(Press-News.org) An increase in female representation in local politics has caused a significant rise in documented crimes against women in India, new research has found.
That is good news, say the authors of the study carried out at the Centre for Competitive Advantage in the Global Economy (CAGE) at the University of Warwick in the UK, Harvard Business School and the IMF, who argue that the increase is down to greater reporting of crimes against women, rather than greater incidence of crimes against them.
The research examined the impact of the Panchayati Raj reform passed in 1993, which required Indian states to set aside one third of all member and leader positions in local government councils for women.
Panchayati Raj was implemented in different years by different states given their own election cycles, and is one of the largest experiments with quotas for female political representation anywhere in the world.
The researchers found that documented crimes against women rose by an average of 44 per cent after women entered local government, while rapes rose by 23 per cent and kidnapping of women showed a 13 per cent increase in the post-reform period up until 2004.
However there has been no significant effect on crimes not specifically targeted against women, such as kidnapping of men, theft or public order offences.
The researchers believe there are two reasons behind the surge in reported crimes against women.
Firstly, greater numbers of female politicians make the police more responsive to crimes against women.
Since the quota legislation, the number of arrests has also increased significantly, particularly for cases dealing with kidnapping of women.
And women victims who encounter more sympathetic women leaders would feel more encouraged to report crimes.
Dr Anandi Mani, associate professor of economics at CAGE, said: "The first thing we want to point out is that this is good news.
"The reason it's happening is because more crimes are being documented than were before the reforms - it's not an increase in incidences of crime.
"From what we can see in our data, when you have more women political leaders it has a motivating effect on the police to take crimes against women more seriously.
"We see that both in the arrest data and also in terms of women's satisfaction in their interaction with the police in areas where they have women leaders.
"And consistent with our reporting hypothesis, areas with longer exposure to women in local government show an eventual decline in the crime rate against women, so there is a deterrent effect over time."
Dr Mani added that it was the presence of women in the broad base of political representatives, rather than solely in leadership positions at the higher levels of politics, that generates the powerful impact.
"Our results imply that the presence of women at the lowest level of governance, where they are closer to potential crime victims, is more important in giving voice to women than their presence in higher level leadership positions."
###
Notes for editors
The working paper, entitled The Power of Political Voice: Women's Political Representation and Crime in India is available here
http://www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/economics/staff/academic/mani/crime_july2011.pdf
The authors are Lakshmi Iyer, Harvard Business School, Anandi Mani, CAGE at University of Warwick, Prachi Mishra, IMF, and Petia Topalova, IMF
Contact details
For further information please contact Dr Anandi Mani on 44-2476-522545 (office) or 44-7942-599621 or A.Mani@warwick.ac.uk
University of Warwick international press officer Anna Blackaby is available on 44-2476-575910 or 44-7785-433155 or a.blackaby@warwick.ac.uk
Quotas for women in local politics brings surge in documented crimes against women in India
2011-12-19
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
A new kind of metal in the deep Earth
2011-12-19
Washington, D.C. -- The crushing pressures and intense temperatures in Earth's deep interior squeeze atoms and electrons so closely together that they interact very differently. With depth materials change. New experiments and supercomputer computations discovered that iron oxide undergoes a new kind of transition under deep Earth conditions. Iron oxide, FeO, is a component of the second most abundant mineral at Earth's lower mantle, ferropericlase. The finding, published in an upcoming issue of Physical Review Letters, could alter our understanding of deep Earth dynamics ...
Elizabeth Barrett Browning's illness deciphered after 150 years
2011-12-19
Known for her poetry, letters, love affair and marriage to Robert Browning, Elizabeth Barrett Browning also left a legacy of unanswered questions about her lifelong chronic illness. Now, a Penn State anthropologist, with the aid of her daughter, may have unraveled the mystery.
Born in 1806, Barrett Browning suffered throughout her life from incapacitating weakness, heart palpitations, intense response to heat and cold, intense response to illnesses as mild as a cold, and general exhaustion in bouts that lasted from days to months or years. Her doctors were unable to diagnose ...
RunningShoes.com Launches Brooks Shoe Giveaway
2011-12-19
RunningShoes.com is hosting a giveaway to get runners geared up for the upcoming new year. The online retailer has teamed up with Brooks to give away the latest style of its Adrenaline GTS running shoes.
Launching in January 2012, the Brooks Adrenaline GTS 12 is the twelfth iteration of its No. 1 selling shoe. Through the years, this stability shoe has received numerous accolades for its smooth ride. Most recently Runner's World deemed the 11th version of the Adrenaline GTS the "Best Update" in its winter shoe guide. For those not familiar with Brooks running ...
Tissue structure delays cancer development
2011-12-19
This press release is available in German.
Cancer growth normally follows a lengthy period of development. Over the course of time, genetic mutations often accumulate in cells, leading first to pre-cancerous conditions and ultimately to tumour growth. Using a mathematical model, scientists at the Max Planck Institute for Dynamics and Self-Organization in Göttingen, University of Pennsylvania and University of California San Francisco, have now shown that spatial tissue structure, such as that found in the colon, slows down the accumulation of genetic mutations, thereby ...
Algal protein gives boost to electrochemical water splitting
2011-12-19
Photosynthesis is considered the 'Holy Grail' in the field of sustainable energy generation because it directly converts solar energy into storable fuel using nothing but water and carbon dioxide (CO2). Scientists have long tried to mimic the underlying natural processes and to optimize them for energy device applications such as photo-electrochemical cells (PEC), which use sunlight to electrochemically split water – and thus directly generate hydrogen, cutting short the more conventional approach using photovoltaic cells for the electrolysis of water.
Traditionally, PEC ...
Study reveals gender bias of prospective parents
2011-12-19
A Queen's University study has found that when people think about having children, men want boys and women want girls.
"Gender neutrality - a lack of preference - is now a standard cultural norm embraced within most wealthy developed countries like Canada," says Lonnie Aarssen, a Queen's biology professor and co-author of the study. His results, though, reveal a strong gender bias, despite the researchers' prediction that they would find evidence of a well-established contemporary culture of gender neutrality.
As a way of explaining these findings, Dr. Aarssen says the ...
New insight into why locusts swarm
2011-12-19
New research has found that a protein associated with learning and memory plays an integral role in changing the behaviour of locusts from that of harmless grasshoppers into swarming pests.
Desert Locusts are a species of grasshopper that have evolved a Jekyll-and-Hyde disposition to survive in their harsh environment. In their solitary phase, they avoid other locusts and occur in very low density. When the sporadic rains arrive and food is more plentiful, their numbers increase.
However, as the rains cease the locusts are driven onto dwindling patches of vegetation. ...
Healthcare Talent Crisis Driving Boost in Human Capital Management
2011-12-19
Healthcare providers' ability to deliver care is more contingent upon people than any other variable, according to the KLAS report, "Human Capital Management: Finding the Right Vendor Mix." KLAS found that many providers are feeling tremendous pressure to replace, acquire, or interface human capital management (HCM) solutions to improve the recruitment, training, utilization, and retention of staff.
While most providers already have an HR/Payroll application--the foundation of an HCM system--as well as Time & Attendance (TA) and Staff Scheduling systems ...
Effect of adenotonsillectomy in children with sleep-disordered breathing
2011-12-19
Alexandria, VA -- Children may have a better quality of life (QOL) and diminished cardiovascular disease risk from the decreased endothelin 1 (ET-1) levels after adenotonsillectomy, according to new research published in the December 2011 issue of Otolaryngology – Head and Neck Surgery.
SDB is an increasingly common indication for tonsillectomy and adenoidectomy due to obstructive sleep apnea syndrome (OSAS). Cardiovascular (CV) disease frequently has been reported in patients with moderate to severe OSAS, related abnormalities include: systematic hypertension, pulmonary ...
1 trait has huge impact on whether alcohol makes you aggressive
2011-12-19
COLUMBUS, Ohio -- Drinking enough alcohol to become intoxicated increases aggression significantly in people who have one particular personality trait, according to new research.
But people without that trait don't get any more aggressive when drunk than they would when they're sober.
That trait is the ability to consider the future consequences of current actions.
"People who focus on the here and now, without thinking about the impact on the future, are more aggressive than others when they are sober, but the effect is magnified greatly when they're drunk," said ...