vision is an international ...
Jacksonville's Real Estate Investor Association (JaxREIA) is Holding Their 11th Annual Trade Show
2010-09-16
Jacksonville's Real Estate Investor Association (JaxREIA) is holding their 11th Annual Trade Show, Thursday, October 7 from 4 - 8:30 P.M. This event is FREE to the public.
Ever been interested in flipping houses? Have you caught yourself watching a home improvement show and thinking, "I could do that?" Wondering how to get the money to get started in real estate investing?
If you answered yes to any of these questions, then come out to their 11th Annual Trade Show and meet investor-friendly vendors showing off their products and services, ready to answer all of your ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Reality check: making indoor smartphone-based augmented reality work
Overthinking what you said? It’s your ‘lizard brain’ talking to newer, advanced parts of your brain
Black men — including transit workers — are targets for aggression on public transportation, study shows
Troubling spike in severe pregnancy-related complications for all ages in Illinois
Alcohol use identified by UTHealth Houston researchers as most common predictor of escalated cannabis vaping among youths in Texas
Need a landing pad for helicopter parenting? Frame tasks as learning
New MUSC Hollings Cancer Center research shows how Golgi stress affects T-cells' tumor-fighting ability
#16to365: New resources for year-round activism to end gender-based violence and strengthen bodily autonomy for all
Earliest fish-trapping facility in Central America discovered in Maya lowlands
São Paulo to host School on Disordered Systems
New insights into sleep uncover key mechanisms related to cognitive function
USC announces strategic collaboration with Autobahn Labs to accelerate drug discovery
Detroit health professionals urge the community to act and address the dangers of antimicrobial resistance
3D-printing advance mitigates three defects simultaneously for failure-free metal parts
Ancient hot water on Mars points to habitable past: Curtin study
In Patagonia, more snow could protect glaciers from melt — but only if we curb greenhouse gas emissions soon
Simplicity is key to understanding and achieving goals
Caste differentiation in ants
Nutrition that aligns with guidelines during pregnancy may be associated with better infant growth outcomes, NIH study finds
New technology points to unexpected uses for snoRNA
Racial and ethnic variation in survival in early-onset colorectal cancer
Disparities by race and urbanicity in online health care facility reviews
Exploring factors affecting workers' acquisition of exercise habits using machine learning approaches
Nano-patterned copper oxide sensor for ultra-low hydrogen detection
Maintaining bridge safer; Digital sensing-based monitoring system
A novel approach for the composition design of high-entropy fluorite oxides with low thermal conductivity
A groundbreaking new approach to treating chronic abdominal pain
ECOG-ACRIN appoints seven researchers to scientific committee leadership positions
New model of neuronal circuit provides insight on eye movement
Cooking up a breakthrough: Penn engineers refine lipid nanoparticles for better mRNA therapies
[Press-News.org] The Confrontation Clause: New Meaning for The Twenty-First CenturyAny person accused of a crime in the United States has the right "to be confronted with the witnesses against him." However, our understanding of this right has evolved with time.